Ares Expedition extra time
Transcript
Kyoto and welcome to this extra time video for Aries Corporation if you're wondering what happened to my face well we did a Halloween photo shoot recently and I shaped it all off so it'll grow back this weird face is is is anyway we'll move on to what we're actually here to talk about now extra time is a video series that I do infrequently when I come across games and I just have more to say about uh there's something that I can't cover in the 3 minutes that I really want to talk about and with Aries Corporation it's really about a originality in board gaming before we get too far into this video I want to make it clear that this isn't a Witch Hunt and I'm not calling for anyone's heads or anything like that and we're not even really accusing anyone of plagiarism what I am going to talk about is how you can make a good game that's fun that's playable that's engaging and enjoyable but it's still not very original because that's what's been bugging me about the Aries Corporation it's a good game it's a solid game I had fun playing it there are great interactions in it and it's it's good it's it's very good even but the one thing holding it back for me is it just didn't cover any new ground whatsoever it was one of the safest designs I've seen in a very long time they essentially took the foundation blocks from race for the Galaxy terraforming Mars and spliced them together to make a very sound but very safe game now if you're watching this video I'm going to assume you've seen the Aries Corporation video so you know how that game plays but I want to do some more direct
comparisons between the Aries Expedition and uh race for the Galaxy uh unfortunately I don't own a copy of race for the Galaxy except digitally at the moment so I'm going to have to substitute in its cousin role for the Galaxy sometimes there are things in media that are just too familiar a good example of this is when you hear a piece of music that sounds an awful lot like another piece of music so Billy Jean Michael Jackson and then you hear Billy oceans Caribbean
Queen so those are very similar pieces of music um yet distinct enough when you put all the bits of pieces together that they're totally different songs but the base hooks uh have a lot in common and that's kind of what's happening with uh race for the Galaxy and Aries Expedition here the the base hooks uh the cor building blocks of the game are similar the difference is in music uh if something is that similar people Sue and there's millions of dollars but in board game design because you can't copyright a mechanic and because well if you could um basically no board games would get made um it's a little bit different but there is that level of similarity between the games let's pop over to the other table and here we are with both of the games rooll for the Galaxy representing the Galaxy series of games and terraforming Mars Aries Expedition now if you watched the video you saw that there are these five turn order tokens that terraforming Mars Aries Expedition has well Ro of the galaxy has f 5 2 and we should go through and compare just how similar they are because they're remarkably similar the first one is the explore phase which in race for the Galaxy lets you draw cards um the bonus for selecting this one is it allows you to draw more cards and to keep more cards which is exactly the same as the research tile these two tiles are virtually identical one just happens at
the start of the round one just happens at the end then we've got in uh race for the Galaxy we've got the development and the planet planetary phase I can't remember what it's called build colonize settle we got the develop and settle phases and these allow you to play uh two different types of cards which is exactly the same as the Development and Construction um tiles in Aries Expedition development lets you play one type uh like development does develop in race for the Galaxy and construction lets you play two types of cards because well terraforming Mars had three types of cards not two then we come down to tile four production they're both production they're both cor production they both produce things and finally we have the action phase and the trade phase and well these are the ones that seem initially like the most different but in the action phase you can do a whole bunch of funky extra effects That's Unique um and not in any of the race or world for the Galaxy games but mostly the core thing of this is spending your builtup resources to score points and that's what you do in trade you spend trade goods to get victory points uh in roll for the
Galaxy this isn't just a case of the system being similar the system is the same it's fundamentally the same with tweaks there are bigger differences as you saw me sort of muddling through trying to remember the difference between race for the Galaxy and roll for the Galaxy then there are between race for the Galaxy and Aries Expedition and this game is a branded for the Galaxy game yet it's more distinct mechanically than this one and I find that kind of frustrating now it's some my style to do a wholesale character assassination on a game unless it's really bad and I want to keep repeating this Aries Expedition is not a bad game uh first of all the components are topnotch it's beautiful the gameplay Loop because it is so close to race for the Galaxy uh is is excellent so it is that brilliant hybrid of race for the Galaxy and terraforming Mars it does combine aspects from both those games and both those games are bangers and they're really good ones to play so if you are looking for that between game that Nestles between those it takes an hour or so to play and has a big amount of engine building for you not as much as terraforming Mars but a bit more in depth than race for the Galaxy this could be a gr game for you it's really good in that regard but that doesn't take away from my original point that it's safe and it doesn't do anything original so as a consumer there's
nothing really to be concerned about here no one's been victimized or or ripped off or anything in the making of this game and Aries Expedition is as I've said several times a good solid game so why is this bugging me so much and why have I felt like I needed to make this video and I think I distilled it down to this one issue I cannot see a way Aries Expedition came about without an initial conversation that said you know what we should make race for the Galaxy but terraforming Mars this isn't a case of parallel development this isn't a case of we came up with these ideas and oh they just happen to be in this exceedingly popular ubiquitous game I can't think of how this game came into being without it being deliberately derivative of race for the Galaxy and that bugs me slightly it feels cynical it feels a bit lazy to be honest and while they've still delivered a good game I think this niggle is just going to get under my skin with Aries Expedition every time I play it every time I play it I'm going to be just like this is race for the Galaxy on Mars and it's like you're watching a a good film you're watching a really good film but then you click to something you're like wait a second this is about a Belgian detective on a Transcontinental Railroad
uh solving a murder but it's not an neth Christie and someone goes yeah yeah yeah it's not murder on the orian express it's murder on the Mariner Express cuz it's in space and the characters are different and the setting's different but it still feels really really familiar and that familiarity might be a good thing for you you might slide in to Aries Expedition like a hot tub and just go ah this is this is great this this is exactly the game I wanted I wanted race for the Galaxy and terraforming Mars to have a baby and for that baby to be this game and that baby is my baby and that's cool ultimately I hope this video just prompts a discussion on originality in b g how important is it does it actually matter um that games are quite derivative should we just expect that is novelty in board gaming overrated and is it just that hard to actually come up with something new because every single game I've played is a derivative in some way nothing is totally novel every lcg uses a resour system and probably tapping of cards magic might have been novel at one point Dominion might have been novel but every deck builder is essentially borrowing from those core mechanics every game is made up of little building blocks that have appeared elsewhere it's the unique combination and unique presentation of those building box that make makes each game what it is and the last thing to
conclude on is will this game grow on me will I be one of those people who finds it a comfy hot tub to crawl into when I don't have the time to play terraforming Mars or am I going to be one of those people who goes nah this one's not for me anyway anyone out there who's played terraform Mars RAC for the Galaxy and Aries Expedition let me know in the comments how similar you found the games and whether that was a good thing for you because found it comfortable or whether it was a bad thing because it felt Overexposed or whatever your reasons for liking or disliking the game were and if you can provide other good examples of games that when you played you went wait a second this feels entirely too much like another game and another game put those in the comments as well and finally I earlier talked about music with the Billy Jean and Caribbean Queen example but a lot of songs are essentially for called turnaround songs and if you've watched the four cord uh song video U by aess of awesome you'll understand that a lot of music is just taking the same building blocks and and putting different things on it and board gaming is a lot like that a lot of it is derivative while I have picked out the Expedition for a bit of a thrashing here that's just board game design that's just a hobby if I ever play 100% original game I will let you know and three minut board games does not do paid content if you like what you see here come support us on patreon and if you enjoyed this video hit the notification button subscribe to
the channel and please come support us on patreon