Captain Sonar Review
Transcript
Welcome to John Gets Games. Today I'll be reviewing Captain Sonar. In this game, up to eight players will split into two different teams, each piloting a submarine. They're going to be moving around the ocean map, dodging islands, and most importantly, trying to find the opposing team in order to shoot them with torpedoes or launch mines to try and destroy that submarine. Uh, this game is mostly played in real time, although there is a turn-based mode. I will explain how the game plays, and then I'll tell you what I think about it. The first thing you have to do when playing Captain Sonar is put this really large screen down the middle of the table. Then you're going to have to split your group of players into two different teams. Uh I'm going to teach the game as if it is two teams of four, but if you have less players, then uh certain roles uh certain people will take on different uh numbers of the roles. There are four roles in the game. We have the radio operator, the captain, the first mate, and the engineer over here. So each player will sit down in front of them. And now I'll go into explaining each of them. Let's begin with the captain map. And of course, one thing that everybody can do optionally is they can name the submarine and give themselves a specific name as well on their player map. But what we see over here for the captain is the overall sea area where uh both teams are going to be playing. What's going on in this game is we are each in a submarine. We're going to be moving around this map and trying to find each other and blow each other up. At the beginning of the game, the captain arbitrarily picks one spot on the map. Well, maybe not arbitrary, but they can go anywhere as a starting location. So, for instance, they could just put an X right there. And this is now where they're going to begin the game. Over here, we have a section that is purely for notes. And realistically, all the captain is going to be doing is navigating the submarine around this
map. From this point on in the real-time game, the captain is simply going to be giving out orders. They might say, uh, heading south, and then they just draw a line on their map. They might say they go south again. And every time they give a heading, the first mate and the engineer are going to have to mark something on their boards. And I'll show that in just a minute before the captain is allowed to go again. The main restrictions that the captain has is they are never allowed to overlap back on their line. So at this point, they would not be able to go west. They would have to go north or east in this uh instance. So once the captain starts moving around the map, they are going to eventually find themselves in a position where they uh might not be able to get to where the opponent is. So for instance, uh if we now find out the opponent is over here now, it would take a really long time for the captain to get over there and potentially shoot at them. So, they might think about surfacing, but I'll talk about that when we're going through the engineer role.
But first, let's talk about the first mate. This player sits to the right of the captain, and every time the captain gives a heading, whether it be north, south, east, or west, the uh first mate is going to check off one section on one of these power meters on the board. Essentially, uh at the beginning of the game, you have five different abilities you can activate. Down here, this says scenario, but there's only one map in the game currently that actually uses this. So, for the most part, there are five different things that you will be doing as the first mate. Now, when you are checking these off, you have to start at the top and then work your way down, but there are no specific rules. So, you can hop around with the different headings that the captain is giving and jump around or just go down really hard on a specific one. Again, checking down one box for every single time that the submarine moves. Another important role that the first mate has is they track the amount of damage that the submarine has taken throughout the game. They check off these boxes here to show the damage that they've taken. And once any submarine has four damage, then that submarine is destroyed and the game ends winning the game for the opposing side. I think at this point, let's now briefly discuss these five abilities because they really are a big part of how the game plays and we may as well begin with the drone. You'll see that this is completed at this point. And as long as the engineer says that the drone system is activated, and I'll explain in a minute what that means, if it might not be, then at this point, the captain would be able to stop the play. They would uh in fact yell stop out to the entire table and then they would say they're activating the drone. At this point, the first mate would erase everything, all the marks on here and the captain will evaluate this ability.
If you look down here, this one's really simple. The map that we play on is split into nine different sectors and you can see the number is kind of highlighted underneath. So for the drone, you simply ask the opposing team, are you in a specific sector? And they have to say yes or no. The counterpart system to the drone is sonar down here. And you'll see this only takes three sections in order to activate. And this one is arguably much more interesting. If you look down here, it says one true and one false. And what that means is the captain is of the opposing team once the sonar is activated is going to have to give one truth and one lie about their current position. So for instance, if this was the opposing team, they are currently in the location L10 when it comes to the row and column here. But they would have to say either a column, a row, or a sector. and they'd have to say two things, one of which is a truth and one is a lie. At that point, the radio operator, which I'll explain in just a minute, will write that information down and try to use it against the other team, try to figure out where they are on this map. Next up, let's briefly talk about silence over here. Now, you'll notice it has six marks. In fact, it's definitely the hardest one to get active out of all of them because it is a very potent ability. Once you've activated silence, you get to move up to four um movements in a straight line in any given direction. But most importantly, you don't tell the opposing team which direction you've gone. That's one important thing. When I mentioned the captain earlier, they are saying they're going north or east, and they're vocalizing it to the point where the opposing team can hear it as well, but not so with silence. So, in this instance, for example, if we were right here, we could move down twice, but we
would potentially hit an island. We could move up three times, or we could go four times in this direction. And most importantly, the opposing team is not going to know which one we picked. All right, it's now time to talk about the offensive capabilities that we have with the submarine over here with the weapon systems. We'll start with a mine. And once you have uh put all three chunks into the mine, you can lay a mine in a spot that is adjacent to where the submarine currently is. So, for instance, if we were still in this position, we could put a mine here, here, here, here, here, or here. You're not allowed to put a mine where you are or behind you. And when you put a mine down, you put a little M down on the map. And what this means is at a later part during the game, if you suspect that the opposing team has uh moved in such a way that they are either on the spot or within one of that spot, you can then detonate the mine and try to do damage to them. And the way damage works for mines is exactly the same as the way it works for torpedoes. So, let's go ahead and talk about that. Now, this also takes only three activations. And the way this works is once you've activated the torpedo, you can shoot it out from your submarine and try to hit the opposing team submarine. And the thing about torpedoes is that they have a max distance of four from where you currently are. So, I've drawn a little squiggly line around all of the areas on this map that we could currently hit with the torpedo. And as you can see, it's quite a lot. Now, uh once you have fired the torpedo, then you stop, you yell stop to the table. And then you tell the opposing team a column and row coordinate, which is in this different this area right here, and you ask them if it is a hit. They will either say a partial hit or a direct hit. If it's direct, that means they were exactly in the spot that we said. If it's partial,
that means it is adjacent to that spot in one of the eight spots around it. As you can see down here, if it's a direct hit, they're going to take two damage. And if it is a partial hit, they're only going to take a single damage. They will write it on their board, and the game will continue. It's also important to note that you are going to be giving your opponent a reasonable amount of information when you shoot them with a torpedo because they now have a general area of where they think you could be on the map because you have to be within four of the location that you fired to. Next up, we have the engineer role. And just like the first mate who will be sitting to their left, every time the captain gives out a directional order, the engineer must cross something off on their board. But instead of powering up systems like the first mate, the engineer is actually destroying or just damaging things on the ship. Now, you'll notice we have a west, north, south, and east section.
And that means that if the captain says south, the engineer must cross off something that is in this south section of the uh engineering panel. You may have noticed that many of these symbols on the engineering board directly match the symbols that were on the first maid sheet. And what that means is if the engineer marks this off when the captain goes south, the submarine in general can now no longer activate either of the two green abilities, which are sonar and drone. Uh so it's really important to try and clear these things up, but every single time the captain moves, you need to keep breaking things. If they go south again, well, suddenly we need to do this, and then now we can't launch any of our weapons. And if it goes south again, we do this, and now we can't go silent. So, it's really important that even just one of these symbols will lock down an entire subset of systems that the first mate is trying to active activate. Fortunately, if the captain now decides to go east, the engineer would have the option of going here. And if you'll notice, all of these are connected by the same line. And that means they are a subsystem. And once all of a subsystem is damaged, then for some reason they miraculously repair themselves. And now these systems are usable again. You may have also noticed these symbols down at the bottom of these directional areas and how they are not actually connected to any specific subsystem. First of all, we have the symbols that match the other ones. So, if we cross this off, then once again, we're not able to activate the weapons on the ship. But we also have these over here, which are the uh rad uh nuclear radiation energy creators, I think, for the ship. Essentially damaging the um the reactor for the ship. And the only way that you're going to clear these off is through the three ways that you can do an entire board clear. The first way that this happens is if you damage every
single aspect to one specific zone on the ship. So if you've done all of them in the south area, then the ship immediately takes a damage. And you can see that down here showing all these crossed off. But in that moment, the engineer is now able to cross all these off from the board. So it's kind of good to clear everything off. But of course, once you take four damage, you lose. So the second way that they can clear everything from the board is if every single one of these reactors gets crossed off. The moment that happens and you see down here, you once again take a damage, but you also once again get to erase everything that is on the engineers player board. The third and final way that you can get a full board clear, let's see, I just messed this up really bad. Is if the captain announces that the submarine is going to be surfacing. The moment that happens, the engineer is going to start drawing a line on one of these sections. It doesn't matter which one, they can choose. And once they finish that line all the way around, they're going to initial that section. And then they're going to pass this entire mat to the first mate who will then pick a section, draw a line, then pass it to the captain and then finally the radio operator.
Once everybody has drawn these lines and initial the comes back to the engineer who shows it to the opposing team as the engineer and if they confirm that they have not touched any lines, then at that moment this submarine can once again dive down underneath the water and the engineer can fiercely uh erase everything off the board. So this is the only way that the engineer can do a full board clear without actually taking any damage. There is one other aspect to surfacing that has to do with the captain player. When you surface, you want going to want to mark the location you are currently in. And then you have to broadcast to the opposing team which of the sectors you are currently in. So in this case, we would have to say we are in sector 5, which is going to tell them quite a bit bit of information about where we may be in sector 5, but also they are going to try and come down and hunt us while we are slowly drawing the little lines. The other thing that the captain gets to do is they now get to erase this entire line drawing that they've made on their map. But it's really important to note that they don't actually erase any mines that they have dropped because they still exist. This is really important because now the captain can come over here again because once again, they're not able to move onto a space they were already at. So surfing is a really good way to uh open up your options for moving around on the map. Last, but certainly not least, we have the radio operator. They have this board that looks just like the board that the captain has, but they also have this transparency which they put over on top. What the radio operator does is they are constantly listening to the opposing team's captain and listening to the directions that they give. They can start somewhat arbitrarily on this transparency, but if the other team's captain starts by going north, then they're going to draw north on this transparency. The other team's captain goes east, they're going to follow that, and they're going to continue to listen to the captain, and all the while
they're going to be moving this around, trying to figure out where the opposing submarine might be. Now, this can seem a little bit daunting as the opposing team will continue to add coordinates down onto their map. But as soon as our captain announces the use of the sonar or the drone, we can start to get some really good information. For instance, at this moment, if we had some suspicion that they might be over there and the captain announced the drone, we could ask the captain to check for sector 5. If we find out that they are not in sector 5, well, we can just ignore that and start looking elsewhere on the map. Instead, if the captain activated sonar, then this is really quite interesting because remember this is the one that forces the opposing team, let's put this right there, to tell one truth and one lie. And when this happens, uh what I like to do is I like to put like a little uh number down here to show when the sonar happened. And then I write the details up here. So they might say that they are in column K and that they are in row 8. That means one of these is true and one of these is false. And I know this position here. So I can start to look at column K and see if there's any way that this is wrong entirely because if it is then I might know that row 8 is actually valid in which case I can start scrolling this over there. Now what's going to happen is you're going to keep adding these on. The posing team is going to continue to move and at some point they are going to activate that silence. And man, this is where it gets really quite interesting because you're not sure at this moment if they went north or west or south and you kind of have to track all these things. So you might do little dotted lines to show the extent of where they might have gone.
And at this point, you need to consider many different uh attributes to what they're going to do. And as they continue to move, you might want to continue to track where they're going from all these locations. And if they went north, then maybe in this instance, you figure they probably couldn't go north. But what if they just went once? They could go north again. So there's so many things to think about as the radio operator. I've now shown you how all the different roles work in the real-time perspective. So the captain will be moving and the first mate and the engineer will be checking things off every time the captain moves and the radio operator will be listening across the way and everything is just happening all at once. But there is an entire other way that this game can be played and that is turnbased. You'll notice that this map is much smaller. There are many less locations that you can go to. And the main difference with this one versus the other is that in this case one team will perform an action and then the other team will perform an action and it will bounce back and forth. You don't have that real-time stress associated which I think is why the map is so much smaller. I'd also like to show you that there are many more maps that come in the g this game. This is the alpha map, but there is also the delta map here which is covered in ice and you actually take damage if you surface anywhere that isn't these holes in the ice. There is this echo map right here which is covered in neut neutral mines that you can actually activate using that scenario ability that is in the bottom of the first main area. This allows you to do this to launch the mines and try to blow up your opponents.
There are also uh two other maps which are a little bit more generic. the Bravo map which has many less maps uh islands on it versus the alpha map and then finally the Charlie map which is really light on maps on islands sorry and uh the big difference here is essentially alpha is the uh easy way to find your opponent submarines. Bravo is the medium and finally Charlie is really hard to find opponent submarines because there are so many different places that they can squiggle around without running into these islands. So now let's begin the review for Captain Sonar. And we'll start with a few positive points. But before I even go into that, I do want to say that pretty much everything I'm going to say about the game in this review will be in relation to the real-time game. I never actually played it as a turn-based game. I will mention that briefly a little bit later, but let's go ahead and jump into that first point. And that relates to the emotions that this game is able to conjure up while you're playing around the table.
It is a fascinating experience to be playing this game and seeing the eb and flow of the stress, the anxiety, the um the excitement, all these things that can really pull in everyone who's sitting around the table. When the game first starts, you uh both the submarines are in a random location essentially, and they're moving around and the opposing team's radar operator has no idea where they are. So, the first 5 minutes of the game is pretty stressless, right? The captain's just kind of moving around trying to activate some um some of the abilities on the first mate's uh area, but there is no feeling of, oh, we're actively getting hunted at this point. There's no real like um sweating pressure or anything like that. It's more like, you know, just kind of getting into the heat of things. Once you get to like the 10-minute mark, then maybe around then, depending on the map that you're playing and the situation you're in, the radio operator might have a pretty good idea of where the opposing submarine is, or maybe they know where you are. And at that point, the tension starts to ratchet up a little bit. And when I say tension, I I mean a fun kind of tension.
Like it's definitely a real-time game, and real-time games can get stressful at times. And in general, just so you know, I don't enjoy real-time games for the most part. I was actually surprised, it's a bit of a spoiler, that I like this game so much. Um, so talking about that emotion, once you finally uh once everybody stops, you know, the captain puts up their fist and they say, "We're firing a torpedo." And if that torpedo lands, it's like you uh initiate a new type of emotion around the table. Suddenly excitement uh blows up on one side of the table and the other side they they start to maybe maybe not panic but it's definitely like you know um all systems are red. You can feel the claxons clanging in the submarine as you're trying to get away maybe activate that silence ability to shoot away or maybe even launch a torpedo back because that's another really interesting thing about the game is when you launch that torpedo it's dramatic and it's fun but you're also giving your opposing team a pretty good idea of where you are because you have to be within four spaces of that location. So suddenly they could fire back. So that excitement that you had for just making a hit could instantly get be doused by uh dread as maybe it's even like a direct hit. You take two of the four damage you need to.
And at times the game will stay tense and exciting until the very conclusion at that point because sometimes once you get a direct hit especially the game could end somewhat quickly. But oftentimes one team is able to silence and get away or both teams might have taken damage and also the captain's map is getting fully clogged up. The engineers all got all sorts of things crossed off. So, one team surfaces and often times another team does at the same time and the motion quells down again and suddenly everything is a bit uh quieter, a bit easier. It's a little bit closer to the beginning of the game again, but odds are good. Well, I mean, odds are for sure that the opposing team has a pretty good idea of where you are because you have to announce what sector you're in. So, I think I've talked about this enough. I just really enjoy the eb and flow of the emotions that happen around the table. And for the most part, I enjoy the emotions themselves, even when it might be um a bit of stress or anxiety or even frustration if you're the radio operator and you just cannot figure out where the opposing team is.
For positive number two, I'm pretty much just going to tell you why I think the radio operator is the most interesting and best part of the game in general. Now, this is the role where the person is listening to the directions that the opposing team is doing. They're writing them down on a transparency and they're kind of moving them around a map trying to figure out where the opposing team is. And if that's all it was, it would not be incredibly interesting because you have to wait a long time until you have enough information to really be able to lock them down. But once your captain starts activating those green special abilities, the sonar and the drone, you can start getting some more information. Like for instance, uh you ask the opposing team, you know, give us one truth and one lie. That is an interesting piece of information. You can like put a little X down on your line. You write that over to the side. And now you can kind of move your transparency up maybe the column and the row and figure out if um either of those things is just impossible in every single spot. Or of course they could also tell you about the sector which also tells you quite a bit about that area. You kind of move your transparency around that zone and you're going to start to kind of hone in and you're going to start to get an idea of where they are. And I've already talked about the emotional uh ups and downs and wonderful uh aspects of this game, but I will say that it's definitely um at its peak with the radio operator because when you start the game, you know nothing. you have no idea what's going on and at a certain moment you're going to realize that you think you know exactly where they are. You might math it out. You're like, "Yep, this is the only moment. This is the only spot where they could be and you just get flushed with this conviction and zeal like, "Oh my gosh, I did it." You know, everybody, everything is riding on you. The game ends once the opposing team, well, once one team is destroyed. So, you can't win
without a good operator. So, with all that pressure you potentially have, you suddenly know where they are. You try and launch their torpedoes. And I had this happen once where I just knew 100% where they were. The captain launched a torpedo and it completely missed. And I just went from this this being so full of myself like with this ego like I figured it out to just being completely cles fallen. But in that moment it wasn't a bad either. I just reconvicted myself to figure out where they were and ultimately I did actually end up tracking them down and we ended up going on to win the game. So, I really enjoy the the shift of of of not really knowing what's going on to really thinking you know what's going on, but then also having your hubris checked in a very big way because you probably did one slight difference. Maybe you were one column over or two columns over, I guess, otherwise you'd have a partial hit. That's just really great stuff that's going on there. The radio operator also has the biggest uh learning differential, I'd say, between the skill of a person who's new to the game and the skill of a person who's played the radio operator a few times.
And that is because I think you get better at managing the stress and all the inputs because you're trying to figure out where the uh the opposing submarine is at the same time as listening to the opposing captain like staying on it to get all those different directions. And of course many times we would kind of pause and make double check the line with the opposing captain to make sure we had it right because you don't want to lose the game because one order got missed. That's not really the way we wanted to play it. But uh what I found was what we found was we started developing tips and tricks like maybe doing a solid line and some wiggly lines when they go silent so you can track the different directions that they might have gone. Uh one of the people I play with figured out a really cool trick with silence where um the direction they go after silence will actually tell you one of the directions they couldn't have gone with silence because if they go west with silence for instance and then they um they go west again well then you know that they could not have gone east.
And the reason for that is because if they had gone east, they could not immediately double back on themselves and go west in that case. So instead of having three different directions of not knowing where they go, you now always have two different directions. And the silence goes from being a terrifying thing. Like when your first radio operator, the first time your opposing team goes silence, you're just like, I give up. I don't know where they are now. They could have gone everywhere. You almost feel like you want to erase your whole line and start over. But you really shouldn't do that because of all these tips and tricks that you could do. And then you're going to try and track from those two different locations instead of three and try to hone in on where they are. And I think it's incredibly satisfying getting good at being the radio operator. It's incredibly satisfying being successful as a radio operator. But I will of course admit that if it does not click for you, it is going to be the most frustrating experience that you could have playing this game. So it is going to be uh player dependent. And I for me it went from being the one I was most intimidated by and least interested in playing to now the one I am most interested in playing pretty much all the time because of that the satisfying nature of just figuring out where the opposing team is. It's just such a great moment. And now for positive number three which relates to the engineering role and why I think it is so darn interesting. This is the one where you are breaking something every single time the captain moves the ship. And let me tell you, you're going to move a lot.
So, as the engineer, you you almost feel like you never get a break. From a thematic perspective, you really feel like you are down in the bowels of the submarine trying to keep everything uh going. Like it's less like you're actually breaking things and more like you're running around trying to patch things up because as much as you love to have all the systems running all the time because they're all great, that's just impossible to happen considering one thing gets checked off every time you move. And so the engineer role, they kind of they feel the the burden of the the roles of the ship much sooner than say the radio operator does. Even though I think the radio operator is ultimately a little more important, the engineer is very important. And it's almost like everything rolls downhill on top of the engineer right from the very beginning. And they they're just making kind of tough decisions and they're they really need to make sure that they're communicating with the first officer and with the captain to keep the correct systems open at the at certain times.
And I think that the engineer can sink or swim off of their communication, off of how well the captain communicates back with them, but also with just looking at everything on their board and really trying to figure out how best to keep these different things open and knowing when maybe you just need to suck it up and take a damage uh clear off one of the systems. Um that's going to make it less likely that you win the game. But sometimes those kind of things just happen and I just love that experience. It's just it's thematically fun. It's mechanically interesting. uh trying to keep this puzzle going. You're you're kind of spinning a bunch of plates essentially and uh yeah, I've really enjoyed playing that role and I think it is far more interesting than it at first looked. Let's now move into a couple neutral points and the first of these relates to the captain role. I've played this one more than any of the other other roles and I've really enjoyed it.
There's a lot of fascinating things you can do as the captain. My problem is that I find myself slipping into an alpha captain situation or syndrome and I've seen other people do this as well. And this might seem a bit silly, right? You're the captain. You're supposed to tell everybody everybody what to do. But what I mean by alpha captain is I found myself trying to tell everybody exactly what to do by essentially playing the game for them. With the first mate and with the engineer, I essentially lean over and move based off of what I think I need cleared off on that engineering board because I can just look over there and see what what what directions I need to go in order to clear out those systems. And I can look over at the powers on the map and say, you know, like um do this twice and then do this once. And that's really unfortunate because it means that you're playing the game for those two players. So they're going to have a lot less fun. They're going to be they're going to feel the theme much less. And that is important.
Like you're playing these games to have fun. And I felt really guilty after one game in particular where I did it egregiously. I straight up apologized to both of them. And they were both okay with it. They said they still had fun. But I I knew that I had crossed the line. And I've really tried since then to communicate more to talk to them and figure out what they think they want to do and have the first off first mate try to um communicate to me what the needs of the engineer because this game is really supposed to be about engineering. And even though in my mind it feels like you're going to play better if you lean over and just play both of those maps, you're essentially playing a two-player game and just ignoring these two people. And that's just not cool. And the flip side of that is as the captain, like the map in front of you, not the ones to your side, there's some interesting smart things that you need to do there. And I think that if you are spending the whole game looking at everybody else's maps and then kind of arbitrarily moving around yours, you're going to play a a poor captain in general. I do think that if you are not playing the alpha captain, you will probably play the game better in general, even if that does clash in my head. Because one of the most important things you do as the captain is tell those clues back to the opposing team when they ask you for a truth and a lie. And if you do that poorly, you can just immediately lose the game for everybody. And it's kind of deceptive in how you do that poorly. You need to really look at your, you know, snake line of where you've been and tell your the opposing team something that you think is going to be nice and vague that they're not going to be able to glean anything from that. Also, you need to pilot the ship around in such a way that you are also not giving away where you are because you're just hugging too many islands. Like it's good to try and stay in open spaces as much as possible, but then also maybe even move in such a
way that makes it look like you went around an island. There are all these layers that you can get into and if you're alphaing the game and playing other people's roles, you're not going to be doing that. And I think that is comes to the detriment of the entire experience. I've really tried not to do it myself. I don't think this is a flaw with the game, but it is kind of more of a me issue, but I've seen other people do it as well. is something it's a bit of a trap that you can fall find yourself falling into and you should be cognizant of it and try to play the game correctly and just talk to the people and let everybody play the roles in front of them. For neutral number two, I want to talk about the real-time versus turn-based aspect to this game and just kind of cover it briefly. And I will state as I did earlier that I have not played this game in turn-based mode. And on one hand, you might say I shouldn't be even doing this review without playing it in a turn-based setting. But I also don't think I ever will play it in a turn-based setting because I don't want to because it really does seem like this game is better in the real-time mode. But I can say that I think that you could have fun with the turn-based game. And I think if you wanted to play this game with four players, that could be a really fun um deduction experience because you have one person playing the radio operator and the other person kind of playing all three of those roles as maybe an alpha captain, but you don't have that stress of the timing on you.
So, it's a little bit more true cat on cat on mouse kind of situation because you're both kind of hunting each other. Um, I think that it's great that the game comes with turnbyturn uh rules because for some people that they're going to learn the game better. I have taught this game to many people now and we've always jumped right in with the real time and not had a problem. But, I've heard some people say that they've had better success by doing a real-time game first. Um, so it's good that it's in the game. It's probably a satisfying experience, but it's going to have nothing like the emotion that the real-time game evokes. Um, but a lot of people hate real-time games. I'm one of them. And I happen to enjoy this real-time game, but some people won't. And so, it's great that there are these options for everybody in this game because there's just a lot of interesting stuff going on. And I would hate for some people to just write it off entirely because it doesn't jive with a style of play that they like.
Let's now cover my one negative for the game, which relates to the first mate position. I've kind of covered all the different roles as I went through this review, and this one is definitely the weakest. Not only from a interesting decisions perspective, but also from a responsibility perspective. A big part of the fun of this game comes from knowing that you really matter on the submarine. You're the engineer. You got to make sure systems are available at the right moment, and you're going to have to do that by creatively crossing things off. If you're the captain, you need to answer correctly across the way and make sure you're piloting really well. If you're the radio operator, oh my goodness, it all falls on you because you got to find the opposing team so that you could shoot them. And then there's the first mate who just checks boxes off of this little sheet in front of them. And for the most part, they often times have many things checked off. There have been several times where the first mate had everything on their board checked off, but because of the engineer, maybe they weren't able to activate these things, and then they really aren't doing anything. Like, they don't even have the illusion of interesting decisions at that point. And realistically, even when your board is cleared, it's not that amazing of a decision figuring out if you put the checkbox right here or the checkbox right over there because the captain's going to move again and you're going to keep putting these things down and it comes so fast that it doesn't feel that consequential. Um, so on one hand, this is kind of a good thing, right? Because if you are playing the game with a bunch of people who know how to play already, but you have one or two people who are new to the game and maybe are a bit intimidated by the team-based nature, by the real-time based nature of the game, punk them down in the first mate spot.
They'll get to feel like they're part of the team. They'll get to play the game. They're going to have a fun time. And they can't screw things up very well at all because their role is so inconsequential when it comes to that. And after they play that one game, we'll then move them on to something else. It's nice that you have kind of an easy mode to wean people into the game. The issue is that when I've played it where everybody knows how to play the game, it almost feels like you pick the short straw when you are the first mate because you try to stay relevant. You are trying to communicate with the engineer. trying to, you know, go back and forth between the captain and um, you know, really work on these things and just almost make excuses for why you are sitting at the table. And and people might disagree with me and they might say that the first maid is actually very important because of that communication, but we have not noticed that. And I really hope the game comes out with maybe like a promo board or an expansion that has like a hard mode first mate where you are doing something on your board besides just checking things off.
You know, like the engineer is like playing bedazzle bejeweled over there like making kind of match three and you know, you have the the captain playing snake, you know, snaking all around the map and then the um the first mate just feels like they're playing that fruit ninja game where they're just kind of swiping at their iPad slicing this fruit and getting a bigger score. It's just not it's not interesting enough. And I will gladly play as a first mate again in the future so that other people can rotate through the more interesting roles, but overall it's a bummer that this one is so weak. Now, let's discuss the variability of Captain Sonar, and I think that it is quite high. Part of that has to do with the different maps that you get in the base game. I believe it is five different maps. You kind of have an easy, medium, and hard base map, and then you have a couple situational maps. One where the uh the water's covered in ice, so when you surface, if you are not in a hole in the ice, you take damage. And another one has the map covered in mines that both players can activate, which I have not played yet, but I really want to. That one sounds very fascinating. And that right there provides you a really nice amount of uh variability right out of the box. Then you add on top of that the fact that there are four different roles. That means that you can play this game many times before you feel like you are doing the exact same thing that you played before. One thing that we as a group we fell into a little bit is we kept playing the Bravo map which is kind of like the medium map. And the part of the reason for that is because the Charlie map, which is the hard one, it's so open that we were worried the game's going to go like 45 minutes or something like that because there's so little information to really lock in on and the opponents might keep going silent. We haven't actually played the Charlie map.
I do want to at some point when everybody knows what they're doing, but we have played some of the other maps. There were some promo maps that I got, um, two of them, I believe. Yeah, when I bought this game from my friendly local game store and I don't know how you can acquire them now. So, I'm not going to hawk them too much, but we played the Manhattan one of those and we had a really good time with that as well. So, it's a very variable game. You're going to have lots of different game experiences when you sit down to play it. I think it's really high. Captain Sonar plays two to eight players and I've only played the six player game once and then the eight player game I think six times now. So, I'm mostly going to speak to those, but I can also talk about what I think the other player counts will be like. And I'll go ahead and start low and say that the two and three-player games, the rules say they must be played in turn-based mode. And that makes sense. In a two-player game, one person is doing everything in front of them. And I just don't see how that would be that engaging of an experience because you're just going to have your brain split in so many different ways. I think that the four-player game that could be fun. The rules don't say that you have to go turn-based there. I think real time would be a bit crazy because, well, the captain is doing the first mate and the engineer all at the same time. That could be fun. But I think if you were looking for a really good turn-based experience, the four-player game would probably be best for that.
And that could be a good experience, but it's definitely not where this game is going to shine. The six-player game I played worked really well in that one. The captain plays both the captain and the first mate, which is not a big deal. As I mentioned before, because the first mate is such a simple and kind of inconsequential role that those fold together very easily. Uh, I would definitely play the six player game again. And I think it plays very good at that role. But this game is meant to be an eight player game. Like with eight people around the table, even though that first mate is feeling a little bit out of the loop, it just has such a better energy when you're sitting around the table. It's just such a wonderful experience having all those people. And of course, the seven player game just has one team of four and one team of three. So that should work out really well as well. I think that this is the kind of game that you're going to acquire for those times when you have six or more people around your gaming table. uh many games don't play that player count well. So, it's great to actually have a game where you'll say, you know what, this is ideal. We have eight people. Let's play this. This is the best game we could be playing right now. As opposed to a game that maybe stretches up to eight players, but doesn't play very well at that point. In conclusion, Captain Sonar has completely blown me away, and I'm honestly very surprised by that. I went into my first game of this expecting to dislike it, or maybe even moderately enjoy it a little bit, but it's a real-time game, and I just don't like realtime games for the most part because they usually just stress me out. out. I get anxious.
There's usually, you know, yelling and maybe people trying to grab cards before other people or figure out the solution first. But Captain Sonar seems to have dodged all of those issues and gone the complete opposite direction for me mentally to create this wonderful, emotional, evocive, satisfying, interesting experience that is also real time and just super fun. And it just avoids the negatives while just really harnessing all the positives of those emotions that you can have to the point where even when you have crestfallen moments or frustration because things are just not working out as the radio operator or maybe as the engineer, you're still having a good time. And I think part of that is the camaraderie. You're all in this together. But part of that is also just the great thematic connection that this game has to each of the people around the table. For the most part, they're really strong connections. You know, the engineer feels like they're kind of running around the engine room and like steam is blowing in their face and they're twisting knobs and cranking wrenches trying to keep everything together as the captain is just moving this boat, this this submarine to its extremes, you know, trying to go around and find the enemy and blow them up. You have the radio operator who's like holed up in their little room where they have maps all over the place in their headset and they're just listening to the that other submarine and where could it be and try to figure out where it is. It's just really great moments from a thematic emotional perspective for everybody around the table and I've just had so much fun playing it and pretty much everyone that I've played it with has also had a great time. Even people who maybe after a game or two were like, I'm kind of done, like I'm a little burned out, they still really enjoyed the experience. And I'm really looking forward to playing this game many more times. And I know I say that somewhat often um for games I recommend and I strongly recommend this game. But man,
this one I really mean that. I very much looking forward to tons more games of this in lots of different roles, teaching it to new people and seeing their eyes light up as they they figure out how this all works together and they get into the emotion and the wonderful feelings that you get as you're playing this game. I think I could probably ramble on for a lot longer about this than I need to. So, I'm going to pretty much wrap it up at this point. Like I said, I strongly recommend it. It's been super fun. It's just a wonderful experience, especially um to have an ideal game for eight players. It's so rare to have that around the table. It's just a super fun game. I'd like to thank everybody who's been supporting my channel through Patreon, including the producer level pledges. If you too would like to directly support the channel, you could do it at patreon.com/jhongsgames. Also, if you'd like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one, as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs, please subscribe to my channel.
Thanks for watching.