Skip to main content
Loading video...

Animals on Board Review

Transcript 17:07

Welcome to John Gets Games. Today I'll be reviewing Animals on Board. This is a set collection game that has you using a simple iclit you choose mechanism to grab a bunch of animals as you compete with Noah to fill your ark before the flood. The only catch is that Noah steals all the pairs of animals that you have at the end of the game. So make sure you don't have any. First, I'll show you how the game plays and then I'll jump in on my review. There are 12 different types of animals in the game and there's a value one through five for each of them. In a four-player game, you'll use all the tiles in the game. For three players, you will remove all of two different types of animals from the game. And for a two-player game, you remove all from four different types. Each player takes a cardboard arc, which they will put just like this in front of them. Then they'll also take one food and one flag, which I'll explain in just a little bit. The players also draw three random tiles and choose one of them to be a starting tile for their ark. Now, the values on these can indicate how many victory points they'll be at the end of the game based on your setup at the end of the game. In general, higher is better. So, this player might take this five, put it into their arc here, and then take these two and put them face down into the middle of the table. And once all players have done this, we will flip all these tiles face up in the middle of the table.

And then we're going to add more tiles to this until we have the correct amount. In a four-player game, you need 12 face up tiles and a single face down. In a three-player game, it's 10 face up, one down. And in a two-player game, it's eight face up, and one down. So, in this case, we need to add four more to the stack face up. And then here is our faceown unknown animal. The starting player takes his token and the game can now begin. Turns are quite simple. You choose one out of two options. The first is you could buy a group of animals, but you need to have food enough to afford one for each animal in that group. So this is a group of 13. So obviously I cannot afford it with this single food. So instead, we look to the second action option, which involves taking one group of animals and splitting it into two. So we can start by maybe pulling these over here. And what you're trying to do here is not leave good options for your opponents.

And the goal of the game is to get sets of different kinds of animals. So, we know that we started the game with a giraffe. So, these two giraffes right here are somewhat um interesting to us. We might not want to split those up. But, we don't know anything about these apes or maybe these rhinos. So, we want to split them up so that players, our opponents don't have a good shot at grabbing multiples. So, we might pull these over here. Maybe grab this rhino, put it over there. That way, uh they are not together with their other ones. Maybe grab this elephant. Go over here. This is random and you won't know what it is until you buy it. So maybe we'll stick it over there. And let's see. Lastly, why don't we go ahead and grab ah this little crocodile here. So you don't have to do even splits. And obviously you can't with 13 tiles in the middle. But you can do something like this. And once you've done your split, you then take a food from the bank so that when it's your turn next time, you have a better shot at being able to purchase a group of animals cuz the groups are getting smaller and we're getting more food. Now that our turn is over, it moves clockwise. So now this player can take the same turn where they either buy a group of animals or they split and take a food. In this case, the player has only one food, so they also cannot buy a group. So they might look around and notice that there are two giraffes in this one group that we tried to make. And they might put a fix to that by splitting this group into two groups just like this. And then of course they would get a food for doing this action. At this point, I'm going to fast forward through a couple turns until somebody buys a group of animals.

So, it's now this player's turn, and they have two food, which means they could afford to take this group, this group, or any of these groups of one. This player decides they want to spend both of their food, and they're going to buy these two tiles here. So, they're going to go ahead and put them into their ark. And now what they do is they take their flag here, and they stick it into their ark into a little slot that you can see right there to show that they are now out of this round. Play will now continue between the players who have not made a purchase and not put a flag down until all but one person has made a purchase. At that point, that last person gets one more action to either purchase or just do a split and save some food. You're never allowed to have more than five food. In fact, if you were to try and take a six food, instead you're penalized and you go down to four food. But in general, having more food is good, especially jumping between rounds. Starting around with a lot of food is definitely a good thing.

So, the round is now over and we're going to squish all these animals back together into one group and then refresh so that we once again have 12 face up and one face down. Nobody took this face down so we don't add a new one. That is just going to be the face down one for the next round. The first player marker will then move to the player who made the first purchase in the prior round. So, it goes to this player here. And we will start playing. Everybody's going to take their flags out for this new round. And you're going to keep doing rounds just like this until one round ends where a player has more than 10 animals in their given arc. At that point, the game will end at the end of that round. Now that the game is over, players need to check two different things in order before they can score their animals. The first thing is if they have any pairs of animals, they immediately lose them because Noah is also building an arc and his arc gets all the pairs. So that means these two giraffes right here, well, I don't get to score them at all. they go to a different ark, a non-player arc who definitely gets in our way and those are gone. The second thing that we do now is we check to see if we have more than 10 animals. And if we do, we have to discard animals down until we have 10.

But at this point, that's okay. We only have seven now because we weren't able to get to 10 at the end of the round. Some players will have 10, and some will not quite have that. Now, we get to score. Now, the animals that we have that are singletons, they score victory points equal to their value. So, that's five plus 4 plus two plus one as far as scoring goes. But then all sets of three, four, or five are going to be worth five points each tile, even though they are lower numbers than that. So this chunk right down here is worth 15. And you add that to the top row, which is 12. And that's going to give this player a score of 27 points. And you won't be surprised to learn that the player with the most points is going to be the victor. So now let's begin the review of Animals on Board. And I'm going to start with a couple positive points. The first of these relates to the great simple way that this game utilizes the I split you choose mechanism. You know, at its heart, this mechanism is a great balancing tool. It says, "Here's a bunch of stuff. You have to cut it into two different groups, and then your opponents get a shot at it before you do. So, you're incentivized to make them mostly balanced, depending on the game situation." The interesting part about this game is that at the beginning of each round, there is a huge pile of animals in the middle. So, it's not like you're splitting this and then you know that your opponents are going to uh grab this great pile right away.

There's going to be a round or two probably of splitting right from the very beginning. So, you have some different layers that go in there. You can kind of the same animal into one group and maybe get at it, but you know, your opponents are going to see that and they're going be like, "Oh, well, that was intentional that they left two giraffes there. I'm going to split those up." Um, but you could also potentially try to get into their head about that and know that they're probably going to do that. So, do things based off of what they think that you're you think that you're trying to do, which is a fun aspect of the game. But I also love that the um the inverse to splitting up the animals is just buying a group for the amount of food and you get food for doing the splitting action. So it's a really great tight small little economy where you need to split in order to have food in order to buy. And I just really like the way it works out in this game. Positive point number two relates to the overall presentation that this game has.

Uh to start we have the arcs which I'll be honest took a little while to put together. You punch these out from the cardboard when you first get the game and you have to fold certain bits and put those folded bits inside other bits. And there were a couple that kind of frayed a little bit at the edges. But either way, when you look at these on the table, it's great. It's a nice little stand to hold all your tiles so you're not constantly looking at what you have. And it has a nice thematic aspect where everybody has these little arcs in front of them. On top of that, you have the wonderful art with all these tiles in the middle of the table. The first thing that happened the first time I played this game was we revealed the, you know, 12 um animals in the middle of the board and pretty much everyone on the board started looking at them and like coupooing like, "Oh my gosh, that was so cute." "Oh my gosh, look at that one over there." You know, they're all great. I mean, every single tile has different art because there are five different tiles for each animal. And the low value ones are like baby animals and the high value ones are old.

And it seems like the three value animals are like crazy teenage animals with some kooky eyes. Um, either way, it's a really great presentation. Uh, and it adds a lot to the game. I'm sure the, uh, appeal of seeing this on the table and enjoying the look of all these different animals as you're collecting them and putting them into your ark, um, it's going to really help out the gaming experience for some people, and it definitely made mine more fun. Positive number three relates to the arch nemesis of everybody at the table, who is Noah, who's going to be stealing all the pairs of animals that people have in their arc at the end of the game and how neat this little twist on set collection is for the gaming experience at the table. Because normally in set collection games, you're just trying to get as many of a specific type of thing as you can. And often times there's diminishing returns. But in this game, you really need to be careful. You you take one of an animal. That's fine. Especially if it's a like a three, four or five point animal. Well, that's okay if you leave it till the end of the game because you're going to get three, four, five points for it, which is pretty good. But if you take like maybe a one or a two, then you're definitely going to feel incentivized to try to get two more to maximize the amount of points you can get from those. So, in that case, it's a bit of a no-brainer. If you have a um, you know, a crocodile level two and another crocodile comes out, you probably want to try and grab it and hope that a third crocodile becomes available for you. But if you have that um hippopotamus number five, then it's going to be really risky to take that hippopotamus number three that's out in the middle of the board, especially if there isn't another one out there because you're essentially putting that five points at risk. You might lose it entirely, which is a neat little idea of push your luck really because you do

need these sets of three or more in order to win the game. I've seen that. I've tried playing the game so that I just have like threes, fours, and fives of singletons, and I I ended a game like that, and I came dead last. So, that was obviously not the strategy to do. You really do need to try and shoot across the span of having to and getting into the three and more. And I just really like the um the pressure and the interesting decisions that that gives you and the pressure luck feel trying to jump the chasm of going from one animal to three. Now, let's cover my one neutral for the game, which has to do with how a good memory can really help you out with this game. And that's not necessarily a bad thing, but the game does not sell itself as a memory style game. And seeing what your opponents are grabbing is really important. And remembering what they've grabbed is huge when it comes to how you are going to be not only splitting the piles in the middle of the table, but also potentially buying these tiles. Because if your opponent is able to get to three or more of a specific type of animal, each of those being worth five points is humongous. and it is probably in your best interest if you realize that they've already taken two pandas and they're in a position to take a third one. It might make sense for you to counterdraft away from them and take that panda so that they don't get it.

Especially if it's maybe the the four or five value panda because you'll still get a pretty good amount of points and you'll be potentially denying them a whole bunch of points. So, I want you to know that you're coming into a game where memory is very prevalent. And I know a lot of people don't like it when memory is really important to playing well at the game. And I think if nobody is playing the game too seriously, then memory is not that big of a deal. People are just kind of trying to make sense and oh maybe they did this, oh maybe they didn't. But if you play this game with people who really like to play games and really try to dig into it, it can become a very dependent on who can remember who grabbed what in which situation. And I just thought that was worth pointing out. As far as negatives are concerned, I've only got one and that relates to the role of luck and how it can have definite impacts on who ends up winning the game. There have been several games where we end the game and one person has a really large score. In fact, it seems like in general the winner of the game will have in the low to high 40s and the maximum score you can get in this game is 50 because you have 10 tiles and they can be five points each. So there are many times where we end the game and one person says, you know what, I just I picked two of this in the very first round and two of this in the second round and none came out after that of either of those two things. So, I did other things, but I just lost those animals because once you take an animal, there's no way really to ditch it before it gets taken by Noah. Versus the player who wins, they often times have at least two sets or at least one humongous set of maybe four or five of these animals. And this game really should be about the splitting and, you know, getting into the mind games of what your opponents

have. But if the right tiles never even come out onto the board, then you just have no chance of even getting into the mind game of just being like, I need to get this one rhino into my space. How do I split the board to do it? If just round after round, no more rhinos come out. That is a bit disheartening and it doesn't make you feel like you lost cuz you didn't play well. It makes you feel like you lost because you took a risk that didn't pay out and your opponent's risk did. And the relative value of these risks is oftentimes equal. Now, sometimes the starting batch will have like three of one animal, but odds are good that one person is not going to be taking all three of those, which makes that even riskier when you think about it because now there's only two more in the entire rest of the stack. So, um I wish maybe that the game told you to play with less animals at different player counts. And I might experiment around with putting one or two less types of animals in so that you're more likely to pull them out because at the end of the game, there's still a big pile of animal tiles that have not been taken. It's not like you go through most of the stack. And I think that is a little bit of a problem for me. I kind of wish really that maybe you went through the entire stack every single game, but it and it was just really contingent on who split in the right way. Although maybe once you did that, then everybody would score really well and the difference between low and high player would be like four or five points. And that is not the most interesting thing either. So I'm not sure if I'm going to house rule it, but I do want to let you know that this has been a frustrating factor. There have been several times where the person who came in last really felt like they didn't deserve to because their tiles just didn't come out. Let's now discuss the replayability of animals on board.

And I think for this weight of game, it's pretty much average. I would not expect variable player powers or different board setups for a game this simple with this small of a rule set. Uh the game plays in 30 minutes pretty much at the most. And if you're playing with lower player counts, it's almost for sure going to be much less than that. So I think it pretty much hits a sweet spot as far as replayability is concerned. I think they could have probably done something to make it slightly more replayable, but um I don't think I'm going to dock it any points for the fact that you're playing the same exact game on the table every single time because it really feels like that is what this game was trying to be and the variability between plays is supposed to be based on the variety of animals that come out in each subsequent round and how you're going to play around those. Animals on board plays two to four players and I played all of those counts, although mostly at the four-player count. But uh starting with the two-player count, I will say that I was surprised at the one game that I played at two players how well it played. And that's because it almost had a different feeling to than the three and four player game because it was just u right back and forth. You do a split, it's to your partner, and then it comes right back to you. And it's much easier to track what your partner has taken from a memory u standpoint. I don't have the best memory in the world, but when there's only one other person, you can have a better shot at remembering what they're taking. And also, it's more interesting to carve out the pile of animals when you know that there's only going to be one more split before it comes back to you. Can so you can definitely set things up to take a bigger set of animals that really work well for you. And it felt like a much deeper experience. Probably the deepest

experience you can have with this game is at two players. uh versus the four-player game where you do a thing, you maybe split the animals and then there's going to be, you know, three other actions before it gets back to you, which might be three splits and oftentimes is in the beginning of the game, which makes it feel much more tactical, like you can't play plan ahead anywhere near as much, but it played fine at four. And I think because of all things when you consider them together, the three-player game is probably best. Um, I did enjoy the two-player experience, but having a little bit more going on and having another player to bounce off of and potentially uh counterdraft against a player who is perceived to be winning is, I think, a little bit better. But ultimately, it plays good at all these player counts. I would recommend them all. In conclusion, I've had fun every time I've played Animals on Board. It's a neat little package. It is definitely good at what it is trying to be, which is a simple uh tight rule set to give you an interesting experience of I split you choose with some great art and table presents and it pulls all of those things off. I don't think it is a terribly interesting game. Like I do really like the idea of not ending the game with a pair of tiles, but I also don't like the fact that sometimes the third tile just never ever comes out and it's never even an option for you to take into your little board and then Noah just steals those tiles and man that risk feels like it didn't pay off.

whereas it might have paid off for an opponent. So, I don't love the randomness there, but I do love the interesting decisions that comes from the no mechanic of losing those two. And in general, it's just fun to look at on the table. It's also a quick game, so if you have a frustrating experience where the right tiles don't come out, well, you were probably playing for like 20 to 30 minutes max. And that's not the end of the world if uh you have randomness be a little bit larger of an effect in a game that is that small in its time frame. So, ultimately, I recommend the game. It's fun at all player counts. It's a neat package and experience. It's just not one that I'm necessarily jonesing to get out to the table that often. I'd like to thank all of the people who are supporting this channel on Patreon. And you too can support the channel at patreon.com/jhitsgames. Uh if you'd also like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one, as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs, please subscribe to my channel. Thanks for watching.

Progress saved