The Hungry Gamer Reviews Arkham: Traces to Nowhere
Transcript
Ooh, that looks tasty.
Welcome, folks. Today, The Hungry Gamers back with another quasi episode of Boards and Brews. Not really, but it's a minor fast quick time like the music player episode of Boards and Brews where I'm rejoined by Micromaxx and Bob who needs no last name. And we are continuing our discussion of the newest Arkham Horror The Card Game, not the $800 Game Found campaign, the card game cuz we just finished last weekend. We had to replay it, which is why it took us an extra weekend. The latest campaign pack, which is a single scenario, Traces from Nowhere, Traces to Nowhere, Traces of Nowhere. It's got Traces and Nowhere in there.
Prepositions are really all the same when you they're completely fungible when you think about it.
Exactly. That's a great word, fungible. I am actually going to put up the definition of fungible on the screen for this. But so we just finished it. And in this particular one, as I said, it's just a single story or a single mission that it was, which can be used as a one-off one-shot or in your campaign you can say, you know what, we're going to stop chasing down Yog-Sothoth or whatever his name is, and we're going to take a little side quest and do this less important thing. And there will be spoilers in this review, but we're going to contain it kind of all the spoilers in the middle. I'll be very clear about when they start and then when you can come back. But Micromaxx, can you tell us what is happening in Traces Preposition Nowhere?
Sure. Um so this is a story. This is again, I think chapter two has been a very big focus on like Arkham The City. Um so this is another sort of another example um just what just how like um you know Children of Blood was set in various parts of Arkham. This is set sort of also in Arkham specifically. We are private, you know, we are helping out a private investigator who has gone missing and who was investigating the I think what patriarch of a of a of an old family who also went missing.
It's always a patriarchy that gets you.
Well, I mean I think the patriarchy was gotten in this case, like so yeah. So but we we go around, we interview suspects. You know, we sort of we we interview suspects. We try to avoid, you know, being murdered by gangs and
And and I don't think it's a spoiler to say and abductions happen.
Oh yes, abductions happen. There's a whole mechanic around something abducts your cards and people.
Yeah, but they they come out of your hand or off off the the table and get put under something and sometimes it says test based on how many things are abducted. And so that's kind of the main new mechanic on this one. And so broadly speaking, broadly speaking, no no spoilers here, what did we like about it? I'm going to I'll jump in first cuz there's one thing that I really really liked about it and that was the abduction mechanic. I hated when it happened to me so very much cuz it took a couple really good cards from me, but I thought it was really cool that now that was something that we had to worry about. And the second time we played through, we did a pretty good job of not having all our junks abducted.
And I thought that was really cool, especially when you compared it to Children of Blood, that that that just felt like a standard mission where it's like, you know, fight stuff, don't die. So I thought that was really cool. Along with that, you mentioned the finding the not victims, the
suspects, witnesses, witnesses, suspects, victims to interview cuz there was this deck of lead. again, this is in the setup. And you had to find leads and then you would that was shuffled and they'd be flipped out.
them.
And And that's how that was dealt with. And then each one of them might have told you what you wanted to know, might not have. I thought that was a very cool mechanic that even though it was just theme, but I thought it came through really well. So that that was my favorite thing about this new one. How about you guys? What was your favorite?
I guess maybe I'll I think I can go next. And I think I was actually also going to think say something similar in that I'm just very very happy that um like the Codex mechanic where like you do a thing on a card and it tells you go go to the book and read this thing in response. Um the fact, you know, this was introduced in Feast of Hemlock Vale, sort of the end of chapter one and then integrated as like a core mechanic in the chapter tool like core game. And I'm just excited I like I think it's a great mechanic. I think it's a way for them to add a lot of flavor without trying to like squeeze it onto a card or squeeze it onto the back of a card or like do all these crazy work arounds. Um and I think they used it well here again. Like all of the characters you're able to talk to again. I think parlay was something that I think was not as much used in chapter one. And like I like going around and talking to people and you know, being able to sort of like interact and react to them. So
It was neat that as you flipped through like there's definitely branching paths that we could have gone on depending on who we talked to and did and and not. So that I thought that was a Yeah, that that's a close second for me. All right, Bob. What was your favorite?
I mean Excuse [clears throat] me. I think the um the the the feel and the flavor of it came through very well. I think the um it was it was a little surprising to me that it didn't reuse basically any core set um encounter [clears throat] sets. It was all self-contained. On the other hand, that's kind of convenient for setup and everything. Um you know, there's there's value in that. But it was a little odd to me that it was, you know, we're we're still in Arkham. It's kind of interesting that it used all new locations and sets and everything. But that being said, it felt very Arkham-y. It felt like a pulpy detective adventure, You know, it was all of that. I think it played well. The kind of I don't I'm not going to dignify that. Um no, I think it I I I think that part of it was good. Um I think it's I think it might be telling that we're most of our praise has been for the fluff side of things. I guess we'll get to mechanics. Abductions and mechanic and there's there's there's some replayability we talked about. I don't know. I I I am struggling to come up with anything mechanically that I think this
Okay. Well okay. Well here it comes. Now now not spoiler yet.
we get into that, before we do the hate train, I will say I think the feel of it was very good. Narratively, you know, the the the vibe you get from this is fun. If you're into kind of classic you know, Call of Cthulhu, Arkham Horror, you know, gumshoe detective stuff in 1920s New England, boom, nailed it.
Yeah. And And I think now before we we really cuz we are we're all going to name the same thing as what didn't work first the most, but before before we jump into that, cuz that's going to have to lead directly into some spoilers, I'm going to phrase it in the a term you guys taught me. There is the possibility and this is what we all didn't like for a soft lock. I didn't know what that meant until it happened cuz these two were like, oh is this a soft lock? This I was like yeah, sure. And now I know there is it is possible for you to spend a long time still playing the game and you just don't know that you have already lost. We had lost the first time, I don't know, 40 minutes before we were like, did we lose?
And we we had already lost. Now before we open up the spoiler bag, is there anything else that wasn't your favorite about this? I will throw it. I thought it was a little bit long for for a a scenario, but it was a standalone, but it was like still 3 hours or 3 and 1/2 hours, something like that.
We we played for a while and I don't think we spent a lot of that time, you know, kind of faffing about, right? Like we we we played. There wasn't a lot of analysis paralysis or anything like that. We we went through it and yeah, it's just long. I I agree with that. Um you know, that's
Yeah.
I don't know I'm I'm so used to playing two player that I'm not calibrated for three player. I think that is within the range of how long a lot some scenarios in campaign play can be, but definitely on the upper end. Um
And and I'll throw that I think I was going to throw out two things. I think one other thing that I liked a little bit from the mechanic side was I think this is effectively like part of the setup as well. So like the fact that like when you talk to people, you like interact with the token bag and you like, you know, change tokens and things. Like I thought that was actually a pretty cool mechanic. I think I haven't seen a lot of because then it actually it does sort of interact with how probabilities and what happens for the like the rest of the scenario. So that that adds in a little bit of extra spice. I And then I think I'll also say yeah, again, I think maybe on one hand, like you don't want your standalone to be way too short cuz then you're like, why did I, you know, I I can't replay this? Um you know, again, this I think primarily designed by Nicholas Corey, who um one of the main one of the devs on Arkham who also did Murder at um the Excelsior Hotel. But I'm sort of saying that because it's sort of somewhat similar in that there's like an an opening intro and then like sort of it sets you know, like things get set up and then there's like an additional sort of an additional later stage after that's, you know, sort of after that sort of initial phase. So like you know, it is a it is almost sort of like two or like it's like a scenario in half that sort of is like jammed together into one scenario. So Yeah, so and just
And just
And just a little little side note talking about the token bag. Can we just take a moment to recognize that I had one failed pull the entire day and it wasn't even for something that mattered. Well, but
In in our second successful run.
To to our second successful run. Our first successful run I did my normal nonsense.
successful. Yeah, well.
Well, Bob pulled the autofail five or six times.
And and and for those of you watching with with a background in Arkham, for what I was pulling the autofail on was lock picks. I upgraded lock picks as Andre Katana. So I should should never be failing that test and never losing those charges. Obviously I'm only ever going to take a lock picks test when I'm up a lot, so the only way you would fail is with the autofail, so it's not interesting to say that I lost all three charges to the autofail. My first two tests on this lock picks I pulled the autofail and I was very salty about it.
It was very salty about it.
All right, we are opening the spoiler section, so if you don't want any spoilers on this, use the timestamp, jump to the end, and you'll times on the screen right now. All right. Let let us have it. Here we go. I'm I'm going to let you guys take the lead cuz look, we got we got locked out and that was annoying.
Yeah, it's it's too swingy. Um it's too This is already a swingy game. You know, Max and I have pulled this before. We've gotten to the end of a scenario, especially one that we're not playing blind for the first time where we've seen it before and maybe should know better and we're like we did some things wrong there and also we had some horrific luck and we just want to take a mulligan on it. Like sometimes it's Arkham, you just lose a scenario to some bad luck or you get a bad outcome. That happens. It's part of the game. It's a deck game. There's a randomness mechanic with the chaos bag. On top of that, this scenario has too much randomness in it. It is too swingy, I think. The leads deck is a randomization mechanic. You can get very unlucky with the leads deck. You can get unlucky with spawning the abductor in act agenda two, whichever one it is, which we didn't at all in our successful playthrough, which I think was a big factor.
And then you can This can be mitigated a bit with with smarter play, which we did the second time, but you can get pretty unlucky with those witnesses just getting killed, which I guess we're in the spoiler The soft lock, if you have not encountered this, is you need to interrogate successfully two witnesses to um progress. It's pretty easy to wind up losing two of the three witnesses, at which point you cannot progress. There's no resign option. So you're then just sitting around ticking out the doom clock, which is not fun.
For for for I don't know, the 45 minutes we did it and those are how
so yeah, we
Well, we thought we we thought we were locked and we're like, let's try it anyway.
We we hit the condition early. Yeah, yeah, we hit the condition early and didn't know yet for sure that there was no way out of it.
And for
then, once we realized we were locked, we were like, well, there's one of eight doom on this agenda. Should we play seven pointless turns or just pack up? And we just packed up, which again is a bummer of a feeling. There's no resign option either. So that's the other thing. And I know you've been trying to send me Mac. My last throw-in complaint. If you play this in campaign play and you hit the soft lock, I'm pretty sure the failure condition on the resolution is all the investigators were killed. You're going to lose your campaign because there's no way to walk away from this, I don't know, kind of low stakes noir plot. I don't know. It's weird. I didn't care for that. Go ahead, Max.
I think I was just going to say that and and like I think for those who hopefully don't run into it and are like, what are they talking about, which you know, awesome. Um
We hate you, but you.
but I I think part of the point is that not all of the witnesses contribute to moving the scenario forward. So like you can have like your leads and like your leads deck sort of ala Explore Deck and whatnot can has encounter cards in there. So like effectively you can have a non-empty leads deck but none of but but like nothing that will actually advance the agenda and and like the game will sort of like let you keep playing but then like you can't act you're you're locked out of the agenda of of the agenda.
some of those as you mentioned like they're they're red herrings.
Yeah.
That's the you your witness it's they're useless. And so
Or they're helpful if you advance, you know, type of thing like, he, you know, but like
phased with that.
But yeah, they're just
But like they don't they don't directly progress you. So
And and to Bob's point of the randomness to it, it's all the the bag is already punishing, right? It's just it's going to be negative almost all the time. You have that randomness, but then we kept the way our uh the the cards at the beginning of the round were coming out and what we were getting and stuff was being abducted left and right. We were losing good stuff. They were taking away the witnesses that we had just because that's the way the deck was and then the other ones were all the way at the bottom of the deck and then we get to them there's a here's a witness. It's a red herring. It it was long and and the swing I thought was pretty brutal for
then we played better, played smarter with better decks the second time through. Obviously that's what you would do. That's the difference between blind play and a replay. But we also got much luckier. We we you know, the witness the useful witnesses were towards the top of the deck, not the second at the bottom. We never spawned the abductor other than the one mandatory time on an act change. Like it was it was dramatically better. I think I kind of feel though, you know, who knows, that we swung from, you know, below average luck the first time to quite above average luck the second time. I don't know that we necessarily merited the outcome we got. We got kind of lucky. But that's just that's part of the that's the thing with this scenario. I think it's very swingy like that.
Yeah, and then the last thing I'll I'll just say is while I enjoyed playing through and I enjoyed the story, to your point, yeah, what it it was it was a ham sandwich, right? I mean it was just like, oh yes, and we went to this town and had a ham sandwich and she walked into my room with legs as long as can be and I was like, here's a sandwich and we were done. Like it wasn't particularly exciting. It was like a slice of life in Arkham Land.
Yeah, and I think that's fine for a side scenario. Um this is I'm kind of curious how my feelings on this will evolve in the context of chapter two with the shorter campaigns. Like like throwing this into a Scarlet Keys run would be cool. That'd would It's a it's a it's a pop back to Arkham and have a filler episode in your otherwise maybe somewhat intense Scarlet Keys run.
So it's like in your your anime season you have the we're going to go to the DMV or the beach.
That's exactly that's exactly right.
I I like how you I like how you chose Scarlet Key, you know, as as the other scenario that involves abducting cards, you know, like
think that thematically fits. B it's fine to go back to Arkham. It'd be weird if you were in like the jungles of Forgotten Age and then oh we popped back up to solve this detective mystery.
The the other I did want to sort of like throw in like as we were talking sort of about the swinginess. Like I think the other other thing around the soft lock is it's just I think yeah again the fact that the witnesses have like two sanity um and like there's a you know there's a chaos token that puts sanity damage on them. You know like and I think you know then like we have an abductor like you know that I think even will automatically teleport to them and like start you know trying to take like it was just a little they were just like a little too weak or like if there was maybe an ability for us to heal them or if they had you know three sanity instead of two then like it might have been like enough to like you know that might have also sort of given it enough so that we had like the time
it wouldn't have been a bad deal.
per they should be one per investigator sanity to a minimum of two. Like like that's that's this is this goes to my feeling that this probably just needed like another two weeks of QA. Like I think probably this is some of this stuff you could get iron out of it and some of it maybe is structural but I think some of this stuff just could be tweaked and
And we're hoping I think you know hoping that there might be like an errata or a
And nothing
or a something that you know comes out that you know smart people rebound it a little bit but
And I think mechanically speaking before we end our spoiler section here it was really I thought a bummer that in the second play we did it was like no no no don't flip a lead cuz you're our third player in the round and if we don't have someone with all their actions, we're going to get soft locked again. And I and I thought that was a bit of a miss.
Yeah.
Oh, go ahead.
I was going to say some of that is, I think, an okay kind of skill expression thing. Like Max and I tend to do this with advancing the act a lot too. Like Don't don't look at me like that. We do.
No. What are we doing?
We will sometimes say, okay, we if you have a if you have a may condition on an act advance, you don't do it with the last action of the last player in the investigation phase, right? You sit out a mythos phase, and then you advance when all players have their actions. Some of that, I think, is a is an okay like this is a gameplay choice that you're allowed to make. And, you know, it's fine for the game to give you options even if some of them are sometimes suboptimal. It certainly was annoying our first time through when we spawned it, and it just instant died in the mythos phase. Like it got abducted the abductor hit it for one, and one of us pulled the bad symbol. And that's why again, I think it should probably be one per. Like if you have more pulls, you just have that many more chances to kill it. That's annoying. Um but some of that is is a like we knew that. We learned that after the blind run, and that's that's a skill expression type thing.
And so I know we're all on the clock here. We're we're all on the clock here, so we're going to I'm going to wrap our spoiler section. I'm sorry, Max. I'm going to wrap our spoiler section. And so everybody, welcome back. The spoilers are over. Max had something really important to say, and I cut him off cuz we're on a timer tonight. And so here here's what what I'm going to leave us with. Did you have fun? Would you play it again? And do you recommend the Uber fan gets it? Now, I can't speak to the Uber fan cuz I don't know it like you guys do. I will say I did have fun playing with y'all, especially Bob pulling the fails over and over again. Would I play it again? I would, but I would say maybe we need a house rule or two based off the stuff we said in spoilers. And so uh we'll have Bob, you go next those three questions, and then I'll leave let Max wrap it up for us.
I have the opposite problem to you in terms of the Uber fan. Like, apart from a couple very rare things that are out of print, Max and I own everything I ever released for this game. Like, yes, we think you should buy it. But like, maybe we're not the most If you if you are not a completionist for Arkham, I think this one's probably not essential. I would I would maybe, you know, play some old standalones with chapter two you know, chapter two characters or or you know, wait to see what else comes out. I don't think this one's essential even in the already somewhat optional category of standalone scenarios. But I absolutely had fun, you know, because I almost always have fun playing Arkham. I really like this game. So again, not the most useful answer.
you play it again?
Yeah, I would I would give it another try. I do think there's some interesting replayability in there. It's not like the most exciting form of replayability. We didn't talk about that too much in spoilers. I won't bring it up here, but you know, you could play it again and see some other stuff. So yeah, I would play I would try it again.
All right, Max.
I think I think I I think similar feelings to Bob there. It's like I think it is not yeah, it is not necessarily an essential standalone like I don't know if it ranks at like the top of my standalone list. Like I think I want to like I feel like again, I think this is most similar to like at least for me to like Murder on the Execlsiar and I would probably I think that one like nail nails nails the combination of sort of like replayability and like and and just like story a bit more. But like yeah, I I think I had fun. I'm glad we played it again and had a better experience. Um you know, the and like and got to and got to go through it. And again, I'm like I'm excited to to like continue seeing the stuff they put out. So
All right, so there you have it, folks. As always well, as always for the second time, thank you Micro Max and Bob who needs no last name for joining me and schooling me on this. And I'll say I now those are the first time that we played through and I was like, okay, I know what's going on here. I wasn't lost. Every and then I was like, I don't know what you guys are talking about, you and your red clock, but I wasn't lost. I knew what was going on. I had a great time. I look forward to whatever it is they they bring out next. Everybody, if you enjoyed the episode, like, subscribe, share, do all those things. Buy your Arkham stuff. Thank you so much for watching. Have a wonderful wonderful day.
And shout out Red Clock. It's worth 10 XP. It's so fun.