Skip to main content
Loading video...

Cards We Won't Miss From The Path to Carcosa (Arkham Horror: The Card Game)

Transcript 24:08

It's what you do. It's what you do. Speaking of stage fright, not yet, though. Hello, everybody. Welcome. These are cards we're not going to miss from the path to Carcosa. Uh, if you don't know, rotation is coming pretty soon, and all your cards are going to be mailed to Travis to be incinerated, shredded.

I haven't decided yet.

Okay. I hope you make like some sort of sculpture out of them.

Make a giant Cthulhu.

Yeah, that would be kind of hype as hell.

And you could like put people in it.

Okay. Oh, that's really big. like a wicker.

Oh, frick. Don't go to Travis's house, everybody.

Well, it's just going to be the people who don't bring their cards.

Yeah, but they're going to they're going to be like,

"Burning me won't bring your current cards back." Travis is like, "I know that it will."

Oh, that's great. Oh, god. All right. So, a few weeks ago, we did cards we were gonna miss from Patarosa, but these are the good riddance to this bad rubbish for this video here. So, uh, we always like to do when we have a video where we're talking about things that we like. We love to do things about talking about stuff that we hate. So, that's going to be happening in today. And let's go with a card that we unanimously despise at this table, which [clears throat] is Sharon's Oal.

Yeah. I don't know if we ever played with this one.

I think we did it. Well, you recently played with

it like a couple weeks ago.

Yeah. But that was part of the meme. That was part of the meme because you were going to [clears throat] be a little

guy.

Yeah. And this saved you. This saved you a scenario.

It was just for a joke.

Yeah. Yeah.

But I think the only time is one of us might have played it. I think I played it once when I did book Jenny in like one of our first like early campaigns. Yeah.

Um

and then after that, the reason why we don't play it is one, there's only one. And two, I think the three of us all agree that you don't really need the experience.

Right. And the other one is that it suddenly changes the stakes when it's just like, oh, if this person dies, they're gone. Right.

Yeah. Like the team loses all that experience.

Yes. And like then it's like one of those things where it's like, but you chose to put it in the deck, but now we have to kind of bend over backwards to save you.

Yeah. We suffer the consequences for your decisions.

Yeah. And it leads to kind of like just an unhealthy play pattern. So, we kind of just all like we never even said don't play it. We just all stopped. Yeah, we just stopped.

Yeah.

Yeah. I think this card [clears throat] where initially was was they were designing Rogue differently where they intended them to be uh your deck to eventually have a bunch of exceptional cards that were like the sort of the capstone for your builds.

And then they moved away from that and they were like, you're just going to get like normal cards that don't suck.

Yeah.

Yeah. That was fun. And so when you needed like this card was helpful when you're like I need 10 experience [clears throat] to get a good card into my deck.

Uh but when

it's like a little on the strong side when you're like I I'm just building a normal deck.

Yep. Yeah. I mean I think I think we also like we got to a point where in design they were like these exceptional cards are awesome and you need a lot of XP to buy them. And that's true. They are awesome and you do need a lot of XP to buy them.

Yep. Most of them are awesome. But you can just spend that XP on non-exceptional cards and have your deck be better.

Yes.

Yeah. They're also awesome.

Most of the time. And they're also just kind of awesome.

Yeah.

Yeah. Like how many exceptional cards are better than Lucky Cigarette Case 3?

Not many.

Um I think probably the only one I'd make a case for is Red Clock 5. I think everything else

is like goated.

Yeah. And even then I still I think Lucky Cigarette Case just reigns supreme. But that'd be the only one that I'd be like

Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah. Like maybe the golden pocket [clears throat] watch.

Maybe.

Yeah.

Like that one. That one definitely has

that's probably the highest rate of winning you the game when you resolve it, right? Yeah.

But it is it's one of those things. Yeah. Just like buy the small [ __ ] and just

Yeah. buy the other [ __ ] and move on, right?

Yeah.

Like

we don't we don't need this kind of effect anymore.

Mhm.

No, we don't need any kind of experience.

We don't need any kind of effect.

Yeah.

We're just going to play blank cards.

Yeah. I mean, I would love if they just like stopped doing this kind of thing apart from like with like I think like will Yoro's bury them deep is my favorite experience thing because I feel like investigators should be allowed to kind of break

kind of boundaries a little bit.

Yeah. It's also very like [clears throat]

how many times can you abuse this? It's probably like8 experience per scenario.

Yeah. When it's all said and done. Yeah.

Like it's fine.

Yep. Yep. Yeah, something that's like extremely narrow like refine I also think is horrible.

But it has to be like very it has to be not oh this is upgrading a a card type. It has to be like this is upgrading like a very small subset of cards that you're not going to interact with outside of this expansion.

Yeah. Like the kind of like even just like the reason there's a reason to play it as opposed to a re you have to find a reason not to play it. Right. And I think like we found a reason not to play Sharon's oel.

We did not a good one. If we were like if we were like Yeah. It's not a good Yeah. It's not a good reason. Yeah. Well, it is for us, but like if we were like all tryhards, we'd be like, "Okay, who's taking Sharon's this time?"

And who's dying and taking the aesthetic once you know you're dead, right?

Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah.

All right. Next one. Here we got cheat death. Uh doesn't do what's on the table.

They lie to you.

Yeah. You can in fact not cheat death. You can only cheat death in one very specific way and that is the way that they'll allow you to cheat death. But all the other ways you want to cheat death, you might as well just like go freaking die and not cheat it. Yeah,

pretty much.

So like a big thing for this was like um the events, right, that were like that's where we first started to come with this. The events that are like you were defeated, right? Mhm.

Um those are considered to be a cost and the whole cost and then the whole cost thing in Arkham always rubs me the wrong way. I think it's kind of just like stupid when how it works sometimes. And this one is making noises.

Yeah.

Oh, you pulled two feathers out. Good job.

Yeah. Would you like to reiterate how the cost works for people who don't know?

Yeah. So if the cost cannot be you if the cost isn't paid the effect after doesn't happen. So, for example, we thought and a majority of player, well, not a major, I don't know the number, but a lot of players also, I assume, thought that if you played a card that defeated you as part of its cost, you could use cheat death and not be defeated, right? Especially for a 5XP card, but because you do not die,

um,

you don't do the rest.

You don't get to do the rest.

So, then you can also not stop the cheat death part even happening in the first place. They said you can't even do the front half of this because that's a cost and it wasn't like the same as being defeated. And it kind of just like took any sort of like slot for this and kind of just said like

Yeah, I think that the way the costs work is is fine. Probably avoids more problems than it creates. And it's really a templating card on this issue where, you know, you're like the card says I'm defeated and it says I can play this and I'd be defeated. Why can't I do it?

Yep.

Right.

Yeah. Um, and I also I mean I understand like the philosophy of the design here. It's here to protect you when you Sharon's oble, right? You take Sharon's oel and this just is like you spend some of that experience to stop that. But the reality is is also just like not dying is a pretty good way of winning the game.

It's also supposed to be a big flashy event for Safina.

Yeah.

Which is really unfortunate cuz it doesn't actually do anything. Like even if this did function in the way that you thought it would

but you need to do it like six times in a game that would become enhance the game plan at all. You're just like, "Oh, I'm not dead again." They're like, "Great. I still need six clues to win."

And then the monster [snorts] comes over and tries to hit you. You're like, "Oh, I'm not dead again."

Yeah. Yeah. Cuz you get rid of all treacheries in your thread area, but the enemies, they're like, "No, that's someone else's problem now."

Yeah.

Yeah. All right. Next up, it's over. One second. It's It wouldn't be a PPG video without one of these. So, give me a second. All right. Once more with feeling. We got slight of hand.

I'm going to miss having to remember what it does cuz it is not what is printed on the card like ever.

Yeah.

It was once for a glorious about two and a half months.

Yep.

And then it wasn't and it's never been the same since.

Yep. feels like uh playing cards for free is a [clears throat] very powerful effect,

it turns out.

And then once there's like no cap on it, it's very powerful.

Um

yeah, that's is that what the kids mean when they're when they say no?

No cap. You know what? I'm going to say yes.

Is that is that what they mean?

I'm going to say yes. Yeah. Yeah. Uh, and [gasps] but uh it's it did some things with the secret Necronomicon as one of the reasons why this card got like toned down and like some other things as well with that.

You know, as much fun as it was to slide of hand like a flamethrower into play.

Yeah, cuz the flamethrower was the start cuz it originally was two to onehanded and then it was zero to three

and it had the weird thing where then like it didn't work with signatures anymore because those technically aren't a level. Don't get me started.

It's the whole thing.

I don't like that [ __ ]

I mean, now that I'm here, you should allow investigators to play signatures from like if there was a card that was like, "Show me the cards in your hand." If someone else's signature is there, you should be allowed to play it. It's so stupid that you can't.

Yep.

That's just like it it that's okay. That's okay. That's okay. I think Oh, he's over there now.

Yeah.

But yeah, no. Uh, this is just like a very powerful card that also was kind of like a

It's convoluted. Yeah.

Yeah. This card's also like [ __ ] and puts a heavy cap on the items that they can design.

Mhm.

Anything that has limited uses or that like like the Necronomicon um basically you can't print while this exists.

Mhm.

So, you know, it's a good thing it's gone.

Yeah. Yeah.

Hey, this card's a problem.

Yeah. Yep.

And it's good that it's gone. Um,

watch them just print it again.

Yeah. I mean, like the last couple of cards they got to spoil.

Yeah.

If removes itself from the game after, that's

Yes, that would be like if if it was the same card but just like removed itself, that would be nice.

What if it put a finality sticker on the card while it's in your hand?

I don't want stickers. Please.

What about a small object you slide into a sleeve? A bead of some sorts. It's a finality bead.

No, I also

What if they looked tasty like the batteries from Galaxy Trucker?

No.

Okay.

No, I probably [snorts] No, that's too much temptation.

Yeah. Um, but no, this thing it's just like there is I mean we're now that we know there's a new core set, we'll probably do this for the core set, too, so we can [ __ ] about scavenging and recursion. Um

yeah, the designers, they took a look at every other card game that's ever been printed ever, and they were like, you know, having like capitalless res uh resource um recursion didn't work for them, but it might work for us.

It might work for us.

Yeah.

Yeah.

And then it didn't.

It didn't. No. No, it didn't. And it's it's a problem. And it's good. It's gone. Uh we've seen some examples of the recursion like hunter instinct I believe it's called from the new core set which is only for level zero only for events and it's also only um like three uses. So like that's like already there's like restricting it which is cuz I think that like recursion is still fine in survivors pie but it needs to be a lot more restrictive and they just be like well is the card red.

Yeah. What they did is they they were like they put like not named resourceful and they said

they kind of thought

Yeah. They're like job's done that there. This is never going to be a powerful thing we can imagine is people throwing a pitching resourceful to get back resourceful on every test.

Yeah.

Dang perpetual plus one as long as they pass.

Wow.

Yeah.

Yeah. I I'd be curious like that we've talked about other versions of resourceful if it was like only got like level or lower. So like level zero can only get level zeros, but there was like a level three that could get like level three or lower.

See, now that would be a good customizable card that can only equal to the experience you've put into it.

Bring them back. That's actually they haven't spoiled those yet on the core set. It's going to be there's a whole suite of customizable cards just to really just establish that those are evergreen.

[ __ ] caster.

Yeah, you bet.

We couldn't figure out a way to balance for true solo. So here you go.

Yeah. Bye-bye. That's her waving goodbye to us. Bye. Hey, no. That's her trying to get a scissors to defend herself as Travis's paper machiner to the Cthulhu statue.

Yeah.

All right.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Lola Hayes,

fun fact, I don't know if you actually found, but you gave me mod status in the Twitch thing, and I actually made it. So, watch this. was a uh

that makes so much sense because I was so I was actually streaming and the automod flagged watch this and I was like why the hell was this auto like on this flagged and then someone said maybe it was because of spam bots linking videos and I said yeah that makes sense that makes that so much funnier

the only moderator action I've ever taken

and the best thing as well is that that was only like a week ago.

I flagged it like 2 years ago.

That's incredible. That is so [ __ ] funny. I love that. That is great. Honestly, that's like a great use of your power. That was really good.

All right. Lola Hayes, the punching bag that came out with Pathosa, the investigator that both Travis and I played. We tried her out and we were both like, "Wait a minute, this is awful."

Um, it was not

just bad. Not even fun.

Not even fun. Yeah. Like I understand the design philosophy that she was kind of like neutral with the idea that restrictions were to keep her in rain, right? She had a big card pool,

but I think it was too early to make a neutral investigator. I think they needed to kind of understand more of what that meant, what the game was. Charlie, I think, is a perfect neutral investigator.

Yeah, he is.

And Parallel Lola is actually also a fantastic neutral investigator.

How about Suzie? Susie, I don't I think she's bad.

I agree.

Yeah, I think she's I think she

Yeah, but I can have like 600 cards in my deck. Justin,

you could have a lot.

I think the issue with Susie is that I think that she's a joke that people take seriously, right? When like Lola was serious but then turned into a joke, you know?

Yeah. So, that's that's like [clears throat] this u Carcosa run when we when we switch over to X. I'm playing Lola there. [clears throat]

No, I'm playing Lola. He's playing Susie. He's

Yeah, I'm gonna eat I'm gonna eat whatever card it is that I had.

Hello, fellow humans.

Yeah,

Michael. What happened? You know, Michael McGlenn? Yeah, he's my uh distant grandfather.

I ate him.

Yeah,

I have his DNA. [clears throat and laughter]

That's good. That's good. Um, yeah, but I think just Lola uh she was tabooed. She became more playable with the taboo, but like that's not like a huge mountain to climb

because like the level like the original version was really rough,

like borderline unplayable.

Yeah. And uh yeah, so now that the parallel version, that's to me like the the true Lola. And those have been handwaved into current. So easy peasy.

Because who wants to figure out what the hell they count as?

Yes. Yeah. There's just like Yeah. Please just like blah blah blah blah.

Sorry. What did you ask questions about the investigators and the new core box?

No, the book investigators and the parallels. What? What are those?

Whatever you custom cards you play with your your collection to whatever you want.

All right, [snorts] Brid, your good buddy Dario Elam.

I'm not going to miss him. I'm glad he's dead.

Yeah.

Yeah. Oh, now David Renfield was here. You know what? That is kind of crazy. The David Renfield versus Daario just like comparing

also part of that.

That's crazier. That's even cra This is all the patron cycle where they all did some sort of resource reduction, right? What was the guardian the the guardian one?

Guard dog.

I like look

I could I have the tab open.

The seeker [clears throat] one was that guy.

Oh, they didn't have one. Charles Ross.

They didn't have one.

Charles Ross. Yeah, that's right. Guardians didn't need an ally.

They don't need anything. No, they had Mark Heragan. They had a gun. Yeah.

Um but yeah, he really is like even though we never really played Dr. Charles Ross, I think that he there's more of a fantasy to go with him, right? Like there was like

I mean I think Brendon just played Dario out of spite like some

you have like a niche where you could effectively [clears throat] give the resources to other people.

Yep. Yeah. But you you were just like I think you're like punishing yourself whenever you because you just also just played him like you just you just played him as well.

Level zero green allies are awful.

Yeah, they are mostly pretty bad.

Bianca Decats is pretty all right.

You only get one.

Yeah, that's true.

That is true.

It's like what? Leo cost six.

Yeah, he's very level. He doesn't really do anything.

Yeah,

you got uh you got Gregory Gr. He's fun to gamble with, but you got to be like, I'm going to bear doing tests.

Yeah, you have to go hard on it. Failed actor.

Yeah, Henry Juan, which you love,

which I do enjoy playing.

He's definitely lost as a non scenario. So,

that's cool.

This guy stop myself.

14 money is an absurd amount of money for plus one book and plus one brain.

Um, like an impossible amount of money.

Yeah, but every time you activate him, you're like getting an action.

So, he's basically like a four cost. gaining like

that gives you stats

cuz gaining a resource is the weakest thing you can do.

This guy's like four cost Leo who gives you plus one and two stats and uh no he soaks the same.

Gaining a resource is I will I'll say it again for the folks in the back. Uh gaining a resource is the weakest thing you can do.

Is that cuz I'm at the back table?

Yes. Okay.

And clearly you didn't hear me.

No. Sorry about the people I have locked up in there. M

but like

well attacking and like making attack enemy that your teammates engage with that you can't possibly

you're like Norman Withers punching like a freaking like punching a ghoul priest

punching a rat. Norman Withers can punch a

We know Norman Withers can punch a rat.

Punching a the ghoul priest that is a little bit crazy. Yeah.

Yeah. Apart from like actively griefing your team or yourself or whatever. Anyway, this guy's not great and I'm glad I'm never going to have to play with him again.

I would love a keyword in the news cycles that is like retaliate for the person holding it. So then like Travis, I could be holding an enemy. You can have like retaliate and like outburst and then you attack into it, miss, it hits you and me and you shoot me. That would be great.

God.

And then we have even more like do you trust me? It was just like

actually that would be a really fun uh keyword to pair with like some of the inmouth style enemies that punch you from engaging them as well to balance that.

Yeah. Yeah,

that would be nice.

Yeah,

that'd be cool for a revisit to the

the fishman.

We'd love the fishmen, but we hate

the composure cycle. So, this is our last one we have here for this list. Would you like this book if you already had fishmen on it?

No.

No, I don't think I would. Yeah. So, this is all of them. This is

Scientific Theory, Moxy, Grounded, and Plucky. Those are the five along with Combat Training.

Yeah, they all just kind of suck.

They ate five experience cards in this cycle and this cycle really didn't have the card quality to to be able to afford that. I mean, I think apart from the fact that Will York's in it, um, there's a lot of like Brin cards in here again because of Will York, but it makes sense why you and I don't prioritize this one so high, too, because when we did our drafts,

it's cuz the cards suck.

Yeah, the cards weren't great in Carcosa. They weren't.

The investigators were really good.

That's what I've uh what I've learned is that like while I want this one, I can also let it go real late cuz no one else takes it and the investigators are goated out of this.

Yes. Yeah, cuz I think we did. Yeah, you did like Mark Harrian when you did like your flex Mark Hagan.

Yeah, like Mark Harrian's sick

and you did you did Will Yor is sick. Will Yoro's sick. The yellow one is yellow.

Uh so it doesn't matter.

Um you can be happy and the purple one is a great purple investigator. You're just like extra charges on all your [ __ ]

She's very fine.

Yeah, she's awesome. Um yeah, if you get like Edge of the Earth for one of your high picks or um I don't know, maybe like Dream Eters, you can probably afford to take Kosa as well, but you really need

Y

uh like a very strong base to build.

Yeah, if you've got if you Yeah, you can't

those.

Yeah,

unless you're on the wheel.

Yes.

In which case, like you can grab this and one of the other ones that has enough cards for the thing you're trying to do.

Yeah. Yeah.

To make up for the fact that this one has none. It isn't. It is interesting. It has like a lot of good um like level zero cards. There's a lot of banger zeros in here.

Yeah.

Um

secret cards are solid but not great.

And it's kind of like Dream Eaters is very similar too where like most of its upgrades are like

they crush it

and they're but they're also like there's a lot of like that space that goes into well bonded cards but also like the decks that they fit in best. Yeah. You know, like so like you're like a survivor going into dream eaters and you like lose some pieces because you mean yeah you got brute force and sharp vision but then you look at cornered and you're like I'm not going to play this in my deck because I'm not actually discarding anything right.

Yeah, that happened when I was playing Hank for a survivor run. I was like brute force can be sick and then my my level zero deck I was like oh

it's a like three assets or whatever. It's a really interesting thing to see from like you'd look at a slice of a of a of a box of player cards and knowing that in Carcosa five of them were eaten up by these composers that kind of actually just like

do nothing really.

Yeah. They they just takes up space.

Yeah. So, I'm not going to miss them. The upgraded ones, as we said before we prep, are very good. Those ones are those ones are bangers. I think they worked really and they they feel really nice for 3 XP.

Yep.

But these probably could have been

free. Anything else?

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Just even a different

card. I wouldn't play this [ __ ]

No. No. We mean Yeah. Cuz

Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah.

All right. Well, those are cards we're not going to miss from Pat Carosa. Uh it's going to get spicier from here because I think Forgotten Age is when things started to really kind of click for card pools in both like the good and then also like the Arcane Researches started to show up starting going forward here too.

Yeah. Like Arcane Research.

Yeah. So, there's going to be some stuff that's going to be spicy when we do that. And then also we'll talk about the corset too now that we know that is rotating out. But in the meantime, thanks for watching everybody. Have a good rest of your week. Let us know some cards from Carcosa that you hate because it's always fun to [ __ ] about cards that make you go, I hate that card. Or also cards that make you become a friend with someone, go into their mod privileges and then ban it from their chat. That's also pretty good, too.

I didn't become a mod. You made me one.

I don't mean I had to. You You were there once and I was like, Travis, you're not a mod. That's crazy. Yeah. And then I gave you a sword.

And I used it.

You used it.

See you.

Progress saved