Skip to main content
Loading video...

Good Kitties Review - Go Viral, Avoid the Dog & Catch the the Mice!

Transcript 16:48

Hey, I'm Alex from Board Gameco and today I'm reviewing Good Kitties from Peacock Games. Good Kitties is a one to four player cooperative game in which players are taking control of a variety of cats as they attempt to try to outwit the mice and the dogs and accomplish their mission objectives. This is a prototype all components of exchange and I'll have a link to the crafting campaign down below. Also, this channel is sponsored by All Play. More about them at the end of the video. I should also note while you're checking out the crafting campaign, this is part of a twoame crafting campaign. You can check out Super Chunk as well if you're interested in that. With that said, in GoodKitties, what you're going to be doing is you're going to be trying to accomplish your mission objectives. There is a tutorial that's going to be this. It's going to guide you through the first few turns of the first mission. But whether you use that or just dive in from the rules, the basic idea is you have I believe again prototype over here. I believe there are going to be six missions in the final game. My prototype had the first three missions. That's going to be these mission boxes over here. each one once you open them are going to give you a variety of components and mission objectives that you're trying to accomplish. In this case, I'm trying to accomplish these objectives first.

Building a camera and learning to scratch. Uh for learning to scratch, I'm going to have to have my cats wander around the board and capture various mice. And once I've captured four of them, we're going to go ahead and gather a new car. That's the learn to scratch ability or mission. Outside of that, building a camera is going to have us trying to get various items. So, if my cats wander around the board trying to go over here, getting this item, getting this item. As you pick up a variety of items, once you combine those items, you'll have the opportunity to build the camera. That's the general idea of what you're trying to do. You have these missions. You're trying to accomplish the missions. The way you do that is you're going to be going through turn order on this track over here. Players are going to go ahead and looking at over here, we have the green player going first. So, the green player is going to go ahead and grab a card. Maybe they take their five over here and they put that onto the board over here and they'll get five movements. So, my green mouse over here, my green uh cat, my mouser over here is trying to get the things. Where's my mouse? I'll put that back. They're going to go ahead and go one, two, three. Moving there, picking it up. They will put it on their playerboard. Cats can hold one item unless they are strong cats. Strong cat can hold two. All the cats are asymmetric and come into play with different small abilities. So, now he's moved three. He's gathered the item. He has two movement left. Unfortunately, the mouse currently is in the mouse hidey-hole, so he can't get there. So maybe he'll wander up over here hoping to pass through this supply gate on a future turn which will add new supplies to the board. You do need to constantly add supplies to the board because otherwise you'll run out of things to go ahead and use to build objects or to use for their abilities. The items have built-in abilities that you have on the player board. Just discarding them will do a variety of different things. Not always discarding them, but using them will have things like the laser cat to

move another kitty. Catitude will increase your catitude, which is helpful for those cat and dog encounters. You got to be all primed and ready to go. But the basic idea is you take a card, put it onto the player board over here, and activate your turn. Depending on the player count, the boards have two different sides, but basically you're going through an arc of taking abilities with your cats. Now, the next cat over here, it's going to be their turn. They can take the other action. The other action is simply swapping moves with somebody else who's in that same phase, meaning on the same player board, you can swap with a cat that has not yet activated. Sometimes it's helpful for other cats to go in different orders, especially depending on where the dog or mice are in the scenario. So on your turn, you either play a card to the player board, take his ability, or you swap, and then that cat takes their ability instead. So now that we've done that, we have the blue cat, our tough cat over here, is going to take an ability. They're over here. They want to get some items. So they'll go ahead and play their four. Maybe they'll play uh you know what, they'll play their they could do their four. I think we'll just do the regal over here. So we'll do the regal. Uh take that card. We'll play it onto the player board. So what they're going to do is they're going to go one, two, three, picking up that item. So we now have another item in play. And then they're going to regroll, increasing their catitude by two, which again is going to help them for those encounters.

That's going to be the first few turns, which means it's time to reveal a nuisance card. Nuisance cards are how all the bad things go. The general arc of the game is you're trying to gather items and accomplish objectives, but the game's not interesting if things aren't getting in your way. Nuisance is how things get in your way. First, you're going to have the mice activate over here. The mice are going to activate the bottom half of the board. The mice either activate on the top half or the bottom half of the board. In this case, we're going to have them all activate, and they're going to move their movement speed, which is three. So, we're going to go ahead and have this mouse go. We'll say we'll say we'll go one. Well, actually, they won't go anywhere because they don't actually have an objective right now. There's no tokens for them to go for. And in general, mice are going for either the mouse or token or alternatively an item or trash or to their hidey-hole. In this case, there's no objective in this room for it to go for, so it won't go for anything. This mouse, on the other hand, will try to move around the board. They're going to go 1 2 3 over here trying to get closer to this item. In general, if there's a tie, they go for the highest space. So, they could have ended in 1 2 3 in the five or in the 10. They always go for the higher value space if there's a tie.

So, now they're here. They're ready to try to pick up their objective on another turn. And taking this is not going to be good for you because they're going to go onto this track, which basically is the way one of the ways you you lose the game. As this track advances with various items or trash collected, once it gets to the endame token over there, you're going to lose. So try to avoid them taking away items from you. Both because it's denying you an item you can use and also because it's how they win the game. Outside of that, the last mouse is going to go. So we go over here and we're going to have this way go. Let's see. He's trying to go nowhere. We already took his thing. So again, he has nowhere to go. So he's done. Which brings us to the dog. The dog now moves. And the dog's priority is going to be going for either this green token over here if you've placed it on the board, which you would do by discarding a yarn. So place the thumb the thump up to two spaces from you. It's great to try to attract attention, making sure the dog goes to where you want it to go. In this case, though, the dog is going to go for the thump. There is none, which means now it's trying to go for a bad cat. None of the cats have played the bad cat's cards yet.

Basically, the advanced cards over here will result in you taking a bad cat token. There's always only one bad cat at a time, which is a great way to pivot control away from the dog to constantly have different cats attracting his attention. In this case, none of those are true, which means it's going for the closest cat. That's where we made a small mistake. We have the mouse or cat getting a little too close to the dog, not realizing he's going to get targeted. So, the dog's going to move and go one, two, and get involved in an encounter with the dog with the cat. To that end, we're going to go ahead and roll these dice over here. That's going to give us a nice boost over here. Look at that. Our catude jumped from one to four. We got the highest value. That is the best scenario we could have gotten over there because now we beat the the the dog strength. These are modifiers that can increase as the game progresses. But for right now, we beat the dog strength, which means we actually win the encounter, sending the dog across to the board over there, and then losing our tokens over there, losing our catitude if we had any. We'd lose two catitude after that encounter.

But we had a temporary boost of three. This is the best possible result you can get on that die. By the way, that was a one in six chance of surviving that encounter. Otherwise, my my cat would have been sent back to one of its starting points instead. That's the basic arc of the game. You take actions using this this board over here. Every two turns, you're going to have a nuisance card activated. That's going to send the dog and mice around the board with different values over here. So, you can't always rely like this on the top half move. Uh, this time was always fives over there. It's always fives. There we go. We got a four. I think like the dogs cards range from three to six if I recall correctly. And then you have various values. You could boost these things. When you get objective cards, you're going to be upgrading the the the cats and the mice over there. The dogs and the mice. This over here, for example, would will boost its movement value. So, now it's four plus one, which makes the dog faster. And eventually you get to a point where the dog can jump onto furniture. We haven't talked about a lot of the small details of this game, but right now the cat and the mice can go onto furniture. The dog cannot. One of the safest ways to stay away from the dog and stop them from messing with your plans is to be on furniture at the end of your turn. But eventually the dog will have the opportunity to jump on furniture. So you need to adapt to that.

That's the basic arc of the game. Take a turn, which involves playing a card. That's going to have you moving around the board trying to gather various things in order to ultimately build towards the objectives. There are different objectives as you go through the missions. Again, I've only played through the first few missions cuz that's all I have. But you will have different things, more components being added, knocking Well, I want to say what you knocking over things. I'll say knocking over things because I started saying that, but different things like you'll go through a progression of quirky little moments of things that you're doing, of building various gear, using that gear to do other things. The objectives kind of tell a little story as you go through it. Once you finish the game, the scenario, you go to the next scenario, and then continue going through them. Uh each scenario you can play at any point on its own. There's no real progression in going through it. I do recommend going through an order because why not? But that's basically how you play Good Kitties from Pink Games. Which brings me to our review of what I like, don't like, and consider not liking. Starting off with what I like. In general, there's a good balance of control over the environment while not having so much control that there's not perfect predictability at any single point. You know that you have two turns.

You have two turns on this board before the nuisance card is going to come out. That gives you control over some of the cats, but not all of the cats. And because the dog's constantly chasing the closest cat, that gives you a degree of how do I manage it all? Especially as the mice move, when the mice jump out of the holes, they can very easily, one thing we didn't really show you over here is if you cross one of these lines. So, let's say this cat crosses a supply line, we're going to reach in this bag and we're going to take an item and put it in that room and that number. So, this goes on 11. And then we look at that room and we put this down over here on a 12. Well, which on the one hand is good because we have more gear and more things. On the other hand, that's more opportunities for the mice to scatter out of the rooms grabbing various things. There's six rooms and only well in this game there's only three cats but you can have between I think it's between three and four cats in the matter of the player count and so you have a maximum four cats to go ahead and deal with the six rooms you have and four cats might sound better but then they're activating less frequently as well meanwhile the mice are gathering items running back to the holes and inevitably this track over here is slowly creeping up and getting harder to master and as you accomplish objectives the mice and the dogs are getting stronger both in terms of their speed as well as in terms of their strength which happens when you get an encounter with them as well as in terms of abilities like jumping onto tables for that dog.

And so the game gives a nice degree of again, you know that the various variables in play. You know that the dog's going to move this way or that way. You know that well not really that the movement you have more control over because either putting down the thumper or alternatively having to jumping on tables, but the distance is a little more controllable. The mice is kind of a 50/50 which one's going to go. So you constantly have the ability to look at the board to plan around how things are going to happen, but not in a way that is perfect control, just more like playing the odds control as you go through it. the asymmetric cats and gear and items, all of those are fun things. Uh, starting with the fact the cat fact that the cats have abilities, which is already a good thing. They're not super gamechanging, but it's nice to have like a cat that can, you know, have better equipment, a cat that can uh more aggressively attack things. That's the mouse over there. Cats that are uh, you know, that are holding multiple items. So, having asymmetric cats is not a bad thing. Having the gear, four different pieces of gear over here that can all be discarded for different things if you're not saving and using them for the build action to build the piece of equipment you need for the mission objectives. And then I can't get into it. Well, not camp, but I'm choosing not to get into latest scenarios, but there's other fun things you'll be able to go ahead and uh build and do stuff with that are not necessarily in every single game. So, there's a t a lot of uh fun little abilities that you're playing with as you go through this. Speaking of which, the procedural missions give a nice degree of adding mechanics and difficulty to the game. So, if you start from the first mission, you want a little bit more. The missions do give you a little bit more. And again, I only have three, so I can't speak to the full aspect of the game, but I'll say that both in terms of small ways that the game shifts up, as well as other things you can do with uh various things that'll be unlocked, that is a nice little extra element to have. It's also a very thematic implementation, both in a way that is funny and charming, and

sometimes in a way that's a little crazy, but just a little uh story of the various good and bad kitties. Those devil horns are there for a reason. Uh the good and bad kitties as they attempt to live in a house with a bunch of mice and a dog and trying not to be the one blamed for everything. And I'll also note that I really do enjoy this tutorial over here. I like when a game gives you a guided set of rules. I find it's very helpful both for edge cases as well as just if you're not fully groing things from a rule book. I'm a big fan of like here's the rules and also here's like three turns so you can see how it all plays out. And I like the fact that they did that here as well. As far as things I don't like in the game, the biggest thing for me is that being caught by the dog seems like a big threat, but it's not really that big of a negative impact for you. At least for me. At first, I would say when I played through this, at first I really tried to avoid ever getting caught by the dog. And I actually really enjoyed that puzzle. Trying to make sure I stay on tables and then my turn. Making sure I always have a uh you know, a thump in play that I can go ahead and throw somewhere else. The dog's running towards that or unlocking your cards so you can go ahead and play them. I almost wish like and and this is one of those things where it's like I haven't play tested this aspect. I almost wish you lost if the dog caught you. I wish it was like not like rolling the cat. I wish the dog was a straight up you lose if the dog catches you. I think that would really add. In fact, I don't again I haven't play test this at all but while the game does have different difficulty modes I don't think at least I'm pretty sure there's not a difficulty mode that has the dog just immediately catching you and you lose I almost wish that was there because I found the game a lot more charming when I was really trying to stay away from the dog and then the first time I was finally caught by the dog I was like oh it's actually not that big a deal I was kind of treating it even though I'd read the rules I was treating it like I cannot

have this happen and it's really not that big a deal you roll some dice you win or lose you reset you drop any items along the way like there is a impact and it can mess with their plans, but not nearly as game-breaking as I thought it was. I actually enjoyed the game more when I was treating it as something that could not happen. And once I figured out it's not always a big deal, it kind of made the game a lot easier to manage. And that kind of comes down to who the target audience is, what's the age range for me, I would recommend that as a nightmare mode if you're playing the dog cannot catch the cats. Full stop. Although again, I'm not saying that's balanced or doable. I think it's doable within a degree of control. You just have to play very, very strategically. Outside of that, I'll also note that I'm not sure I mentioned this is a prototype, so I'm not sure where final art graphic design are in this. I will say I guess the way I'll put it because I'm not entirely sure is if this were the final version of the game, I would not I would I would want things changed.

I think that more so in graphic design than art, I think the art's very charming, but I I think that to me, again, I don't know where this is, so it's a weird aspect of like I don't know whether to be critical or not. I would just say I would want things not where they are right now if this was a final game. And then lastly, despite the mission variety and the extra things the game gives, to to a certain extent, the core game does come down to run around the house, grab objects, catch the mice, avoid the dogs. The missions do change up aspects of that, but that is the core experience. The core experience is run, grab objects, avoid avoid the dog, and catch the mice, which is not a bad thing, but that's just the kind of core gameplay loop. I almost wish the missions mixed things up more than they currently do for that extra degree of variability. As far as I can see others not liking, the mice can very absolutely be overwhelming and luck driven. I've had games where I felt in complete control like the way the mice for example played on that first card where like they didn't even have anything to go for. I already grabbed things. The mice can absolutely you can be in complete control of them with no problems at all. But that can play out very differently if the first card I had played had been a top half. They would have ran out, grabbed objects already, and I would be one turn away from having to take care of all three of these mice unless I draw another card. And if it were a top half again, not a top half, not a top. This is not making my point over here, but if we had another top half, maybe I grabbed one of those and the other two have already gone back to their hidey-hole, putting it back on the track, and we're one step closer to losing. So, I have found as I play this that sometimes you can feel like they're not a challenge at all. And other times you can feel like you cannot keep up with them, and that very much is a combination of the choices you make and the way the cards come up. So, overwhelming and luck driven might be a problem for you. For me, it's part of the chaos of the game. I'll note, by the

way, that my own experience is that going back to that whole dog versus mice thing, my own experience is you can plan around the mice and then be more blindsided because that full top half or bottom half versus the dog, I find that if you are really clever about it, you can like again my first game, I'm pretty sure I don't get to get caught at all by the dog my first game. And only in later games that I realized that that's going to happen and then became less scared of it. And that's basically Oh, and then one more thing is uh the random nature of objects appearing. Again, kind of same idea of that luck aspect. Objects will appear all over the board. Sometimes they're not what you need to build the object you're trying to build. And that could be frustrating and luck driven. Granted, when you build, you could trade in at two for one. So, there is that aspect of you're never fully not going to have your object come up. Like, even if it happened, you can trade things in. Uh, but still, there's definitely a degree of luck as to where they generate, how easy a mice can take it, how close it is to your cats, and how it all comes together. As far as final thoughts on Good Kitties, it's charming. At the end of the day, this is a charming game that gives you missions, abilities, asymmetric stuff. All of it's very much on the fun side. For me, my favorite way to play is definitely that nightmare mode. My biggest criticism is that I felt like this is a real puzzle to challenge out until I first got caught and then realized that it was more easy to manage than I thought. Uh overall, I am going to come in at a 3.5 out of five. It's a charming game, whimsical art, a cute theme, and overall well implemented. As far as other game recommendations, definitely check out The Loop if you are looking for one of my favorite cooperative games. That's a real puzzle to stay alive. and check out Bark Avenue if you're just looking for another pet themed game. Very different and more pick up and deliver. It's competitive. But if you like pets in your games, you're looking for more, Bark Avenue is a very charming game. I

mentioned that Allplay is a channel sponsor. If you go to All Play, you can find a variety of games, both from All Play as well as their partner publishers. And definitely check out Quirky Circuits. Quirky Circuits from Pla Hack Games is another game of moving animals around the board, uh, but much more in a programming sense. Definitely a charming puzzle to dive into. In any case, and until next time, I'm Alex Radcliff from Board Game Co. Hope you enjoyed this video and as always I hope you have a good

Progress saved