Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 24:00

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games onl and today I'm doing a discussion over Utopia now this game as a disclaimer was sent to me as a review copy but I'm not getting paid or anything like that I'm not threatening you know them with a with a review for money or anything it's just they reached out to me asked me if I wanted to cover the game and I'm like sure why not and uh and typically what I do now is actually I I uh you know um investigate in um whatever the word is right now that I can't think of um I check out the game and see if it's even you know a game I might be interested in because I don't want to take some game that I know I'm not going to like and then play it and be like I don't like this and then you know review it knowing full well uh but Utopia sounded really cool it's a worker placement game where you are gathering resources to be able to uh create Butterfly Effects uh to create different worker placement spots based off some alternate effect that happened um and I was like oh yeah that sounds really neat and then I played it um and the like I I said this in the solo variant discussion these discussions are always the hardest for me because it's not like it's never fun to be able to be you know kind of gifted a

game reached out to and then not like the game and I don't think Utopia as a multiplayer game is bad I just don't necessarily think it's fun you know um the theme of the game is really cool the artwork is great I think that they're uh really creative with their time you know travel stuff but the overall actions of the game I felt kind of lacking so in a multiplayer game you essentially have workers which are your ships and your ships are uh assigned a different type of knowledge whether it's military Explorer politics culture and scientist and those are essentially your resources which come in with poker chips and uh I will say the production of this game is done very well I think the board is done the rule book I really don't like it looks it's literally like a black it's just like black text um like that's that's it it looks like a Word document in in dark mode uh off my so that's what the the rule book looks like um weirdly worded to kind of make it just felt a little off that that's the only thing that I don't really like but the poker chips are really nice the card quality is nice the boards are okay like I will say I don't necess like there's no design on the back of these at least whatever copy they sent me now this

could be a prototype copy I don't think it is and if it is good prototype um but if these are designed or anything and like a if there is a final version then ignore this part but overall like the game design is clean like everything is laid out it should be and so your workers are your ships and you basically go to various locations and gain poker chips to finish out Butterfly Effects the first person to do three Butterfly Effects wins and when you complete Butterfly Effects like found the Neanderthal civilization um that is a onec uh a onec you know um alternate time zone and you read it and it's like oh you can found the Neanderthal civilization and it gives you a little flavor text or you can banish the homo sapiens underground and these kind of uh like the flavor text for that is just that it's flavor text but the big difference of why you would do one over the other is the action up at the top so founding the KN uh Neanderthal civilization gives you an assassinate spot that you can go to and the other banishing them underground gives you science so whenever you place the alternate time zone your work gets to go there do that Action for free like the putting a drone on it so you kind of own that meaning if other people go then you

also get to benefit from the action so being able to assassinate twice would be huge in a game um but that's that's pretty much it like there there's action so you the crew mates that you get are from various time periods and they're all historical figures the text which there's not many of it's either travel or communication text which realistically just oh hey the communication Stone in the first section you know that gives me culture or politics if I'm the one who created it and that goes to slot one and if anyone else goes to time zone one then my text there I also get something and there's games that do that where it's like oh you went there I also get something uh and there's nothing wrong with that but that's that's kind of it you you get some characters with abilities and the abilities are rep you know repeated like from character to character like you can have ones that are like Oh Hey whenever you complete a a butterfly effect then you can get to knowledge this of your choice okay well Alexander the Great has that don't really know why he has that but he does have that ability and then other characters have that ability um like I swear she's in here no is it not here oh it might

be I swear there was another one I'll have to find it but there we go Napoleon uh bonapart when you completed Butterfly Effect Mission you gain two free knowledge disc of your choice uh and they're all icon based but but you other other characters will have that same ability so the abilities aren't necessarily tied to the characters the characters are just there uh for historical hey this guy exist at that one point or this guy doesn't exist because they're all the way in the future um so nothing's necessarily exciting and that kind of bummed me out because the theming is uh really cool but when you complete a mission and the missions can also be fun like they go way back it like all the butterfly effect missions are tied to uh you know what time period they're from so like for example save the dinosaurs that's a 1B uh time zone so that's obviously tied to the um Ice Age kind of time zone and hey you can save the dinosaurs or you can save planet Earth but saving planet Earth gives you the assassinate icon and saving the dinosaur give you a scientist icon well that's the same thing as the 1C location uh you can establ you can invade England which gives you a politics or you can colonize Vinland which gives you I don't remember what that one was um that one is a merchant

where you can trade up to three knowledge SS of your choice so you get what I'm saying it's like saving the dinosaur sounds like it should be a huge deal and all it does is give you the science trait which I mean science is used to build text but like that overall theme sounds like it should be really exciting but overall it's just not at least for me I found that like you played the game and you were like all right like that was that was a game like that that was around and the other thing that's kind of you know weird to me is all the missions like some of them just require the same amount of knowledge discs regardless of how many you've completed so I've personally never found a real reason to like and this do depend on player count but to go out of my way to get more ships which are essentially your workers um you start out with two and then to get your third one Eric requires two discs of the type that you don't have so for example if you have an Explorer ship and you have your military but you want to get a scientist well you need two science chips uh and then you go recruit a scientist but then if you get your fourth one you need three so that means if I need politicians I need

three poker chips uh and then your fifth one you need four in that case I would need four culture and you might be thinking well that's not a bunch and it's not because it's not like sounding but whenever you send a ship to a location of that ship so let's say I don't have a politician and I send my military guy to the politician spot I only get one and since I don't have that many workers and there's only one politics spot uh it's like okay well I guess that's that now of course you can always send you know let's say I send my Explorer to the explore spot SP when you send a ship that matches the actual location you get two it's like okay well my Explorer went got me two so then with my other action I'm going to go to the trade and the trade lets you turn in two of one for two of another which means hey there's two of my other one and now I just go and I need a politician it's my fourth it's my fourth ship so there's my three so again there are ways to go about it if that's exactly what you're looking for but at the same time I never found there was a real reason to because the missions don't get harder and harder for you to get like there's no level one Mission you know okay hey here I like this is the first mission I'm trying to complete it requires you know four total knowledge chips of various types okay well that's

done now here's my level two missions my level two Butterfly Effects and there there's no second deck of that so if a miss comes out that already that you have the ships for oh I'm going to go to the mission spot and take that and then just kind of rinse repeat like my very first game of playing this all my missions required military which I had a military ship and then like exploration which I already had of uh had one so it was just kind of like rinse repeat and I just find that extremely a weird design decision to not have like the cool thing for the Butterfly Effects would be to have kind of like level one um you know Butterfly Effects they're they're kind of they might be noticeable they might be not they might not um but they're not going to be huge and then your second one you know if there was a second Butterfly Effect deck okay yeah that's kind of a big deal and then the third one if that's your third and there's a third Butterfly Effect deck that's huge like oh hey exploring Antarctica that is not the same as um founding a new religion or starting the industrial or or defeat the Imperial powers in Africa I'm looking at these specifically cuz I just did the solar variant but there's some like that's like they have the alternate time zones but I don't really care about those I care more about what these Butterfly Effects are and the alternate

time zones could I mean still could be neat and an effect but it'd be really awesome if it's like okay that's the level one butter fly effects exploring Antarctica yeah okay cool but the second one you know that's founding a new religion or building the Great Wall yeah those are pretty big deals and then the third one that's saving the dinosaurs that's you know whatever going and giving nuclear weapons to some you know Neanderthal civilization or whatever it might be like those would all be huge and that kind of reminds me a little bit of like another worker placement game called overlords of infamy where you're this evil master Mastermind and your level one nefarious plots are just kind of whatever mild annoyances it's like oh hey uh make everyone's socks wet oh that's okay that's kind of annoying but yeah I can move on and then whenever you get to the the the third tier it's blow up the Moon it that kind of stuff I would have liked to see in this game where that you know now you're requiring some now you're required to own multiple tax and have requirements of hey no to do this you need to have this worker so you're so now you go out and get your worker that you have to oh hey that's a mission I want to do that is going to uh that's my third tier one and I need to go to this like kind of like Yeo stuff as well because some of the missions require you to go to a certain time zone if you had

one that was hey saving the dinosaurs that should require you to have mult multiple texts I mean that one specifically kind of does actually it requires you to have two communication texts but um that I which that's actually kind of harder to do because you have to wait for them to cycle but it's still shuffled into the deck but it was like Hey you have to have multiple tchs you need to have multiple workers because you need to be you need to be in time zone 7 and time zone 4 in time zone 10 like which means you need three workers there which means you have to go out and get the knowledge to get more workers and then you also need the knowledge disc that to to save the dinosaurs for example would be would be cool that would be uh like kind of more exciting it would take more planning and then the game weirdly adds the stupid Cutthroat element in an assassination there's a spot on the board that you send a worker to that all you do is take someone's ship and you put them in limbo you take one of your available drones pop it on the location they were at and you get to do that action and they have to spend knowledge disc to get their workers back it just feels so out of place in a game like this it's like oh yeah we're Time Travelers we're going to go see and do this all other stuff and let's kill that guy you know yeah it's it's time travel so he's not really dead he's just in limbo but and he has to get out so

but is just like yeah let's really dick over this this guy for no reason just to Pro make him spend his knowledge disc uh I I find it completely out of place here yeah it kind of makes your action economy work a little bit more but not really because it's like oh man I really wanted to go there I guess I'll assassinate you so I still kind of can why that didn't need to be in this game particularly I didn't find it that that interesting um but in a game like where you actually had to meticulously plan and you needed certain resources yeah like it's like oh you're on your third one oh he's getting really close like okay yeah I'll assassinate so he has to spend oh yeah now he's one less knowledge short like yeah you maybe stall out a little bit if the higher level Mission if there were higher level missions but there's not so it's a minor inconvenience to just assassinate someone's ship and just kind of feels completely out of the place but it does slightly remind me of the hero of from the kingdom of good and overlords of infamy where you know uh at the end of your turn you roll a die at theend turn I think in certain section yeah certain spots the someone rolls the die and the king the hero moves around and you kind of move it into other people's zones to potentially you know steal resources or

remove resources that's kind of a little bit what it does here but that takes some work to get the guy over to their spot to really hinder them this game it's just like oh and and because the knowledge that you pay has to go to someone who has the least amount of butterfly effect missions so I'm just like ah that that didn't really need to be in here but yeah I I find this game just kind of kind of just whatever the Technologies in a game where you think Technologies especially in a Sci-Fi game you think the texts are going to be badass and it's like oh paper making yeah I guess I get I'll get a culture or a politics if ever if anyone ever goes to time zone 2 then I'll get those resources like and I'm not trying to be redundant or sit here and be be like oh yeah all you do is place a worker cuz I find that annoying in a lot of games where you can do that with literally any game oh in Dominion all you do is draw and play cards like you know like that I'm really not trying to do that here but that is kind of there's five knowledges that you just collect and then you flip you spend them and you flip a card this game you know succeeds in theme very very well and in production I

remember when I got it I was kind of like okay yeah I need to do a review over this and then I opened it up and I was like oh po poker chips wow like the the cards were like clean and organized like everything fit in the Box there's specific sections there not a lot in the box but it's like yeah they have slots for these poker chips nothing juts out it's not weird they have containers for all the ships that are just have its own SE section in the inlay uh it's a very clean game and I mean it's also not expensive so it is on game found they're not promoting this at all and um but yeah I mean you can go late pledge and it's like $70 US dollar 60 lb uh just stretch pay for like 20 you know 20 pounds or what that's like what 26 bucks or something um yeah I mean it's it's relatively cheap the artwork is really good uh I like that I like that they range all the way from um the Ice Age all the way to oh where is it all the way to yeah the year 2500 which I mean yeah that's just made up at that point but yeah the butterfly missions that you get they uh yeah they're all tied to like

their location so hey you can win the second world war first human on Mars build a theme park on gamed construct a Dyson Sphere explore the outer limits of the universe but even then that's the section uh 13 and that requires four exploration and two politics and you go to you go to space you go to 13 and that's that's a mission how was that like how is like and yeah you look at the explore the outer limits of the universe and then you're like okay well what's the butterfly effect so you grab that and it was oh I was like where the hell is it and it was right right right somewhere so it was 13 but now I can't find it oh it is right somewhere yeah you launch A Space Odyssey or Clos Encounters of the Third Kind and again that's a science and a engineer location and the engineer as an Al Zone lets you trigger one type of tech you control

so I don't know I don't find any of like the special actions like particularly exciting especially it's like oh I'm going to go there to trigger that Tech which gets me to Military knowledge and then I'll spend that to finish a mission I will say a benefit of the game is that it's not that long um like for it's like it says I mean it says 90 to 120 Minutes I don't think it takes that long I'd say probably 60 more 60 to 90 minutes it's not that complex of a game but yeah maybe at five players I I haven't played this at five um so yeah like that's that's my thoughts on Utopia on a scale of 1 to 10 I'm gonna go with five I think this is a very average game really cool theme but unfortunately the game play Just is is lacking in in my personal opinion um and I couldn't even be like oh maybe this is a good solid first work replacement game because the rule book doesn't really want it to be that it uh it feels like they want it to be more complex but also want it to be digestible so you can't really have your cake and eat it too it's fine Utopia is fine the price point is nice for kind of

the production um I think it could for the game play it could be a little cheaper but if you're making payments on it through stretch pay might be a little bit easier I don't know again they're not promoting me to try and sell their game I just got to tell you what I overall think and I think Utopia is okay and that's it so that's my thoughts on Utopia let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved