Is A.I. a Threat to the Board Game Hobby?
Transcript
in late August of 2023 Kickstarter announced its new policy that all crowdfunding managers disclose how they use AI for their projects almost immediately after that stronghold games the producers of terraforming Mars launched their immensely successful campaign for more terraforming Mars and as a result of this policy had to disclose how they use AI for the generation of the game's artwork well this became a target of severe controversy because if artists start losing their jobs to AI then what next where do we draw the line at what point will AI begin completely designing games for us that is the topic of this video we'll look into what AI really is its limitations and what it holds in the future of board gaming what is artificial intelligence now I recognize as a channel that does board game reviews this isn't your number one go-to for discussions on this topic but as a former math teacher and software developer this is a topic that fascinates me but you know what I specialize in I specialize in summarizing complex board games in 60 seconds or less so why not do a 60-second or less summary of artificial intelligence seen Plinko before right imagine a crazy idea what if I could take a message like what's a good YouTube channel for board game reviews and encod the message using a simple
pingpong ball code so that after the balls had jumbled around they came out the bottom with a new coded message that gave me the answer board game Dad it's not going to happen on the first try so what if I could repeat this drop millions of times each time making small changes to the shapes of the pegs the spacing and keep adding more layers until it worked consistently this contraption Bears a few similarities to a neural network the engine behind most AI technology the pegs are like nodes the rows are are like layers with an input layer an output layer and the hidden layers this process of adjusting the nodes as we repeat the experiment over and over again is called training this is obviously a flawed metaphor significantly a neural network doesn't operate by adjusting probabilities rather it adjusts the weights used in mathematical operations between the layers the most important takeaway from that video is that artificial intelligence or machine learning works because of training data in the example I had to give it a question and an answer pair so the innovation in machine learning is not a machine's ability to be creative but rather a machine's ability to automatically adjust the little pegs in the Plinko machine so that after giving it millions and millions of sample data with question and answer pairs it can eventually give me a predictable or believable response on a piece of new information I can give
it a question I've never given it before and it can give me a new answer but it's an answer that's based on patterns that I gave it and that is why there is so much accusation about plagiarism the whole reason an AI like mid Journey or Dolly can generate an image based on a text input is that it's been given millions of pairs of images and captions to go together but that artwork doesn't come from the computer programmers it comes from scraping the internet and taking these image caption pairs from non-consenting artists or photographers and of course they aren't being compensated setting the ethics of that aside I just want to be clear that machine learning draws from examples it is the heart of what makes the technology possible and also its biggest limitation the first first limitation of artificial intelligence is they can only do things based on examples that I give it the second limitation is that artificial intelligence can only do one thing very very well and that thing is whatever it was trained to do so to give you a specific example let's take a look at chat GPT I'm very curious by the way to hear about your personal experience with this have you tried using the free chat GPT tool and if you have haven't checked it out yet there are lots of resources in this video's description or
if you have have you upgraded to 4.0 uh please let me know in the comments what your experience has been and as well as your concerns with artificial intelligence but uh for now one of the reasons why I'm making this video is because I've heard so much hype about how powerful chat GPT is and all of the things that it can do but the truth is chat GPT only does one thing very well it's a natural language processing tool it can take a human written text and it can translate that into meaning for a computer and it can do things with that now people will say it does so much more it can write poems it can write a story it can it can even write a board game rule book and yes it can do that I'm just not saying that it does it well if you play around with it long enough you'll find that the jokes get old the homes are predictable and the stories are ordinary they can be a whole lot better if you put more input into it but at some point you've got to ask is the idea from the story or the joke coming from chat GPT or is it coming from your own creative input now my goal is not to disparage chat GPT I still think it's an awesome tool in fact I used it throughout making this video and if you're curious to find out how uh again check out the description I will put a article on my patreon page talking about
everything that I've learned and studied and everything I did for this video but it's a little beside the two points that I want to make lesser point you cannot use a tool like chat GPT in its current state to do something like design a board game by writing a board game rule book you can try and it will make something for you but to see how horribly it fails at this you can check out what I tried and the second major point is that if chat GPT can't do this then what would it take to design an AI that can and make all board game designers obsolete the first major obstacle to creating AI that can design board games is creating an AI that can play a board game I think this should go without saying but you cannot design a board game if you don't know what it's like to play one now of course there is precedent for this already there are AI that can play chess and go there's even AI that can play a lot of board games that you may play on your phone like Through the Ages but this isn't what we're looking for because these computers have specific games that they were designed to play Rather we need an artificial intelligence that can understand gaming as a whole and play any game that you would give it there is a name for this it's called General game playing and there are actually competition where computers will compete against each other at board games that they were never exposed to until right
before the competition begins to find out more about this you can check out the association for the advancement of artificial intelligence however I will say that while that sounds very exciting it's not as exciting as you would expect I'm thinking that you're going to take a photograph of carcassone rulebook or something and the computers going to start playing carcassone but that's not quite where it's at right now in order to deliver the rules to the computer they have to be described in a game description language which is a you know essentially a programming language so they already have the advantage of having the game being put into terms that they can understand what would it take for a machine to be able to read a rule book and understand the relationship between what's written on the page and how that gets played out and not only that but the computers that we have that play things like chess and checkers and go the game state is represented by the physical proximity of pieces on a board what would it take to be able to analyze board games that have cards that have text on them and to be able to understand the strength of a certain card or its action and the resources it takes and the economy of designing your own engine and all all this extra stuff computer science isn't there yet but it is considered a major milestone
in the development of true artificial intelligence a milestone that we haven't hit yet the second obstacle is how computationally expensive it would be for an AI to generate an entire board game from scratch now to understand this a little bit let's look back at history if you go back to the late 90s the computer deep blue was able to play chess and beat the best chess players in the world this technology did not depend on neural networks rather it depended on processing power it played chess by analyzing all of the different moves and choosing the one that was proven to be most successful fast forward about 20 years now we have programs like Alpha go which are able to beat the best go players but not depending on processing all of the different moves that are available rather that technology depends on a neural network so in order to get from chess to go we needed an entirely new innovation I am claiming with my limited knowledge of course but from what we've looked at even in this video that it would be too computationally heavy even with a neural network for a computer to fully design a board game from scratch I mean just think about what we've looked at we don't even yet have a computer that can play a general board game so an AI would have to
iterate through game design much like the Plinko machine moving the little pegs around but every time it's moving pegs around it's actually redesigning a whole new game and playing it again and again it's too computationally expensive to do that right now is it possible is it theoretically possible for a a neural network to be trained to do these things yes I believe it is but is it practical no I think in order to design board games it still requires the creativity the vision that a human can bring to the table which brings me to the next major question for this discussion if the art of Designing board games is truly a human effort then should we decry any intrusion of AI as a contamination of our beloved craft or in other words is this ethical my answer to this is that even though it can conveniently mimic intelligence artificial intelligence is still a lifeless tool and as a tool humans throughout history have never hesitated to adopt the usage of a tool our adoption of AI is inevitable and we can look at history to see how it's happened before the printing press made scribes obsolete the photograph ruined things for portrait artists the automobile disrupted jobs for anybody who was involved in taking care of horses telegraphs nearly eliminated Messengers television cost the jobs of
so many radio actors computers and internet disrupted everything e-commerce destroyed brick and mortar stores but we've never let this stop us we've always adopted these tools and they've always opened up new opportunities they've always created new jobs and despite the cost we've always figured out a way forward there is also always a stage of discomfort a stage during which the people whose jobs are becoming obsolete are clinging to the last bit of business they can get in before they have to make an inevitable career change if that idea is something that you would like to see embodied in a board game then I have a recommendation for you it's a longtime favorite for me than the game Innovation that area of discomfort that question of do I keep using the technology I have or do I invest into the new thing is best embodied in this game now taking it back to the discussion of how we use artificial intelligence in board game design I think it's important to recognize that stronghold games the producers of terraforming Mars are using artists artists who are using artificial intelligence to produce the artwork the jobs are there they're just new jobs they're new jobs and they're adapted to a new tool the beauty in board game
design is when a carefully designed game intersects with a passionately researched theme machines don't come up with ideas they emulate the ideas they've seen before and this goes back to the point that I made at the very beginning artificial intelligence is the innovation of using machine learning to perform tasks but in order to be truly intelligent it has to have its own goals its own Drive its own interest its own passions in order for a board game to be good it has to be the product of somebody's interest of somebody's passion but can we make a machine that can understand interest and passion if we can we haven't done it yet thank you for watching this video I hope you found it enjoyable and informative please tell me about your experience with artificial intelligence with chat gbt whatever it may be and if you are especially knowledgeable in this topic if I've made any mistakes especially in my metaphor that I use there please let me know let us all all know in the comments down below and finally I'd like to remind you that this video is supported by my patrons and I have a special debt of gratitude to you for both the financial support and the
emotional support through our Discord Channel and our discussions very much appreciate the community that is being created there for information on how you can get connected you know where to find it thank you again for watching I'll see you next time bye-bye