Skip to main content
Loading video...

Luke Reviews - Chiyo's Secret

Transcript 5:43

I've been having a hard time recently because there was someone who I was supposed to trust to to show me a good time to entertain me and my friends for an evening and really give us a rulebook that made sense and a game that was exciting and interesting and I mean Shiho just kind of led us down I heard dirty secret just got in the way of us having a good time I just don't and I don't know how to bring it up I don't know how to how to talk to her or to the audience about how I feel it's just it's very upsetting and I don't know how to handle it in Chiho secret you are one of four different characters who are all trying to reach different endgame states mo Tanaka is the game master and they are trying to run out time before anyone else is able to get their victory conditions each of the other three characters are trying to get certain figures to certain locations before the end of the game if you're able to do that in the end game state than you win on your turn players are trying to gather information as to who these two fugitives disguise themselves as which is secretly selected by the game master at the start of the game by moving around different fingers on the board you're gonna move around characters that are face down or face up trying to move them to different positions and get information about them and you're also going to move around these two characters to do specific

actions moving two characters without either of these figures will allow you to ask the game master one of three yes-or-no questions which are preordained by the game moving a character and the daimyo will allow you to reveal characters on that location to try and ask the game master if any of them are one of the fugitives and then the rival another character can be moved to a location so that you can interrogate them to see whether or not they are one of the specific characters once the group as a whole has deduced that a specific character must be the Ronin or must be the geisha then that character is replaced by that one on the board and certain effects occur the second action will always be something that benefits the game master either moving the timer forward or allowing you the game master to get different resources the endgame state is when both of these characters have been revealed and placed in the appropriate spots where their disguises used to be and then the entire round state changes because each character is going to take turns based on how much honor they have at the point where the second one of these characters are revealed at that point players are trying to organize their different characters onto the different spots and whoever is able to do that first wins that was the most tiresome I don't I don't understand how to explain this

game like this game wants to be interesting and cool and I like that I like how involved all the stuff is I like the story that it wants to tell we have these fugitives that we're trying to scurry around the board and have revealed dramatically over the course the game as people use their deductive logic to find out oh it's the Royal Guard is the person who the Ronin the Ronin has been disguised as the whole game but it just comes off as tedious you know everything about this game is just minutia and rules and details on top of details and no one knows what's going on at any given point during the game no one really understands what's happening and so there's never a point of cleverness there's never a point of excitement of reveal of that ah I was the mastermind I was the usurper and I pulled off the impossible game there's never that it's always just Oh someone wins for what it's worth Geo secret try some very interesting things in creating a big experience in a small and affordable box and in some ways it succeeds in that but I think that success is that the cost of feeling like you make an impact in the game most games feel like they play themselves rather than have the players make any choices and ultimately this isn't a game this is not a game that I can in good conscience recommend over any other social deduction game Chiho secret is

tiring and I don't see a reason and revisiting it and I wish that this game did so much more but if you're looking for a story-driven game that is a social deduction style game look at the resistance avilon which tells the story of king arthur and the knights as they're trying to fend off against the forces of evil or play the menace among us which is coming out from smirk and dagger this and is focused on aliens that are trying to survive traders that have infiltrated the ship there are a lot of other games that have interesting themes that do the social deduction thing well and chinos secret is not one of them thank you so much for watching and I'll see you next time if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our Channel and website cardboard Herald calm our content is the audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard Herald

Progress saved