Skip to main content
Loading video...

Courtisans Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 12:29

hey everybody today I'm taking a look at quter Sands this is a two to five player card game that takes 20 minutes to play now before I get started on my review of quter Sands I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor kendra. who are my goto online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so setup for quand is going to look a bit like this where you have this large deck of cards and if you are playing with fewer than the full complement of players you're going to remove some of these cards from the deck you've also got this banquet table which acts as a a kind of a score tracker because this game does have an element of uh commodity speculation where cards you collect can be worth positive or negative points depending on the state of play of the banquet table uh during setup each player is going to get one of these dark secret objectives as well as one of these ones and these can do lots different things and of course you'll be keeping these hidden from your opponent and aiming towards them to try to get some bonus points for example this one says you know at Le to get three points you'd have to have at least one card in each family must be must be below the game mat as in having all the across here or the carps must be fallen from Grace So generally speaking there's two terminologies there's esteemed which means there's more cards above than below or fallen from Grace which means there's more cards below than above and of course of course I'll

touch on the relevance of that shortly uh the other cards are things such as this you know you must own at least three spies you must own fewer butterflies than your left neighbor and so on now generally speaking the game Flow is very simple where you'll have three cards in your hand drawn from the deck at the end of your turn and then you're are going to decide how to deploy these three cards now you have to deploy each of these cards in different locations and those locations can either be in front of yourself for your scoring Tableau so in this example I might want to play this blue card in front of me you can play them to the banquet table in two different ways so in this example I might want to play this blue card above the um in the esteemed position for the blue faction meaning that at the moment there are more blue cards above than below meaning that the card I have in front of me is now worth one point but of course players might want to start playing them below to make this card worth negative points now third card must be played in front of an opponent so you can choose which one that is and you'll have to give this card to them of course you generally want to be giving cards away that are in the Fallen from Grace position in addition to those standard cards that I've shown you some of the cards have special abilities for example the Nobles here are worth double strength so therefore if you have one of these that's going to be worth you know plus two or Plus or negative -2 points if it's in front of you at the end of the the game and these are much more

powerful in swaying the council in whether to be esteemed or fallen from grace and of course you can give them to your opponents if they're you know worth negative points you've got the Assassin which depending on where you play it it can eliminate a card from that region so you know if I know that my opponent's got a bunch of the blue cards I know want I no longer want the blues to be worth positive points I might want to play the red card up here to eliminate the blue card from this area and again you can play this in front of yourself to eliminate negative cards or in front of your opponent to eliminate some of their positive cards you've got the um the guarded cards here that with the shields on which simply protects you from the Assassin cards and you have the spies now the spies are cool because they actually are played face down and again you can play them in front of yourself and opponent or when you play in the banquet table you'll place it above or below the queen as to not reveal what suit that is and at the end of the game once the decks run out um they'll be revealed and put in their relevant positions like so and that's essentially how the game plays you're going to keep on deploying cards uh and again depending on the final position of all the different suits on the board here you will um tally out the points you know depending on um Who's got what and you know Etc so if there is a particular C that is balanced on either side like the red one is here then um those that particular suit is going to be worth nothing you know regardless of how many you have in front of you and at the end

of the game the player with the most points will be the winner okay so let's share some thoughts on corisan and as you could see from the overview there this is a straightforward game it's not terribly complex and the the rules are straightforward but sometimes you are presented with some pretty difficult decisions of course depending on the cards that you draw I generally like commodity speculation games because they keep you engrossed in the state of play and you know especially in this one when you are forced to make those decisions as in playing one card to yourself one to an opponent and one to the uh the banquet table and when you combine that with the special abilities you know sometimes you are forced to make those tough decisions as I mentioned you know if all the cards are bad do you want to maybe start trying to know turn the tides by changing a you know a fallen from Grace category into a positive one and then start investing in those considering that your opponents have already given up on them or even sometimes you are forced to make kind of the best of a bad decision where all the cars might be worth positive points to everybody therefore you want to try to dilute those out amongst the players and do that kind of mental arithmetic and try to make sure that you're gaining the you know the net gain and winning the overall hand essentially um I do like the way that works again I like some of these special abilities in terms of the spies to not give that perfect information at any times because know if you have a very delicately balanced um suit as in like this one here if one of these hidden cards are fallen from grace and somebody has invested heavily in this one when it comes to the end of the

game all those points they've collected are going to be worth nothing so you do need to consider that which brings the Assassins into play which of course brings the uh the Warriors into play with the shields on and so on so I do think those extra touches of the special abilities make the game come to life and definitely um make it much more interesting for it and at the same time the Tactical decisions you're making throughout the game might sometimes butt heads with the secret ability that are divided out at the start of the game as well because you know often those cards are given to you you know with no no choice of your own and that will often conflict with the cards that you're given for those endgame scoring now that being said I do find that games of this nature tend to have a habit of sorting themselves out so normally you'll find that each player will kind of invest in one or two types of the suits or maybe three of the types and obviously try to increase the value of them and collect those cards for themselves and of course trying to tank the values of the cards that other players have collected and once that's kind of sorted itself out you tend to stick to the game plan and just keep on doing the same thing so that can sometimes bring the game to a bit of a predictable state of play um I suppose you can deviate from that based on those cards that you are given but that seems to be a pattern the games like this follow and that leads me on to probably the biggest critique I have for the game and

this is through experience by playing games that are similar to this so and there are several games that have this mechanism where you are forced to take a card for yourself and give one to your opponent or multiples to your opponents but normally when that happens you are forced to draw one card at a time and make that choice on the spot whereas this one you have to draw all three and then make that decision with more you know more information I suppose now I actually prefer the other way where you know with each card that you're presented with you have to make that choice and it gives this kind of push your luck mechanism where you think oh this car's fantastic but there could be an even better one later so how I going to risk giving this one to my opponent am I going to keep it for myself and maybe draw an even better one that I'm forced to give to my opponent later and so on so the game that Springs to mind with that mechanism is biblio I think biblio has quite a similar feel to this um know bioses has an extra stage or two involved but I definitely think that the uh improved version of that mechanism is by doing one card at a time rather than having all three in your hand at once and being made to being forced to make that decision with more information at hand actually makes it much more tense and much more exciting by doing one at a time the interaction for this game is generally quite good because of course the the state of play is always in flux I think the interaction is much better when it comes to the higher player counts because there is more cross contamination and crossover with the other players because you and maybe multiple opponents might want to boost

or you know crash a certain card type and you know you can even like maybe invest or even give cards away to other players to try and put them under bit of pressure to try and jack up those prices which you know you will benefit from as well but that doesn't quite shine through as much with you know three players or two players um because again it's a bit more transparent about what players are going for and you'll stick to that affir menion game plan the pacing for the game is very good the box does say it's a 20-minute game and that is accurate there is no next to no downtime with this one no scope to lose interest and it kind of doesn't not outstay as welcome at all so definitely fills that category of a filler game very well and production wise now I really do appreciate the look of these cards and the artwork they very nice sized cards you can see that these cards have this kind of gilding on which looks fantastic it has this kind of old school disney-esque artwork which looks fantastic for this kind of you know fantasy Kingdom artwork with a big banquet table uh the matte is fabric which is a strange choice but I'm not against it um so all in all um I'm very happy with the production comes in a nice Sleek little box so yeah no complaints all in fact it looks very very nice okay so let's share some final thoughts on cartans and you know I think this game is adequate I think it does what it says it does it keeps the game very

simple and it stays true to One Core mechanism and generally speaking I do like commodity speculation um and it does shine through a lot stronger when you are playing with four or five players as I mentioned there is more cross contamination with the other players and it makes those choices a bit more interesting now sad and this tends to be um a reoccurring uh comment from me there are games out there that do a better job with this mechanism than qu sand stars now the game I'm thinking of is biblio I would highly recommend picking up biblos over this one because those choices are much more tense um especially because you have to make one choice at a time rather than having all the cards at hand at all times now I appreciate you could probably house rule that and it would probably improve the game actually and but I think you know why would do have to houseful it when there's a better game already out there with some additional bells and whistles as well now that being said I do think a lot of people will like this one it is a true filler game it is only 20 minutes it looks lovely on the table and you can have some good swings of momentum by you know converting one from Fallen to um you know esteemed whatever it's called so yeah there are sometimes those swings of momentum but generally speaking things will start to sort themselves out and you will know what you're going for you generally have a bullar figure fig about what your opponents are going to go for and so on yes the spies do spice it up a little bit um but if you're going to heavily invest in something then that's normally not going to be quite enough to uh to turn the tides but

still not a bad game by any means but I think it's just suffering um because there are other games out there that I would rather play than this one that do very similar things so for that reason I can't really recommend ctis xans um despite looking wonderful on the table

Progress saved