Lorcana Our Verdict | Right For You / Wrong For You Review
Transcript
hello welcome to quack thank you for being here today we're bringing you a right fore wrong for you review on the Disney card game lorana this is a trading card game that we picked up at Gen Con recently we dived into it head first feet first we each we got a whole series of game plays we had a whole coup's league where we each got to open packs based on winning and losing we created Our Deck space to the best of our abilities we failed to find any other rare cards which was disappointing along the way yep and here we are yeah time to talk about it time to let you know first off whether or not this is going to be a game you should add to your collection and then finally whether or not it's a game we are Desiring to add to our collection this is a right for you R for you review this is a review series we do here at quackle where we look at seven categories to determine whether or not a game should be added to your shelf first we discuss the overview taking a quick look at how the game plays and what makes it unique then we take a deep dive into the theme and here for lurana there's not much to talk about finally well not finally additionally we talk about the accessibility how quick and and approachable it is to play We dissect the game play We analyze the modes of Play We taste the Innovation and we Captivate the price she's trying to add the scripture words like I do but I'm a southern boy with a uh so much better at it than me desire to talk about anything with a metaphor or a simile that seems to make sense but no one's ever heard before I've been practicing that since I was about 20
years old then we'll give you the comparable games and finally finally we'll Bell finally we will belly flop into our verdict letting you know whether or not this game is in fact right for you wrong for you right for us or wrong for us lurana Shira give an overview of this game this is your first debt construction game yeah this is the first trading card game that I have di dived into this is a game where you are going to be playing a 60 card deck with two different ink colors there are six different colors that you get to choose from and you are essentially trying to go on quests and accumulate 20 lore before your opponent does you're going to be inking a cart which is going to be your resources your Mana the amount of like money that you're going to then be able to play out cards you're going to play out cards and then you are going to exhaust them and tap them to be able to either go on Quest or challenge your opponent challenging your opponent will keep your opponent at Bay going on Quest is actually going to take you up and win and so it's that balance between those two actions that you going to do you're going to play your cards and see what synergy you can combine your turning Pages do you have anything to add apparently turning Pages distract sh some along the way yeah if you have ever played a game like magic the Gathering Pokemon the trading card game Yu-Gi-Oh one piece it's going to be very similar in a lot of ways those type of game systems resource costs deck of cards in your hand and an objective to win instead of taking down your opponent's life you're scoring points which makes it a little bit more of a solid hair puzzle but still allows a bit of interaction between players and and it being chapter 1 there definitely is a
lightess to the overall structure of the game it's designed to be a firsttime playing Family approachable style Disney game it's not meant to be the crunchy genre filled you know nerd culture Magic the Gathering world but I think it's going to walk a lot of people into the hobby space so if you're familiar with those heavier games and you want something that's on the lighter side this might be right for you however if you're looking for something that's just as crunchy or has the potential to be just as crunchy I don't know that Disney lurana is going to be quite that however if you've tried magic or you tried Pokemon or you've been interested in those but intimidated by the subcultures and the lore and the world that's built around them or you're trying to get some family members to play some games with you your kids a significant other who just hasn't taken that deep dive yet L might be the perfect entry point into not only this hobby space that genre of Gaming but also the perfect Gateway game to people who usually snub their nose at card games I mean after all it's covered roof and mouth with Disney characters okay let's talk about the theme them you said there was not much to talk about here you know what's funny because there is unique artwork there are custom you know like custom artwork custom named characters quotes and songs and a lot that's supposed to be here however the theme of the game the actual if you get down to the thematic overtones of the game spending ink to tell a story a
story that's combining all the Disney characters there's not a lot here in fact the way that they actually have the decks constructed is you can't even build build synergistic decks from one story line you have to mix everything in with each other and so that's what frustrating some people because they can't do an entire lined theme yeah um deck because there are different Lon themed characters amongst all the ink colors and so you could certainly argue that they're is some type of theme here but I'm going to be honest I feel like the theme of lurana is mostly Disney it's Disney you have Disney you know the Disney stories you've played the Disney games you're bringing that theme and that lore to the game playay but outside of that there's not much that I can see I I'm interested to see what else approaches but I think games like key Forge even games like magic have much more depth and a richer understanding of the world that they've created uh whereas something like this feel like they're using the IP as an excuse to not have their own story mhm so if you're looking for a game that is Disney this might be right for you it might be right for you if you don't like Disney you're looking for a story that goes some does something else or goes somewhere else with the characters that you know in love might not be right it's not here it's nothing it's nothing at all let's talk about accessibility how approachable is this game and how can you play it this is weighted 2.06 on BGG this is a very accessible very light game in you know those strawberry candies your grandmother always has at the house yeah it's about
as going with that it's about as complex is unwrapping one of those yes it is not very complex at all you have a starting deck that they've already made for you you can get up and going really easily you can teach it to anybody the mechanics we've already gone over you're either putting a car down into your ink well only restriction on that is that you have to look in the top corner of the car to see if it's inkable and then you were going to be playing out a car based on how much ink you have you were trying to get to 20 lore it is very easy to teach the cards are really easy to understand they'll have some keywords that they'll then have um a explanation on the symbology is really great as well there's the attack there's defense and then what you can quest for and how much l you can accumulate I don't think we really had any core questions when diving into the game it it's very there are a couple questions that do arise when you put different cards together and how they will take down each other what action comes first etc etc but those are really nuanced and the community has been addressing a lot of them online very clearly um yeah the other note is this game does not have to be two-player yes it can be played in multiplayer we didn't dive into that one too much you could technically I've heard play with a room of 60 people everyone's going for lore and hitting across the table and stuff like that that sounds chaotic it's not really what it's meant to do I think it scales up to on the box maybe four players there's leagues that are going to be happening so you can play competitive against like in your home you can also go and join a league where you can play competitively in the Series and win some prizes so if
you're looking for a two-player head-to-head game that is very easy Orana might be right for you might be right for you let's talk about the game play What in the game play makes this game right for you or wrong for you again not how to play but what makes it stand out and I will tell you the key thing for me is the severe lack of card draw and deck cycling in this game you might if you're lucky if you have a good game get through 22 to 25 cards in 60 card deck and an average game with some of the color combinations that you can do in the starting decks the demo decks they give you I was going through 15 to 18 cards before the game cycle was over I was top drawing by the point that I was on the sixth round of the game and the game might last for eight or nine rounds so three or four rounds I'm sitting there drawing the top card and playing whatever it is completely takes away user Agency for me it was the biggest thing that made this game wrong for me I house ruled a few options we deck built specifically to solve for it and it was still a problem time and time and time again even after going through two full boxes of cards 48 packs and deck building as much as I could I still had some games where I was top drawing more than not yes I would agree with you there I think the mechanics that made this right for for me were deck bu deck crafting I am not necessarily I haven't I've gotten shifted away a little bit from deck building mid game where you're
building your deck but deck crafting was actually really interesting to me because I would get in between games I would look at the cards that didn't work for me that I wasn't interested in that I was always constantly inking and then I would sub them out with things that I was enjoying playing more and so by the end of our league I actually had a deck that I was excited to see most of my characters come out and I had to make those decisions of like ooh I really want to play you but ooh I need that ink and so that mechanic was right for me if the game just gave me more ability to find those cards that I put into my deck though it would be much more of a satisfying puzzle yes so some of the things that we talked about the that 20 lore seems a little bit too quick for me having not as many car drawing abilities they have been mainly located in the yellow and purple decks if I'm not mistaken there might be a couple in the blue and gray but the ones in the blue and gray actually like make you trade cards from your hands you're not actually getting you're not gaining you're not going through your cards a little bit more but you're not necessarily netting positive Like Jesse is saying and so that problem still exists there are twerks that I'd like to see adjusted with the second chapter that will eventually come out I'd like to see it get deeper I'd like to see it get a little bit more complex uh but those are the big elements for me in terms of anything that made this game right for me really approachable very quick playing sure night we probably played what maybe 20 game plays over the course of the first two weeks that we had it y just going back and forth mixing up decks recycling it it was really really fun and really really easy to get to the table with you and I enjoyed that actually something that we can take out on dates like we can each
take our deck and play it in uh like and play it out at a restaurant we if you have the app on your phone you can keep track of your L you don't really even need these flimsy pieces I would say component quality is lacking there but you know it's a mass produce game yeah uh so if you're looking for a game that is easy to play good for date nights can bring you and your spouse to the table and gives you the feeling of crafting and creating a nice deck something where you're excited by the time you're you know through a few packs to see what characters come out and see what you can mix into it this might be right for you it might be right for you that being said if you care about card draw ability at all if you hate the idea of top decking if you want to make sure that up until the final battle lines are drawn you have agency over the game if you want comebacks and if you want C IES and we barely ever saw a comeback we barely saw a comeback until much later in deck building the only comeback that came while playing the original game was with me top drawing only yeah yeah and that only comeback and if you want to see cool combinations between characters that come out into play then this might not be right for you yeah okay let's move on to modes of Play We address that up at accessibility yeah a lot of games have solo mode have mix mode I will will say this there's certain modes of play that game stores do like multiplayer you know up to four players or there's competitions that you could play in or sealed leagues or other things like that or you're opening packs and it's all
contained within store there will be various ways to be part of this community that doesn't require you to spend too much money and doesn't require you to have too much knowledge or requires you to spend a lot of money and demands that you have all of the knowledge of the game however you want to dive into this you'll be able to dip your foot in there's a big Community that's growing around it big warning though big big big big warning games like this are designed to be addictive even the fact that they put the Rarity of the card on the card is almost like we are showing you exactly how rare your card is to get you to want to open 20 more packs to find more there are going to be people that are so into this year that they spend thousands of dollars making sure that their favorite deck is all shinies I have seen people already take a box and put it off to the side and said they're putting it in their attic for 30 years yeah so there are people that are going to treat this like a collector's game like a hobbyist game there's going to be people that go obsessive over this this is a Disney game retail stores that got access to this were selling this at three or four times their markup we've seen cards sell for $2 or $3,000 before the market tanked and now they're worth maybe a couple hundred at the most if they'll even sell this is collectible yeah it's Disney it is a card game May maybe it will have legs but do not get into this as an investment strategy do not get into this thinking that you won't get hooked by the little bit of addictive ideas they present to you if you have an addictive nature if you're someone who can't go
into a store and say no to buying just that extra pack you have a gambling habit or anything like that living card games uh not living card games collectible card games trading card games are not right for you they are designed to take advantage of you and designed to manipulate you why do we know that because both of us already have that little bit of an instinct of like we are collectors we both have addictive personalities and tendencies and we're aware of that and so when I sit here and look at this I want every card I want every card shiny I'm the type of person that would spend thousands of dollars deluxified my deck or when you said someone put it in an attic for 30 years yeah I'm the type of person that would also do that it's not the right decision to make it's not a good use for your money it's not a good use for your uh for your extra bandwidth that you talking about how the industry has changed so much and so back in the day like like 20 30 years ago when someone did do that with magic the Gathering and it became a hot thing nowadays the industry is kind of more aware of that type of thing and so many people are going to be doing it that it's not going to be worthwhile in the end yeah at this point okay so modes of play If you're looking for a game that's designed to make you buy it this might be right for you it might be right for you uh let's move on to Innovation is anything about this Innovative I guess we'll have to wait for the the lawsuit to resolve before we determine that yeah for those of you who don't know there's two Publishers that are currently suing each other because the designer uh might have used a similar system in one design and another design
yeah I don't know enough to actually comment on that lawsuit but we just being snarky I don't think anything about this game is innovative the only thing Innovative is theme and you just have to buy the IP and plaster it on I don't think it is innovative I think attack defense abil there's nothing Innovative you played magic for the first time after you played This Magic felt more Innovative with the amount of different types of creatures that you can put out on the board you have like the ones that come out temporary the ones that are permanent or Mana like but here's the thing this is just scaled down that and every head Ahad card battling game I've ever played after playing Magic after it's existed for so long is just a reiteration of what is currently the king of this industry uh so it's not Innovative but it's disne Disney so if you want if you want Disney this might be right for you it's that it's still that moving on to price as much as you would like to spend what it would what do you think it actually costs to play this game really to actually play cuz the starter decks are garbage garbage I mean I think where we are currently with the amount we paid is a good place to be in terms of the amount of cards we have $550 well no that was for each of us uh that was individually I'm saying individually I think maybe one box and so 24 packs 24 packs and a starting deck starting deck of each of each so that you have those base cards okay so so we are saying that the starting cost 275 is
a great entryway which is remarkable because we don't have that much in front of us here yeah and it doesn't cost them that much to make paper and when you think about board games like actual we we have to take into account we did buy those de boxes we did buy these binders we did buy the sleeves the you you might be but but a but a box right now box right now $150 $150 yep so $200 $250 is not unreasonable in terms of what you're going to get when you get started you're probably going to grab a mat you want to get a binder to organize stuff you might do card sleeves like yeah I would rather have gotten more cards and I would have rather not had these IP components yeah they're not very well made they're very very chunky in my opinion like we I don't even use the binders anymore I got a better binder that has sleeves more cards like when you open these binders you have location for four cards here but then middle what are they doing here you have like spaces that is just too big for anything I again I think they were for the rules and stuff then there's four of them five six seven eight you don't need eight different rule books and like the rules yeah they have a little tips and tricks for each color and then the deck boxes the deck boxes both bugged me to no end because when you would open them they don't stay open they close again on you the sleeves were annoying to shuffle with they stuck together the over production quality on this I I love the artwork the artwork is great artwork is Disney though I know
but but the artwork's also new it is new artwork I love the theme I love the artwork I love that they didn't just skin old Disney characters on top of it outside of that this feels like a game that is designed to make them a profit yeah and a really good profit yeah if you want to get started in Disney World even like upscale these like so many people are doing things with them but the war counter they're they're you can do PL I mean they're pieces of people people are going to do themself so if you are going to get started in here we're saying about $200 will get you up and running a this game yeah with a deck that is actually worth playing cuz the starter boxes are not the way to start playing this game you will have a bad time I promise you it's not the point of the game and they they built them poorly I don't know if they built them poorly so that you'd buy more cards I'm not sure uh so we did Magic starting decks and the magic starting decks were very very cohesive Commander decks yeah but like they were still like decks pre-made decks we didn't have to build them and they were very cohesive so with that in mind $200 $250 to get started in this that's a lot there's so many more games that I could buy half a copy of Kingdom Death for that yeah that's the game you're wanting to play I'm just saying yeah half a Kingdom Death half a kingdom death for what you us together could buy one copy of Kingdom Death yeah and the amount of replayability and the amount that we want to get out of it is so much more expansive so if that all sounds right for you if you're comfortable spending
that type of money for a game that you're actually going to play a hobby that you're going to get into by all means go for it but it's not a little bit and it's not the first time they're going to dip into your pocket we're already prob going to be spending another $200 a piece when season 2 comes out one chapter two second chapter comes out the third chapter they do not have a cap on this they can continue going forever and ever and they probably they probably will uh okay so with that all being said comparable games we've kind of talked about those any other trading card game magic the Gathering Yu-Gi-Oh Pokemon there's a lot of them out there if you have enjoyed playing this light version and would like to dive into something deeper check out Magic the Gathering it's the classic in this industry same warnings for all of those though I me they are dangerous games to get into they really are this is this is one of the parts of the hobby that snakes people yeah uh danger danger Warhammer um okay verdict verdict is this right for us right for us wrong for us I have had a really good time playing it with you but when I look at $500 spent yeah on on the stuff that's in front of me here on the table I would choose to have my $500 back I'm a mixed I said what I wouldn't want from here I don't yes I think the playmats are pretty but I don't have a strong need for them I think I can play on the table just as easily there's nothing on the playmat that actually shows you where to put stuff I only want the playmats
really I love the playmats I think they're beautiful I think they're they're pretty but like people are making custom ones already that are so much cheaper I have no need for anything besides the cards I don't want these deck boxes I don't want these components I don't want these binders I don't want the playmats I just want the cards and the cards I'm enjoying and until you get me hooked on another trading card game that's the question this is going to be the one that i' I have the Nostalgia for the Disney and I really enjoyed I enjoy if me and you each take our Deck with us we can get up and running just like this this is all we need I think for myself my verdict it's been a couple weeks since we've played we've let it sit we've let it rest unlike you I'm not missing Disney lur con at all I'm missing playing games with you I like playing I like playing a cage construction game with you I'm really really excited to play Magic and I'm still debating if I'm going to spend money on this next wave of magic um I might try to sell some things or something in the house so I have that extra budget but I really want to play magic sealed league with you cuz I think you'll get hooked to that even more than this uh I don't think Disney Lor con is right for me not until not until the game gets a little bit more complex I'm saying this purely from a fan girl standpoint like mechanics wise this is not right for me mechanics wise I'm bored mechanics wise there is not enough variability within my own deck after I play my deck three times I'm like okay I'm done change it up like I want a new
deck and so mechanics wise this is not right for me I think but Nostalgia wise I really like the characters I really like the artwork there is a lot I mean every bit of 30 years of indoctrination from Disney has convinced me that I love this yes and yet I it is very interesting to see that at play in your own mind of like this the only reason why I'm still wanting to get this out is because look there's fan the Flames look there's Donald Duck look there's Genie there's Mickey Mouse and so but I I really think I really think this is not yeah while I think we'll continue playing it and we'll probably still purchase in the next season and I'm excited bring content to the audience and the channel at the moment I don't think this is right for me I don't think this is a game that I should have bought or I should continue to buy yeah yeah I'm not too far away from that but I'm not letting you sell it either I know but we're going to keep it we're going to keep playing it Disney wins that's the You Know lesson of everything yes H thank you for watching thank you for being here let us know is this right for you is it wrong for you are you buying into it have you already bought into it and are you sad that we're not bringing you more coverage of it do you want to see chapter 2 as soon as it comes out are you personally I'm curious to our timeline because like they talk I think talked about this though back like a year ago it took forever for them to get this up and out and so like how long
is it going to take to get chapter 2 up like this is August I would expect something for the holiday season would you yeah late October November something getting a pro like because this is going to be old news by Christmas time and they want to have people buying this with like special Christmas packs and Frozen packs that are advertising for the holiday season they're going to they're going to get as much out of this as they can if they were if they were smart if they if everything goes as planned I am sure that's what they have down on paper so thank you for watching thank you for being here whatever the case whatever you do remember to do the important thing just play Magic Gathering just get out and play some games do that games see you next time bye bye