Whirling Witchcraft Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at whirling witchcraft which is a board game designed by eric anderson sunden and published by aeg this one accommodates two to five players and takes around 30 minutes to play on average this is very much a family week style game that looks like this when it's on the table where each player has their own personal player board and they have their own cauldron you're going to have some communal resources such as all these cubes which all correspond to a different ingredient that you might find in a witch's cauldron such as these black hearts these mandrakes these mushrooms these spiders and these frogs there's also going to be a big deck of cars here which are going to be drafting from as the game game plays on and each player is also going to have their own personal card here and which you can use these novices or these initiates here as a general basic setup but you have got some variability if you want to try some different powers now the objective of this game is quite strange where you want to be trying to overflow the cauldron of the person sitting to the right of you and we'll explain how that works in the gameplay so the first thing you're going to do in a player's turn is that everybody is going to get given four of these cards and then simultaneously you're going to pick one of those cards um together so let's say i picked this this one here i'll put it face down and once everybody else has picked from their set of four cards we'll reveal them all together like so so let's say after three rounds of drafting i'm going to end up with these cards here now the idea is that i'm trying to convert resources or these cubes from my personal player board into
other resources that i'm going to give to my opponent because if i ever have too many of these resources you know overflowing these spots then they're going to basically go on to my opponent's board here and if they ever have five of those they're going to automatically win so you want to be keeping these down as low as possible and the way you do that is you're going to be allocating these cubes onto these different cards so let's say i put this mandrake token on here i put this blue spider token on here that will automatically convert it into a white and either a red or a green so let's say i took a white from the common supply like so and i also take a green from the common supply now i can either choose to put those straight into the cauldron which will get passed to my opponent and then go on to their workshop again with the idea of trying to make it overflow or i can actually use that to trigger another card so i can actually use this one to go into this one here and convert it into two additional red ones all with the idea of trying to overwhelm my opponent with cubes so they can't stop it from overflowing and you can do this as many times as you want as long as you have the resources to pay for it so again i could put these on here put another red one on here to convert it into two greens and a blue like so now all the cubes i converted are going to go in to the cauldron like this and then again that's going to get pass to the opponent on your right hand side so i've only got a two player game here so we're actually going to swap but i've not done this players but you know you get the gist um they're going to swap
directly to the person to your right again in a two-player it's just going to get back and forth then all those ingredients are going to go are going to go into the workbench of that player like so and as you can see as the game goes on you might want to start tailoring towards certain strategies because your opponent might be finding it difficult to manage a particular resource and any resources that you spent to actually convert to others just go back in to the general supply so that you don't have to worry about them anymore and that is basically how the game plays until someone is so overwhelmed that they cannot fight off um you know the five resources that they need to win so let's say for example this player had a full run of greens they ended up taking more they go into this area here which also they go into the person who's given those given the cauldron to that player there and if they ever collect five of those then they're going to win instantly there is an additional consideration you need to make when drafting these cards because as you can see at the top of each card you have these symbols corresponding to this little arcana card here and whenever you collect symbols of that type you are going to go or when you get to an even number so there's two four or six you're going to get a special ability and those abilities are quite simple so first off the book one here lets you take ingredients as if you had them on your player board and fulfill these recipes um you've got this cauldron here where you literally just get to chug any cube you want into your culture to try and throw your opponent under the bus and this final one here just lets you remove any two resources you want from your workbench so that's essentially how
the gameplay is going to work if nobody wins in a particular round you're going to draw back up to four cards draft a new card and then pass those cards to the player on your left so let's get on to some final thoughts on whirling witchcraft so first off gameplay-wise you know this is pretty much as simple as it gets but it does have at least some degree of engine building here all this kind of conversion trees which i quite like you know you can convert these goods into these goods and then those goods into these goods so it has got that again that branching off engine builders style mana where you can end up duplicating and just expanding and multiplying the cubes that you're putting all the idea of overwhelming your opponent by putting them into their cauldron and you do have an idea of what they might be suffering with you know because if they if again if they've got a whole row here of greens then you might want to really focus on getting those greens to try and get that win um i will say that i did find the luck of the cards in this game quite a significant factor because yeah although you have a choice of four cards at any time when you're drafting one um i did find myself on more than one occasion if i'm really struggling with a certain resource and i didn't draw the card that i needed to get rid of that resource then i'm pretty much done for there's nothing you can do about it i do like the flexibility of some of these cards you know when when you draft them you can choose to orientate them any way you want but they are going to be locked in that way for the rest of the game but you know if you're particularly struggling on a particular type then you do have the option of rotating it to you know to what suits you um additionally you do have that kind of tool in your back pocket that you can use you know if you're really struggling with one if you focus on
these raving raven symbols then you might be able to you know dilute your workbench down on that particular resource type so you do have some options there but it did again it did come into play more than once where i had no options whatsoever in order to mitigate my my cauldron or from my workbench being overloaded and um it just worked out that way because of the cards i drew i actually do quite appreciate the approach this game has gone for you know with the a very alternate victory condition you're trying to overwhelm your opponent's cauldron i've never seen that done before you're simply trying to force one player into losing essentially or although you're essentially winning by overwhelming them but you are essentially trying to make it as difficult as you can for one particular person because you are only ever interacting with you know the person to your left or right you know left in terms of the drafting but right in terms of the cauldron movement and that for me is a bit of a double-edged sword because although it's great that it keeps the uptime really strong where you are everyone's playing at the same time you don't really have to worry about what too many other people are doing so they're you know for that reason it scales very well you know from that two to five players it's not really going to take much longer no matter how many people you play this with but when games like work like that i think skill level comes into this game quite a lot where and and also like seat positioning so if you're sat next to somebody who's maybe not such a gamer isn't quite so up to scratch when it comes to these kind of conversion mechanisms um you're going to have a massive advantage over a person like that where you know if you've got a really experienced euro q pusher kind of player
they're gonna find it a lot easier to you know to manage that to manage that system than somebody who isn't so experienced yeah you can say that about a lot of games but again because i think this one you are particularly playing with one person then um yeah that's going to massively sway who's going to win the game or not the time investment of this game is generally good you know the box does say 30 minutes and i would say you know just as often as not it takes actually shorter than that and that's again kind of a double-edged sword because again you are only playing with that one person and on your side of the table you might just be in a really gripping tight game with you know and having that back and forth whereas on the other side of the table then somebody's getting completely overwhelmed they've got nothing they can do about it and then the game suddenly ends really abruptly there's nothing you could do about it and it's simply a war between those particular players so yeah it's it's weird in that respect where the game can come or can feel very at climactic because again you are so engrossed in your game and over there it's just ended and there's nothing you can do about it you've had that kind of rug swept from under your feet and it feels a bit anticlimactic when that happens the replayability is so so i mean for me personally i i wouldn't really go back to this one um because i think once you've done it you've done it there's not really much to explore i think the biggest thing that's going to get this back to the table is how quick it is they have made some efforts into getting injecting some different player powers that you can choose to use you know you've got like characters like this that let you convert mandrakes into you know the book ability or this one here says after passing recipe cards you must rotate this card
so each time you've got your own kind of personal ability there we can convert frogs into mushrooms so there is again a little bit of effort there to be made to these different characters and which i suppose is appreciated but i don't think it's going to massively change anyone's mind when it comes to the replayability from an aesthetics and production standpoint i think the game looks fantastic i really do like this artist um webison santiago he's got a great art style i'm very unique i think he's a brilliant artist he's made games such as um the bloody and i think this is a really really standout and you know striking out a style that i think is brilliant um all the components themselves are good you know of course you've got your standard wooden euro cubes which are which are fine they're nice and bright the cauldrons themselves are good you know they're a nice prop but not they're a good kind of standout piece but not overly done so i think it does strike a nice balance of being a nice well-presented product but without being overdone and superfluous so yeah i've got no issues at all with the production so final thoughts on whirling witchcraft so first off i think i have to give it props for being unique i can't think of any single game that plays quite like this and you know where you're trying to constantly you know sieve out the um crap from your bench and give it to your opponent on your right that's quite cool and it has a very different feel to anything else out there i like how quick this game is you know only takes 30 minutes maximum really um and it has a great job of scaling you know you can really play that five player count without adding too much time at all on to the actual time stamp of the game i do like some of the potential to
convert things into other things and you can get these cool kind of networks and chains going um but ultimately you you kind of react to what you've got and the decisions are fairly obvious because you know if you have too many blues you want to be converting blues into other stuff to try and keep your workbench down as much as you can so despite having some pretty interesting chains here it is pretty obvious what you want to do and i do feel like sometimes the luck comes into a it pays too much of a factor and because i said if you struggle with a certain type and you don't draw a card to get rid of that type and your opponent can produce a lot of it then all of a sudden you're overwhelmed and the game is over so yeah unfortunately i wanted to like this one much more than i did in actuality i think it's okay at best because i didn't quite find the game satisfying you know before you get anything going it's over and sometimes you've got no control over that so yeah i appreciate what this game does but it's not one for me unfortunately um i think there's a lot better family weight games out there and despite this one being unique so you know i think i think there is definitely a crowd out there and people who don't really mind that balancing issue of you know who you sat next to is going to massively impact on the game um but yeah overall um it's just a bit of a miss for me and i didn't quite hit the spot so yeah unfortunately i cannot recommend wearing witchcraft i just think there's too many other great family weight games out there