Skip to main content
Loading video...

Lords of Waterdeep Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 16:01

Hey everybody, and welcome to Chairman of the Board. Today, I'm looking at Lords of Waterdeep, which is a worker placement game for two to five players set in the Dungeons & Dragons universe. Now, the idea of the game is that you are some kind of shady lord behind the scenes kind of pulling the strings to get these different bands of warriors together and send them off on different missions. Um missions give you victory points in return, and at the end of the game, who's got the most victory points is the winner. So, I'm going to quickly show you how it plays and then give my thoughts. I hope you enjoy. Okay, so the board is going to look like this. And I've set up a game here for two players, and you're going to give each player one of these boards here. Um a number of workers depending on the amount of players. So, for a two-player game, you you're going to get four workers. Uh you're going to get these different um little chits, which will come into use later, and some money. Um this represents your money here.

Um you're also going to get uh a secret lord card, which is kind of represents who you are. And um this is obviously secret, and you don't show anybody else. But at the end of the game, um you get bonus points if you complete a certain type of quest. So, for this one, um I get an additional four points for each Arcana and Piety quest I complete. Um these are the quest cards. They look something like this. So, um I've got two Piety quests here, which actually works in favor with my lord. Um so, basically this this part here kind of explains what I need to complete this quest. So, I need two white cubes, which represent um clerics, three black cubes, which represent rogues, and four money. And if I cash those in, I would get 20 points.

This one here, pretty much the same, a bit of simpler, two white cubes, an orange cube, and two money to get eight points. Uh and this is a plot quest. So, from then on after I complete this, I would get an additional bonus two points for each Piety quest I complete. Uh you're also going to get these uh intrigue cards, which look like this. Each player starts with one, but you can get more throughout the game. And they let you do loads of things, which can kind of mess with other players, or help you, or even help other players. So, for example, this one lets you take two orange cubes, which represent uh warriors, I believe, uh from the supply and place them in your tavern, choose one opponent, and that opponent takes uh an orange cube, too. So, you're kind of giving another player a benefit there, as well. Um okay, so yeah, basically the the idea of the game is that was very simple. All you're going to do is you're going to take one of your workers and you're going to put them on one of these spots on the board. You've got the harbor, the castle, the tower, all these different locations. And as soon as you place them on these spots, you're going to get the relevant reward. So, let's just have a quick run through what's actually on the board. So, you've got Castle Waterdeep.

So, if I put my guy here, I would get to draw an intrigue card from this stack here, and also take the first player marker. So, in future rounds, I'm going to get first dibs on these different spots because um naturally, if you go to a spot, then another player can't go there. So, it really is a race to get the resources you want. Anyway, so that's that lets you take the first player and an intrigue card. This one lets you get a purple cube, which represents wizards, I believe. Uh you've got get two warriors from the Fields of Triumph here. Uh this little section here, the Cliffwatch Inn, lets you um pick up different quests and also kind of wipe these different quests here and get a new bunch in. So, if there's something here you don't really like, you can replace them. So, yeah, we've got a draw a quest and get two money, get a quest and get an intrigue card, or as I said, reset the quests and then draw one.

Um and as you can see, some of these have really different criteria. You've got the simple ones here, which only need three cubes, but this big beast here takes all these different cubes, but obviously you're going to get bigger rewards back in return. Um you've got the Grinning Lion tavern here, which gets you two black cubes. Uh the Plinth, which gives you a white cube. I think they are particularly rare. Uh you've got this little section down here, the shop, which gets you four money. Um and my favorite part here is the Builder's Hall. Now, this is really cool because if you put your worker on here, then you get to pay money um to buy one of these buildings. So, say for example, um I wanted to buy this one, I would I would spend my um my money here. So, this one costs four, but I'll get one change from that. That's a five. Uh and then I would put one of these on one of these sections here around the outside of the board. You've got all these different sections.

And then I would put my little marker there next to it, just to say that I'm the owner of that building. And from then on, this spot here is going to be available to the to the players. Um so, they'd obviously get the reward as as per normal, but now um the owner of the building is going to get a cube of their choice every time someone chooses to use that one. So, there's this real kind of um a little economy that goes on because if people use your buildings, then you get a reward, too. And there's loads of different buildings in this stack, and as soon as you um as soon as you uh build one, it's going to get replaced. Um and that's pretty much it. At the end of at the end of the game, the person with the most victory points is going to win. Um you're also going to get one point for every two money you have, and also one point for every spare cube you have at the end of the game.

And that's how you play Lords of Waterdeep. Okay, so apologies for the very brief overview there, but I think that's enough to for me to give you like a a basic idea of how the game actually works. And as you can see, um it's pretty simple. This really does sit in that entry-level bracket for um worker placement games, and just that next step for like games or or like families and kind of the more casual gamer. So, it really does suit that kind of gateway niche, which a lot of people do actually uh you know, they do lean towards Lords of Waterdeep to fill that niche, and it does do it really well. Um yeah, so as I said, mechanically this game is very very simple, very smooth. Just put your worker down, get the reward, cash in your cubes to get points. That's pretty much how the game works, but it does work really well.

It's a real breeze to explain, you know, there's no real niggling rules here. It plays nice and quickly because uh you know, the decisions are pretty you know, intuitive. You're not going to be completely brain burned here, but you are going to have to divert your strategy if certain players do block where you were planning on going. And um it gives it gives a really nice atmosphere of a game. It's There's enough of a game there to keep you engaged, but without, you know, being a complete brain burner. A very very nicely kind of weighted game that's very very accessible. Um mechanically, as I said, it's very very simple. Um but something that really does kind of strike a chord with me that I think works really well is the um the Builder's Hall. The idea that you can spend your money to put a new building out, which is like a new worker spot on the board, and then every time another player uses that, you get a you get a reward, too. That's really really clever, and very simple, and it just works so well. Um and I absolutely love it. That's what really kind of um that's what really kind of hooked me with this game. Just that little twist that makes it a bit different um and a bit more kind of exciting. I really really like that.

Um I also like planning on how efficient you have to be with these missions because certain missions uh give you rewards back in return, and then you can use those rewards to kind of put towards other missions. So, you can get this real kind of chain reaction going on and try to be as efficient as possible. Uh the the implementation of those intrigue cards adds a lot of flavor to the game. There's loads and loads of them, so there's loads of variability here. Some of them are pretty damn nasty. So, if you are a bit um a bit of a carebear kind of player, you might have a bit um a discomfort here, but um especially with these certain cards called mandatory quests, because um if you go to a spot on the board that lets you play an intrigue card, you can actually force a quest on somebody, which they have to complete before they do any other quests. And that can really throw a spanner in the works, and um it can actually have the potential to rub players the wrong way.

Um I'm not quite sure how I feel about it, but I'm not against it yet. I've never taken them out, but um it's I guess it's a good way to stop a kind of runaway leader. But again, it it does work well for the game, and it does add that extra layer of player interaction other than the actual blocking of spaces. So, yeah, I really like the game mechanically, very smooth, very simple to learn, and um yeah, I like it. Uh decisions-wise, as I said, it's all about adapting if players do jump in the spots that you want. Um but you can actually go for different strategies as well, because um obviously you've got to kind of lean towards your secret identity, because you're going to get bonus points at the end of the game if you complete certain types of quests. But you can also like kind of play a long game by maybe getting more and more buildings early in order to reap the rewards as the game goes on, and hope to and hope to kind of peak later in the game. Or you can just kind of get loads and loads of little small missions done and just gently nudge up the score points, or just build and build and build resources and get big blocks of points at a time. I really like that.

The the actual way the scoreboard moves throughout the game is really kind of dynamic, because everybody is completing loads of different missions, which all have different rewards in return. Um so, I do like that. Uh balance of the game seems pretty good. I mean, if you're new to this game, you got to stand a good chance of winning, because as I said, the decisions are pretty intuitive. You're you're not going to be completely overwhelmed with decisions, and players who've played it before aren't going to have like a huge advantage over newer players. Sure, they're going to be probably going to be better players in general, and probably going to win, but you are going to have you're going to be able to put up a good fight just knowing the basics of the game um straight after teaching the rules. And I do like that. And as I said, this is a gateway game, so you do need that with a game like this. Um okay, time investment.

Plays really quickly if you if you play a certain way. Um if you do have players who are going to overanalyze this, then it does have the potential to outstay its welcome, but uh nine times out of 10, you're not going to get that because all you're going to do is you're going to put your worker down, get your reward, and keep doing that over and over again. Cash them in, cash them in. It moves really, really quickly. Uh really low downtime here, so that's really good at keeping players engaged. Um but yeah, time investment, you can if you've got like three players who are nice and quick, you can play it in like an hour's time. That's uh that's a real sweet spot for this game for me. Um if you get to that four with four is just about okay, I think, but if you get to that five-player mark, um with the expansion, you can even go to six players, and I wouldn't recommend it for that because um it can drag on longer than it needs to. But that's just a personal opinion.

Uh re playability-wise, I think it's pretty good, actually, because there is such a huge variety of um of different intrigue cards, loads different quests. You're going to get different uh lord cards. Um there's an expansion to this, which is excellent if you do want to add that new layer to the game. I'm not going to go too far into detail of that because I will be putting a review out soon. So, but it's good to know that you can actually expand this if you do actually take a good liking to it. And uh this is a very popular game, so obviously people do like it. Um player interaction, as I said, most of it is going to come from the blocking of spots, that frustration of oh, I was going to go there. Or what order am I going to go in because I've got a feeling that this player is going to go there first, so I'm going to get in there before him. Or am I going to take that first player marker just so I make sure that I get what I want next round.

When am I going to play my intrigue cards? Uh who am I going to use them against? It's just it's good. It's a really good level of interaction here, and the decisions are there to be made. Um aesthetically, I you know, it's pretty standard fantasy design here. I do like the the board, I think looks really, really cool. Um the actual wooden blocks, um you know, they're so-so. There are actually ways you can upgrade these by paying extra to get um some nice meeples which represent the actual uh characters they're supposed to, rather than just a black block or an orange, sorry, cube or a white cube. It's a bit boring to look at like that, and it looks a bit abstract, but um I do like the actual uh idea of having to recruit these warriors to send them on quests. It makes a real nice change other than collecting resources like your stone, your wood, your gold. It's just a nice nice twist on that, and I just I like the the way the theme is kind of integrated. Don't get me wrong, this is a pretty, you know, a substantial Euro game. You can tell this this game isn't about the theme, but the skin on it does work really well.

You know, like the missions you're sending these guys on, they do actually work thematically. Um all the different categories of the missions, you've got your warfare ones, you've got your arcana ones, which are like your more magical ones. And you know, the flavor text and the names, the actual cards themselves are really well done, very cleverly thought of. And um what you get in return and stuff also makes sense sense thematically. Uh the buildings make sense thematically. It's just really a really nice kind of general or generic D&D-themed game, which is more of a skin, but it does work really, really well. Uh setup time is not really an issue here, not really at all. Um you can set up in 5 minutes. Um and the same with tearing it down. So, really not much um not much of a problem there at all with setup time.

Um let's talk about component quality. Pretty average here. You've got your you know, about a seven of seven out of 10. Um you know, little wooden cubes, the cards they're not the best quality, but they are nicely done and designed. I think the game is actually nicely designed. You know, that quality of the design is better than the actual quality of the components, if that makes sense. Um you know, everything looks good, but it feels a little bit cheap. Um but certainly not enough to be an issue. You know, it's your standard seven out of 10, in my opinion. Um so yeah, overall, uh Lords of Waterdeep is a really, really good, very simple, very smooth entry-level worker placement game. Um very accessible, really engaging, really good fun. Um one that I can really, you know, it's stood the test of time already, and I can see it standing the test of time going forward. It's been in the BGG top 100 for a really long time, and rightly so, because it just fits that really nice niche of not being a gamer's game, but satisfying gamers, and not being a kind of family game, but also being accessible to them.

And I really like that kind of sweet spot of a board game, and I think that's why this game has done so well over the years. Um one that I certainly recommend um personally, my tastes as a Euro gamer have kind of evolved a little bit beyond it, but it certainly satisfies me enough to um get enough out of it. So, for me, it is uh it's an excellent game, an excellent game. I really do recommend you check it out. Um it's been out there a while now, so I'm sure you probably are aware of its presence and probably even know uh a lot about it, but yeah, I definitely recommend it. Um especially if you like the fantasy theme, and you just want an you know, you want your staple worker placement game in your collection. So, that's my opinions on the game. Um one that I definitely recommend. So, I hope you enjoyed the video. Uh if you have, please hit like and subscribe to my channel, and also check out my other videos. For everyone else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye.

Progress saved