Cola Wars and AI (a response from the designer) - Bower Rides The News
Transcript
Ohoy there YouTube. I'm back again today for another episode of Bower Rides the News where I take a look at a different news story happening in the board game tabletop world and put it in my eyeholes and put it in your aisles pretty much the same time. And today I've got some new hot juicy Reddit news called Cola Wars and artificial intelligence. A response from the designer. This was posted three hours ago by Gray Fedor. So, if you enjoy this sort of news content, please be sure to click on that subscribe button down below. And if you're looking for some of the best Kickstarter services on the planet, please be sure to check out onero.com, who seriously just click on the link, check out the people they've worked with. You'll be amazed. But let's get into Cola Wars and AI. Now, there's been a whole lot of nonsense flying around about Cola Wars, and it's frankly been aggravating to watch from the sidelines as the designer. So, time out. Cola Wars currently on Game Found. It's raised $54,000. had just launched say a day or two ago. Been a good deal of buzz leading up to it. The publisher before had a $ 1.3 million project with Ascendency and a follow-up expansion that raised a half million.
Just so you're caught up, this is my first ever game last week. And once again, this is the designer, the person who actually made this game, not the publisher who is bringing the game to life and putting it into boxes and paying for manufacturing just to put those two apart. I was playing it with the Dice Tower in Florida and genuinely having a great time. This week, the whole thing has turned into a total nightmare. I've been having many conversations with the publisher over the past few days trying to impress upon them how important the AI issue is. To be honest, I don't understand why they haven't been more transparent. They haven't just been evasive with you guys. They've been evasive with me, too. But honestly, my name is being dragged through the mud along with theirs. I'm going to set the record straight. Honestly, as in in so many cases in life, the so-called cover up is far worse than the crime. It's so stupid. Too long didn't read. I'm pretty sure there's some generative AI art in the game. It's actually not very much. I'll tell you everything I know. The game found page was created with AI, but that's not what you're buying. OMT is going to get rid of the remaining AI art in the game. OMT is the publisher. The hangup is just whether they admit they suspected there was any in the first place. All right, so let's read. Here's something important to know. First, I'm the designer, not the publisher. Two years ago, I signed an agreement with One More Turns Games to publish Cola Wars. Later, I'm going to get why into why I signed with One More Turn Games and why I'm sticking with them because I think that's important. If you know how the
industry works, then you know that after signing with a publisher, the designer almost never has final say or something even sometimes even any say over things like art, marketing, pricing, or manufacturing. Sometimes Matt has asked me my opinion about art because OMT has been very collaborative throughout the whole process, but I haven't had a say in where the art comes from. But to be honest, talking about generative AI has always been a bit of a third rail. When I once when I signed with One More Turn Games, I originally asked for a clause in the agreement banning generative AI art. Matt told me that in this day and age, it's very difficult and not impossible to guarantee that art doesn't contain AI elements. Huh. While I wish I had pressed him more on this point at the time, he's not wrong.
AI is now a part of the workflow of many genuine artists. It's hard to spot and getting harder every day. A bunch of amateur investigators on this forum think they have finally tuned AI detection with their sophisticated count the fingers technique, but they've been wrong even more than they've been right. How do I know? Because I, too, have the receipts, quote unquote, the real ones. At a certain point, we decided that it would be easier if I made direct updates to the inesign files for the game rather than passing everything through CSV files and risk creating errors, so I have the working files. Here's what I know for a fact is not AI generated. The game boards and cards were designed by Matt Pquette and company. Big ups. Matt Pquette is one of the best graphic designers in the industry. Hard agree.
His team has designed a lot of the games you've heard of. Just look at their portfolio. Nice. Nice linking it. They do not use generative AI as a matter of professional pride. Matt Pquette is very expensive and worth every penny in my opinion. I've heard similar because I think they've done excellent work on this game and they've put a lot of hard work into it. The characters on the executive cards were all illustrated by humans on Matt Pquette's team, not AI. Some people like the art style, some people don't, but they are categorically not AI. After being harassed in the middle of the night by brave keyboard warriors, and after having private conversations released to the world at large without their consent, some of the human illustrators have understandably asked to have their names removed from the credits. This is a tragedy as their work should have been recognized. They don't deserve what has happened to them.
And while OMT is partly to blame for that, some of the people posting about this issue have really gone far beyond the pale. It's disgusting. It's getting worse and worse by the day. It feels like uh you can openly hate on anyone using AI art at this point. And everyone's like used to be like and and I will tell you this, I've been in this hobby for 15 years pretty much uh at like behind the scenes as a media person quote unquote. And it is a very progressive, liberal, forgiving hobby for the most part that's like, "All right, we want everything to be, you know, hunky dory and everybody to get along and we're going to make sure that happens." But with this AI thing, they're like, "Yeah, we're we're going to turn our eyes to whatever you want to do or say to these people cuz they're like," and it's it's fascinating. It is so fascinating to see these same people just who would have defended at the drop of a hat now be like, "Hey, what's what's going on over here?" Uh, after being harassed in the middle of the night by brave keyboard warriors and having private conversations. Oh, the rule booklet was designed by a human, too. But I see that they've been credited on BG. So, I don't want to name them without their permission. That they haven't been credited. Excuse me. Let me put it this way. If the rule booklet had been designed by AI, we would have a Skynet situation on our hands because we put that person through hell with revisions.
It's not AI. I believe that 100%. Uh, that's that's how rule booklets work. As someone who does work on rule booklets for people on my Fiverr, check out the link down below. Very highly rated. Um, yeah, lot lot of revisions and um I haven't tried to do it with AI. I'm not saying it's not possible, but I'm saying yeah, you would you'd burn through a lot of credits with the amount of like tweaks here and there to wording and things like that. The player aids, yes, we do have them, were designed by me and look like it. The 3D components were also designed by me working in Tinkercad. The vending machine was designed by an absolute genius, but again, I don't see their name on the BG page, so I don't want to name them in case one of you decides to put a horse head in their bed. So, uh I imagine that they're referring to uh the there's like a soda pop machine. Yep. That one. That is also a dice tower, which was probably done by someone at the the factory who uh who does that. And uh that's that's a thing that a lot of factories will offer like oh yeah they'll they'll work for per hour and they'll you tell them what you want your cardboard components to turn into and they'll be like all right we'll design it and test out make sure it works. Let me know uh let me now turn to where I know for sure AI has been used first. We used it in prototyping. I believe this is legitimate. Usually prototypes contain a lot of artwork that actually is stolen from human artists.
Whatever you feel about AI and I feel a lot of the same things. It's better than stealing actual human art. People who played early prototypes remember that this art was always clearly marked as temporary in bright magenta text and I would call attention to the AI art when I taught the game. The intention was always that this art was going to be replaced. Transparency is the important part here and I think it's where one more turn game screwed up. Oo I actually just used their whole name and not OMT. If people know about AI then they can make an informed choice. Some people don't care. Some people care maybe to an almost psychotic degree. And a lot of people like me have deeply ambivalent feelings about it. I work in advertising and AI is turning my industry upside down. People are losing their jobs. I'm scared. I get it. I also used AI to help me figure out the math for shelf space because like I said, I work in advertising and my master's degree is basically in fingerpainting and fart jokes. Finally, the whole game found page was vibe design. Is that a thing?
By Matt Mele, not Matt Pquette. Using generative AI. Ooh. Oh boy, this is the this is the marketing. So, it is not what you as a backer are actually paying for. That's not an excuse, but I do think it makes a difference. Also, not everything on the Gamefound page has been updated recently. So, some of the art from the game featured on the page is not correct. It drives me up a wall, for example. The box art still says won five players when Cola Wars only plays up to four. Don't get me started. Once again, it costs credits to do things, right? like what I'm sure about, but I suspect is AI. Okay, so we covered 87.2% of the cards, but we have not yet covered the vice president cards. Here's where I'm not sure. And Matt from OMTG claims uh not to be sure either. I don't know what Oh, because now you changed the initials on me. Whatever. Matt says that he worked with artists informally by email on the VP character art and that he sent them AI generated references. He has told me he wishes he had asked the artist more questions about whether the work was AI generated or not and that he suspects but does not know for sure that a lot of it was AI. Honestly, I don't know what to make of this because it's also possible that Matt simply typed a prompted toy GPT. But I also think his story while crazy is plausible. First of all, prompting is a kind of a skill and I'm sure that Matt has enough design vocabulary to be able to prompt an LLM to get consistent results like the VPR.
And yes, if you don't use artificial intelligence on the regular, that that is true because you have to make tweaks after tweaks and it will screw up sometimes and every time it screws up, doesn't matter. It's wasting your, you know, your credits. Uh so yeah, I get it. People have claimed that One More Trends Games is a massive corporation because of the sex success of Ascendy. Then they're stupid. Like that come on. Like come on. Have you actually seen that game? Like, yes, they made $2 million on the base game and the expansion to make the game and ship out the game, but all those like the it's a massive game. Like, yeah. Um, I'm going to guess that they say that's kind of ridiculous. If you think any publisher is is like just sucking off, you know, a golden tea. I don't know if that's an expression, but just living the high high life, there's a there's a very few.
Okay. Secondly, as an advertising professional, I've been around usage rights for my entire career and I know all of the traps around copywriting and work for hire. I'm not sure Matt does and I believe that beyond the agreement with Matt Pquette and co, it's likely he would be just making handshake agreement with illustrators. Yeah, like Fiverr and stuff like that potentially. Um, people have claimed that One More Turn Games is a massive corporation. Oh, sorry. So, we Yeah, got lost. Massive corporation to successive ascendancy. It's not. It's two guys and a lot of the time they're figuring stuff out as they go along things that seem basic to me like having proper agreements with the artists that include provisions about AI generated art. Yeah. Like that's why I'm saying they've done one game with an expansion. Now that game is massive like both in making over a million dollars and the scope of it like it's a huge game but but like yeah this is they're new publishers. Uh this is a whole industry of amateurs folks like it or not. You talk about greedy publishers. Yes.
That's what happens with Kickstarter. Like like Kickstarter is amazing. It completely changed the hobby as we knew it and allowed every Tom, Dick, Harry, Henry, Jane, Jill, my neighbor to go start a board game company. But running a board game company and starting a board game company are two very different things. So, yes, we have a lot of relatively new publishers in the hobby because it's hard to get that shiny thing dangled in front of your fans if you don't take care of your fans on Kickstarter, which is its own separate process that didn't used to be nearly as big of a deal. It's just like, here's our game, buy it or don't buy it. Now, it's like, here's our game, buy it or don't buy it, and maybe it'll be here in 18 months, maybe it'll be here in three years, maybe it'll be here in five years. But after it does ship out in five years, you're then going to ask me to to give you more money, especially if the game was like, it's it's so weird.
It's such a weird time in hobbies right now. But anyh who, you talk about greedy publishers. Most of these publishers could be making more money doing almost anything else. Yeah, Colaw is a game by a first-time designer being published by a second time publisher or third time if you include the Ascendency expansion. Ascendy was a huge success, but what I've come to learn is it wasn't a huge success because those guys really knew what they were doing. It was a huge success because they put a massive amount of work into it because they genuinely care about and nurture the community. Yes, this right here uh I can't think of a lot of other games or even Mr. Whisper would come to my mind where I have seen Cola Wars and heard about Cola Wars a good deal over the last year or change. I I remember seeing it I think at Gen Con. I think I saw it at Origins potentially or or like Yes, I agree. which means that that's definitely got to be a gut punch, you know, drawn in 54,000 bucks after 48 hours, right? For for a lot of people, that's amazing. But if you shot a million and then you did 500,000 on the expansion, you're definitely hoping to break 100,000 on the first day, I'm going to guess, right? Like, so yeah, and and I wonder I wonder if we go into that controversy and go to the comments section, we'll probably see the other side of this picket fence if the comments haven't been deleted. We'll get there.
Anyway, I believe uh I said to see here we go. Why did I sign with One More Turn Games? That's why. Not to get sappy. I believed in them and I still do. They're good people. And yeah, up until this point, like it felt like Cola Wars was going to be a slam dunk in my mind. I was legitimately a tad bit shocked and reloaded my page when I saw it was at like 54,000 bucks when I looked at that earlier today. I was like, "Whoa, whoa, what?" Like I thought that thing was going to do some pretty dang good numbers. So in conclusion, the sum total of the actual AI content of the game, not including marketing, which I talked about above, is at a maximum. The character art on the box, though not the design, it's a bad one to have like the the the p the main image of the whole game. And some are all the character art on the VP cards. There you go. Full disclosure. I wish you heard it first from OMT and not from me. I wish I did not have to do this, but One More Turn Games has forced me to do this.
There are admittedly still a couple things I don't understand. First, One Mortic Games has invested a boatload of money into Cola Wars. I have no idea how much. They certainly would never tell me as the designer, but I estimated at least 40 to $50,000 on art and prototypes. Matt Pette is very talented and very expensive and tens of thousands of dollars more on marketing and conventions. Yep. like I just said. So, it doesn't make sense to have a few bucks to save a few bucks in the art for 12 cards because four of the VB cards still have no art at all, AI or otherwise. Secondly, I don't know why Matt hasn't been more transparent because while mistakes were made with foreseeable outcomes, and we talked about this before the campaign even launched, it doesn't seem that bad to me. You could judge for yourself how you feel now that you know all the facts. I think the answer to this is that some people out there scared the poop out of them with their AI witch hunt. It's gotten pretty vicious. It really has.
Like I let off by saying that and I I'm I just see it and my job one thing that I try and do every single day is post on Reddit is post on Facebook is post on X is to post on Blue Sky, right? Like that's part of being a social media person and I see it all of the time and it's it's like blue sky is such an inclusive caring place until you start like AI there's like ah beat them down it's like wow it's it's it's wild bottom line almost all the art in the game is now AI generated but a little of it bit of it probably is it's going to be removed the marketing graphics on the game found page We're all so done with AI. One more turn. Games made a mistake and then made the mistake far worse by not owning up to it right away. They're human, but they're good people. I hope they don't feel betrayed by this post.
Uh I wonder because we we're going to get a response. I bet we'll get a response. I said above Cold Wars is my first game. It means the world to me that so many people have supported it and that people care enough about it to have such passionate feelings. It's a cool theme. I've enjoyed meeting you at conventions and sharing the game with you. I'm sorry that I didn't push the point on generative AI [clears throat] harder in my original agreement. I wish I had, but I was frankly amazed that anyone would want to publish this game and I didn't want to lose the opportunity. I think One More turn deserves a chance to say, "Yeah, yeah, first I want I want to I want to cut off the person writing this to say, "Yeah, if you're giving this person crap, just shut up. Why do you sign with them?" Because they did one other project and it raised a million dollars and then they're like, "We want to pump money into your project. We like like what are what do you I people just they blow my mind. I wish I had but yeah like I imagine most publishers would have been absolutely thrilled if they're like oh this was your first one and you want mine to be your second one or your third like all right one more turn deserves a chance to make things right. If you don't, I understand. But either way, thank you from the bottom of my heart for your support. Um, I was as frankly amazed as anyone publishes. So, final notes. Now that I've laid out the facts and thanked our supporters, I'd like to address the people who have so zealously prosecuted the case against Colawars. I have poured more than three years. Oh, man.
Yeah, this part's not going to be fun, I bet. I poured more than three years of my life into creating this game. You've spent three days trying to destroy it. Cold Wars is an original idea. That's not based on stolen IP. It's not a fan tribute. It came from all my own all too human brain. Over the past three and a half years, I play tested it more than 200 times. I created 73 different iterizations of the board myself in design without the use of AI and redid the card decks 74 times before we got the graphic designers on board and dozens of times since. Call of Wars started as a simple worker placement game. Then it became a deck builder. then a baffling bafflingly compl complicated Tableau builder. Then the streamlined combined worker placement table T tableau builder it is today. Each of these changes meant blowing up the game and essentially starting again. I've taught and demoed Cola Wars for 14 hours straight at conventions. I've driven between Toronto and Gen Con and Indianapolis four times.
I stayed up all nights in between days of a convention to completely reinvent the game for the next day's play test. I spent literally thousands of hours and tens of thousands of dollars of my own money getting this game made. As I write this, I stand to make $1779 in additional royalties from the crowdfunding campaign. So, believe me, this is a project I'm doing for love, not money. I quit my job this summer so I could focus on launching this game. I found a publisher. I worked with them. had arguments with them, shared wins with them. They let me change my mind way more often than is reasonable. They encouraged me. They gave me some amazing ideas and a couple of terrible ones. They've sunk an unimaginable amount of their own money into this project in addition to untold hours of time.
They've become my friends. I've always been pretty down my own creative work. I've always been pretty down on my own creative work. I think it's supposed to be there. Uh but after three, I've always been pretty down my creative work. But after three and a half years of working on Cold Wars, I finally convinced myself that it's something special. It's not for everyone, but the people who like it will love it. This game is the product not just of my own blood, sweat, and tears, but of a team of other human creative collaborators, including Matt and Lucas at One More Turn Games, Matt Pquette, and artists who are now too scared to take credit for their incredible work. Uh, actually, let let me phrase that. Matt Pquette, and the artists who are now too scared to take credit for their incredible work. Yeah, Matt Mquette was too scared to take credit for his incredible work, but he wanted me to make sure I mentioned his name. No, that's not what it was. Uh, I wanted you to know about the game you're calling AI slob. Woo.
And this is like full color like, oh yeah, there's somebody behind the other end of the keyboard. Reminder, this is one thing to call it a company or decisions made by people at a company, but harassing of individuals at a personal level will result in a ban. Thank you, ugly walrus. Uh, it is incomprehensible why you as a publisher decide to have most of the art handmade and that have hideously ugly AI images for the first cards that I see on Gamefound page. Yeah, I actually just said this to a different game that um that that had that where it's like, wow. Like, don't lead off with the AI art slapping people in the face. Like, nobody's really going to like that. Like even if you're pro AI art, you're still gonna be like, "All right, can we get to the point?" Like it's not like um yeah, leading with that. And I haven't checked out the campaign page now. I feel like I'm gonna have to if it's if it's the buzz, ugly AI images for the curse cards that I see on the game found page. Terrible, terrible idea. I'm sorry they did this.
Lol. I'm baffled, too. Whatever the motivations were, I think they were as nefarious as people assumed. I don't think they were as nefarious as people assumed. To muddy the waters, it it is the AI playbook. Make everything a mess and let anyone trying to be honest pay the price of bad PR and clean up. The lack of consent is 100% part of AI's business model. This one's this is incredible post. Thank you for sharing with us. I agree. This is what actual transparency look like. I have no dog in the fight. I'm with you in the pool of people who have deeply ambivalent feelings about artificial intelligence. I'm not a backer, which is not a fault of the game, just my budget. Congratulations on the design. But I felt compelled to highlight a few things that stood out to me. When I signed with One Return Games, I originally asked for a clause in an agreement banning generative AI art. Matt told me in this day and age, it's very difficult, if not possible, to guarantee the art doesn't contain AI elements. Matt said that he worked with artists formally by email on the VP character art and that he sent them AI generated references. Matt's right that it's impossible to guarantee when you don't try at all. Sounds to me like he talked you down from doing something hard because it's hard. These two passages were incredibly frustrating to read. A little due diligence goes a long way. Yeah. I mean, but at the same time, if if your game's about to get signed to this company who's got this track record that is perfect at this point, like perfect.
And I'm sure they talked about how how much they liked it and big plans and like it's hard to say no. But especially, you know, if if you see you see a million dollars, oh yeah, we made one and a half million dollars the first time. You know, Matt's right that it's impossible to guarantee. Uh bottom line, almost none of the art in the game is now is JI generated. The sum total of the actual AI content in the game, not including marketing, which I talked about above, is at a maximum the character art of the box. I know to you this feels like a reuse of the VP card art and relatively minimal. But you can't underestimate the importance of the art in the box. Oh yeah, a thousand billion%. Like that's that's why I joked about it earlier. Like that's like the most important piece of artwork. Like if you're like, "Yes, we're going to remove all the AI art from the game." The box is the most important one. That's your first impression. Like like come on.
That's the first thing I see on board gamegeeek. Like like one need looks no further than Concordia to see how much box art can impact the impression of the game. It's the singularity most significant. It's the singularly most significant piece of art attribute to the game. So yeah, the AI art is limited to just few cards. Oh, and also every single person's first impression and lasting memory of the game. He put it funnier than me. So yeah, or they put it. I don't know. So yeah, the art is limited to just a few cards. I don't I didn't I don't remember who wrote this. Uh oh. And almost every single person's first impression and lasting memory of the game. Uh it's a bigger deal than you're making it out to be. And if you put AI art as the feature on your box, you're presenting your product as an AI art game. Hard stop there. He didn't, but it is true. Uh, whether you meant to or not, and whether it is an AI art game or not, it sucks that people harassing you. I think Matt Meeple needs to take a lesson or two from human transparency, which is especially ironic because on his website for Cole Awards, he claims Ascendency earned us the backer given title, one of the most transparent creators in crowdfunding. O, I'll go for a couple more, but then I do want to go to the crowdfunding page, see what it looks like over there real quick on the comments. This is incredibly well-made response and uh it's what should be the standard in situations like this. I can't think of anything else I would want to see in a post like this.
Hopefully it helps move the needle for them, but I mean oh rough. Yeah, this is this is going to be really interesting to see what happens with this cola wars. I'm still chewing on my own opinion on all this, but thanks for hiking a genuinely great response. Thank you. I appreciate you're giving it some thought. Hey man, thank you for sharing your story. The situation sucks and I hope this doesn't ruin the great experience of having your game published. We're in the middle of a transitional period and hard lessons are currently being learned. Even if it's frustrating, the person to be angry at is your publisher and not the community. ANOTHER PUBLIC [screaming] who no, it can totally be right to all the people who decided to take this way too far. Like let's not just don't cuz that's like oh don't don't don't focus on the ba the people over there.
Focus on like you can be focused on both. I don't like that basic, but all right, let's keep going. Uh, not the community. Yeah, ports of the community. Another publisher known for heavily investing into human artists with creative directors and all the effort you can imagine recently had the same full paw. They invented a ton of money into amazing human artists, but then used generative AI for the crowdfunding page and got torn to pieces. Such a dumb mistake because you invest all the money into artists. You spend years on making the game come to life, then you cause a pa crisis by having trying to save a day of work. Asking people to fork over money years before they will see the actual product is also a question of trust and crowdfunding as failed projects and scams. If you signal you were happy to use general day of for one thing, why wouldn't you be happy to use it for the other thing was that one's that one's a bit much.
Like I feel like that one's a bit much there because I love AI art because it tears down a barrier to becoming a board game designer. It really does. Cuz now it's like, all right, I can design the mechanisms. I can talk to the manufacturer. And now with the the magic of this computer, I can have it look presentable. And yeah, there's going to be a portion of the world that hates it just for existing, but I, you know, I don't have the thousands of dollars to pay upfront for the art. Hundreds if you're lucky, but realistically thousands of dollars. Um, I I feel like a lot of times people forget about that. Like the Oh, yeah. It actually does make the board game hobby more inclusive, especially for designing, asking people to fork over money years.
Where is the line for you? And obviously being ky as f about it like Matt will only make it worse. All right, let's see what the uh let's see if they've had let's see if they've addressed it. Hold on. The cola wars. They are changing. This one is from yesterday. Wow. A new campaign that didn't bombard you with updates in the first 48 hours. What's happening? Okay. Hey gang, the core war campaign on gamefound is changing. We've been absorbing your launch feedback and though it is about a fun, frivolous game, we're taking it quite seriously. Today's been hectic. So, now we want to say that is all we've been talking about and we'll be uh back tomorrow with the details. Oh, okay. Hopefully, you'll make a public apology, cancel the campaign, pay real artist to redo all the art like you pretend you did in the first place, then come back with all the stretch goals unlocked day one since thus far they've been nothing but what you were advertising in the first place and likely charging for. And then maybe you'll have a more successful campaign and potentially start building back any lost trust if you also then deliver a quality product.
Was there no period in there? I don't think there was. I was waiting for the period and it just didn't come. All right. Quite literally the everything that had to be said. 18. I was just trying to not pass out. I didn't even really hear it. But yeah, sounds good. Let's see how they have the comments. Memo from the VP of uh brand excellence. Yes, this is fantastic. This is what everyone wants to see right now. A pinned post from uh April 23rd. Oh. Uh, so yeah, let's get to the real comments. Thanks Cameron for the post on BG. We met briefly at Gen Con. I'm happy to support after transparency. I was super excited for this game. Extremely disappointed the AI use. We have lost the trust of a previous backer. Canada friendly shipping, but then saying subject to trade war.
Hi everyone. There's been a lot of legitimate questions asked about the campaign and you deserve answers. You can expect an official update for One More Trend Game soon. But the meantime, there's a response to his side of the game with all the facts as I know them on here. The plot thickens, but now we venture over to Board Game Geek. Okay, the actual receipts from the designer me. Oh. Oh, so this wasn't just a Reddit thread. It's also tearing up the charts on Board Game Geek. Well, how about Oh, 36.25. Come on. Come on. Let's double that. Double. All right. Anyway, great post. I'm sorry you're getting put through it. And it was one of the and I was one of the the people who without trying to witch hunt tried to get a direct answer as to the use of generative AI in cola wars. I was interested in the game until not just the crime but the cover-ups as you'd say. The way the publisher was so incredibly evasive at first. We paid real humans to generate art instead of just outright saying they either didn't use AI or would remove it gave me the ick and turned me away from what looked like a pretty fun originally themed worker placement game. It did look very neat. that along with the way the campaign is being run, which is actually included for the $127 includes shipping. There's stuff included in the component list that may or may not be a stretch goal has made me very hesitant to back, which quick shout out, go check out my Fiverr down below. Get yourself a pre-launch campaign. I pretty much do give you a Kickstarter critique that you get and you can do with it what you will. A lot of times people will make big changes to
their campaign page. Uh, it sucks that your design so you don't make $100,000 mistakes potentially. It sucks that your design got embroiled in this since as you say it ultimately on the publisher, but their response and the way they manage their AI generated gamefound campaign has left a bad taste in a lot of people's mind space as it were. Yeah, if I would have, for instance, if I they would have been like, hey, I want you to look at this pre-launch. I would have led with like, you know, I don't care if it's AI art or not, but if it's anything that even looks questionable, I wouldn't lead with it because the people that want to smell blood in the water have their nose deep in the water. It sucks that your design got embroiled in this since, as you say it ultimately on the publisher, but their response and the way they manage their AI generated gamefam campaign has left a bad taste in a lot of people's mind space, as it were. I'm not 100% out, but I need to see a pretty hard about face from OMT Games to consider. Uh, so apparently they responded in here.
Let's see. Sassy Cat, Michael Sims, uh, Cameron Fleming. Oh, believe me, they've heard from me. Okay, so this is the designer again. And actually, we've had very good and productive conversations. It's just taking them a little while to get there, but they are getting there. Your comment is fair enough. It's fair though. I guess to me it feels like a witch hunt because initially people were saying the whole game is AI art which it isn't and then they started investigating quote unquote using pretty aggressive tactics. Many of them also haven't corrected or apologized for the inaccurate information they posted here and elsewhere. They won't even though they themselves discovered it wasn't true. Maybe witch hunt is the wrong word. Vendetta. I'm not saying people aren't right to be angry. I sure am. But I'm not sure their was proportionate to the situation. And there was a mean-spiritedness because it that doesn't to me seem helpful. Of course, I'm a target of it, too. So, of course, I would feel that way.
Uh, let's see. Danielle Perkins, for what it's worth, I was always drawn to the theme and the play of the game. This is a fair post giving much more clarity than publishers clearly. No, I want to see if the publisher jumps in here. Here it is. Madam, this is 100% what bothers me. the designer should not have to Oh, that's not the the same Matt M that we're looking for, but we'll read your post anyway because you got a great name. Quite frankly, it has felt like a witch hunt due to the tone of these conversations I've seen. There are are tactful ways to go about conversations around com controversial issues. What I've seen put forth has been aggressive and accusatory in tone since then. Is it fair to assume the worst of people? Let's see. Matthew Oh, here we go. Cameron is right that Cola Wars is not an AI art game. He is also right that I should have been clearer sooner. That part is on me. More to come. Okay, this is from two hours ago, by the way. So, we get Did he respond? Are we Are we catching some breaking news? Cameron said, the designer said, "I work in advertising. My job is already affected by AI. People in my industry are already losing their jobs. I could be next." I mean, I don't think anybody's I thought you said you you quit. I thought I'm I thought he quit his job in the summer.
Okay, here we go. Uh, that's Dang it. Other madam, get out of this freaking post until the Sorry, it's not you, it's him. Your name's similar. Did it go? Did we go? Did we go? Whoever's get I'm reading the last comment. I don't care. All right, Debo, you get it. I'm sorry that you chose to live in a world devoid of beauty and wonder. I hope that thinking exclusively about the bottom line eventually brings you something you believe to be joy. Debo sounds like they are probably uh not a fan of AI generated art. I'm going to guess. Okay. So, no response there. It's going to be really interesting to see they how they work themselves out of this one. Um, yeah, it's rough. So, there you go. Cola Wars. That is Bower Rides the news. Let me know what you think about it in the comments below. And if there's been some hot breaking uh what is it? Development. That's the word. Development in this story, please be sure to post it in the comments below. And that might lead me to make another video. But at the least, I will be sure to pin it. And if you want to see a specific news story covered, be sure to drop it in the comments below. I do love talking about the news. Have yourself a good one. Bye-bye. Oh, and um yeah, I just I'm not live streaming.
Bye.