Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 30:15

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for merchants cove uh which is a game that i i i was kind of intrigued i think i remember i backed it on kickstarter uh for a little bit and then ended up pulling out just because uh final frontier games typically for me uh are kind of all bark no bite and uh merchants cove is a really interesting gimmick it's kind of how this is a very gimmicky game um i don't really have any problems with it per se but i wouldn't want to play it again right it's kind of where where i'm at like it has a lot of moving parts but it's kind of like the game is i wouldn't say it's overly long i don't know i don't know how i kind of feel about this it's like yeah this was neat what you were doing was neat what kat was doing was neat but ultimately i didn't give a [ __ ] what you guys were doing right and i don't think it mattered i mean yeah it doesn't really matter that's why the end game like like we're all creating something that's what we're doing yeah at the end of the game it's more this is gamesmanship yeah and yeah that's kind of the only interaction you kind of you don't hate draft necessarily because like when you're placing them there's enough information for you to look at the boats and kind of adjust accordingly but it's kind of really i felt like the biggest time that the boats mattered was if you were lucky enough to be the one to draw last he was like

oh wow lucky me i mean there was a time where you were able you kind of were like oh cat has um you know a large you know you know large red whatever potion and it's like i'm gonna move this boat to the small dock and it's like okay well that's just kind of annoying and that's really the whole crux of of this maneuvering the boats to position it but really i don't think it it like ever mattered well the thing we we never did do this aspect but you because you don't have to sell your stuff like yeah if you get kind of if she's if kind of built a couple of big things and there wasn't any thing you kind of wait and see you just wait till the next next time and then you sell a bunch yeah i mean it's that's a risk though no it is because considering the the game is only three rounds uh good length though i love i've always loved this mechanic the more you do bigger actions um like the way you're able to like okay everyone's taking big action i'm gonna take some smaller ones so i'll get to i'll get the team up and of course being the chronomancer i had uh i had ways to actually take more actions than those actions flying out of your ass right you're doing all kinds of i never felt like like honestly i don't think any of them were cool like when you have a faction that is all about controlling time it was more like i was doing piddly [ __ ] i was going i was oh i'mma do this to stop time to get a little artifact like it was it wasn't it wasn't cool like i was actually kind of i mean that that is a big benefit i mean because you

scored 30 point we both did because i managed to get two red things too but that was a big that's kind of the play you try to make and yeah i hope somebody else that knew it because that was a big swing 30 points that we just both happened to get 30 points exactly and that's why i was saying this this didn't end up mattering they're trying to even swindle the combination of getting artifacts it's just like oh you can do the exact same thing so the 30-point swing if you're ahead or find my head it just it just shifts us i will say that hold on real quick cat what do you think it was going back and forth and cow wasn't saying anything so what do you think again i liked it you liked it yeah no well great no yeah i liked it no yeah i like totally yeah yeah they're like my favorite i just left it like that but um what i think the one thing i mean i specifically liked being the alchemist i guess um i didn't have any qualms with it i i would say the only thing i didn't like was the pacing of like the turns oh you don't like you don't like the the turn thing off um i and i can see why people wouldn't like that because it's like you you think sitting in oh hey i just went brad just went right you should go oh no sorry cat you have to wait a little bit longer because brad and i are actually going to go back and forth yeah yeah um so but that's at least interesting but i agree with you when you say it's a little bit gimmicky um but i liked it oh look at that moon boat yeah i mean and that's the thing this is what i was going to say there's there you could play with different boats like yeah five slaughter you're gonna have more people out this one

can dock anywhere even if there's another like it could be oh it could come up on you they can come up and at the end and sure there's so there's very little bit of boat variation with that and stuff you know it's like for me when it comes to asymmetry because like obviously we all played we played the game uh really different it was when it comes to asymmetry and obviously the biggest one i can think of is root obviously very different game but the concept is in root yeah everyone's trying to get 30 points but we interact with each other completely differently this one you don't interact with each other at all so it's very euro yeah and you do the exact same thing or your end game is like oh yes we are all getting the exact same artifacts uh we just go about doing the same thing differently and so whenever you're scoring points it's just like oh okay well i guess i got i got my big red different than you got your big red but nothing you do nothing i do nothing cat does to get the big artifacts matters yeah and you know and like i said this is like the first three player game i've played most of it's just been kind of walking through with a couple and i think there is something when i've watched playthroughs online and stuff of that like we said it's a risk yeah but holding your stuff and selling it at the most opportune time sure because if you hold stuff and you're hoarding a bunch of stuff in your cabin cabinets and you just happen to get this yeah and you have you know oh yeah yeah you can really

point out but that's a risk yeah and that never really occurred to me but yeah it's you could very much do that you could get like a bunch of these big ones and then just hope that the doc goes like the colored you know meeples go to the dock that you want them to but i guess my question to that would be what the hell do you do in the meantime like if you already have if you've been holding them you're just like well there's nothing else for me to do except build potions or build sorry where you just keep building and keep yeah keep trying to get your people you know people but these can't these don't stack it's one it's it's only one i mean honestly the people i mean yeah that's actually how you ended up winning was was these these icons here at the end of the game and for me i actually kind of find this annoying because you get the one time ability yeah it lets you do these which is cool i like that that's a spot that you can run down but it's almost like wait till the end of the game or wait till like the you know the the the last round and then oh just wait for the sponsor and then just get a bunch of the same color and it's like oh okay well lucky me i have four i have four green there's two four six there's seven there so you know that's whatever 28 extra points that no one else is gonna get uh yeah so they i mean cat ended up kind of getting two and really the only time i ever found them useful was to counteract the corruption which the corruption was neither here nor there it wasn't that big of a deal i

mainly mine were just getting rid of the corruption i mean it can be if we you know i mean if it happens yeah if you if you want to try to extend the game and plus uh we played with the card because you see where the bottom of that with the little circle zero the other ones have abilities where if you draw um the gray guy out they automatically go down there they don't even go on a boat yeah you know so there's different variations and then sure you know all that stuff so there's this was just like the bass bass game yeah you know and stuff so i mean like i said i i i didn't really have any problems with it it was just the concept of the game and my my friend uh uh brett he he likes to say this for a few games and i i kind of agree on this one i feel like they had more fun making it than it actually turned then than actually playing it like it's like ooh okay yeah we're gonna we're gonna have a dice guy we're gonna have a marble guy we're gonna have a tile guy we're gonna have a dry race guy well do they interact with each other or do anything different not really all right um it's i wouldn't say that they weren't unbalanced this took the asymmetry of like a root but turned it into a it used the the euro game like you were playing your own euro game yeah trying to come up with the same level of of things right i mean that's like you know if you're a war game liker this isn't going to go sure you know if

but if you like like i prefer this even though it's more convoluted and everything like i prefer the hell out of this over bargain quest oh really yes oh yeah absolutely not just just because i like the the having the dice the options and doing that stuff and having the meeples out there and doing all that you don't have to worry about the adventures going out what they do after they buy your stuff yeah but that's for me that's kind of the fun it is kind of a similar idea i guess uh for but for me it's kind of like since there's this is this is the tile person that's all he's ever gonna do so it's like there's nothing else to him like okay yeah you played the blacksmith you're gonna mess with dice but you're gonna mess with them really in the same way i'm trying to think what game we played not too awfully long ago that i there's one i showed you and i said that oh i guess it would have been uh when we played uh uh what's the one the diablo one sanctum oh sanctum yeah like with with that you know like you're good playing that character maybe once or twice and then you want to really like like this is the one i played the most yeah you know i played him now now i want to kind of mess with those a little more i'll get the expansion once and then once but like as far as playing this like 50 times probably not not unless i was showing other people okay this is this is way better than sanctum right but yeah it's in the same concept it's like i would i do want to try the other factions but it's like all right yeah this is the chronomancer okay i get it

all right yeah i'll try the dice guy okay i get it but once again you're really going about you're really making the same [ __ ] just now it's with dyson i don't have tiles and one of the other uh heroes is the dragon rancher but you're creating dragons to sell off to people yeah let me guess it's blue red green yellow dragons there might be different points because they're weird but anyway um the other cool one is the innkeeper so you're like running it in and you have beds and all this stuff and you're like selling hotel like yeah you know stuff like that yeah once again that sounds like a blast in in the design department to come up with all that and i would have that's probably where because let's see six because all the points are the same yeah there you go that's that's where the variety would have came out there's points because of the rarity like the yellows and blues or it would have been it would have been cool if the way i mean i don't know that they would have had to really work on it but if the artifacts that i'm getting were different than the weapons you're making than the potions she's making um that would have made the game way more complex for what they were going for but i think that just adding adding more uniqueness to the faction that you're playing because all the expansions are they are it's just another another way to play the same thing the secret stash had a few module little things like it changed um like there was more different versions of the the faction houses yeah that would let them like if the creature the people that were on

there it did a little bit different things oh there's some different things to change the faction houses up yeah there were some more townsfolk that got added um we didn't play with some of the fat town spokes cards because it said this just to do the you know there's two versions there's another one that affects boat movement like you can move people from boat to boat that would have been nice right i mean that's so that's another module thing that you can it's a module expansion well it's just a little more cards to put into the town gotcha town deal because like if you'd buy them the immediate effect would be like you could pick somebody from this boat to move to that boat or something like that it's kind of annoying with cats though is i feel like hers was completely written both ears were completely random mine weren't right in any way i think like i got to choose what tiles were going and in what order they were going and kat did you feel i mean the point spread for this between me and you is really five points uh but honestly it's like between cat to us is is wicked like did you feel like you were struggling harder to get potions because i felt like brad never was like oh i'm gonna make all these i misread something at the beginning that hindered me so i did it to myself i could make big batches of potions and i was only doing one at a time oh so yours is kind of like when i was do a forge action i could make everything i was prepped gotcha oh and i just i just misread it um yeah which is something to bring up is i mean i mean they give you their own rule book so thank god this is nice uh that you just handed to someone you set it up all different um but yeah in any asymmetrical game

if it's these are very hard to teach it's kind of like oh uh i've only ever played you know the the innkeeper it's like how do i play the alchemist yeah i have no [ __ ] clue read it no one's playing it yeah and they're like uh like i don't i don't know these kind of games and so they're like they're gonna have a bad time i mean i've had that same problem with root how do i play the erie on a [ __ ] final you know i mean i know how to play everyone in the in that game but you you someone pretty much has to put in the time to sink into each of them i don't know like i said it's uh it's it's definitely not a bad game but it's not honk maybe maybe it's like if we didn't play that i probably shouldn't no that's not true no this game really it just didn't grab me honestly like it it kind of felt like three rounds was good but i was ready for it to be over by like the end of the second round because i i mean also with the randomness of the meeples coming out it's like oh okay drew this and it's like okay well it's not that color so i guess i just don't really care i was really just waiting for your guys's turns to be over so it can come to me and i can see where cat's coming from if we're taking pilly turns and she's like i'm gonna go get some stuff for my potions all right i'm just gonna hop two over and then we're going to 1-1-1 and then even with me it's even worse if i'm in it because then it's like i'm gonna do one action okay nope it's free i'm gonna do another action nope it's free right um in fact i even had some cool combo where i was able to

well that whole faction thing where you got 12 points yeah one turn didn't matter like it was just okay like i did that uh yeah i guess they balance them by the fact of i have to move the to the two characters that are obviously very blatant rip-offs from uh back to the future um okay okay yeah go ahead no no go ahead i was gonna i was gonna have cat chime in on more stuff yeah go ahead um if you had anything else to say no any comments did you did you like the meeples did you like the the boats coming in what did you think that was yeah i like that balance of variety um i mean it's random so i don't think it's like i don't i wouldn't know about balance but uh i liked it i like the variety because it gives it no one has an edge no one's like yeah i'm gonna like main red potions or something or whatever we're doing um yeah it's i actually i felt like cat i felt like you actually had the easiest way to get potions it just takes time yeah because i you have to you have to load them up and you have to make sure you have the big enough dice or the small enough dice yeah and then you know the times i did look over i was just kind of like oh you you never had a problem getting getting the dice you needed yeah cool because i get extra dice once i unlock these

yeah that's a two-step thing i have to put something here to put a dice there and then i have to forge do whatever it is i could get a lot done in one turn like it took me a lot of turns to load up those yeah and then i do the forge and i could just think which is what she does yeah it's like she just so you set up the time i mean really actually if you kind of think about it you guys are playing really the exact same way she plants her potions all in four batches you plant you you make your armor i was the only one that couldn't do that if i was rolling i rolled pretty well i was rolling big numbers or smalling you know so i had to be able i was able to mess with that yeah you didn't really have to go and modify your dies at all because the only dice modification on here is changing the coal you know yeah and that would be yeah that's the only thing yeah i cool concept the yeah you were gonna say i was just gonna talk about the product the production value is awesome yeah as far as the the that's two or whatever they call that the dual layers i mean these were kind of a pain in the ass to put together they remind me of uh heroes of land aaron's seat yeah yeah exactly um are we you know each one of us had our has our own unique i like whatever the hell i have over here it's just like a table or something it's just a workshop oh it's stupid but uh well in the uh the captain that's in there has a she because she has a spinner but you'll do a spinner with her but she has like a little like a dock that you put her stuff on and everything but but uh you probably would have enjoyed the captain i mean that's the thing is like once again i i have no

real complaints um there's been a few games we've played lately that i was like this was good that's that oh yeah yeah yeah and you know that like i said production value was great on this i mean this is the retail version it's the same as the kickstarter version you know when i got the other stuff i even got the kickstarter exclusives that were in the the one expansion box so yeah it's extremely colorful you know the extra the extra module stuff that you that you mentioned sound like uh it'd be cool so it's not just kind of first come first serve right you know it's not it's not hate drafting but it is kind of luck of the year and it's like luck of the draw and luck of the placement it's like oh man lucky me i'm gonna place this exactly where i need it and then for the solo people uh if you get the the secret secret or secret stash or whatever it has a booklet full of solo scenarios to play with this and everything plus there's a whole solo board and everything that just comes in the base game that you can play and solo with stuff so okay i mean there's there's that avenue to to check too um gotcha i don't know like if i was buying this if i you know if somebody was interested in this i would say get the base game uh and then get that secret stash box that's like 17 bucks i think that's all it was yeah um and that way you get that stuff and don't worry about the other characters unless you really you know what because the characters were only like 18 bucks too it wasn't like it was a ton sure yeah and then which is nice because most games that are on kickstarter

rather than they don't go to retail if they do you're missing half the game right so i mean yeah i think i you know what i i'm because i was sitting here in my head thinking all like i'm like okay why do i like root so much and not this because the argument of doing something different for the same end goal still applies to root because obviously it's just different ways to get victory points and i think the biggest reason between this and that besides obviously the main game yeah it's a war game versus uh right that's whatever the hell this is area control seems to be stuff it's the interaction no it's a player interaction right like the fact that what you do does matter to me um what both of you do and it's like okay how am i gonna stop cat from gaining victory points because she's the eerie she's stacking up on all these and she's gonna get like 20 points if that goes off okay we need to like there was it obviously it doesn't make sense for me to be like oh i'm gonna go through time i'ma [ __ ] with your your dice but i would say the only time it matters is is truly like how much time we're taking and who we're taking from the yeah and that's it that's really because i i prefer i shouldn't say that i've changed a lot the last couple of years i was total ameritrash player interaction now i've gotten into these i like the euro where i'm just kind of doing my own thing or you're literally a solo gamer well right but i mean euro games there's not much player interaction that's that's the whole point of that's why euro games are euro game there's the player in action is not as very light which this is very light

because the only only player interaction is where you're placing the meeples and stuff so i've kind of went more euro euro gamey the last little bit just because i like the i don't like i don't think that i don't think that holds true as as much you know like if i [ __ ] up it's going to be because i [ __ ] up not because somebody comes in and screws my game up for me yeah um i think that's how euro games used to be where i mean obviously there are still some that come out where it's like oh i'm doing what i'm doing and there's nothing else we don't touch each other at all where it's a it's a co-op or it's a multi-player solo game um i think you prefer because you only look for games that are solo so that it you're you're basically playing a solo game but you were just kind of around i think but there are hybrids yeah and and i don't mind those two i mean a lot of these new hybrids yeah you know stuff that we've played with you know uh marco polo and stuff like that there's an interaction in that but it's not a ton where it's you know yeah i think for me it's like whenever it comes to like solitaire multiplayer games it's like almost kind of what's the point like i don't i don't play board games to sit here by myself and only focus on what i'm doing and then just kind of like you know see two hours go by and it's like oh okay let's look at the victory points okay well that was fun we didn't talk to each other at all i didn't care about what you were doing um so it's like i still like euro games but i like it whenever

what like we actually care about we actually are competing uh but it's just different taste right um so yeah can't really think of anything else to talk about you guys got anything to bring up i don't it's gonna be an interesting ranking uh all right a scale of one to ten brad you get to start um one yes uh this one's one i think for everything that's here plus all the expansions it was like 120 bucks so it wasn't a big yep a big undertaking you know with all this stuff um i haven't touched the solo stuff so just basing it on on uh oh actually before you say your ranking yes the other thing is kind of to touch onto like you're kind of doing your own thing and not really focusing is i feel like i wouldn't want to teach this game because because of that aspect it for me this wouldn't be worth setting up teaching the game for me not to care about what anyone else is doing um so that that was just one thing i was i was meaning to say because it's like yes here's the alchemist i mean even i mean almost kind of the game almost is feels that way hey here's your rule book [ __ ] off you know well how do i i don't care what you're doing i don't even know what those marbles are about you have your rule book figure it out i got my time [ __ ] i'm figuring that out

and and we'll see each other at the finish line right you know so if you're like me and you you're gonna be the one that's gonna own this and and set it up and teach people it it's a little bit all bark uh uh very little bite but anyway so that was just another thing yes all right so with the possibility of the solo stuff that i've been hearing and with the play that we've done today and everything and with we're needing to explore the other heroes i'm probably going to give this an eight an eight yes wait you're including the possibility that's not always going to be good but it would be higher oh it's good because i love the aspects of the game i i like having my kind of get my engine going i would be very intrigued to hear like to see if this lands on your top 100 and if it stays because yeah i don't see this thing that's what i told you earlier was like playing these each of these a few times yeah good the solo that book of solo stuff it's whole different setup it's sure it's total setup scenario different like i think it even changes how you play the game and what your goals are and everything i don't think it's point-based oh yeah so i don't know i haven't really looked at a whole lot but regardless yeah you know yeah but yeah i don't think it'll be a top 100 for a long time ago because of the replayability exactly yes isn't yeah okay uh cat five just a very really um i thought you were joking because you said you liked it no i did like it but yeah i mean i i uh she's like seth is

spitting some [ __ ] facts over here no i'm just i'm just very like you know just sort of like yeah i'll play it if you bring it out yeah i mean that's a good point like if you came over you're like hey you want to play i'd be like yeah i'll try the innkeeper yeah it's like i would want to try every faction once and be like i never want to touch this game again or if uh if you know we were in a big group of people and they're like hey you know we need another player i'd be like oh sure yeah yeah it's uh jump in yeah yeah but i won't be like don't you ever [ __ ] ask me to play this this has been a i will say kind of and i i'm not trying to be like i'm the smartest [ __ ] guy there are very few games that i i i am that stop me you have five points uh no i know that i'm handed and taught and i'm like so what the [ __ ] do i do like even with root i'm like oh yeah it's all right here i just go top to bottom and that's that uh now obviously there's a nuances of what the faction does but here it was kind of like okay i've never played the chronomancer so how do i like what do i do what are the actions like uh and i said stump not stop i wasn't trying to but they didn't get stumped wasn't trying to be like oh you [ __ ] [ __ ] loser uh yeah it was so weird because i was like in a foreign territory i'm just like what are the actions well it's a weird teach because you know when i was teaching this it was like i i was wanting to teach what this did yeah before anything else you know and then with this stuff i mean

it's pretty much just knowing what your symbols do yeah and everyone has the same symbols right but how you do them though like yours is completely different that's why i said that one's the most difficult because and even then it wasn't it was i know but it's just that bouncing well i'm saying that for them right like out of out of all other you know the three um i think it did in terms of the easy the heart it'd probably be easy than middle hard so i picked that one as the easiest it's pretty [ __ ] easy the only reason i say that is because you have an entire bag of marbles you at least have five colors oh the the bag is literally you just replace what you took right but it's still completely random in terms of the potions you want to make and then the order they're falling down you have you have more control over your dice and she does her back i mean there's that's the only reason i say that you guys are pretty close i can pull an acre down and that's just like a permanent free spot does it stay there yeah yeah it does not ever i just didn't do it because i didn't want to i didn't i just didn't want to start railing potions out if you get those dropped down well maybe catch a sucked ass at playing the alchemist there was a lot that i was like oh i don't want to do that because it takes so much to make a potion but it turns out yeah kind of it was potions plural yeah because you were able to you build up for it you guys really are kind of similar um you have the randomness of that versus the randomness of the bag i didn't have any randomness the only thing that made him difficult which i think is actually a really good balance is the fact that for me to get sponsorships for to balance the fact that i can control time i have to then cover up the sponsorships um but yeah i mean obviously they're more

complex uh let's see i think i'm gonna give it it's weird i hate ranking games because it's like that was it's like watching a movie you're like that movie was great never want to watch it again you know um i'm gonna give it a six i guess slightly above average um so yeah i think that's where where i i shall fall so yeah so five six eight eight yep all right so that's our thoughts on merchants cove everyone uh let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day that's for you

Progress saved