10 Biggest 'What If...' Moments In Wrestling History
Transcript
Hello, I'm Adam, your Uatu, the watcher from Blompco Incorporated, traveling the wrestling multiverse looking for importance since 2015. And cosmic thank yous to Chris Rhoades for commissioning this list, asking me to look back at some of the moments in wrestling history where things could have gone very differently indeed. See, WWE's motto is then, now, forever with [clears throat] a together tacked on because WWE is a company that cares very much about you until you run out of money, in which case you can die, you filthy casual. The then, now, forever is very much by design to give you an idea that not only is WWE your omnipresent wrestle lord, but that such a thing was always an inevitability. The WWE's success was fated to be, birthed by the twin titans of Hulkamania and Vince McMahon's genius. But of course, that's not true. Fate is what we make up to stop ourselves from going mad at the sheer fragility of life, how every choice we make can have a truly devastating number of consequences and trying to plan anything is like trying to grab a race horse by its eyelashes.
Wrestling history is full of those precarious moments when decades and careers and even livelihoods find themselves altered by a coin flip that very almost came up tails. A few quick rules for this list because of course, rules help control the fun. There's going to be no ranking. I'm just going to do these in chronological order. And also, more importantly, these have to be relatively isolated moments. Obviously, we could ask what if WCW never went out of business. But that company was killed by a thousand paper cuts rather than one single ill-fated decision. These are all choices, accidents, days where wrestling was set on a wildly different course whether we knew it or not. I'm Adam from Blompco Incorporated. Here are my 10 biggest what if moments in wrestling history. If you want to be like Chris Rhoades and commission your own top 10 list, you can. You can head on over to patreon.com/blompco where you can order your own. Check out a number of exclusive top 10s that we have hidden away over there. There's so many and it's lovely. Number one, what if WrestleMania one had flopped in 1985?
Like all parents, WWE have cute little lies they tell their children to amuse themselves. Like, we love you or it happens to everyone. We had 93,000 people at WrestleMania 3, said WWE. The Undertaker is our best pure striker, said WWE. You are the authority now, said WWE. One little lie that WWE liked to push is the life or death narrative of WrestleMania one. That Vince McMahon leveraged everything for that one show. And if it had flopped, then WWE definitely would have gone bankrupt and would have died and would have exploded and all of their bits would have fallen on you. The truth isn't anywhere near that dramatic. Before WrestleMania even aired, WWE had secured deals with CBS and NBC, providing them with TV slots for primetime wrestling and the Hulk Hogan's Rock 'n' Wrestling cartoon. If you didn't know that existed, here's a clip.
[screaming]
What you going to Scooby-Doo, brother? Those deals meant that WWE had cash in the bank. So no, WWE would not have immediately folded, but it certainly would have meant slower expansion. Vince might have lost a few of his bigger, more expensive talents back to the territories. And almost certainly, it would have meant there would be no WrestleMania as a brand. Instead, it's much more likely that Jim Crockett's Starrcade would have become the sort of industry leader through most of the '80s. WWE likely would have tried the big supercard thing again, but probably with fewer celebrities to keep the costs down. And so, the whole identity of WrestleMania as this mainstream crossover pageant might not exist today. And we might not have had a WrestleMania prominently featuring Pat McAfee, Lil Yachty, Jelly Roll, and IShowSpeed. And I think we'd all rather be dead than live in that reality.
Number two, what if Magnum T.A. stayed healthy in 1986? Some wrestlers become a big deal despite a fundamental lack of ability. Whoops, how did that unrelated picture of Lex Luger get there? Some wrestlers never become the big deal that they in fact deserve to be. Whoops, how did that unrelated picture of me wrestling my five-star match with Rampage Brown get there? And some have their opportunity removed by a cruel twist of circumstance so we'll never truly know. There are loads of what if scenarios where wrestlers never have that one career-changing injury. What if Bret Hart never suffered that kick? What if Austin never took that piledriver? And what if Brian Pillman never took that motorcycle ride? But maybe the biggest what if of all time goes to Magnum T.A. A wrestler poised on the edge of a super push in Jim Crockett, a man reportedly booked to beat Ric Flair for the NWA Heavyweight Championship at Starrcade '86, but who got in a serious accident when his Porsche went off the road near weeks before the show, forcing him into retirement. Conventional wisdom has it that had Magnum emerged as the major babyface in JCP, then that would have delayed the rise of Sting, perhaps derailed the Flair-Steamboat rivalry, but also, would he have then made the jump to WWE, a company looking to replace its own Hulk Hogan in the early '90s? It almost certainly would have meant fewer world titles for Ric Flair.
And that stat would have consequences reaching as far as WrestleMania [ __ ] 41. Number three, what if Vince is found guilty in 1994? The steroid scandal changed everything. It changed the world's rosy perception of WWE as family-friendly entertainment. It changed the landscape of the locker room. It changed Hulk Hogan. Look how much this [ __ ] shrank. Like Vince left the heat to iron his washer-dryer. In 1990, Dr. George Zahorian was arrested for steroid distribution. And after his conviction, over the course of 1991, we saw an exodus from WWE of the suspiciously jacked Hulk Hogan, the dubiously swole Ultimate Warrior, the curiously huge Sid Justice, and overtly thick British Bulldog, to name but a few. Not only did the scandal usher in the new generation of smaller, better wrestlers like Bret and Shawn, but Vince himself was put on trial, eventually found not guilty in July '94 of steroid distribution and conspiracy to distribute steroids.
Unlike WrestleMania one, if Vince had been found guilty, there's actually a much stronger case to be made here for WWE going bankrupt. Jerry Jarrett was waiting to take over the reins if Vince left, but this was about the time where business was all the way down. Without Vince and the Mr. McMahon character, is there a strong enough counter to WCW and the nWo? Does the locker room get spooked by Vince's sudden and public departure? And does the company lose even bigger stars to Ted Turner? I'm honestly not sure WWE makes it through 1995, the worst business year ever, under those circumstances. Number four, what if Hall and Nash stick with WWF in 1996? Speaking of the New World Order, holy [ __ ] what if Hall and Nash stay in the Fed? You see, with Vince's running dry in the lean years of the mid-'90s, WCW started to make big plays for some of WWE's stars. Eric Bischoff would drive a truck of money to people's houses and say, "Hey, more money for less work." And many wrestlers said, "Oh, go on then." Kevin Nash, aka Diesel, and Scott Hall, aka Razor Ramon, were two such men. Their departure had crazy consequences. Not only did their arrival herald the start of the nWo storyline, which made wrestling cool again after years of camp '90s bollocks, it kept WCW in business. It made Hulk Hogan a proper star again. It forced WWE to choose their own, more adult approach. And beyond that, the curtain call the Kliq
performed when Hunter and Shawn hugged Razor and Diesel goodbye at Madison Square Garden and someone caught it on camera and Vince went [ __ ] apeshit. That saw Steve Austin being given the King of the Ring push that was supposed to be given to Triple H. That led to Austin 3:16 and Jesus Christ's jumper is now just a pile of wool on the floor. Austin's rise was likely inevitable, but without former WWF champion Diesel crossing the street, would an invasion angle have anywhere near enough juice to finally lure Hulk Hogan into a heel turn? What if mid-'90s family-friendly wrestling continued forever? It would be like how Raw was in 2010, but forever. [ __ ] ah! Number five, what if Bret didn't leave in 1997? In 1996, partially in response to Hall and Nash leaving, Vince locked Bret Hart down with a 20-year multi-million dollar contract.
On the way home from signing it, however, Vince decided to check his bank balance and immediately went, "Oh, fuck!" By 1997, Bret wanted to go, Vince couldn't really afford to keep him, and the two men mutually agreed to void that contract, leading to an incident very rarely reported on in wrestling YouTube, the Let me hang on a sec. Montreal screwjob. Without this one incident, without the screwjob, without Vince publicly shafting Bret Hart out of the WWF title and sending him packing to WCW, it's genuinely hard to reckon with what happens next in the actual year. Honestly, WCW probably still goes out of business. But what the hell else happens? Without the screwjob, does Mr. McMahon emerge as a heel on-screen character at all? Do we have to have Vince on commentary screaming what a maneuver throughout the entire 1990s?
Jim the Anvil Neidhart, British Bulldog, and Rick Rude wouldn't have quit, and Bret would not have wrestled Goldberg at Starrcade 2000, meaning he could have been at the top of WWE for years after. What does that do to the ascendancy of Steve Austin, The Rock, Triple H, especially if main event money remains tight because of this contract? Is Steve Austin
who he is without Mr. McMahon? And maybe, perhaps, if his brother was still around, would Owen Hart have reverted to his blue blazer gimmick, which is, as far as I think I can speculate in good taste. The screwjob is perhaps the biggest canon event in WWE history, and what if it never happened? Number six, what if Eric Bischoff had bought WCW in 2001? I don't think there's one single incident that stops WCW from going out of business. Maybe signing Hulk Hogan because that ushered in the age of former fed guys coming in with fat contracts and creative control. But then, without Hogan, WCW would never have had the record-breaking year of 1997 and would have kept losing money. While WCW being put up for sale by AOL Time Warner feels inevitable, its purchase by Vince McMahon is actually much less so. In 2001, Eric Bischoff and a media company called Fusient, I hope I'm pronouncing I I don't hope I'm pronouncing that correctly. I don't care. They made a bid for World Championship Wrestling. Rumors swirled about then a big reset pay-per-view being planned in Las Vegas called The Big Bang with weekly shows then run in residence in Sin City for the foreseeable. The deal fell through, but what if it had been accepted? I mean, easy predictions to get out of the way are well, there's no invasion, and oh, no.
That's too bad. Some of the bigger, more expensive guys might still have jumped, but the guys who were so committed to WCW working that they went and debased themselves for Vince, guys like Booker T, DDP, they probably would have stayed. Bischoff has gone on record saying he would have made a big play for RVD and focused on cruiserweights, so Rey Mysterio might never have crossed over. Honestly, it probably would have just become what TNA became with cruiserweights instead of an X Division and almost exactly the same amount of Jeff Jarrett. But, does that mean no brand split for WWE? Certainly no Eric Bischoff as general manager. WWE's business likely wouldn't have been hurt too much. They'd probably have to work a lot harder with their old rivals still around, albeit in a diminished form. I have a hard time seeing how the industry would have been made worse if Eric had succeeded, but then again, I would say that.
Love you, Dad. Number seven, what if Eddie hadn't passed in 2005? So, I'm not going to joke around for this one because this is a really dark chapter in wrestling history. In November 2005, Eddie Guerrero passed away from heart failure in his Minneapolis hotel room, and apart from the obvious tragedy of losing Eddie after he had scratched and clawed his way to the top of WWE reputedly weeks before another world title run, there were significant knock-on effects from his passing to make fans wonder what if Eddie was with people that night and had been able to receive medical attention earlier. In terms of the on-screen, well, you certainly wouldn't have got Rey's Rumble or world title wins, but it likely wouldn't have halted the rise of Batista or Cena. However, the behind-the-scenes ramifications would be much bigger.
Eddie's death is widely seen as contributing heavily to Chris Benoit's depression prior to what happened in 2007 with people saying that Chris never got over Eddie's passing. Although, with the extent of Benoit's CTE, if Eddie had lived, Benoit's mental deterioration most likely still would have occurred, but maybe it would have been more jarring without Eddie's passing serving as an explanation for that depression, and maybe it would have made the mental deterioration easier to spot. Either way, it is more easy to speculate about the existence of WWE's talent wellness policy, launched in direct response to Eddie's death, monitoring WWE wrestlers for drug misuse as well as annual cardiac screenings. It's possible that without Eddie's death, the overall health of the industry would have been much worse for not having that policy in place for years. MVP, for instance, was diagnosed with a heart condition during a wellness policy checkup that could have been fatal if left undiagnosed.
It's difficult to speculate around this, but what's not difficult to say is rest in peace, Eddie Guerrero. You are still very much missed. Number eight, what if Apollo 55 didn't break up in 2013? If you just said, "Who?" out loud, then kind of fair enough, but also please know that Tempest is now on his way to your house with vengeance in his heart and poutine in his pocket. Apollo 55, or Apollo Go Go, were the tag team of Ryusuke Taguchi and Prince Devitt. If you just said, "Who?" out loud, then I'm sorry, but Tempest is now inside your house. 13 years ago, at Invasion Attack 2013, Apollo 55 broke up when the man who'd become Finn Bálor turned on his long-time tag partner and formed an alliance with Bad Luck Fale. This led Devitt to found a group called Bullet Club, which led to T-shirts, which led to Pro Wrestling Tees being the brand that it is, which also led to the spotlight on the Young Bucks, then AJ Styles, then Kenny Omega, then Adam Page, which gave us The Elite, which gave us The Elite now featuring Cody, which gave us AEW. That is a lot of things to happen from turning on Ryusuke Taguchi. Shawn Michaels attacking Marty Jannetty gave us the Showstopper. Devitt attacking Taguchi gave us All Elite God Damn Wrestling. Without Bullet Club, it's likely that the members of The Elite might have still known each other, but without the once hottest faction in wrestling binding them together so deeply, the kind of bond that only being part of a super cool clubhouse for super
cool boys, would The Elite's friendship been the sort of thing to build an entire company around? Number nine, what if Don Callis didn't call Chris Jericho in 2017? I mean, sure, All Elite Wrestling wouldn't have existed without The Elite. That's what The Elite stands for in All Elite Wrestling. But AEW also wouldn't have existed without Tony Khan, the wrestling industry's most successful 12-year-old. Because you see, there is a different timeline that leads to AEW, and it's a tale of Chris and a tale of Tony. In the summer of 2017, Don Callis phoned Chris Jericho, who was now out of his WWE contract, and offered him a match against Kenny Omega at Wrestle Kingdom 12, which led to huge streaming success, which led to Tony Khan believing there might just be room in town for another wrestling promotion, which led to Jericho being flown to work All In on Tony Khan's private jet, which led to a huge signing offer, which led to Chris Jericho being the first AEW Champion and the mainstream name that All Elite Wrestling was built around.
Without Don bringing Jericho to New Japan in 2017, who's the big cross-generational name that Tony Khan builds AEW around? Cody? Maybe, but does AEW then seem like too much of a vanity project if a member of The Elite is the first All Elite Wrestling Champion? Do they just go with Kenny straight away, or does it all just seem like a pipe dream that Tony Khan never actually brings to fulfillment? And hey, while we're talking about AEW, number 10, what if Punk didn't do that dive in 2022? This year, 2026, CM Punk, no ifs, ands, or buts, or night one doesn't count, main evented WrestleMania, an achievement that fans once thought would never happen, and probably so did CM Punk when he walked out on AEW Rampage back in August 2021.
You see, for a time in AEW, Punk was happy. Punk was over. Punk was having all-time storylines with MJF and winning the AEW Championship at Double or Nothing. And then, a week later, on June the 1st, on Dynamite, new champion CM Punk jumped off the stage into the crowd, cracking his foot on the barricade, breaking it, leading to him vacating the AEW Championship and going home to sit and think and think over and over, night after night, about a little comment made by Adam Page before Double or Nothing, going ever so slightly mad, so that when he came back, he was looking for trouble. And he just so happened to find that trouble after All Out 2022, calling out Page, The Bucks, Kenny, probably Jesus Christ himself, there'd been one more muffin on the table, which led to a dust-up backstage, which led to a lot of people being suspended, which led to Collision, which led to All In and Dust-Up 2, Geriatric Punkaloo, which led to Punk being fired, which led to hell freezing over, which led to the main event of WrestleMania 42. If CM Punk had just stayed on that ramp, would being on the road have distracted him from his grievances?
Would he have been able to work things out? Would he still be in AEW today, having turned heel to help MJF win the AEW Championship and rule the promotion with him as father and son? I'm just asking questions. And those are my 10 biggest what if moments in wrestling. What are yours? What do you think could have been different in wrestling if just one day had gone differently? Let me know in the comments, please. Please actually do, because I do want to read them. Thanks once again to Chris Rohde for giving me this super interesting commission over patreon.com/blomko. Until next time, I am Adam from Blomko Incorporated. Get back to work.
Woo!