Dark Souls - The Card Game: Discussion
Transcript
hey everyone welcome to discussion for Dark Souls the card game now to reinstate if you want my discussion and run through of the miniatures game you know that wasn't really a huge fan of it I think it was a lot of bang for its buck it only was successful because of the Dark Souls license behind it but the actual gameplay was very shallow repetitive and and boring except for the boss fights but no one could really enjoy those either because the rule books were awful well let's go so so that's that now how does this compare to the the board game personally I actually like this one quite a bit better than the board game I think that it's very streamlined it's quicker it's it's it is repetitive in a sense but not really because as you go through these encounters yeah the spots you're going to are the same and the number of enemies are going to be the same but they're gonna be different enemies versus and and it's just ok ok I'm a flip of cards yep oh that's going there oh and this one okay that's going over there and and you just that's how quickly it is so if you're not pulling miniatures out trying to organize them all then you're moving miniatures cards are gonna stay there and if they do move like the bosses do it's just a quick boom boom and and that's that everything is very much streamlined in this even with your actions now I'm not saying the other the board game was difficult by any means it really I mean that in terms of actual you know understanding how to
play yeah like your terms were also very simple but here it's just so quick and you you get through these encounters very fast it's just like okay well this is where you're weak dude that's so much that's what your field is that's your damage okay let's just deal with that and then you just kill them and you get your souls and then you get these stamina cards once you go and rest and you get some items and and you just kind of do a little bit of deck building based off of who you might be the night his starting deck of twenty cards deal a lot on strength and and faith and so you can keep going down that route just buying cards that benefit that and hopefully getting AI that get you get you what you want but most likely you're going to be drawn cards back oh that will benefit me so I'll use my souls to kind of get some intelligence raise that a little bit so I can wield the weapon and then kind of go from there and hope I get that combination but it's uh it's it's really not bad I actually kind of like this it gives me that same feel at the board game gave like I'm playing Dark Souls and I mean granted like I'd rather play the video game versus any one of these but I'm not having to try and set up some [ __ ] [ __ ] oh man here's all these boards and let's get let's get all these miniatures over there and then bring them on oh it's gonna be the exact same encounter as the last one this is fun oh I'm limited to the number of bonfires like it oh and see here's the thing that bugged me is like and what I like about this your souls are not spent on like
leveling up your character not sitting here like oh I'm glad there's a Morningstar oh I need 38 intelligence and it's like oh but we need to share soul so no one can ever really level up and it's super expensive to do so anyway but we don't get enough so we just have to keep grinding over and over and it takes two hours to even probably getting me to the first boss fight and after that you're just like [ __ ] it I don't want to continue anymore here it's just like okay I beat that oh I get two souls I get two souls and I like I said I played this with solo and also with with another person and - because I think three or four is too much I wouldn't enjoy it but we got enough souls that it was like okay well let's uh how about how can we like each get one it wasn't that bad because all you spend so long are these stamina cards and they're super simple hey do I want this one that gives me Intel or faith or want this one that gives me Dex or Intel and there's no like argument on well I really need love so I can hopefully wield this weapon there's none of that there's no weird stupid you know non thematic hey I there's a stack of weapon cards that oh I didn't get anything that benefits it so we have to keep grinding nope this one is just okay well I guess I'll get some of these cards and all and and as you rest your bonfires and this is another cool thing whenever you do rest it's not just oh man I'm
almost about to lose its and there's still that but you get some benefit Hey when revealed gain one common treasure okay cool so now what would we get Oh a a sunlight straight sword so that's pretty sweet who who does that benefit especially if you're playing solo it's just like oh yeah I get what that one and then oh I can hold more cards so most of time the souls are gonna get and some of the treasures you'll you won't have to read really deck build it's not really gonna be until later where you get more and more you know items that you're like okay I need to pull out some of these single ones because they're not benefiting me at all and I'll just replace them with the stronger dual powered you know stamina cards and then all I'll fill in with these weapons like it's just it's so much quicker and I thoroughly enjoy that by the end of it I had gold pine resin in a halberd and a bunch of dual stamina cards and a budding green blossom and a scimitar and my Knight shields were a stone greats or the great sword of judgment that I at least got to use once that was Anna Morningstar Anna parrying dragger and all this all these different weapons that you just get to use like when you're looking at a weapon it's not like okay I have to meet all these stats that cost me you know 50 souls to be able to get to just use one card nope in this one it's oh hey I got a halberd okay I just need I there's multiple options it's do I wanted this to stay in my in my hand and use potentially later but it does less damage it's like okay well
that costs to strength and a faith but that does three damage in the fat I get it back or do I want to use a faith a strength and anything else that also has range but it gets discarded so how do I want to use this and or the the button green blossom which this discarded that allows me to take two cards from ICONic it essentially heals me but at least I get to pick what's coming back versus just because it's whenever you heal it's just the bottom of the discard pile goes to the bottom of your deck and yeah like I I think that this is what the Dark Souls game should have been because I the character development is super quick super streamlined there's nothing like you know finicky about it there's no arguing between players and and and and then it comes to the boss fights so which is a good point now let me talk about the boss fights here versus the boss fights in the dark souls board game they're virtually the exact same except here it's it's a lot simpler it's not you trying to figure out okay so so how are they facing yeah that's more thematic and I guess kind of more to the video game you know learning their pattern unless they get heated up or they change up their attack the exact same thing is here except there's no movement facing it's like okay so in the board game we had to make sure that
they're facing the right way and that's how they would move and then if we're if we can't anticipate it we can get on their weak side which will do more damage and it's like okay so so how is this more so are they going to move like this and okay well I don't really get it here it's okay the boss is here hi Lord Volvo Lanier is there these are his hands I flipped on his card that shows me where his hands go and uh and and then I attack them you know like I have to be in the right spot you know and there can't be any enemies in front of it if there are I can't attack a little size range and it's just everything is just so much quicker and every like really everything is better about this game in my opinion except obviously there's like no variety like so those are all things I liked about it and I think I don't like about the game is the rulebook is number one steam forge games needs to figure out how to actually write a cohesive rulebook instead of just putting [ __ ] together it's like they had everything and then they just kind of like like the intern dropped the papers like oh I got to get this to the to the printer and he puts them just together like they're all cathouse would be struck me puts them together and you fold in and staples I mean sake here here's the rulebook and you're like oh so there's deck basics wives I have to but there's encounter resting in the bonfire but how do I even do that like what's with the encounter setup I exploration why is resting it's a they need to figure out who the hell
like they need to fire the guy who who makes the rule books cuz he obviously has no idea like my Dark Souls board game how the play video has so many I'm a bragging that has so many views because it versus any other how the play I've done because no one knows how to play that goddamn game probably the same way here luckily this game is simple enough that like even after playing it once you'd be like oh okay I'll remember because it's it's virtually super simple which is a good thing but man that rulebook is just so stupid so that's that the other thing I don't really like is ah man there's there's really not like a whole lot I don't like about it like nitpicky um there's not a whole lot of variety it's like now that I fought all four bosses look scuse me it's like okay well I don't really want to fight them again I mean maybe with more people or maybe with like hey maybe I'll try a solo assassin thing like they do have alternate modes of play so technically the these two are you're supposed to fight together then you can flip it and then there's the other two bosses and those are you supposed to but there's an alternate which you can actually just do the slightly easier bosses which are fort and hide Lord vulner or harder bosses the abyss Watchers and Pontiff you can mix and match on who you're fighting doesn't necessarily have to be the the two of the board and then you
can kill yourself because you're dying a lot so whenever it comes to that there's just not a lot of variety now do they fight not if they probably making expansions I'll get them because I actually I I enjoy this it scratches that same edge let's see what else don't I really like I I can't really think anything like oh no I I don't like the fact that there's not really a hope a lot of point to moving it really more in solo what I've noticed because then the other one I was playing Harold and and my friend was playing the night and so we had different ways and different strengths you know to combat the weaknesses of the enemies so we did kind of have to move around but it's like oh crap you're in my way if I want to attack him and just kill him outright instead of you not will have to move but I can't go in your spot so we need to swap and then now okay now he's weak to my attack so now I can kill him in bypasses his defense I but other than that it's just kinda like you can't move to really evade an attack like there are cards like like the repairing dagger which I get rid of a dex card to just dodge all damage and there's more cards like that in the game more I can do it to actually deal some damage and there's another one if I discard this and the decks and another any other type of stamina I'll dodge all damage and I'll
inflict one damage on an attacker so stuff like that but you don't really move you just kind of stay in the same spot and dodge I but I don't really like the fact where it's like oh okay they're gonna hit here like I'm not there okay yeah I miss nope then there's somehow even though they were gonna hit here they also cannot hit you know two other spots but why that's just one regular slash attack why can they office in here take out but there's no one here well then they change and they're gonna hit everyone up in this row with the highest threat so it's like someone's always going to get hit and I understand why they did that otherwise this game would be more complicated and probably super simple because it's like since the cards and enemies that come out are random you have like the chances of them actually hitting you are slim to none like right now if I was in the middle the wing Corvin would hit down here if that was all he hit he would miss and then the Hall of manservant would hit here so it's like okay what's the point and I just come up and kill him okay then I can see the fact that he's gonna here so I'll just never go down there I get it but at the same time it's like I don't know it's just kind of weird like they're always gonna hit someone regardless unless it's a full area attack then it's like oh thank god okay we'll just stay over away from there but even then you'll have to go to that side at some point because they where is it where am I I might have shuffled her back into them into the deck but it was the the witch maybe she was a little too
but the witch attacked both these sides and it's like well she's not gonna move over to my spot so I can't I have to eventually before and I can only move once so crap I'm gonna take that damage then I'm gonna run up and then I can eventually attack her so it's just kind of like movements definitely slow there's not a whole lot of cards in here that allow you to like double move cuz in the board game you at least got to like sprint and and get around the board you know easily even though there wasn't really a whole lot of point to that because line of sight it was just you were almost always gonna get hit anyway but what I really like about this is that while the threat is the threat only comes into play whenever they're like whenever someone's not being targeted like if I if I had another person down here in the hall Mansura he would hit me it's not like he just automatically goes to the highest right even though most the time if like we we would always stay up on the front lines so the knight was always getting attacked we're just kind of a bummer but it's not like in the board game where someone had like the threat token like the aggro token or whatever so they were just getting [ __ ] the entire time and at times they would get like double fun here it was a pretty good share but that's why the herald was really good because I could heal it's like okay well you use your ability to you know block some damage and then and I'll heal you and and we can work out that teamwork I can only imagine with like four people because then you only really have two free spaces so it's kind of like that picture puzzle we're take okay I'm slide this up
to slide this over and get the picture cuz it's like well we really need to swap move so I need to move here and then on your turn you'll have to swap spot and then that'll be it but you can't I don't you cannot move diagonal hell I'll even know if the enemies can actually move dang like the bosses are the only things that move around versus because the enemies just stay in their spots you it's if you don't want to shell out all the money for the Dark Soul for game which is outrageously expensive and ultimately kind of a waste of time and money but you still want that Dark Soul sing and blood-borne didn't do freaks blood-borne was basically a wreath in cutthroat caverns anyway that one was just stupid blood-borne could have been this but set in that universe and and be really awesome I'd rather have that I don't have this people had born then Dark Souls but if you still want that that itch and you're a huge fan definitely pick this one up because it works fine solo and it it works fine with two people I haven't tried over three or four I don't really think it would work that well because all let's do me granite yeah I don't think it would work that well so I mean and and that's the thing is you really just have to is this gonna work for you do you like the deck-building thing personally I like that deck is your health I liked it in Pathfinder the card game and it's always giving you like that sense of reads us I go crack do I really want to use this
for a more higher attack that's gonna go on my discard pile or that's a crap I didn't really get anything I want do I want to discard some of these to draw and hopefully get something that I can use these for because that's your life and that's you're getting tired I originally liked the idea of the board game words like your health and your stamina met that you died but after playing it and after thinking on it it's that's really [ __ ] stupid to because it's like why like why does my stamina equal my health as well it's not like if you're playing the video game and you run out of stamina you start eating away at your health that's not a thing you just can't you know roll or you can't attack as much and it's so hard and you got some stamina back just this this is this is this is what it should have been I I do enjoy this I just want more at this point like more cards and and there are a variety like heavy gems up glare partisan that has range to a sharp gem which makes things like hey now it'll give it like a weakness or give your next attack a weakness so we can kind of vary it that way a fashion wolf night armor and then just a special you know uh whether they call it or whether it was called what these new ones are crystal soul spear Katarina armor where is it ruh-oh armor of the Sun so give these these unique ones instead of you know killing a boss and getting their
set of armor to carry over you just get a random one but you take that with a grain of salt and yeah I mean that that's pretty much all I can think of on a scale of one to ten I would probably give this a seven seven out of ten i if there was if there's expansions coming out which add more like they can they'll even have to add more of these I can keep everything the same you can just do small packs like even the the monsters you don't really need it just more bosses like more bosses would be really cool eventually like with those bosses you can added some more treasures that'd be a lot of fun you can maybe do a better rule book but if they just act it you know if they support this like they do the Dark Souls the board game then this would be an eighth for me but as of right now it's kind of like like it's very streamlined once you figure out once you trust through that rulebook and it's it's not like finicky and and makes no sense and long like this game it's not long it says sixty minutes about right and you're not punished just for resting like you actually get bonuses for it yeah yeah 70 no 10 it's all a solid game for me so let me know what you think of this game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you liked this video and click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and right
next to that subscribe button is a little bed I'll click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this for you