Signorie Review
Transcript
welcome to John gets games today I'll be reviewing signorier this two to four player game puts you at the head of an Italian household a few hundred years ago and you're trying to make your house the most powerful and you're going to do that by sending your kids off to war into the church and to marry off into other alliances with families so mechanically what you're going to be doing here is a dice pool draft where a bunch of dice rolled every single turn and then all players will be grabbing one on their turn until the pool diminishes down and everybody's done with the things they want to do first I will show you how the game plays and then I'll jump into my review here we have the starting setup for a three-player game of signorier each player gets their own player board as well as some women and men figures in their family and there is a central board here which contains the dice which we'll be rolling in just a minute some towns that we can be influencing through marriage or other political acts and lastly a turn counter with some bonus actions at the beginning of the round all these dice get rolled and there are always one die per player in each color so if this is a two player game there'll only be two in each and a four player game would obviously have four uh the structure of return is really quite simple all you do is choose any one of these Dice and put it onto your player board so for instance a player might take this four right here you then place the die down in the appropriate column to the color of the die and it's important to note you're never allowed to have two dice of the same color within a given round so once you take one yellow not gonna be able to take any more now let's look at the numbers printed on the board and this is a threshold that lets us see if we need to spend forums in order to place this die down the way it works is you look at the value on the board and the value of the diets placed if the die is less than that number then you have
to pay the difference in Florence so obviously the one for the yellow die you will never have to pay for ones in order to place here because no dice go less than one however if instead we had grabbed this purple too then we see that it is one below three so we'd have to pay the difference in Florence and discard this to the bank in order to use this die let's go back to our yellow four to show how a turn actually resolves we notice there are these three different icons in each of the top boxes along your player board when you play a die down you're then going to choose one of these three options now at first you'll see along the top that these are all the same with just slightly different colors these icons are associated with the 10 assignment tiles that are randomly distributed at the beginning of each round what these let you do is spend your female or male family members that you have in your personal Supply in order to do various things for instance right here you could spend three of your female family members in order to get three female or male members into your stock so you can essentially turn women into men this one would let you spend up to three of your mails in order to get two Florence for each one that you spend uh on over here we could spend two females into in order to marry off a third one so there are a variety of options that you can do the next potential action that you can do for placing this die is to hire a Helper and you'll notice again across all of these there is this helper spot but the colors are slightly different in the ring underneath now what this means is for a yellow dye action we can hire a teal Helper and if we look over here we see these three teal disks down here in order to actually hire the helper we need to spend foreigns equal to the number that is on the spot that we want
to cover up for instance if we wanted to put a helper right here that would cost us three of our Florence from our supply but what this now means is that every time we take any teal action whether it be the assignment action the helper action or the different actions along the bottom you will also get three victory points and let's show one other example let's say we had hired this helper on a previous round by this red action here then that means every time we take a yellow action for the rest of the game we're going to get one to six initiative based on the pit value of the yellow die that we activated so with this activation of a four we would get four initiative so as you can see by hiring this helper down here as well as these three which behave very similarly you're going to be incentivized to take higher pit value picks in order to get a bigger bang for that helper buck and lastly each of these columns has a third action option which is quite different from the others so let's go over those briefly now the yellow one is really simple you just get three fluorines and again you're gonna choose one of these three things when you place this die down not all of them but you'll always evaluate all helpers that are underneath that column for the red special action we'll get to and arrange a marriage with one of the female members of our family we do this by choosing one of the cities and then placing the woman in the lowest value slot in that given City now we have to spend four runs equal to the value of that slot but then we get victory points equal to twice the number of florins that we just spent as a dowry and lastly we grab the tile that is in the woman slot on this specific City and we're going to get to place this into our area this tile gets placed into the marriage row on the right hand side of your player board and this signifies your family joining in with this family that
has this coat of arms it's important to note you're never allowed to have two of a the same type of coat of arms in your given marriage row and you'll notice that down here this shows you can have one of each of the six coats so now we have the purple action which is simply to have Offspring what we're going to do is roll these white d6s equal to the number of um I guess matriarchs we have in the family at the beginning This Is Us right here and we have a wife but as the game goes on we might uh have more in our family because our sons get married so let's say we had three of these well then we would roll three of these Dice and then what you do is you look at the pit values on them and if it's a one two or three then you'll gain another woman in your family and if it's a four five or six you get a man so in this case we would actually generate Three Men and they'd simply be added into our supply before I show you this gray action let's look at the teal one this lets you bump up any of these four tracks up to four times and this process uses the mail Offspring in our extended family so the way this works is if you have nobody on the board at all you can spend a point to add one of them to either of these three tracks this one being nobility then we have a religious track and finally Warfare you could also spend these points for the teal action on your initiative track which is right here which I talked a little bit about earlier I could just spend all four points going one two three four and add nobody to these tracks if I wanted to or I could do one initiative track here I could add one person here and then add another person and jump them up twice because that's also a way to use four and we could also just add all four of our people directly
onto the track now the way these tracks work is the higher you go on these tracks you're going to start getting some benefits for instance if this guy right here goes one one two three four then you'll immediately get to Florence and if it ever makes it up to this spot you'll immediately get an extra initiative a more important thing is these little numbers that are along the side this shows you the level of skill I guess that this person has this being one two three three and four and this will come into play when I show you the last example so let's just pretend I did that and got to Florence finally let's cover this gray slot which involves sending a family member on a diplomatic Mission this action is quite similar to marriage except in this case we're taking one of our figures off of these tracks and we're going to add it to one of the Cities now the location of the figure is important because this one right here is a level two not quite level three and what that means is we could not put this figure down into the city because all of the ones or twos are filled and it didn't quite get to rank three it's not quite I don't know smart enough in the clergy so that does give us these two options over here if we went to this city we'd have to go to the lowest value or the city again to the lowest value and what happens once we go into one of these two cities is we look up here we see that we're not only going to take the tile that is associated with the right hand diplomacy side but we're also going to score victory points equal to the value of the spot that we pulled that person off of which was a four so this would be a four point grab we then sort the title into the correct row this was a clergy based diplomatic Mission so it goes up here and we're allowed to do this because we see the symbol on our player board now for everyone's marriage slot it's one of each but these top three spots are different for each of the player boards we're looking for different sets of these coat of arms and just like the
marriage slot you're not allowed to place a Crest over here that does not match one that's on your player board but you're still allowed to take the Diplomatic Mission you would just leave the title on the board if it didn't match up with what you were looking for at this point let's discuss how we actually get points out of these tiles now there are victory points on the tiles themselves however you get no points in a given row unless you have at least three tiles in that row now that is going to incentivize you to get the correct tiles but through various means you will be able to get these kind of neutral tiles that are just one point each on the back so that means at the end of the game right here we would get four points for this row here but if we never got any more marriages this two points would be lost we would not be able to score it because we don't have at least three tiles players will continue to take turns going around the table grabbing one die per turn until everybody passes we now look to the initiative track we see that the yellow player is going to score four victory points for getting this High the blue player will get two points and purple player will get none once we score those points we will modify the turn order to the new initiative track so yellow will actually go first blue will go second purple will go third and finally all these collapse down and we reset the initiative for the next turn and now players check to see if they get a reward at the end of their turn and this is based off of the number of Pips that they've taken throughout the turn we look up here and we see that the number is 13 and that means if you add up all the Pips on these Dice and you hit 13 or less in this case we have 13 exactly then we're going to get a reward we're either going to get three florins or we can take the reward associated with the tile that is associated with this current turn so the first turn of the game it would be this three Initiative for the next round uh in
subsequent rounds we'll flip these over so if we were on the fourth turn of the game we would be evaluating this one over here in addition to taking the money or the bonus tile you could also arrange a marriage with one of your sons this is how you get more of these white meeples here two roll my dice for your Offspring and as the game goes on you'll also get a dowry of multiple foreigns it's worth noting that in the sixth and seventh round of the game instead of getting more of these tokens you can instead spend five floors to get five extra points immediately and these two are randomly Associated tiles as are all of these but these are specific to getting you points based off of your placement on the cities on the board once Sevenfold turns have been played the game is over we'll then pull all of the people back from this track and you're gonna get victory points equal to half the value that they were at and then you add in all the points you got for these family seals down here put it onto the track Whoever has the most points is going to be the winner before going into the review I'd like to briefly point out these three variants that come officially in the game the first says open Gates and this allows you to activate diplomatic or marriage actions in cities that are completely full under the normal rules you can't do anything with the city once it's full but this lets you go there get the points for it even though you won't be able to get a tile the second variant actually says you play six turns instead of seven you just don't even do this first turn of the game so the game is an entire turn shorter and the last one is private messages which says whenever you activate one of these assignments you actually flip it over so that for the rest of that round no other players are going to be able to evaluate that specific assignment so let's begin the review of signorier by covering a couple positive points the
first of these relates to the dice pit mechanism whereby you sometimes want really high value dice because it's cheaper because you don't have to spend as much money to put them on your board as well as maybe you have some helpers down such that those higher numbers are going to make you do more stuff on the board like push your people up farther on those political tracks but on the reverse side you are always trying to get underneath the threshold of Pips so that you can get that bonus action so getting low value dice is also really important and I just love the decision that that gives you while you're playing the game I think it's important for a dice game to be good to make sure that all dice rolls can be good in different situations and I think this game does a good job of that because you will find yourself in a situation where you're trying to figure out do I want to just blow through that threshold and just not get that bonus action but do a whole bunch of other things like is it going to be worth it to me to do that or do I stay under the threshold but I'm going to have less money for the next turn there's a whole bunch of things you can think about based off of Just which die you pick I mean it's very simple take one die put it on your board each turn but that definitely uh differentiates out into a bunch of different options and just looking at the dice immediately you're not going to say oh that's a good or a bad role you're just going to say oh that's an interesting role positive number two relates to the balance between a slower engine building uh strategy which is like putting lots of helpers down on your sheet versus a fast Victory Point Cash Out engine where you're just pushing people up the political tracks and marrying people off as quickly as you can and not really focusing on getting those helpers down and I've noticed that the scores can be pretty comparable it's like on one they
shoot ahead and they just go with same speed really quickly and the other one ramps up and by the end of the game it seems like they're pretty comparable and I like seeing that kind of thing for me I really prefer engine based gameplay so when I played it I've usually spent a lot of effort putting tons of these helpers down so that on future actions I'm going to get to do even more stuff but I I played a game where I went heavy on that I had like five or six more helpers than my opponent who just went blitzing on just getting points as fast as they could and at the end of the game I think the difference in our points was less than 10 which is quite a bit considering the scores I think where in the 200s definitely in the high 100 so there's a lot of victory points in this game and I like seeing the balance between these two strategies you can take so now shift into a couple neutral points and the first of these relates once again to that helper board in front of you now I really love the idea behind this system where you can invest this turn into making a future action better with a bonus action and every time you hit that in the future you're going to get that bonus action and there's a great variety of them you could do extra marriage actions you could just get victory points uh depending on the pit value of the activation you can get a bunch of the political or military um advancements happening and these are all fun and they're interesting things you could do my problem is that it's the same exact set every time you play for every player around the table and maybe I've been a little spoiled with many games having asymmetry or modularity when it comes to this kind of thing but when I see that and I play the game at multiple times I I already feel like it's getting not necessarily stale but I
feel like I'm gonna do a similar thing every single time I play it if I am planning to win and that's because some of these just feel better than others especially early game rather than late game so I have a hard time seeing myself not just continuing to do pretty much the same pattern of helpers on that player sheet now if I'm doing a heavy player a heavy helper strategy I will obviously Branch out more into different of the options but if I'm trying to do a quick racing style strategy man I think I'm going to be hitting the same three or four every single game because they just feel really good and I wish something had been done to mix it up a little bit like with some modularity or with some asymmetry or something so it doesn't feel like I'm being presented with the same puzzle every single time I sit down and because I usually in those situations solve the puzzle in a very similar way each time and I want there to be more reason to break out and try different things than just doing it for novelty's sake my second neutral point relates to the official variants that come in the game now this is not new for this game many games have variants that you can play with that are printed like in the back of the rulebook this one has them printed on a separate piece of paper that was kind of on top of the stack of stuff when you first open up the game and they are pretty significant variants like one of them you just remove an entire turn from the game make it a six turn game instead of seven for another one you have an entire mechanism B uh the first come first serve like once somebody does it nobody else can get to it there's another one that says once a city fills up you can still put people in there to get points even though you don't get tokens and the vibe of these
variants is they feel like Band-Aids as opposed to actual variants that are going to make this one gameplay feel better than that gameplay it doesn't feel like it's helping replayability it feels like it's fixing issues that have cropped up in the game and from what I've seen it does seem like most people prefer to use most of these variants and uh when I've played it it seems like six turns is the writing of our turns as opposed to seven and it seems like yeah those cities can fill up you want an official situation where you could just pull your people out and get points for them like that shouldn't be a variant it feels odd like why wasn't this stuff caught in play testing and why didn't they just not make these variants just make these official and then maybe even have like a long game variant to do the extra turn or a mean game variant so that once the city's full you can't get into there anymore because it feels like those are much more restrictive and much more kind of like hardcore and not interesting honestly to me that just I don't understand that so I'm not going to point figures and say it wasn't developed enough I just don't get why these variants were not just straight up the main rules that are supposed to be in the game as it shipped let's now discuss a couple of negative points and the first of these is pretty simple analysis paralysis is a problem for me and some of the people I play with for this game now the idea of analysis paralysis is just that you have so many options so many things to think about that you freeze up and you don't make a decision or it just takes you way too long to make a decision and I've seen playing this game that especially once you get to like the mid and late
game things can really start to lock up because there are so many things to think about and I do enjoy having lots of things to think about and the things you're thinking about are quite interesting but it really can get to the point where you are doing all this math in your head for this dive versus this guy versus that die and what order should you do them and if you don't do them in this order and somebody takes that die well how's that going to affect your situation are you going to have enough money well let's see let's undo that and let's see if we do this and this oh but remember you're going to get money for this and that's another little and everybody's doing this but it seems like certain people are doing it more than others and even when when everybody is in an analysis paralysis situation it's going to make the game go pretty long it means that you're oftentimes thinking when other people are thinking which is not the worst thing in the world but this is this game feels longer than it should have been and I think a big part of that is because of just of all this little math that you have to constantly be doing and um it's really important to think about it though because I have found myself in situations in this game where I am one money shy of getting a whole bunch of points like I think I have a plan I'm doing it all out and I'm trying to make it all work and then something happens or I just made a tiny little math mistake on one money shy and now it all goes to pot I can't do any of that stuff and I honestly it feels kind of I feel kind of bummed in that situation so not only is there this analysis paralysis but even after doing all that and finally figuring out what you're going to do it's pretty common for me anyway to still do it somewhat wrong and not be entirely satisfied with the um the outcome and negative number two relates to the
aesthetic appeal of the game while you're playing it it's just a very Bland looking game that doesn't pop with any color it's got a bland map of Italy you have all these house crests which look kind of cool but again don't really pop off the board itself is not very inspiring to look at this is not going to be the kind of game where people walk by and are instantly intrigued by what you're doing based off of the table presence of it and I feel like these are problems like you want to be visually stimulated while you're being intellectually stimulated uh and this game is just not bringing that in it's like these uh political tracks are just kind of a basic grid with a couple little icons along the top there's so many spots where this game could have really tried to pull me in more and also from a thematic perspective it doesn't really help make me feel like I am a signorier I'm at the top head of this house um you know wheeling and dealing with other houses and doing all this stuff it really just feels like a math optimization game with these dices you're crunching all these numbers you don't feel and any political swings you don't feel any power shifts it's just it's just a bunch of addition on a bland mostly Brown map which is a issue for me I normally I'm okay with dry euros and Bland looking appearances but for some reason this one it just doesn't do it for me I found the replayability force ignorea to be below average for me and that is all about the variance of setup and how little variance there actually is each player board has a different set of house crests that you're trying to get on the right hand side but that
differing set does not really make one play feel different from another it just means that you and your opponents won't be buying directly as much for the same exact crests out on the Italy field so it won't be you're one person's gonna be over here one person will go over there kind of by definition because of our asymmetric matching sets but the helper uh set like all the options you can do to put your helpers down it's the same for every player and it's the same every time you play the game and that is a weakness I think in a replayability perspective of course if you really love the game and you love how all this stuff works and you don't mind being presented with pretty much the same exact puzzle every time you sit down then that's fine you're probably going to have a lot of legs with this game but for me I like more variants in setup and more things that push me in different strategies Beyond me just being bored with one strategy and wanting to try another so in all these respects I think signorier Falls a little short so let's discuss the player counts for signorier it is a two to four player game and I play the two and three player game and the reason I haven't played the four player game is because I don't think I want to uh it's just gonna be way too long like I already have analysis paralysis problems with the game at three players having a fourth player is not going to make the game particularly better I mean it's one more dive that's going to get rolled and so that's even more options for you to Crunch through when you're trying to figure out what you're going to do with your turn uh in addition to the fact that's one more turn one more player you're gonna have to wait for them to take their turn and it unlocks one city in the overall Italy map which doesn't really affect things at all in my opinion so I don't see why I would want
to play four player I'm sure it works I just think it's going to be far too long for what it is even I think three player is going to be best because you do want some variety of the dice that are rolled when the two player game I played it somewhat often we would roll doubles on the dice in those different sections so suddenly the decisions there aren't really there it's like if you want a purple die it's gonna be a three or a three on this turn and to certain degree that actually helped out with the analysis paralysis because it's one less thing to Crunch you're like okay well if I want that action it's gonna cost that much done but in the three player game having those three dice it's much less likely that You're Gonna Roll three of the same die and having options with the Pips on all those colors is a good thing so I think three is best two worked okay and four I haven't played it but I don't think I'd recommend it in conclusion I found signorier to be a satisfying gaming experience but I don't know how many more times I'm actually going to play it if at all I think one of my best friends summed it up well he said I'm really glad I played this game and I don't think I ever want to play it again and the reason for that was it's it's got great puzzles it's got great thinky things you're trying to figure out the Pips I love dice Bowl drafting games in general it's a great decisions to be made about which dice do you take now and which ones do you think you could wait on will other people take them or will I get to take it on next turn because it really is better for me to take that on the next turn after I do this that's great stuff and that is in this game but this game is so mathy with its different options and it has so many different options that the analysis paralysis really slows it down it kind of puts the brakes on excitement and fun all the while still providing a
satisfying intellectual experience and I think there's a lot of good stuff in this game I think the helper board is really great but from a modularity replayability perspective I need a little more than what this game has given me in order to keep playing it as the same game every single time you sit down like there are some games that I really like that have no modularity or variants but this one it just it felt a little bit too much like hard work it was a little bit too long and ultimately I might not play it again I am glad I've played it I'm glad I was able to introduce it to a couple of my friends I'm glad I'm able to make a video review for it and I think for many people they're going to love this game they're going to love the humongous tree of decisions that are there maybe um they suffer from analysis process less than I do or they tolerate it a lot better than I do so there is uh definitely probably a subset of people who are really going to love this game but for me I just liked it and that's not quite good enough enough if you'd like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel also you can directly support the channel at patreon.com John getsgames thanks for watching