Polynesia Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
Hey everyone, today I'm taking a look at Polynesia, which is a two-to-four player board game designed by Peer Sylvester and published by Ludo Nova. Um, this one takes about an hour to play and was published in 2020. Now, I don't normally blind buy games, but this was one of them based on this awesome-looking box cover and the fact it is indeed designed by um, Peer Sylvester, who I think is a really solid designer, uh, famous for games such as The King is Dead. Um, I did think this was going to be more of a Euro-style game, but in fact it is much more in the abstract camp that takes place on this board here with all these different islands. And the idea is we are these Polynesian natives trying to relocate on these different islands um, before the volcano explodes. Now, the the winner of the game is going to be the player with the most points at the end of the game and you're going to achieve points by a number of things such as being on these islands here with the turtles on and fulfilling public objectives like so. There are three different public objectives available every game um, based into different decks here, so you've got like uh, your one cards, your two cards and your three cards and they'll all be doing different things and then we'll talk about those in a bit. Um, there is also some tiles that are divvied out randomly um, at the start of the game or at least semi-randomly.
And as you can see, this board is divided into um, these islands which have either resource tokens on which come in the form of fish or these clams and also some islands are kind of paired together in these archipelagos which has this kind of um, line around the pair of islands like so. Uh, every player has also got a player board that looks like this where you have a bunch of your islanders um, in a kind of a a growing order starting from two points and going to seven points. And the idea here as well is if you deploy more of your workers onto the board, the um, the lowest available or the highest available spot you've got left is going to or got revealed is going to score you that many points at the end of the game. So, having more of your people down onto the board is going to be good, but at the same time if your workers are still on these spots here with these orange outlines on, when that volcano explodes, they're going to come back onto your board and potentially lose you points or at least not let you gain as many points as you would have.
You start with a couple of resources like so. And let's have a quick look at the objectives. So, as I said, these are quite varied in terms of you can do quite a lot of different setups. And they are based on different things you can do in the game. So, for example, in this one, this one kind of changes the game rules saying you build onto an archipelago or build a route that goes into an archipelago for the first time, it's going to cost you double the amount of resources. So, it's kind of a a change of the rules there. This one here says that as soon as a player gets a mask symbol, which are these little tokens here like this, then you can choose a resource type and choose whether to take two of those resources or make all the other players lose two of those resources. So, you know, that's got a bit of take that in it. And the number three here, I've set up with the player with the most ships on the map gains three points. And that's the end of the game bonus or end of the game criteria there, which is dictated by this symbol here. So, what you're actually going to do in the game is you're going to flow through this little time track here, which dictates phase and phase.
And the game is going to end whenever the sixth volcano cube is going to be drawn from this bag here. So, let's have a look at the main actions you can do. So, the main actions you can do is explore, travel, populate, or fish. And I suppose they're all pretty simple in their own right. And the the phase that you do these actions in is also really important because as you can see from this track here, the it goes from three to one, then you'll draw something from the volcano, and then one of your resources will be gone based on who's the first player gets to decide that. And then you'll produce produce all the resources, and then the first player will change. So, the importance of it being three to one is because this actually determines the strength of certain actions you can take. So for example, in the in the first action you can take, the explore action, to create a new route, which means placing one of these boats onto the board, it's going to cost you uh a boat, you're going to have to spend a boat, and you're going to have to pay a number of resources, either these fish tokens or these crab tokens, equal to that round number. So for example, if it is that three, then you you're going to have to pay three resources in order to place your boat on any route on the board. And when you do it, you'll spend these resources and you'll put one of those resources next to your boat to determine which you spent when you when you did that action.
You can also choose to build on a route where somebody else already has built. So for example, like this, you might put one of these boats on here, like so. But then you'd have to spend two resources equal to the um type that they've already spent. So you'd have to spend two clams in this example. Now I'll also say in a two-player game, that rule is not an option. You only get the first option of creating a new rather than piggybacking on someone else's route. Another option you can take is the travel action, where again you'll spend you'll spend or get a number of movement points equal to the current round. So it's going to be more powerful in the in the earlier rounds where you get three actions, where you can move your workers from point to point. So for example, here I if I had two movement points, I can go one and move it from along this line here. And if I had a second one, I could follow a route that I control or another player controls, but the cost of that will be different. So for example, this setup was like this, um I could actually choose and let's say this boat wasn't here, and I was this purple player, I could choose to either travel down my route for free for another movement point. Or if I was the pink player, I can still travel down another player's route, but I would have to drag them with me and pay one of the resources that they've already spent there. So that would cost me a clam, and again I'd have to take him with me when I do so.
The populate action is pretty simple where you're going to be adding new workers onto the board taking them from your player board where you either put a worker onto an island where you already have one. So, I could do this for example. Or I can place three workers onto the main island like so. Which again is important because you don't want anyone on there for the earlier rounds or when the game ends because if they are on there, then they're going to go back onto your player board. The final action is to fish where you simply collect resources based on the current round. So, again, if it's that three round, then you're going to get up to or three three resources. If it's a two, you're going to get two. And if it's one, you're going to get one. So, has this weird kind of pacing where some actions are stronger based on the current round it's on and some are weaker. So, obviously when you when you choose to explore, it's going to be more expensive in the in this round than in this round. But if you choose to travel, then it's going to be better if you do it here rather than worse. And again, if you want to collect resources, it's going to be more efficient if you do it here. But the reason you might not always want to do it in that that order is because when you choose to travel on some new regions, you're going to get the tokens for doing so. And you know, these kind of do different things depending on the current setup of those cards um such as and so the masks in this particular scenario going to either get you resources or make your opponents lose resources. These turtle ones here are going to give you points at the end of the game. And um the ones like here such as the fish or the clams are going to give you a more income each round. And again, this one lets you deploy a a boat
anywhere on the board. Now, after those three phases are are done and you've taken these main actions choosing one per turn, you're going to get onto the volcano action where you're going to draw um a cube from this bag here like so if I can sort out with one hand. Like so. And there are three different colors of cubes in that bag. There are these red ones, there are black ones, and there are gray ones. Now, the red ones are kind of a a countdown mechanism where the sooner the sixth one is revealed, then the game is going to be over. The black ones that basically can expedite the end of the game by as soon as you reveal them. So, I'll do this one. You actually end up drawing another two cubes from the bag, which can obviously speed things up. And the gray ones are basically just defunct and don't do anything, making make making the game take a bit longer.
After you've done that, depending on who's the player who's the first player, they're going to choose one of the two resources, either the fish or the clams, in order to make all players discard all resources of that type. So, as you can probably imagine, if another player has stockpiled a load of fish and you've got a load of clams, you're probably going to choose your opponent to lose all their fish. Uh after that, you go on to the production phase where wherever you've got a worker, like so, you're going to generate resources. So, for example, here I would get one fish, two fish, three fish, and a clam. And that will be my income for the next phase. And after as soon as that's over, then the uh the round is going to end, and you're going to change the first player to the next player in player order. And then you'll start again going through through the motions.
And as I said, as soon as that sixth cube is revealed, then the game is going to end. Now, obviously in terms of decisions, you are obviously going for these objectives, trying to get these points as many as you can, trying to get as many um of your people onto the board and get them out of these initial starting regions because you don't want them coming back. Um additionally, you're trying to get them on these islands here with these with these turtles on because although they're harder to get to, then they're going to give you more points at the end of the game. And so on. So, there is a bit of variation from game to game, but the strategies are pretty simple, normally involving getting on these islands with the archipelagos or collecting these turtle symbols or masks and so on. And and that's basically how the game plays. It's not rocket science, but as you probably imagine, it plays in a very abstract way.
So, let's take a look at some of these other objectives that you can set up. So, let's have a look Some of the number one cards are pretty simple. So, for example, this one, you're going to get one point for each archipelago where their tribe is present on at least one of the islands. And if you're present on all of the sets of archipelagos, then you're going to get an additional five points at the end. There's ones here where you're going to get two points for each archipelago where their tribe is present on both islands. And And you're going to get 10 points if you have all of them at the end of the game. So, those two go pretty much in hand-in-hand, but one's slightly easier than the other one. Uh you've got ones like this where the first route that connects to an archipelago costs twice as much, which is what I explained during the setup. Um and you've got this one here where the first player to get one of their tribe members onto an archipelago gains a point token. So, you're kind of encouraged to race to these regions.
Uh the number twos, let's just take a look at a few of them. So, again, mask mask obtained. Um it works in the set collection in this um in this scenario where one mask is going to get you uh minus one points, but the more you get, you're going to get potential for for quite a few points. Uh each player gains as many points as the result of multiplying the number of masks they have obtained by the number of archipelagos where they're at. So, again, it's all things based on masks and the number of archipelagos, basically. Um and some of the number three ones, uh let's have a look. All players carry out the resource phase at the end of the game. Um and then the player with the most fish gets um four points. I think that's the same one, but with clams. Um let's have a look at something a bit different here. So, each Every time that a player explores an existing route, they gain one point token for each ship present on that route. So, again, they're just slight different tweaks here to change the gameplay just a little bit.
Now, let's have a think about how I actually think about this game and um my personal thoughts on it. So, I will say abstract games aren't normally my cup of tea, so I'm not the I'm not probably the best guy to give my opinion because I it just isn't my forte. Now, I can appreciate appreciate them, but generally it's not something I lean towards. So, something I do like is this is this round kind of order here. So, not only is it a countdown, but you're you know, your rewards or cost of things deplete as the rounds goes on. And you can use that to your benefit, but sometimes you might even forsake um you know, reaping the benefits of say collecting a certain reward when you have got that three available a particular to get to somewhere quicker than your opponent does because you want to cut get one of these tokens which can naturally be really important.
And then you can again you can play efficiently by you know, if you explore a new route route here, you only have to pay one, but if you take the game game resources action you're only going to gain one. So, I quite like that pacing here where sometimes the actions are better or worse depending on where you take them. Um the the idea of drawing the resource cubes from the bag is I think it's quite a neat idea in terms of making the game last different amounts of times each time you play. You know, sometimes you can particularly get a a fast game where you draw all these red cubes out quickly and then sometimes it might be a longer affair. So, I do like that in you know, not not perfect information about how long the game is going to go on which can make you expedite doing things quicker than you normally might want to because you just don't know when that game's going to end. Now, something I really don't like at all is this action here where you can choose a resource and force your opponents to get rid of all of those resources. And also you have to do that yourself as well. So, you've got to bear that in mind, but it for me it just feels a bit too a bit too take that issue and a bit of an obvious choice because you're obviously going to choose what's going to benefit your opponents more. I'd rather have the resources being a bit tighter and everyone just have to manage them a bit better rather than just you know, giving you loads of rewards and then just having to wipe them out each time.
I quite like the idea here as well with the gaining the resources because in the earlier rounds or or as the game develops, you want to be on all these islands here because, you know, you're going to get more resources from turn to turn. But, normally you get a lot of points for being on the archipelagos and they don't give you as many resources for doing so. So, that's quite cool and you have to kind of generate a little bit of an an economy in order to get that constant income from round to round. So, I do like that. Now, let's have a talk about some of the the player balance here. So, I will say that I think the objectives are relatively well balanced. I think they're achievable, but it's pretty tight to do so, which is, you know, it's just about right. And I I do like the slight economy here of when you have to go to or use other players' routes, then you have to pay them to do so. I do like that back and forth and I generally that's an aspect of board game I like is when you when you can establish something for yourself and then end up, you know, paying people for your investments or people can pay you for previous investments. So, that works really well here.
Uh the you know, mechanically it's boiled down into some pretty simple decisions. You know, just those four main actions you can take. And I suppose most of the actual decisions go into how you're going to use those simple actions in order to achieve the the actual objectives. So, that that works okay as well. And uh time investment-wise, you know, the game takes probably about, you know, 45 minutes to an hour. And I wouldn't say outstay its welcome because, you know, sometimes you're going to draw these red cubes out quicker, sometimes it's going to be a bit slower because you end up drawing all the gray ones. But, it certainly doesn't outstay its welcome and it's not one of those games that drag out. The up time is well snappy turns. You know, these simp These actions are simple in their own right. There's not really much scope for bogging down, um you know, your your thoughts and racking your brain over all the variables. You're going to know what you want to going to want to do, you know, basically get on those archipelagos and get these tokens.
Um replayability is not the best in my opinion. Although there's a lot of options here in terms of the different objectives you can take and set up with. They're all very similar and the game feels very similar from time to time. So, I can't I can't speak too highly in terms of replayability. It's not a game I'm going to want to go back to again. Um but and in terms of interaction as well, I do I do like the way that as I said these these routes work when you when you establish a route, then you can choose to you know, pay people to use those routes and on top of that as well, you know, if you're sharing an island and then you end up moving that route, you're going to have to drag someone with you to take to take them with you, which can benefit them or can even hinder them to be honest. So, that's that's another quite interesting wrinkle there.
But ultimately, I found that although this game scales from two to four players and there is a a double-sided board to indicate that. Um I found that in the lower player counts, you know, particularly at two player, it's it's way too open. Um some somebody can really focus on, you know, the the side of the board and someone can focus on the other. Yes, you have to fight for these archipelagos, but there's so many routes here and that you can take and go around things that you can often ignore what other players are doing and just find your own route there and have enough time to do it. So, interaction for me wasn't wasn't the best. I do like the kind of time pressure of having to be off these islands early um or risk coming back to your player board. So, you know, always having a empty player board is going to be beneficial and you know, if you don't really make much of an effort there, you can end up actually um doing worse than you started with with which is I think going to be a rare occurrence, but it can happen.
Um the the theme, you know, it's an abstract game, but the the designer does explain that this isn't something he's picked randomly as a skin. He I think he's somewhat um interested in this theme and things, but ultimately, it's a skin. It's it's very dry, but it works absolutely fine here with the boats and the and the kind of um residents here just trying to flee and find new homes. That's that's absolutely fine. And set up and tear down time as well is no issue. Just going to set randomly set up these tiles by putting them face down on certain spots and revealing them and I'm going from there. And you know, choosing the different setups here as well is very simple because there's just three different categories which just takes two seconds to sort out. Progression, while I do like the fact that more routes are developed throughout the game, I would see the game isn't going to end looking like this. I've just used this as an example.
A lot of these spots are going to be filled. Um, it kind of I still hearken back to the fact of being a bit too open for me. Being being just a few too many routes, I think. I would have been a lot more cutthroat and a bit more interactive, you know, inevitably interactive if just a few of these routes were taken out. Uh, the scalability, again, it's going to be better with that three or four player count, but I tend to like games being a bit snappier at lower player counts. Um, but if you want to play a game at two players, I wouldn't really recommend this. I would have I would have preferred to have seen an effort to be made to make the game tighter or a lot more restrictive than it is. And comparison-wise, you know, I'm not a I said I'm not an expert in in abstract games. There are a few I like and this one I can certainly see a fresh coat of paint here. I've not really played any abstract game quite like this. So, I do appreciate the the fresh ideas here and the way it plays.
But again, another abstract game which is not something I'm I'm terribly knowledgeable about. So, overall, I would say that I can objectively appreciate the design here, but ultimately I didn't get much fun out of it as I it reiterate, I tend not to get a lot of fun out of out of abstract games anyway. I find them a bit too a bit too transparent in terms of everything being so open. I like a little bit of um not not randomness, but a little bit of spice being added into games where I find abstracts a bit too a bit too head-to-head, a bit too dry. Um but I I just get I do appreciate the different vibe it's gone for here, especially with the route sharing. I get I like the pacing here.
Um I like the um the kind of random not random, but undetermined amount of rounds it's going to take. It could have been a bit more exciting, I think, but it does okay with the job at this. I really hate that take that element of having to choose a resource and choosing opponent to get or choose everyone else to get rid of all those resources, meaning that you're going to always kind of take a balanced approach. Um but yeah, ultimately another abstract game that didn't didn't really blow me away. I felt a little bit underwhelmed by it. Um and I I didn't get I didn't get a lot of fun out of it, which is obviously what I want with board games. Um whereas, you know, every every Euro game I can kind of sit back and enjoy, whereas abstract games I feel I I just I get I just don't get any fun out of them. So, unfortunately, I I can't really recommend Polynesia, but don't take that as a slight on the game design or anything like that. It's more of a personal preference.
Um I hope this has been somewhat useful to you. Um if you have if it has, please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos, too. Uh for everyone else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye.