Picture Perfect: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for picture perfect uh which is one of the newest games by arcane wonders uh this one was a game that i actually had demoed at gen con and had jason levine from the dice tower kind of uh he was he was uh talking up this game what's his brother's name adam living yeah yeah he is he is yep yeah boy that would be quite the the stark difference between those adam's just like um but it was introduced to me as a uh it's a logic game and uh man he really did did hype it up because he's like this is one of the best logic games ever um this game is okay you know what this is my kind of logic like this is this is this is yeah tolerable it's yeah it's i well i thought you'd like to search for planet x the yeah okay i guess you didn't remember not liking it i remember tricking devin on accident well because it was like basic uh because we played on the easy easy version which um but anyway so yeah the point of the game is you are trying to uh organize people and you know in the ways that they they want from their envelopes uh pretty replayable i guess like it has i mean you're gonna you're gonna see the same types of cards but they're gonna be in different envelopes um and i i don't know i think this game is just it's okay it's it's okay so uh i'll let
you guys talk what do you guys think of picture perfect well it can't go because i think she likes it the most yeah i like it um i think it's it's a nice enough little puzzle um you don't have to stretch your brain too much not a whole lot of mental gymnastics going on but just enough that you're like where did this person need to be or like what you do have to weigh like what's more important to you like i can still score off of this or sometimes you don't realize that you can score like uh oh i can actually get two out of three instead of just the one i thought um or you just have those cards that you're like this isn't working at all this person just cannot get what they want yeah at all uh or yeah i don't know i i think it's interesting i think it's just enough like stuff going on for this game but i mean we've played it twice now this is my second time playing it anyway yeah i played that game and that's enough for a while for a while because it's because it is going to get steamy really quick like yes it's just there's not enough variety there's just it falls into the trap of with i mean the only logic game i can think of is the search for planet x because that's also one of the newest it doesn't have the benefits of an app randomizing everything because search plan x does have the app it also has um the expert mode which uh this one doesn't have the same cards the event cards really or how you draft the different envelopes they're the same for it's these six cards just in random order yeah so you know what's coming up you know how you're gonna get some you know uh
i mean eventually you'll most likely get to look at almost everyone uh but not everyone it's very free-flowing which is nice it's not so with this game which is actually a perk over search for planet x is searchable if you if you misinterpret a rule or or a piece of information your game is [ __ ] the rest the entire time yeah all your information is skewed and that's very punishing especially if you're very realistic though i guess but uh it's still not fun if you if you're if you play a game and you're like wait a minute oh i misunderstood that comet rule well whoops all right negative points for me the rest of the game or i scratched out the wrong thing yeah there's no way to recover exactly and this one does not fall into that trap it is like you can look at someone and it's like like you can look at you know the pompous rich kid and it's like i want to stand next to this person and you can take that person he wants to stand next to and put it next to him yeah and be like oh okay now i uh and oh because that's kind of what i did is i had the rich kid and he wanted to stand next to uh yeah like the guy in yellow and then the girl in blue and it's like um and so i just placed them there yeah and then whenever i got those cards i was like oh okay now let's see what kind of rules they have can i finagle this to now meet their requirements as well so i like that it's not as strict or punishing so brett what do you think um a couple of things right off the bat uh one is personally i really really like logic puzzles okay um and i grew up with with doing some in school i i enjoy
playing sudoku oh yeah i was really into sudoku as a kid yeah and and i still am so shut up no no it's not that i don't it's just i'm not going out of my way but anyway keep going so the first thing i would say is i would not call this a logic game okay i would call it a memory game interesting okay even though you are looking at almost a third well in a three-player game uh you are looking at a collection any given time you can look through them it really comes down to and where i lost all the points was either things i hadn't seen which i take some responsibility for that's fine um i but at that point i knew i was already overloaded and if i get more information i'm gonna start getting stuff i'm actually holding on to right now yeah so that's why i said no it's not gonna work for me yeah it does for some people um now there is a logic of course in you've got three rules that each of them want to follow and some of them are self-contradictory some of them are contradicting other people's yeah so it's the puzzle is figuring out how to accommodate as much as possible right so in that sense i would call it a logic game if you had the opportunity to look at all of the envelopes at any given time instead of only the ones that you have yeah i mean but then that and i guess they go hand in hand because search for planet x you have memory aspects as well i mean you have ways of taking notes right like whenever you're given like a press conference or uh you know whenever you're like i'm gonna do do a research on yeah that sector or whatever right uh you have ways of taking notes in that one which help with the memory so essentially this is that you just don't have ways i guess you could take notes but that would
really blog this game down yeah yeah it would so if this were a true okay if this took out the memory aspect then i think it would be really bogged down in rules and trivialities and everyone is just trying to math out the perfect way of doing it and that's not going to be very much fun yeah you lose a few mathematicians right you lose the gimmick of the game of trying to take a perfect picture there's even a rule where you technically do have to take a picture um and which is fun to prove that faces are blocked yeah but that's really it and we'll talk about that in a sec um so getting back to uh so beyond the classification aspect um it is light it is not intended to be you know i'm trying to figure out how to possibly maximize everything at any given time it really is oh screwed up oh well i asked i lost three points yeah the game takes like 30 minutes to play yeah uh slightly heavier than what i would call the filler yeah but it can fit in that classification or for people who really are adept at this it would be a silly little filler right um so uh if it's funny if you mention sudoku quick quick uh bunny trail is uh whenever i was in eighth grade that's whenever i was like really addicted to sudoku my eighth grade science teacher he was like he's like what is that and i was like oh it's just like puzzle game and he got hooked on sudoku as well i'm like oh it's so it's so addictive sudoku dealer yeah handing out books
handing out little books no i remember i bought them like a bunch of books i went to like the dollar store because i was in eighth grade i didn't have like any money and i bought them like but like three sudoku books and then he wasn't there the next year so i was sad but they were like listening i mean probably grown older it's like doing sudoku with kids no it's probably that he just you know got so into sudoku that he forgot about his job and he's homeless he's still on the streets today begging people begging for sudoku puzzles yeah there are some but anyway back to this it's uh so the gimmick of course is whenever they called a picture perfect and then like the demo or was explaining the game and she's like all right you guys need to take a picture and i thought like oh like literally with my phone i actually have to take a picture and she's like yeah and and there's some kind of a scoring app i thought
and that's the problem is that is purely for the sake of gimmicks yeah um there's one logic in this where it ever comes into play and it's like i don't want people to see my face or i don't want you know i don't want anyone to see that person's face and only then does that come in handy i wish that taking a picture mattered more for whatever reason other than just being serious other than because it was so stressed to you as important well it did she seemed like it fits the giving because demowers really can skew like if you have a great demo or it can also skew it in in a way that makes the game better than it actually is uh you can also have shitty demoers which i had and in my whenever i went to gen con last i had a really bad demo that almost made me immediately get on kickstarter and sell the game oh [ __ ] because i was like dude [ __ ] this game and then so i was like i went on and i looked up the pdf for the rules and i was like no he taught it wrong and i'm like oh my god because whenever you're demoing a game you have to be like hey this is a demo this is not we're omitting rules we're shortening it we're cutting it we're doing this so more people can play the game and you're not sitting here and he didn't do that at all anyway but no she seemed like really excited about oh yeah i know you really take a picture so i in my head i was like no that's going to come in handy because we'd obviously didn't play a full game of this we didn't uh look at every single card we didn't look at every single card of these um so i thought like that there was more to it and technically there is but yeah the
picture is just to have a fun picture um yeah but the other thing that uh bugged me uh about the way that they presented this presented this game is that these acrylic clear pieces do not come in the base game you have to buy them their deluxe components and even she was like no you want to get those because the original pieces fall down a lot more and i'm like that's frustrating like granted you get this and then two sets of the deluxe for a four player game for like 50 or 60 bucks so it wasn't that big of an upcharge but at the same time it's like no so you guys just made bad components and then you made the side piece you know just to try and make some extra money so what comes in the original okay yeah they're cardboard and like i mean the bases for these are they're a lot heavier um and i i can't say we didn't play with these in the demo we played with the cardboard and they do fall down like like these do have a little bit more weight to them like just doing just doing this well that but just doing this wouldn't would have knocked those original pieces down right so stray psy would send it all to balloon well that's not a sign yeah yeah and then they all fly across the table but that's just annoying from a business practice to be like okay so you you release the shitty like shitty component game and then you're like oh wait we can fix this give us more money yeah you you uh create the problem so you can sell the solution yeah apple's idea well that's where
pharmaceuticals yeah or i was gonna say mechanics but oh man your timing belts out too sorry man it was working just fine yeah but whenever we fit you know we took we yeah don't be surprised in a week if you have an oil leak so yeah uh the other thing is like the vip card it's like i wish there was something in the in the rules where it was like that it you had a certain timing of when you had to put it to have some risk yeah like for me that put because like for we all had one that we got all three yeah and at the end of the game your whole i mean that doesn't change the score at all the relative score yeah we all pretty much stay the same and it would have been nice that you had to pick one maybe you're opening hand and you're really trying to hold on to that person the entire time because there's cards in here that's like you know steal one you know pass one on i did make myself nervous i put my vip on my plan the second i think like turner maybe just right yeah i think it was the second term and i was like i shouldn't have done that yeah but i was so confident right and it's like yeah that could be stolen and then because the way that the vip cards work is there can be multiple vip cards in one envelope uh but you know there's never gonna be the way that just the game works it's too free-flowing yeah um and that's kind of what what it's like i like the way the game works it works perfectly fine uh my only gripes are really from a business perspective and the demo er yeah i mean she was cool but like yeah the demo was what it's a hyped up gen con demo uh but what boxes this game down for me is that the scores are relatively the same
until and until you know oh i didn't get to see that one ah well i had to play some were there so i guess that's negative three yeah and uh it's too free-flowing for me like yes there's the frustration of search for planet x and you misinterpret the rule and your your game is essentially [ __ ] up but this one is like you can't make you can't make you'd have to go out of your way to make mistakes right be like oh i'm not gonna look at any of them i'm just gonna play some and hope like that's really how you you tank a score but that's just me that's kind of how how i i like games i know there's an auction rule where you have the decorations well throwing the wine ball at the person uh the decorations come into play you actually auction off envelopes uh it that's probably the the extra mode i confess i haven't played that variant which i will um just to see because whenever i didn't like search for planet x when i played the basic mode because i was like ah this game is too easy to figure everything out because everyone finds everything out rough around the same time okay um in the expert mode there's so much you can't possibly find everything and i like that a lot more okay um so yeah that's kind of uh that's kind of the the gripes um like and and the the game it's i mean it's nice otherwise this is what it is it's a it's a pleasant game so i don't know who this is for though it's such a weird theme i bought this mainly because it came out
well i think i think i would say the target audience is people who enjoy light games like not you know just a little bit more than filler and then just yeah just a little lighter yeah people who are very very recreational yeah yeah i would have also like to see more event cards that it's not the same six these ones would have just been nice that you don't know what's going to come i mean more more creative creative ones like the dance one where it's like oh okay you know people go dancing you shuffle them up and then you get more back um they go off to your dance and they come back you're like wait a minute you you weren't uh you weren't here uh before okay where the hell do you want to stand like i don't want to be next to this person or that person and i want to be as far away from the table it's like great well they both want to be by you so yeah yeah and it's like oh wow okay and that's work there is there is it's not so straightforward that you're just going through the motions right because like had said it's like well that person wants to stand next to that person but they don't want to stand next to them it's like okay how can they make you both happy and still get something out of this which is thematic i think they actually do a pretty good job with that uh one thing i think they really miss the mark on is naming these characters yeah like yes yeah yeah no it would have been cute like a couple of lines in the book not on the cards oh yeah just to add to the theme because it is very theme having yeah it seems like this is a family this could be 100 abstract sure and they put on a good theme and they played it up nicely yeah the art the time frame it all fits nicely i mean
yeah the backdrops like of where they're at trying to take and they seem like a family yeah and it would have just been nice for them to i mean you could easily put a name so whenever you're talking then it's like oh by the way we're doing charles and then william and rebecca and agatha and agatha and agatha and charles and brittany and clay and agatha and william skeletor and bebop and he-man and blitz and shits yeah but no i mean i guess maybe that's part of the fun is you you create your own naming them yourself naming them yourself i don't know i mean i thought it was hilarious that you named the dog korg because i thought you were talking about korg from thor ragnarok no it's corgi korg the courtney i didn't know who that's who you were talking about uh see exactly but if he had a name on the card you know who i was talking about they probably would have known something stupid like barry so as you can see this game is fine it's fun but cat said uh it's like all right i've played it you know two times in a row i think i'm done that's enough yeah in a few months maybe maybe maybe a couple weeks yeah it just needs a cool down period that's all sure all right so on a scale of one to ten uh what would you guys give picture perfect you know what i'm gonna give it a seven seven yeah it's pretty decent score yeah right i'll go six i'm at six as well well i'll take it back i think that's five no no
no you you liked it better than you did that's appropriate you know what you're right no seven it couldn't possibly be perfecter yeah we had no your picture probably could though now on a scale of other games it's a little above metal yeah yeah like the actual score yeah uh yeah yeah it's uh slightly above average um so all right that's our thoughts on picture perfect let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this view hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you