Do I represent my audience?
Transcript
this video is sponsored by launch tabletop a board game manufacturer with a print on demand service for designers and Publishers hi I'm Adam Porter I'm a board game designer from Wales and in this is going to be a conversational video it's another one of my ones where I go back through the comments of my previous videos and let's try and answer some of those comments just as topics for discussion so a bit of a casual video this afternoon this is my fifth video along these lines you might want to go back and watch some of the previous ones in the series but we're going to get straight into it so the first question is from the video which I made called how finished should a game be before you pitch it so let's just take a quick look at a clip from that video I was getting all geared up for UK games Expo I had a session booked in the play testing Zone a handful of prototype board games to test and a small number of meetings lined up with a select few Publishers I do most of my pitching at Essen Spiel so I tend to keep my meeting schedule very light at ukge but I had a couple of very promising projects which i' been Dev V in for many months loads of tests polished prototypes and perfectly suited to the Publishers I had lined up this was going to be a breeze but what did I do well I only went and ballsed it up and the question is you mentioned that one of your games went out of print and the rights reverted back to you did the publisher have the right to renew and decline was this a shelf space Finance type issue were you simply interested in self-publishing future versions I think most of the those things aren't the case essentially
when you sign a contract with a publisher it it should have a a clause in there which says that if uh at a certain point the rights will come back to you and often the the the contract will keep rolling right it'll keep on renewing each year if the publisher is achieving whatever goal is written into the contract usually it's sales right if the publisher is selling a certain number of copies each year then they will continue to renew year after year as long as that continues but if those sales drop off then you have the right to send a message to the publisher and say look I'm giving you six months notice or whatever it says in the contract to cancel that licensing agreement and the rights come back to you so you can pitch it to somebody else and that's what's tended to happen in my games some of my games they've you know sold reasonably well for a year or two and then ultimately they they stopped selling well enough so the publisher um stops producing copies and then you know eventually the sales drop off to the point where you're not getting anything really getting sold in a year or certainly substantially less than the the threshold for ending that agreement at which point you've got a decision to make do you let it sit with that publisher and kind of hope that at some point in the future they might revive that game with a new addition or something like that or do you take the game away and start looking at reworking it and see if you know there's something there which you can develop for a new publisher and um that might mean you know a change of theme it might mean a change of mechanisms or it might mean
just taking it as is and pitching it to somebody else so yeah several of my early games now the rights sit with me as opposed to with the publisher and I'm still in that process of working out what to do with it like you don't want to be pitching it to anybody else if there are still copies sitting on store shelves right which have been sat there for years unsold or if the game has sold enough and people still remember it but they didn't buy vast amounts then you're going to need to make some changes to that game before you pitch it to somebody else often after a number of years your own you know my my sense of those games has changed what worked what didn't there's lessons that have been learned so that's another element that I'd be looking at if I if I was taking the rights back and trying to pitch it again so the next question relates to my video play testing the heart of board game design so I'm going to show you a clip from that video how do I know if my game is good enough what emotion do you feel most strongly while playing the game which moments in the game make you feel clever how much does the game feel like work does the game's theme make sense are you engaged right up to the conclusion to what extent do your decisions matter and is the game fair in 10 years running a play testing group in Wales I've learned the power of play testing by rigorously interrogating my designs I've managed to Craft products that Publishers want to produce and customers want to purchase and my new book Adam and Wales play testing tells you everything you need to know in order
to do the same so the question is hi Adam just ordered the book does it cover how you go about teaching the rules when play testing I guess this applies to any game not just prototypes but do you have a set way to convey the rules quickly and clearly maybe you could cover this in another video if you haven't already maybe I will or maybe we'll cover it in this video right now so let's have a look at the book the book he's talking about is Adam and Well's play testing which is available on Amazon there's a whole section in here which is about um the difficulty of playing the game the rules and complexity so what was this question did uh does the book cover how to go about teaching the rules when play testing conveying the rules quickly and clearly well it certainly covers like question number 60 in here is how easy was the game to learn and then it talks about that this question should be interpreted carefully it says players learn in different ways difficulty in learning the game can it be at times be more of a reflection on the teach than the game itself it might also depend heavily on the mood energy level and motivation of the learner so this question is potentially very helpful following a blind play test where players learn the game from written rules without direct input from the designer taking the skills of the teacher out of the equation there's further questions in here could you play a game without needing to consult the rules so factors which make a game's rules difficult to remember excessive complexity confusing perhaps thematic terminology for generic game mechanisms and components uh games with many exceptions to the basic rules asymmetry between players or
straying from well established Norms um let's have a look I'm sure there's more along these lines how easily Could you teach the game to another player are there any aspects you wish had been explained more thoroughly when you started playing so yeah I think the game the book does kind of cover this but essentially if you're finding it hard to teach your game then I think I think it might be that either a poor Communicator or it might mean that your game is too complex but either way the answer is probably do blind play tests so that's where you give the game with a copy of the rules to players and you stand back and just let them learn it that is probably the most authentic type of play test although it's harder to get those play tests done because it's asking more of the players it's the most authentic type of test because that's the experience the players are going to have when they buy your game from a shop and they just take the game out of the box they're going to have to learn it from the rules you're not you're not there in the box if you you are going to be teaching the rules if you are going to be there with the players then you've just got to follow the standard sort of principles that you would take when writing the rules and I have got a video about writing rules if you want to have a look for that one I think it's called rule the game that video um but basically the first thing you need to tell the players is what their goal is how they're going to win then you might want to give them an overview of how a round of play works and then Zone in on specific turns focus in on a turn I would say one thing not to get drawn into to by play testers is if they start sort of interrupting and and saying oh look can we just get started can we just start playing I'll learn it as I go
that's a recipe for disaster your game you do need to get your patter slick but it also needs to be authentic right there's no point you making a really slick explanation of a complex game which then actually is far more complex when people don't experience it with you they haven't had that opportunity of of a practiced facilitator leading the game so your game should be simple enough for people to learn if it's not yeah either a problem with you or it's a problem and when I say a problem with you obviously it's not a problem if you're not a great communicator it just means you've got to look for other tools to assist you or it's a problem with the complexity of your game in which case then yeah you might have some stuff you want to unpick and I think my book play testing will help you to unpick that to a degree so the next question relates to oh it's the same relates to the same video so I won't show you another clip of the video this one says my heart loves game design but my brain is made for play testing where can I apply to test games for designers so designers are always Keen for testers and lots of designers now test their games virtually so you can kind of get involved in play testing wherever in the world you are right you don't need to be local you've just got to find those people through various um online forums and things Board Game Geek forums is a good way to start but all sort of social media forums I'm not completely um up to speed with all of these different um areas that you can look into but I think you need to be present on those social media forums in order to find um you know virtual play testing groups you can Google it as well
of course if you want to play test for a publisher that's usually going to be a game at a much later stage in development so a nearly finished game something you're going to be balancing those sorts of things then it's a case of getting to know the Publishers and again you can do that through social media and through BGG the The Bard Game Geek website um if you're on those social media Pages for those Publishers you might see callouts for play testers um and so maybe that you could apply through those angles you can contact Publishers directly and ask but it might be better done in person attending conventions would be a great way of doing this right to speak to Publishers or even better if you volunteered for a publisher to demo for them and then you get talk into them they might include you as a play tester if they like you right and if they get on with you at that convention so I think those are some really good ways of going about it or you can do the sort of thing that I do which essentially is attend play test groups if there are any in your local area and there are a lot of these play test groups around um certainly in the UK there's loads in America I I keep hearing about lots of them I don't know around across the rest of the world but I can imagine there're sort of pretty much anywhere where there's a board Gaming Community so maybe go into a board game shop or a Board Game Cafe and ask them do you know of any local designer groups designer meetups play testing groups and they may be able to help you out with that allow me 30 seconds just to introduce you to my sponsor launch tabletop what are these gorgeous board games and where can I buy them well you can't at least not yet cuz these are prototypes yep you heard that right they're just prototypes proofs of
concept for pitching to Publishers gone of the days when prototypes had to resemble Middle School craft projects using launch tabletops print on demand service launch lab you can create professionall looking games in tiny quantities at an affordable price and delivered across the globe if you really want to make your design shine visit launtop Ed and don't forget to use the discount code Adam in Wales for a 20% discount was that 30 seconds felt like about 30 seconds it's close enough so next question then relates to uh an older video of mine called I designed a board game and it bombed my main observation about the art style for throne is that it's all very serious I envisaged the game to have some humor but somewhere along the line that was lost and we ended up with some really capably drawn but rather insipid car characters and that's my biggest regret with the production I really should have laid out a clearer vision for the look of the game and the question is the failure of the theme makes me feel the need to remind designers that Ganson clever a dice game entirely without theme is extremely successful if the interesting point is solely the mechanics you can just sell it as an abstract now I don't know if this is true right in my mind a an abstract right is is a theme I know that's s sort of sounds maybe it's a little factious okay but it sort of is right if you if you have an abstract game it sets expectations in the user if I see a game with a grid and wooden
blocks I'm expecting a very simple game with you know maybe a page of rules at the most two or three rules really and some significant strategic depth not very much luck right abstract strategy is a genre in itself and it it it sets promises right it's a theme it's not just a case of any game you strip out the theme and becomes an abstract game if you strip out the theme of pile of cats you end up with you know just a huge pile of polyomino and cards and boards with grids and it would be that that just wouldn't that just wouldn't work it wouldn't sell it would be far too complex without the theme to carry you along and help you learn it and and and help you to immerse yourself in that world and without Something Beautiful to look at it would just be fiddly and massive and ugly an abstract game tends to be something really really simple so I'm saying abstract games are a theme just like space exploration games are a theme right they they carry certain expectations they make certain Promises to the players and I think there are subg genres of abstract games so there are those wooden block and grid games that I've talked about that remind us of things like chess and checkers where we fully know what we're getting into something strategic deterministic low luck um Simple Rules right minute to learn lifetime to master that that famous cliche tagline from a um but there are other genres of abstract games there are those card games where you've just got colors and numbers so that's games like uh Uno or um the mind or all
those all those numerous games that Amigo spieler has which just have colors and numbers games like zebra and you know the these sorts of games um that I've got many many of them in my collection and then there are games where you have numbers and you write them down on a paper sheet in in a pattern right so these I mean they've been around since yachi basically the we're talking rolling rights flip and rights here um yachi Quicks Quinto all those nsv games lots of them coming out from lots of companies over many last few years gone clever is one of the most popular ones but it does fit into a predetermined box right a predetermined style of abstract game so I'm not sure that it's quite right that you can just strip the theme out of any game and sell it as an abstract um I don't think that would work for example for the game that I talked about in this video throne throne has got interesting mechanisms I think it's got a clever Central system and I don't think the theme is particularly well chosen by me and I think it is one of the reasons that the game flopped but I don't think selling it as an abstract is a solution I think that would be even more confusing for the player I think what it needs is a different type of theme a different type of setting so the next question relates to my video user using product design principles to enhance your tabletop game now there's a catchy title for a video isn't it okay so let's have a clip from that video there's no right way to play games people enjoy different games in this hobby for very different reasons
but who are your core audience what do they value I've put together a very loose unscientific classification of tabletop Gamers you could think of these as avatars of the people who play your games and I'd encourage you to come up with your own classification the classification is Broad and imprecise but I do think that creating avatars can help us to focus our designs and the question is I wonder if there's some validity to Simply making a game that I like on the assumption that I too represent a customer profile or Avatar and I'm not completely weird Andor unique discuss so I think this is a really common bit of advice to designers that you hear a lot in design communities design a game you'd want to play and I'm not sure it's always the best advice I think it's great advice if you're not that interested in sales right if you're not trying to create a commercial product if you just want to enjoy the process of Designing and you're happy for a few people to play it and you're not worried about sales figures or anything like that um fine great go for it have a have a whale of a time okay but I think it is a mistake to think that you represent a significant portion of the market okay you might do you might do but you might not okay you're taking a bit of a punt there okay there's a lot of a lot of risk in taking that approach I know that I don't represent a lot of The Wider Market I have so many games right I've got hundreds of games in this room around me and the vast majority of them have sold
very few copies frankly games I love games I absolutely love have sold you know very little a few hundred a few thousand copies I would imagine um so my tastes are not in line with the average consumer and so my job if I want to be a designer is to empathize with the audience that's out there to try and understand the people who are buying games and see if I can make games for them if I want to get sales right if I want sales figures which I do right if I want to achieve sales um so yeah I think it's a mistake to just design what I like to play I think the important thing is to design a game that works for an audience that I've identified that I would also like to play okay if I wouldn't like to play it I don't want to spend my time designing it right i' I'd make a mess of it anyway I've got to enjoy it but it should also have an an audience in mind I think it's just good practice for a designer to try and design a game for somebody else not for themsel it's going to help you to develop your craft right as a designer it's going to make you more adaptable more versatile as a designer you're going to improve rather than becoming you know if if you just look Inward and you're just focused on yourself and your own preferences and and and you know you're going to create the same stuff over and over again and it's not necessarily going to be stuff that other people are going to want to play you're going to become resistant to uh to feedback around it as people try and sort of move you away from your original Vision um I'm not sure it's the best
approach unless you're just doing it for the fun of it in which case fine go for it that said I do recognize that trying to look for a specific audience and trying to identify a a player Prof an avatar there's a ton of luck in it right I don't think you know when Jamie stegmar and Elizabeth Hargrave made wingspan I don't think they expected it to you know to go crazy like it did and to sell as many millions of copies as it has sold right it I think they probably knew they were on to something okay but I don't think they realized it was quite the Fantastic product that it turned out to be and it's easy to look back with retrospect and go oh yeah it's it it's sold because of this this this and this but you know sometimes there's a little bit of a little dose of luck in there that intangible thing catching a moment right and and you'll never quite grasp that but that doesn't mean you shouldn't try okay that doesn't mean you shouldn't try and look at Trends look at the market look at the players and create something that's genuinely useful for people right think create something that people genuinely want so that brings me to a close for today if you enjoyed this casual chatty video then please go back and watch some of my others along similar lines where I've answered questions from the uh from the comments I enjoy making these videos so certainly I'm going to keep watching the comments so if you've got any questions Chuck them in the comments to this video or any of my other previous videos I'm sure I'll spot them and maybe I'll include them in a future video all the best