Skip to main content
Loading video...

How I Rate Games - with Tom Vasel

Transcript 10:02

Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassel. Welcome to the Dice Tower. Today I want to talk about how I rate games. We kind of rate things all the time in life. We all like to rate things. I rate everything. How much fun did I have doing so? And for a long time, I I've I've always rated my board games, but I've resisted putting ratings on our reviews. And that's because people ignore the entire review and focus on the rating. They'll say, "You said you like this game, and then you only gave it a seven. You said you loved this game, and then you gave it a nine. Why not a 10?" And they get so caught up in that. Uh even you know we have issues with the seal of excellence where three people will say it's a nine and then two people will say it's a two and you're like well how can it be excellent then because no one likes every game that's just how it works but I love doing numbers but I I applying a number often dissatisfies people but the question is Tom to me Tom how do you do your ratings? Well I've always was a big fan like I said of of ratings. Um, one of my that even I put a rating on a review because that rating can kind of hone where how you're looking at the review. When I would look at Roger Eert's reviews, who rated games who rated movies on a eight-point scale from zero to four stars and if you saw that he gave it three stars, you read the review in a positive light. I don't know how else to explain it. And if it said one star, you're like, well, he's going to hate this one. And you read it in that light.

But talking about his eightoint system, how do we quantify number systems? How big is the spread? I mean, we, you know, a lot of people have one through 10, right? Some people go one through 100. I used to read PC Gamer and there were the the games on there, they would give them a number from one to 100. Like, wow, this game got a 93. This is amazing game. Um, there's the one to four stars or eight if you do half stars. There's a one to five, which is a 10-point scale. If you do half, sometimes it could be a simple thumbs up or thumbs down. A lot of people these days do some sort of three tiered system. I notic this in a lot of board games where it's a positive, negative, or a try it first before you get it, which frankly should be any game. But how do we do these systems? We do a 20 point system here at the Dice Tower, but not really. Okay? And and I'll explain why. Um because a lot of the number thing is perception. Like I said, I understand the number is perception and a 10 is the best. The number one, the top tier. And in fact, I disagree with my very good friend Sam Healey, who I think is wrong in this where he says no game should get a 10 because a 10 is perfection and no game has reached perfection. But if that's true, then your nines are your tens and you're just throwing people off. But numbers themselves mean something. But who puts what number and what's the value of that

number? I like know even internally here in the dice z six and my six are a little bit different. If I get if I say a game is eight out of 10 or seven out of 10. If I say game seven out of 10 I mean the game's good. You should check it out. But if I gave you a 70 out of 100 in a test I don't think you would say good job. But see that's in a very objective stuff. When we rate things, it's different. So, a lot of people default to Board Game Geek. Board Gamegeeek is the biggest website, a wonderful database on games, and they have a rating scale there. Now, I know for a fact that when most people go there to rate games, they're just saying 10 is the best, one is the worst, and that's how they rate them. But they do have a suggested rating scale there. Uh, for example, 10 is outstanding, always want to play and expect this will never change. Nine, excellent game, always want to play it. Eight. Very good game.

I like to play. Probably I'll suggest it and will never turn down a game. Seven. Good game. Usually willing to play. Six. Okay game. Some fun or challenge at least. We'll play sporadically if in the right mood. Five. Average game. Slightly boring. Take it or leave it. Four. Not so good. It doesn't get me, but could be talked into it on occasion. Three. Likely won't play this again. Although could be convinced. Bad. Two. Extremely annoying game. Won't play this ever again. One. defies description of a game. You won't catch me dead playing this. Clearly broken. Some people take these so literally. This is a suggested rating scale, but like number 10 says, "Always want to play." Well, guess what? There's no game I always want to play. Uh if I'm sitting there watching an exciting movie with my wife and someone's like, "Hey, do you want to play your favorite game?" No, I'm doing this. But also some of these things they write on here I think are funny because like on four it says it doesn't get me but could be talked into it on occasion. If I give a game a four, you're never talking me into that game or three. They're like could be convinced on a three.

I don't think so. But again, that's what they have here. And if you go by the letter law, I can see that could be confusing. My rating is much simpler. 10 the best. Nine amazing. Eight so good. Seven good. F. Six, it's fine. Five, I don't really like it that much. Four, I hate it. Three, I hate it. Two, I hate it. And one, unprintable hatred. But really, when we talk about this and when we do our our ratings of things, there's the closeness of four and two. What's the difference between hate, hate, hate? There really isn't any. And that's because of perceptions. People will perceive the difference between a 7.5 and an eight much more than they will do between a four and a 3.5. Which is why I don't actually do 0.5s in the lower scale because it doesn't matter. When you dislike a game that much, the levels of dislike don't matter. But when you like games that much, you tend to play them more and so you will have more differentiation between those. That's the same reason why there's fewer tens and ones because those are perceived as perfect or the worst. Like I'll say I hate a game dramatically and give it a three. And people are like, "Well, what are the redeeming values? Why is it not a one?" Because one is just absolutely abysmal. The worst games are the worst.

And I save those for just very specific things. While 10, same thing. A 10 is usually the best. In fact, I very rarely give a 10 out initially when I play a game for the first time. Most games grow into tens over time. And do ratings change? Well, of course they do. That's why I do a show called Look Back here in the Dice Hour where I talk about ratings changing and they can even fluctuate in that because it doesn't matter most of the time. If I say, "I like this game a lot. It's a seven." And someone else say, "Hey, what do you think of the game?" I'm like, "Oh, I like it a lot. It's an eight." Am I being wishy-washy? Am I? No. Because my opinions are what matter. That's why we do a review. If it's just a number, first of all, that doesn't mean anything to me. When I go and buy something today, I was looking at a product to buy on Amazon and I saw it had all different ratings, fives, fours, threes, twos, and ones. Well, that doesn't mean anything to me. I look at the ratings and see, why do they say this product's bad? If they go, I tried to return it and they won't give me my money back. Well, that's not as bad as this this product clearly didn't work.

It's what they say that matters, not the numbers. Can we have standardized ratings? We cannot. We We simply can't. But we do have assumptions and the assumptions matter. 10 is the best, one is the worst. 10 is the absolute best, one is the absolute worst. Nines are good. And people understand that your scale may shift slightly differently than other people, but it's not that big of a deal. And at the end of the day, it's the review that matters. We'll keep putting numbers out. I like numbers. I like to rank things. Here's my top 10. That's what we do on the channel. I can rank all the games I've ever played in my life in order from 1 to 9,000. Although, I'm not going to do that. That would be a ton of work. But those numbers are going to fluctuate. And is there a really big difference between number 2345 and number 31?

Probably not. There's so many games out there. Numbers are the guide. It's words, ratings, and playing things for yourself that help you determine whether you like it or not. And you might change from one day to the next. Anyway, hopefully this gives a little bit more insight to how I rate. Is it basically just a 15oint scale where it's 1 2 3 4 5 and a half and all up to 10? Sure. Is that perfect? No. But I'm content knowing that the vast majority of people understand what I mean when I'm rating games and from that number can grasp an idea of where I'm headed with the words that I then proceed to pour out of my mouth and nonsensical words or whatever.

You may disagree with them tremendously, but you understand a little bit about where my conclusion is going to be from those words. What do you think about ratings? What are your thoughts? Let me know in the comments. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vassel and you've been watching the Dice Hour. Hey folks, I'm Tom Vassel. Thanks for watching this video. Check out our channel. We have a lot of videos on our channel. We have live videos that go up each week from live Q&As's to videos where we take a look at the newest stuff on Kickstarter crowd surfing to top 10 lists and more. There's lots of stuff on this channel. We encourage you to explore it. You can find out more at our website, dicetowwer.com. I'm Tom Bassel. Thanks for watching another video on the Dice Tower.

Progress saved