2025's MOST HYPED Board Games That DISAPPOINTED US
Transcript
We've been playing through the most hyped and anticipated board games that came out in 2025. And honestly, a lot of them didn't deliver. We're not talking about games that are broken. We're talking about games that had serious potential, real excitement behind them, and then they just fell flat. Yeah, this was harder to tackle than our previously released video about the top 10 board games of 2025. We're focusing on the ones with real momentum behind them. Games people were excited about that failed to meet expectations.
So today, we're breaking down the 10 most disappointing board games of 2025. For each one, we're giving you the overview of what the game actually is and then specifically why it let us down based on our actual experience playing them.
Let's jump in with number 10. Number 10 is Merchants of Andromeda from RER Canitzia. Released in spring 2025 through AllPlay and Renegade games, Kenitzia is one of the best designers in the world. So, we were genuinely excited about this. Your space merchants traveling the galaxy, bidding at auctions across different planetary boards, collecting resources, and trying to score the most victory points. The game has five separate boards: production, exploration, Senate, defense, and station. Each one has distinct mechanics. Your turn structure works like this. You draw three cards one by one, and you have to immediately decide where to place each card before you even see the next one. You can discard for just resources, trigger board actions, or put cards up for auction.
The auction system is a Dutch auction. You place a card in the auction slot. The app starts at 20 credits, which is absurdly high, and the price gradually drops. All players participate, and you place your finger on the table. First person to remove their finger wins at the displayed price. You get both the resource and the board action.
Victory is most victory points. At the end, you score from remaining credits, board scoring events that happen throughout the game, resource track positions, majorities on various boards, and collecting all three of certain gods tiles for bonuses. Here's where it disappoints us. Despite being from Riner Canitzia, the guy who designed some of gaming's most elegant auction games, Merchants of Andromeda feels bloated with five disconnected miniames that never coales into something great. This is heartbreaking because we love Canitzia auction games and this is the worst of his work we've played. The setup is cumbersome. Tracking across five boards is tedious. The box says 45 minutes, but we're consistently looking at 90 easily. Event cards cascade constantly. We've had five or six events trigger in a single turn when they shuffle poorly. The space theme doesn't actually integrate with the mechanics.
It just feels like someone painted a galaxy on top of a collection of mechanisms. We'd rather play raw or modern art. Cleaner Canitzia designs that are way more satisfying. This felt like a missed opportunity from someone we know can do better. Number eight is Iliad from Bitewing Games. This is another Reer Canitzia design released April 2025. This is a two-playeronly abstract strategy game about ancient Greek warfare. You're playing warrior tiles onto a cloth board grid, and when rows or columns fill up, you score them based on warrior values.
Here's how it actually plays. On your turn, you choose one of two tiles from your hand, place it adjacent to your opponent's tile, optionally activate that tile's special ability, and then draw back to two tiles. You've got warriors with values 1 through 5, plus special dos tiles that can mirror adjacent enemy warriors values to become very powerful. When a row or column completes with six tiles, you pause and score it. Whoever has the highest total warrior value in that lane picks first from two scoring tiles at the ends. These scoring tiles are what you're actually collecting. God's favor, points, special effects. There are five gods, and you're trying to collect favor from all five.
Victory condition is straightforward. First player with favor from all five gods wins immediately. If both or neither have complete god sets, you go to points. The kitia twist is that only your highest value tile from each god counts toward your total.
And here's our massive disappointment. Iliad initially appears strategic, but is purely tactical. After three to five plays, optimal patterns emerged for us, and games felt sy. We felt like we were playing toast with different toppings after the first few replays. There's simply not enough variety between plays to sustain our engagement.
The hand limit of two tiles is restrictive in a bad way for us. It creates frustration rather than interesting constraint. Component quality is a real problem, too. The cloth board doesn't lie flat despite heavy tiles, and the tiles wear quickly. For a 30, $35 game, that matters. Draw luck dominated more than we expected from a Canitzia design. The last few tiles captured get the majority of scoring and we couldn't plan ahead effectively.
We found it enjoyable once or twice and then we just don't request it again. For a Canitzia game, especially two player from someone at his level, that's disappointing to us. Number seven is Foxpaw from GDM games. This is a Harry Potter themed worker placement game. You attend magic school, learn spells, and compete in duels to complete house objectives. We were really hoping this would be what fans have wanted for years. Finally, a good Harry Potter board game.
Here's how it actually plays. You place workers on school locations to gather resources like mana and ingredients. You learn new spells throughout the game, building your deck. There's a dual subsystem where you and opponents play spells simultaneously, reveal them, and resolve effects to determine winners. House goals and personal objectives give you victory points. Victory is most victory points from completing house goals, winning duels, and fulfilling personal objectives. The game ends after set number of rounds or when someone hits a victory threshold. And here's why it disappointed us. The mechanics are disjointed. Worker placement and dueling don't mesh together in our experience. These are two separate games with different design philosophies forced into one box. Worker placement is about efficiency and optimization. Dueling is about direct conflict and card play. In practice, they don't work well together.
The duel system also excludes players. Only two players duel at a time. In a three or four player game, others sit around waiting. That downtime becomes frustrating for everyone not involved. Duels feel tacked on rather than integrated. We felt the game failed to deliver on the good Harry Potter game promise that drew us in. The tone, the attempted Harry Potter whimsy also fell flat for us. Players report engagement drops quickly after initial plays because the mechanics feel bolted together rather than integrated. That's exactly what we experienced.
Number seven is
Magical Athlete from CMK 2025. This is a redesigned version of an older game with Richard Garfield contributing to this edition. You're drafting four fantastical athletes with completely absurd superpowers and racing them across tracks. Think Saturday morning cartoon meets Olympic games.
The setup is spectacular. 35 colorful wooden figures pour from a paper bag onto the table. That ritual invokes the spirit of play. You snake draft. Each player drafts four racers total. Then you play four separate races. Each race is automated. Roll dice, move, watch chaos resolve, repeat.
On each racer's turn, you roll a dieice, move that many spaces, and powers trigger automatically based on where you land. Mot eats racers on the same space, which causes player elimination on turn one if unlucky. Banana trips opponents. Centaur kicks racers backward. Big Baby blocks paths. Powers cascade. One die roll sets off multiple reactions. Victory is most victory points after four races. Only top two finishers score per race. Early races give one to three points. Later races give five plus points or more. The track has mild and wild sides with bonus and penalty spaces.
Here's our core disappointment. After drafting, we have almost no control over outcomes. This is pure roll and move. A game type that went out of style in the 1950s. You roll, move, watch stuff happen, repeat. We felt like a cat knocking the die off the table could have done the same thing as us playing. Player elimination is brutal from our perspective. MOT can eliminate someone on turn one and they sit idle for 10 minutes doing nothing. We experienced exactly this. Getting eliminated on the first turn of a race and having to sit there for 10 minutes doing nothing. That's not fun. After a few plays, the chaos becomes tedious rather than entertaining. The draft is the only meaningful decision we make. Everything else is just watching dice rolls resolve. Number five is The Dark Quarter from Lucky Duck Games in Asthma Day 2025. This is a cooperative horror game that's heavily app dependent. You explore a dark supernatural city quarter uncovering mysteries and fighting supernatural threats. The companion app controls narrative, encounters, and game state. The app runs story progression, encounter triggers, enemy placement, resource tracking, and victory conditions. Physical components include a board, character miniatures, encounters, item tokens. But the app is really running the game. On your turn, you move, take actions, then the app resolves outcomes.
Skill checks involve rolling dice against target numbers that the app determines. You must use the app to resolve the outcome. Encounters are drawn from a deck. The app tells you which paragraph to read. You make narrative choices and the app resolves consequences.
Victory is completing objectives given by the app before collective health reaches zero. Defeat if all players health depletes. Sanity is collectively exhausted, the scenario timer expires, or the app declares defeat.
Here's why it disappointed us. The app is plagued by logic errors. It has grammatical mistakes that suggest rushed development. Events trigger incorrectly in our playthroughs. Game state desyncs between app and board. The app creates bottlenecks. We must wait for app processing. One player at a time interacts with the app. Others sit idle during app interactions. That's not cooperative gaming.
Most infuriating is there's no undo button. The app has no undo. We made mistakes that became permanent. Misclicks, lost resources, wrong selections couldn't be reversed. When the game crawls like this, it feels like a chore. Physical components feel optional. The app is the real game. Diceheavy skill checks feel like a chore, not strategic decisions, too much rolling, too many arbitrary outcomes, no player mitigation. Number four is Crafting the Cosmos, released 2025. You're interstellar architects creating nebulas, stars, and cosmic phenomena. You move marbles around a shared grid, gather resources, then distribute them on player boards to score points. It's a tile placement puzzle game in space. You've got a shared grid main board, player boards for nebula creation, marbles representing resources like helium and oxygen, star tokens representing protolife, stable life, advanced life. On your turn, you move marbles around the grid following specific movement rules. Protolife stars move one way. Advanced life stars move differently. If there's no other star in between, additional restrictions apply.
Then you distribute gathered resources across your playerboard. Place stars, nebula tiles, life tokens, trigger bonuses, and combos. Score your nebula midame and late game. Surround tiles with advanced life tokens for one-time bonuses. Victory is most points from nebula scoring. energy track positions, oxygen stars, stars in specific sectors, goal card majorities.
Here's the massive issue we experienced. Downtime at higher player counts. At four players, we're looking at 10 plus minutes per player per turn. Others sit idle, optimizing their own boards. Minimal player interaction means downtime isn't filled with engagement. We had sessions clocking in at 2 hours or more just for four players.
Component handling is extremely fiddly. Proto and stable life tokens are very small. We constantly adjust pieces. Handling is tedious. Tokens fall over, get knocked around. Rules create constant edge pace questions. Movement restrictions in the rule book create rule questions on basically every turn. We check the rule book constantly, even after the teach video. The retail price is $80. For $80, we get massive downtime, fiddly components, and unclear rules. This is the kind of game we would probably only play on board game arena if at all. Board Game Arena version handles movement restrictions automatically. Eliminates fiddliness, removes rules ambiguity, but for physical retail at that price point. Disappointing.
Number three is Defenders of the Wild 2025 from Outlandish Games. This is a cooperative game where you're defending habitats from mechanical invaders. Players are defenders from different ecosystems fighting to rew factories and protect nature. Four distinct factions with unique identities.
Setup has a modular hex board, faction boards tracking support, a machine deck creating threats, defender decks unique to each faction. On your turn, you silently select a defender from hand, play it face down, reveal together. Defenders produce immediate or ongoing effects. Then you take actions in turn order. Actions include moving across the hex board, clearing pollution, breaching walls, defeating mechs, gaining items, building camps, gaining support. Support is tracked on individual boards. When support reaches maximum, you build a camp on matching habitat. Building camps equals progress toward victory. Then machine phase. Draw a machine card. It spawns enemies, spreads pollution, builds factories. Every card increases adversity. Victory is all factions build all their camps and all factories are rewed. Defeat if two defenders of the same type are killed, six toxic sights spread, or five factories are built.
Once you build all your camps, you exit the game and become a spectator. Here's our disappointment. Silent defender selection promises thematic mistrust, but mechanically it cripples our strategic planning. We can't coordinate effectively. It makes the game harder without payoff. Mechanically, the decision space didn't feel deep overall. Its tactical responses to board state like pandemic, but less satisfying.
The machine deck only has seven cards. It cycles quickly becomes memorized. Adversity feels flat when we know what's coming. Reverse elimination is puzzling. Once you finish your camps, you're out. Become a spectator. In a fully cooperative game, shifting from teammate to spectator bothered us. Some of us sat frustrated watching others finish. Box says 60 to 90 minutes. Actual play time for us 120 plus minutes consistently. Even achieving victory felt hollow. Number two is Cross Bronx Expressway released December 2025. This is a CO N system game counterinsurgency card driven like Twilight Struggle in Labyrinth. It's about construction of the Cross Bronx Expressway and its impact on Bronx neighborhoods.
Historical game exploring Robert Moses's controversial urban planning.
COIN system basics. Card driven action selection with asymmetrical faction powers. Area control mechanics. Resource management for money, political capital, community support. Players represent different factions with competing interests about the expressway. You choose to trigger events or take actions. Action types include rally for resources, march to move influence, attack for direct conflict, and special activities unique to your faction. Area control determines who benefits from neighborhoods. Resources include construction funding, political influence, and community support. Victory conditions vary by scenario and faction.
Here's the devastating disappointment we experienced. The Cross Bronx Expressway is barely visible on the board. For a game named after the expressway, this is catastrophic. Theme and mechanics disconnect fundamentally. We're playing an abstract game about politics and resources that happens to be named after an expressway. The board shows neighborhoods and districts abstractly. Construction doesn't visually manifest.
The game lacks special activities from other coin games. Those create dramatic moments. the gotcha or turning point occasions that make coin exciting. We didn't feel those moments. Faction asymmetry is diminished compared to other coin designs. Many neutral pieces lack clear function. The game is not about the Cross Bronx Expressway. It's abstract and distant. The game fails to capture the historical weight and impact of displacement that makes this topic compelling. Number one is limit a society simulation released 2025. This is a complex simulation of an entire society. You manage interconnected systems, economy, environment, politics, culture trying to create a thriving stable society or achieve specific societal outcomes depending on the scenario.
The game tracks dozens of variables across systems. Economy includes GDP, wealth distribution, employment, inflation. Environment includes pollution, resources, sustainability, biodiversity. Politics includes government stability, public approval, political factions. Culture includes social cohesion, innovation, unrest, social movements. Every action affects multiple systems simultaneously.
On your turn, you choose an action, spend resources. That action affects multiple systems and you update affected tracks. Example, building a factory gains production and employment but loses resources and gains pollution. Politics shift. Corporate approval increases but environmental groups disapprove. Culture drops from inequality. There are intended feedback loops but rules don't clarify which are intentional. Emergent interactions create unexpected cascades. Event cards create unpredictable situations, historical events, or random disasters. Some trigger across multiple systems. Victory varies by scenario, often creating the most stable, prosperous society or achieving specific goals.
Victory is complex and not clearly defined. We experienced what we'd rate as disappointing overall.
Here's why it disappointed us. This plays like an Excel spreadsheet. Overwhelming information, thrilling stories, but bogged down. Information overload is massive. We must track too many variables simultaneously. We struggle to see forest for trees. Analysis paralysis comes from over information. We can't make strategic decisions because we're buried in data. Rules are comprehensive but ambiguous about system interactions. Constant questions arise during play. Unclear feedback loops. The game creates them, but it's unclear which are intentional. Some loops feel like bugs. Others feel designed. We can't tell the difference. It feels like busy work, not strategy. We must calculate so much that meaningful strategy is lost. Calculation fatigue dominates gameplay. Every action requires updating four to six different tracks. Bookkeeping dominates over decision-making. Games feel similar despite variable setup. So, that's our 10 most disappointing board games of 2025 based on our own experiences.