Skip to main content
Loading video...

What’s Not to Like? The Thing / Feed the Kraken

Transcript 16:28

hey lately i've been making a lot of really positive reviews i've played some excellent games and i've been really eager to put those videos out there however not everything i play is a hit and i don't strongly recommend every single game i think from time to time it's good to talk about the kinds of games that i've tried lately actually brand new games i've been really excited to uh give these a chance but um fell a little flat for me so these are negative reviews although i would like to say that oftentimes you know a negative review is very difficult to do because when you find a game that you don't really like you don't spend as much time playing it and getting to know it very intimately and sometimes you miss a lot of extra things it's really easy to play a game you love and get to know it so so very well both of the games i'm going to be talking about today actually no i was going to say i've played them once one of them i've played twice but like once twice how well do i know these games i'd love to hear from you maybe change my mind if you will but otherwise i'm going to talk about the thing and feed the kraken which both were released this year in 2022 so first both of these games are trader games and i do have a little video of each one i will show you feed the kraken first

so nope put myself here okay so this is the board for feed the kraken and what you're doing is you're moving this ship across the board and players are resolving events to see if they will end hey you know what go back there they're resolving events to see if the ship is going to end up in a pirate victory a sailor victory or a cultist victory and so each event has one of three possibilities there's either red yellow or blue and this is a hidden identity game where three players or actually two players are secretly putting cards into a treasure chest and then one player is revealing the result red yellow or blue and then the the result determines which direction the ship moves across the board and as it moves across the board it encounters very various events you can see here there are the kraken and each player has a secret identity which they keep inside this pirate booty bag so in this game and in fact both games actually that i played i was a pirate there and i had like my player card and a few sp oh actually that's the rules but i had a player card with some special abilities everybody has a special ability um and then the other game that i tried was the thing i played this one a little while ago let me take off feed the kraken and show the thing

so in the thing this is uh based on a movie that i have never seen but you are in the arctic and you're these researchers and there is a monster that can infect you in this game i was the thing of course none of the other players knew that and what they're trying to do is perform actions in their laboratory here that will help them escape before the thing infects them so they've got a helicopter over in this corner that they can get into they've got a a vehicle that they can get into to escape but both of these vehicles need uh oops both of these vehicles need to be repaired and they need fuel so at different spaces on the whoa that's a lot bigger put it back where it was at spaces on the board you can get supplies for the players you can get fuel and you can do repair actions the thing is if players are in a space together they can work together and that makes them more effective but the risk of working together is that you may be in a room alone with the player who's infected by the thing and if the player if um if those two players are together then they can have an encounter and then at the end of that encounter the thing can infect another player so it has this viral quality and in fact that is really the core of

both of these games they are both well this one is definitely a traitor game the thing and then the other one feed the kraken i don't know if it's so much of a traitor game um well it's a little there's it's it's three teams but it feels very much like the cultist is a traitor as well in both games one side has knowledge the other the other players don't have the cultists know who the cultists are and the thing knows who the other infected players are and no one else knows they're keeping that role hidden they're trying to be deceptive okay now i understand what a game like this is all about um avalon is like this i love avalon shadows over camelot which is an older game but another great example of a game where you've got a traitor and the the traitor is the one who's really making things harder for everybody else oh and then of course uh oh man the madness the mansion oh man house on haunted hill the classic example of a trainer game but these ones don't quite work and i think the reason why is it's all about knowledge i was very excited to play feed the kraken because it sounded very

similar to avalon with some major changes one being that when you resolve the direction of the ship no one actually knows exactly what's going to happen by comparison if you look at a classic game like avalon different players have a card that they select from their hand every player has access to the same cards they know exactly what they're going to select and feed the kraken the card that you play into the event is drawn from a deck so you could draw a card that helps you you could draw a card that doesn't help you you get to draw two cards and pick one so for example if you're a cultist you might draw a cultist card and a pirate card and in that case you're probably going to want to play the cultist card because that is that works in your favor but you could also be the cultist and draw two uh sailor cards and you're not even on the sailor team but what choice do you have you can only play a sailor card so just because you're a bad guy doesn't mean you have to play a bad card that that mixes things up a lot it also works out if you're a sailor by the way or if you're a pirate by the way no player has absolute certainty on which card they play so you're already dealing with a lot of luck then and feed the kraken it's not just you but you and another player all both selecting one card putting it in a box and then you're giving it to another player that other player gets to have their pick between the two that are

available to them now they may pick your card or they may pick the other person who was on your team either way after that gets picked that determines where the ship goes so there's very little control a player has over what gets selected and i find that feels a lot more chaotic i'm very accustomed to games where players get to be mischievous and then they can lie you know like they can pick the a card and they can say hey you know that wasn't me that wasn't me and it's all about the deception in this game there is some amount of deception but then there's also like just chance that was really weird okay um and we're gonna find out when i when i shift back my focus over to the thing there's something very similar about the thing also the other thing is and feed the kraken after you resolve these cards there are different events and one of the events that can come out is a cultist event where all players are going to close their eyes and put their fists in the center of the table like captain planet or something and then the the um the cultist and the cultist alone is going to open his or her eyes and tap somebody on the fist and the rule book is very cute

about this it says you get to touch them with your slimy tentacle all right the person they touch becomes another cultist and and they get to open their eyes and see the person who infected them so they know who else is occultist whereas every other player doesn't know in other words as you play the game cultists are getting more and more dominant and gaining more and more knowledge while other players aren't gaining more knowledge and they still have the disadvantage where they don't even get to pick their own cards necessarily it still comes down to luck of the draw i found with this game we played it twice this is the one i played twice it was just so uh we played it twice and i was a pirate both times and both times the cultists won and both times it wasn't even hard it was so easy for the cultist to win the second game we played we tried so hard to avoid a situation where uh the cultist event would come up and allow the cultists to affect other other players still didn't happen and this again once that cultist affects other players they gain not only they gain another player on their side but they gain information that nobody else knows it didn't really feel like it had a lot of game to it it felt like

cultists are going to win it's there i i don't i don't see how except for every player working very strategically to try not to let yellow come up yellow is the one that leads to the cultist event i don't see how it could go any other way aside from extraordinary luck it says it's a social deduction game i would much rather play a game where individual players have control over what can happen and uh truly get to be deceptive because they choose their actions not because things are completely out of their control either because of bad luck of draw or because the cultist has switched their allegiance and there's nothing i can do about it so not enough game for me switch that over to the thing so i had said that in the thing at the beginning of the round players are going to determine what room they go into and this is going to happen in player order so the first player goes into one room the second player goes into a different room you go around and around and around and and maybe the last player is going to join another player in the same room now because of the chance of infection remember once this happens players who share a room together are going to have an encounter because of the chance of infection just the fact alone that a player is going into a room with you is enough reason to create suspicion

wait why are you joining the room with me and of course that player is going to say i'm joining because i want to help you out but you say yeah but how do i know that you're not the thing and that's kind of where the social deduction is you know are they trying to be helpful or are they trying to infect you so they go into the room and then you start resolving events again this is a very interesting one because what's happening is players are putting oh boy it's been a while since i can't remember i think they're putting cards they're putting cards in together and then the cards are being revealed to see how effective they are in each room um and then players in rooms with more uh cooperative players in there get get to have more effective actions um but my goodness in this one i was the thing i went i used my turn to go straight into a room where another player was the interaction is very weird in this game everyone has to have an interaction one-on-one so if three people are in a room you have to have an interaction with one person and then another person and then those two people have to have an interaction with each other too and this is awkward to have an interaction you've got to give them two cards one one which is your um like your identity card and another card which is like a dummy card so for example i would give them one card which is truly the thing and then another card

which is like a nothing and then they're going to shuffle them up and then they're going to pick one and if they pick the card that has the thing on it then they become infected and if they pick the dummy card then they don't become infected and then they shuffle them back and give it back to me so that means i don't know whether or not they were infected but then i have to do that again with the other play i'm in the same room with right so everyone is doing this they're shuffling their cards they're giving you cards you're taking their cards you're picking a card you're shuffling their cards you're giving their cards back they're giving your cards back you're shuffling your cards again the other person is shuffling their cards again you're swapping they're swapping so much like you're supposed to avoid interactions with other players because there's a risk of being infected in this game i wanted to avoid interactions just so i wouldn't have to go through the swapping cards ritual it was so awkward as it turned out though i went into a room with two other players both of them were infected by the thing as soon as they came out they went in and did interactions with their players they became the thing everybody became a thing everybody became an alien everybody i would say everybody lost because every single human became infected with the thing but i guess everybody won because if you're on the side of the thing and the humans lose then that means the thing wins so i guess did we all win i i don't like that i don't i don't feel like i'm winning when um

the bad guys wins or the um the enemy wins right both of these games you know we think that sailors or the pirates are the good guys in the thing it's the humans that are the good guys and it feels very much like the cultist or the thing are the um the bad guys way too frustrating when the outcome of the game is determined by who gets infected um i thought it was way too powerful in both cases neither of these was games for me but i'd love to hear what you think i mean am i missing something is it is the thing not so awkward like did we do we do it wrong like uh i don't know love to hear what you think otherwise i don't think i'm in my opinion pretty clear i try to go live with videos every monday at 8pm thank you so much for watching i have more positive reviews coming out this weekend take care i'll see you next time bye

Progress saved