Skip to main content
Loading video...

Nightfighter Command Impressions & Light Review | Solo WW2 Air Combat | Board Game Wargame

Transcript 11:27

Hi everybody, I'm Zilla Blitz and today I'm going to offer up some impressions of gameplay of Night Fighter Command from War Diary Publications. In this game, you take charge of a World War II British bow fighter in May of 1941 and play a 30 sorty campaign over England where you take to the skies and try to shoot down incoming German bombers. Quick caveat as we start out. I've spent about six hours with the game now, and I think a full review would take a longer exploration of the campaign, but I've played enough and explored the core gameplay long enough to feel comfortable sharing my impressions of the game. The short story, I really wanted to like Night Fighter Command. I love the idea of the game, and I'm a huge fan of narrative solo games. After spending a few hours with this game, however, I've concluded it's not a game for me. But let's start out with the things that I like about the game. I love the theme of the game and the fact that the game puts you in the role of a pair of British flyers taking to the air at night over England and hunting German bombers. The artwork here is a huge part of that.

It's simple yet evocative with just the right color palette to place you in a dark and lonely English sky searching for enemies to engage. Most excellent work. The game's core sequence goes to great detail as you locate and then close in on and engage German bombers. The combat weaves a web of evasion and maneuver and spotting and firing that flows back and forth as you attempt to shoot down the enemy. And as a simulation of this relatively unknown side of World War II aerial combat, I found it fascinating to learn how this worked. And getting to experience this in simulation form was a learning treat. The sequence is exquisitely balanced and I imagined as you progress in the campaign that there will be a lot of satisfaction seeing your skills increase and seeing you down enemy planes easier.

In the end, it spins a solid narrative of your plane's experience on each sorty. And there's a lot of variety in things that can go right and wrong. From crash landings to breaking gear, from enemies exploding to detailed injuries to weather and damage tables, the game oozes detail and story. I also love the innovation resolution table, which uses one table for a multitude of game functions in a system that's easy to execute and just works so well for a game of this nature. Kudos on the creativity and sleekness of this system. So, there are most definitely elements of this game that I really like. Moving on, however, to the negatives. Um, there's no other way to work around this. I really struggled with the rulebook, the documentation, and the selection of materials the game gives you to execute the game. I found myself running into questions and wonderings pretty much every step of the way. A few examples. There's stuff missing. U the rules dictate how to determine the moon phase for a single mission, but how to determine the moon phases for a campaign has a chart that's apparently missing.

The rule book dictates things like starting ranks for your pilot and the AI operator, their nationalities, and their starting skills. And the campaign progresses on a daily basis, but the starting date isn't articulated in the rules, and there isn't anything included in the game for tracking time progression or ranks or promotions or kills or sorties or keeping track of your skills between missions, etc. You'll need to grab some form of note paper and just write this stuff down. And for a full-priced professional game, I feel like something to track this should just be in the box. All it would take is an elegantly designed campaign sheet. It needn't be something overly fancy or expensive to produce, but it should be there. Fundamental context is also missing from the documentation. There's no information, for example, telling you that British bow fighters are twoman planes and what skills match up with what person in the plane. The rules tell you for sure that there's a pilot and AI AI operator, but I was left wondering, are there gunners? How big is the crew? Compounding this, the game mat and counter set, which are artistically sound, are some places lacking in functionality. In the old print and play version, for example, the mat had the the skills broken up like this, so that it was clear what skills go with one what person. But the new version has them all at the bottom in a single line here, moved away from the artwork for the flyers. And then the rule book doesn't tell you who does what, or that there even only two people in the bow fighter. Now, bow fighter experts are surely saying, "Well, that's obvious."

But for me, as a novice, I ended up googling details about the bow fighter to figure this out. And additionally, the rules are missing to tell you how to set the starting skills for the AI operator. Likewise, armament information is missing. So, I'm still not sure if the bow fighter has two types of weapons, cannons and machine guns, or just cannons, and how these one or two systems are integrated into gameplay and how reloading on the whole works in the sequence of play. In numerous places as well, details are overlooked. The components list, for example, mentions three white dice, one black dye, and one 20sided die, but my game came with four white dice and one 20sided die. The back of the box mentions that you can earn equipment upgrades as you progress through your campaign, but they actually aren't in the game. There are counters for light wounds and serious wounds, but there aren't any counters to track killed in action, which can happen to enemy bomber crew members. And there are typos in rule duplications in several places as well. These are details, yes, but details matter. And the sum of the lack of attention to detail creates a learning curve where you're left filling in the gaps and guessing for many of the game mechanics. As Donald Rumsfeld so famously articulated, I know I have known unknowns, but I'm also pretty confident I have a fair number of unknown unknowns, things that I don't even know I'm getting wrong with the game because I filled the gap in the rules with my best guess as to what to do, but I'm possibly making a fundamental mistake in gameplay.

The sum of it all feels like a step in the design process has just been omitted. It's a shame, too, because these omissions and errors could have been cleaned up with blind play testing and an editor looking over things before publication. To be fair, I did find the rules largely clear for the core gameplay sequence for the most part. I have a handful of questions on combat edge cases, and the reloading ammo mechanic is still a bit of a mystery to me, but the core sequence I found detailed and relatively straightforward to follow in the rule book. In the end, I was able to play the game. If the rest of the rule book were like these sections, I think I would have enjoyed my time learning the game a lot more. Now, the odd part of this all is that aspects of this game really feel like a labor of love. The detail and balance of the combat sequences shows just hours and hours of attention to detail. I should also add that the designer is responsive on Board Game Geek and there's a Facebook group you can go to to get help with the game and ask questions which is always greatly appreciated. Let's move on now to gameplay though which centers on the individual bow fighter sorties which have a detailed and finely articulated sequence of play. It goes like this. The bow fighter takes off and enters a zone where the ground control interceptor gives you an altitude and bearing on an enemy bomber. You then use a sequence of die rolls to get close enough to the enemy bomber in a targeting circle.

Essentially close enough that your AI operator in your plane can start to get you to firing range on the enemy bomber. Once you get on the targeting circle, you go through another sequence of die rolls where you try to get behind the enemy bomber or at least get to close range. This can be a rather long sequence where you get closer, then drift away. Sometimes drifting so far away that you lose contact with the bomber, and then move on to a new zone to try to refind it. Once you finally get close to the range on the bomber, you can attempt to spot the bomber visually. And this begins a sequence of spotting, firing, spotting by the enemy, shooting by the enemy bomber, and evasion by the enemy bomber. The sequence goes back and forth with trips back to the targeting skir circle to close r to close range and then respspotting and etc. The level of detail and the dance of the planes here is remarkable. Eventually, one of the two planes gets shot down or contact is lost or ammo runs out or something else happens to to end the engagement. Now, in a sense, this is a fascinating process to follow, but as a gameplay mechanic, I struggled with it for two reasons. First, there are so many dice rolls. I'd estimate that dog fights I've done so far have had 50 or more rolls, each with a sequence of die roll modifiers to check before rolling. It's been taking me 20, sometimes 30 minutes to do one encounter with an enemy plane.

And while it's fascinating from a historical perspective, the actual actual execution started to wear on me pretty quickly, largely because in many ways it eternally felt like two steps forward and three steps backwards and a repetitive cycling through of the same handful of steps. I'd spend 10 rolls trying to get in position to get a shot off. Then I'd miss and the enemy bomber would evade, meaning get dropped back to a position where you have to start over with the closing and spotting process. And while this very much may have been the reality of these combat engagements, the long die roll sequences without a sense of progression got tedious pretty quickly for me. A connected element to this is that the process is largely decision-free. You've got some decisions as to whether to take a side or front shot from close range or try to work around to the back of the plane and how long of an ammo burst to fire, but for the vast majority of the time you're watching this process unfold, you've got little to do except roll the dice. Now, I'm a huge fan of narrative games, and I'm okay with decision- light games, but to me, it felt like the dice rolling to narrative ratio was way off. There's so much rolling and you're cycling through the same subset of actions that in and of themselves really aren't all that intriguing. The bang for the buck for me just wasn't there. To be fair, I enjoyed the sequence a couple of times, but by the third and fourth time I encountered a new enemy plane, I was like, "Yeah, I'm good with this." Some final thoughts. Now, this game clearly has a following on Facebook with over 150 members in the group, and Board Gamegeeek has players who've rated the

game highly. So, the question is, what type of gamer will this game appeal to? I think first up, you want to be a person who's okay with either spending a good bit of time tracking down rule clarifications or is fine kind of filling in the rules blanks and taking your best guess as to how the game is played. So, if detailed, accurate rules aren't super important, you'll probably be fine with this game. Likewise, if you're an ardent fan of aviation history, I think the topic and the theme will probably grab you more than it did me, and I think you might find the gameplay really, really interesting. Likewise, I think some people will really enjoy the detailed procedural combat sequences and will revel in a long, intricate, back and forth process that ends with final victory. Getting that first kill in the game could take quite a while. And if you are a patient gamer who's enjoy who enjoys action sequences that articulate every step in the action, this game could be a lot of fun. This is very much a patient gamer's game. In many ways, I think a good analogy is that this feels like a baseball game simulation where you're rolling dice for every pitch thrown. For me though, the combination of the rules, the materials, and the long decision-free combat sequences drain my enthusiasm for gameplay pretty quickly.

I appreciate this game for what it's trying to do, and I greatly enjoyed learning about and simulating this unique corner of World War II history. But after a handful of sorties, I feel like I'm ready to move

Progress saved