Philosophia: Floating World {Solo Variant}: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for the solo variant for philosophia floating world which is one that i was absolutely excited about because the multiplayer game is absolutely fascinating with the unique way that you deck build and the choices that you're giving other players and how uh like the actions that you're going to be able to do on your turn they're the ones that are actively deciding hey here is here's what i have to give you like and what makes philosophy a floating world so great is all removed in the solo variant i am not a fan of it at all and there's a couple reasons one everything about the unme or the ai player is dictated by die rolls like they it it brings in no decision as like to rep to like replicate an actual human player it's really just someone there to kind of sort of get in the way of do things and there's really a timer on what you want to do and for me that's not a solo variant that i like like i i much enjoy solar variant games where it's like oh i want to play this game i'll play that too and this the ai acts like another player and to me this ai does not at all like he would make decisions that completely made zero sense and it
almost seems like it was designed that way because to counteract the randomness of the dice they allow him to get multiple gun borrower tokens that are going to be heavily influenced by the die rules and what i mean by that is in the regular game you actively have to move around you actively have to get search cards you have to get uh location uh cards that let you flip them to to reduce the amount of okay well where could you possibly be uh in this in the regular or in the the solo variant you just flat out cannot do search actions until you like grudgingly go through and flip all those tokens and so because in the in the i mean that's 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 14 locations you have two um and your opponent has two so there are uh 10 locations so you have to actively do that action 10 times and your deck only comes with one so then you have to rely upon going through the actual destiny or the location cards to find the cards that let you do that and there are few and far between actions like that that let you just go out and flip and flip a token because boy oh boy is that just obscene that you flat out cannot do an action until that
is completely taken and i despise that because it completely removes one of the ways that you can win you just have to basically have a thin deck and go through and just flip all those just to be able to be like okay now they're all gone and then you have to do it two more times just to find the two locations that that they're at to be able to get one of the gombaru whereas all he has to do is happen and it's to counteract the fact that he may never roll the search like location everything is like it's drawn out it's boring it's stretched to counter the fact that you have a die that determines his actions like yeah i find it completely unbalanced because in one way it's like yes you have to go through all those locations as as a player um which take about as much time as like him going through this entire deck but the problem is is you know for a fact that you only have those certain actions in your uh in your deck whereas he could roll the search action every single time and then it's like oh okay he moves to sado oh he moves to kobe oh he moves to osaka oh well osaka is my hidden location he found it look at that like but or he could just never roll that die or that icon and it's just so wonky like it makes it a strain on you to basically build your deck like [ __ ] to counteract the fact that he may or may
not do a certain action i very much despise that the other thing is uh the fact that he the ai can get the chi a tokens which are if you get a wisdom card with one of each uh icon you discard all four of those immediately and get a chi token you as the player can only ever get one of those you can only ever get one of each ganbaru token because you need for them to win or two and find the location well finding the location of the ai is basically impossible so you're trying to go for those four and you're sitting there and because the ai does all of his actions before you do yours uh you basically have to be like okay well i built to study okay i need i need one shrine there's a couple there like in one instance it's like okay i need one of those symbols and there's three cards there oh he rolled he rolled study three times so he's just taking all three of those because he can you can only ever have a max of four wisdom cards the ai can have as many as they want for that very reason the fact that oh he might roll study every single time so he just gets to amass a pile and by that point it's just like okay well surprise it comes with no surprise in the run-through he won by getting three chi a tokens and his pagoda i was surprised that whenever he built that he was actually able to build his pagoda blew my mind because it wasn't through any luck it wasn't through any
decision or or instance oh if you roll this and he does this no it's just oh he just happened to have the stuff from just random dumb luck and he gets to build it i was like okay cool that's fine like going through the the different gumbaru tokens and victory conditions i was i was okay great he he can actually do things other than just a mass he might as well just have the entire wisdom deck because what's extremely frustrating is it's not guaranteed that the ai is gonna get all individual um icons which is once again they're trying to compensate for the randomness it's like yeah you know it might be luck it's it's absolutely luck of the draw with the wisdom cards anyway so he might just have a massive pile of cards and he just needs one to get one token it's like okay well that's fine but i'm the one actually playing the game and i need one i need one shrine and when he takes all of them and then we you replenish the wisdom options it's like okay well no shrines came out so i can't and and no wheels i don't remember what those are called but it's like okay so i can't build my shrines i can't build my pagodas because all the stuff that was available is in his deck of wisdom cards it's like okay so now i've effectively had two tokens like everything on those gunbaru are actively
removed from you being able to do anything on your turn just because he gets to do everything on his turn before you and that's not fun in any way like the way that this game works there's two ways to play it in multiplayer either you take turns or everything simultaneous with simultaneous you everyone goes it's just like okay i'm ready for the action phase everyone agrees and then you start going now you prioritize what you want to do ahead of time so if i want to take if there's a shrine in a wisdom and i go to take that and someone else goes oh actually i was going to do that too then you go off initiative it's like oh i'm actually ahead of you so i'm gonna take it and then you move it down boom it's quick it's done and then you move on and then now it's in a two-player game if you go for another thing oh i actually want this shuriken then that person now can be like oh i also want that shuriken and well you're higher on the initiative you pay for it you take it that's how it goes uh the other way is taking turns okay my turn i'm gonna do this i went i go first i want the shuriken i get to go everything moves down and then the then the next person goes okay dang man i really wanted that shuriken but okay so my action i'll just get the umi or i'll flip a location and you go back and forth this game is horrendously bad and boring whenever it's okay you as a player do everything you want to do oh you get to take the wisdom card before me oh you could take the item oh you get
to take the location card oh you get to kill the monster oh you get to do everything that you want to do before i even get a chance to do it and that's not fun and that is the ai that's the solo variant of this game and to compensate for that is once again with this stupid die this die ruins everything about this game it's just like oh okay well uh all right i guess he's gonna study again oh look at that in my in my demo in my example he's studying again and then third action he's building uh well he doesn't have any money so and that's the other thing it's like the way that they phrase the the the rules for building or for for actions it just says ignore it that could be taken in one of two ways either that burns an action of his or you ignore it and you roll until you can do something that he does i took it as because he gets almost everything for free that that counts as one of his actions otherwise this game would just be absolute nonsense and you'd have zero chance the like the fact that it's like okay well he rolled a build oh he doesn't have any shrines so he that's one that's one of his burnt actions uh and that happened multiple times like in the very first turn he rolled three build actions in a row and i'm like well he doesn't have shrines he definitely has builders but he doesn't have any shrine wisdom cards so i guess he just doesn't do anything which once again doesn't replicate an actual player it it represents someone who doesn't like this game and they're trying to throw it it's like oh yeah i
kept all the cards let me build oh well guess i can't do anything on my turn that's how it felt the entire time but yes somehow they still win i did not like anything about this actual solar variant because it doesn't let me do the unique deck building you you basically are playing a solo deck builder i mean that's exactly what you're doing and you draw you draw cards because that's the thing is obviously when you're deck building your entire starting deck has free cards so you get you get choices there but it's not until you buy cards that you get them you know as options but in the multiplayer game if you have you know high value cards like this card costs three yeah your opponent is most likely going to discard that but they may not they may be like oh i really don't want you like like in this particular hand i don't want you to study because i want that for that card ahead of time so i'm gonna actually discard that so you don't have that as an option unless you burn some of your time tokens but instead uh the way that this game works is you build and while your deck is mostly high value uh cost cards so you draw your hand you're like oh never using that okay let me just shuffle and uh all right these are the two and then here's my here's my three and i'll pick which is it takes away the strategy of actually deck building because whenever you're
playing a multiplayer game you build not just for yourself but in a way that makes your opponent have to decide what they are wanting to do because you hand them your cards and then you're like okay you are deciding what two and what three i get to choose from and they're gonna be like oh man like all of these cards are good i don't want you to do any of them so they're trying to minimize your potential or be like okay either i'm gonna give you three cards that are kind of good or maybe not that good but you get some resources or here are two cards that let you do actions but you get no resources and you as a player take those back and you decide you should theoretically have that here but because you're so limited and the ai gets to go before you and everything it's like i personally just didn't care on what three i got there was one time i actually bought a an item where i was like okay great i'm gonna use it so i can use all five of my cards and it ended up being a great turn but that was so few and far between most the time i was sitting here just man managing his dumb ass resources that he always had and then just rolling his action die and having him do none of them half the time except study because there were times where he'd fry the monster and he can find the monster anywhere that's fine i didn't mind that we have to go to actual locations to flip them but we also have the ability to prep i can actively go and shop he has to roll to shop and then it's like oh there's no items there okay
he burns the time to replace them and then there were no items there again so it's like okay well i guess he just doesn't do that and then now he fights well he can't fight because he has no stupid items it's like this was like the dumbest player that you could potentially have who doesn't who has no clue what's going on they didn't read the rules ahead of time you didn't teach them how to play the game but yet they somehow win through dumb luck it's absolutely infuriating there was never a time when i'm sitting here like man this ai is really smart okay how am i gonna how am i gonna outplay a computer like in in all the um uh garfield games the the west kingdom games uh except for architects i haven't done the solo for that uh uh paladins and vi counts it's like oh this does kind of feel like an ai not necessarily because they're still decisions but they they take up spots they remove items that feel like another person could have potentially taken that from you oh they moved their people there so now it's blocked it's like okay well [ __ ] i was gonna go there so potentially in a multiplayer game someone would have gone there before me okay uh in anachrony like my favorite solo game that truly feels like an ai player that you know slots different workers and moves them around and so now this isn't necessarily a work replacement game but the ais in those games if they don't feel like another player they at least feel
like somewhat of a competent person who actually knows okay i i'll block this and then so you have to make your decisions around that because this die here you cannot plan for what they're gonna do you can hope and have your cards and be like oh i want to study a lot so i can get all those cards i need oh nope he took all of them and then now the three available you don't want it's it's very infuriating because there's not enough options for you to be like well he's gonna go the wisdom card route i'll go killing monsters out because once again you as a player can only ever kill one monster but once again the ai player can kill as many so if he happens to only roll shopping and coins for the collection phase and monsters he'll compensate for that by constantly buying uh items and then killing monsters so he can get multiple bushido tokens whereas you only have to do it once but once again that's entirely random and half the game he's either getting lucky and just constantly taking the cards or the other half he's doing nothing and you're just like i'm i'm caught in a chaotic mess of a solo variant it just isn't well thought out and you miss a lot of what makes philosophia like a unique deck builder set in a beautiful game the art is absolutely stunning you may you just lose all decision making because of what your opponents
may or may not be wanting to do because you can actively look at it you know it's a race kind of to for gumbaru or a race once more people are revealing locations to be like oh [ __ ] okay that's narrowing down they might figure out where i'm at and they just need they already have two of the tokens they just need to find my location so now it's a race to try and find yours before theirs and getting penalized if you find their um decoy so boy was it just it it tanked so quickly i got absolutely tired of managing their tokens and once again this die is so stupid because they they just actively feel it feels like they had to die with all six actions on it they didn't know how to balance it so they just went okay we're gonna just try and mitigate the randomness so he's all the ai is almost always gonna have four toe but he doesn't obviously he gains them throughout the game but then it's like oh if he collects you know let's say all three of his collections are so that means he's going to get do six total action so oh okay oh now he searches okay he goes to he goes to thule okay he fights can't he has no eddie okay he fights he can't he has no he's no items all right he's gonna buy hey now he could buy a shuriken and then up here's another action he studies he studies he studies he studies like it's just it it it blows my mind this that that die to
determine his his actions is just so stupid um and they're like backpedaling trying to figure out how to make it work and i guess technically yes it worked you can play this game solo i promise you just get one other person this game is fantastic at two it is great at at low player counts and it compensates for higher player accounts just because in a for the six player game you have uh like just i mean you have more locations and it's that that quicker of a race it's just yeah it there's no reason to play this solo huh so i mean yeah even because technically the other thing it has going for it is it's like hey you can have multiple ai which sounds super cool because most of the time yes it is you and then the the solo variant player and there's been a few that come out that actually have like dummy characters a root for example you can put in one if you don't have like if you really want to play a five player game you only have four you can throw in the dummy player uh tapestry i think also has that um at least tapestry solar variant comp like plays as if it's a three player game and does that pretty well here it's like there is no reason if i had two players and i want to for some reason play a third a three player game there's absolutely no way i would ever
put this in to compensate because it's like great because at that point yeah you do you do go back to um you know drawing six cards handing it to the to the player you don't do the weird thing that the the 1v1 uh solar variant is so you and the other human player are trading cards and making that decision and then this thing just gets in the way so it's like you might as well just play this only at two and don't worry about this dumbass stumbling around just kind of studying all over the place taking [ __ ] from both you because then you're both just annoyed uh because not only are you trying to compete against a human player you're competing against some bumbling drunk that has no idea what's going on this represents the person who was on this phone the entire time while you well everyone else is trying to play i really do not like this solo variant and it's even and it's it makes me dislike it even more because i like the base game competitively so much so with all that being said uh on a scale of 110 i'm gonna give the solo variant for philosophia floating world a three i think it is significantly below average uh it technically does work he won as well through uh i mean really just rolling the same icon over and over it isn't necessarily that long either it's about an hour but i think everything about it just hinders you as a player you're really just trying to battle against sheer dumb luck and i
really don't like anything about it so i'm gonna give it a three out of ten and that's my thoughts on the solar variant for philosophia floating world let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you