Skip to main content
Loading video...

Detectives vs Criminals - Team Based Hidden Movement!

Transcript 17:39

Today we've got detectives and criminals right here at this very table. The criminals may be hiding. Uh in fact, Ryan is in fact Ryan was the criminal. We just played the criminals and I was the detectives. This is detectives versus criminals. This is from Damn Things Game Studio. Uh it is a hidden movement game with fairly significant twist compared to any that I've played. Definitely speaking. For one thing, this is a hidden movement game that's designed for two teams of two. So, it's a 2v2 hidden movement game. And I'm going to put this down, but I love that this newspaper is actually the functional map for the hidden movement players. And I say players because in this game, you've got a team, like we said, of two criminals that are moving around this map independently with their own little hidden movement guides sneaking around. I don't know that I have seen a hidden movement style game where there are two hidden movers. I don't know if you have, but tell me in the comments below because I'm actually curious if this is the first. But when you assign your teams, the two criminal players play by completely different rules than the detective players.

And in fact, they play on completely different sides. We're sitting here side by side. I'm the detective, he's the criminal. But when we play, you're going to play across the table from one another. And it should be noted too, you can play this one v one. There are some slightly different rules, but you're going to be controlling two sort of investigators and two criminals. And there are some adjustments to be made, but it can be played that way. But it is detectives versus criminals. And I think one of the first twists, I'd mentioned twists before that I think is significant here, other than the fact that you can play with four players, is the fact that you're not always hidden. And I know this probably has happened in other hidden movement games. You can be found. It has a significant impact on this one though because the goal of this game for the detectives isn't to just find the criminal.

Yeah, I think that's worth noting because that is also a first for me at least.

Yeah, you can't if if if I find them great. There are some benefits to that, but I don't win the game.

Sure.

You're going to actually kind of play your own game as the detectives, too. And that's one of the first things you kind of have to get into the mindset of here. You don't always want to just be, okay, I need to figure out where the criminals are, go there and find them. I did that in my game. I did that in our first turn. Uh, I was able to find Ryan, and it benefited me a little, but it, like I said, it didn't win the game. It allowed me to move my progress because I'm making progress just like Ryan is making progress as the criminals because the criminals are trying to find between three and five treasures depending on sort of whether you want to play the easy or the

introductory game or the long. We played the introductory game just to point that out which it's a goal of completing three of these u treasures, stealing them on the board or for the uh detectives completing these handcuffs. And you can kind of see this board, it's really kind of split down the middle. Everything on this side of the board is for the detective players and everything on this side of the board here is for the criminals. So, the criminals interact with this little area here where you're putting out some treasures that you're trying to steal and putting out some hidden information as far as where those treasures are on the board. Only the criminals have this information and it's written on your little notepad kind of telling you where you want to go on the board. Meanwhile, the detectives have this area here where you're trying to build out the segments of these handcuffs by finding clues, but also, you know, by exposing the criminals. So, so it does benefit you, but as you play the game, this thing is going to move in circles. Every time it passes, you're adding one link to these handcuffs. And if this is ever completed, that's how the detectives win. So, the criminals are trying to find five treasures before these handcuffs are complete. And the way this works, it's almost like a timer because as this is spinning around, it's ticking a clock because

honestly, the police will just win eventually if the criminals don't work to progress their goals because there's a whole like, you know, mechanic of these action cards that moves this and like there's things that the detectives are doing to move this. So, really like I think if you just stall at the game, the detectives will win.

Yeah. The overall structure of the game are the criminals are going to take their actions and you can take those amongst the criminals themselves and some thugs that they have. Then before the detectives go, you're going to flip over one of these event cards to see what happens. Usually it's going to have some sort of unique impact, but it's almost always going to move this along or have different varying progress for that and other things in the game. But like this card here says, it just moves one. For every clue token I have here, for every one of his criminals that are sort of exposed or on the run, it's going to move an extra space when it moves. So if he has one, two of his criminals out on the board and one of these clues, this actually moved it four, which is enough to get a full length.

A full rotation gives me a full length. So, I can play my game using my actions to put clues out on the map and then go to those clues just like he's putting treasures out on the map after he finds them and going to those treasures.

Yeah, it's an interesting kind of setup here where you're going to choose kind of these treasures that you want to have. And a lot of this game is going to revolve around this deck of cards, these DVC cards. They're multi-use cards, using them for a lot of things. One of the primary ways, at least the criminals are using these DVC cards, is to find these treasures. Each treasure is going to have a required amount of cards. Now, the goal is to secretly get to the city that the treasure is in and steal the treasure by turning in those cards. It seems simple enough. I'm taking actions to move. I'm writing down my move locate, you know, like a hidden movement game and I'm getting there. But as David or the detectives are starting to kind of investigate areas, they're trying to figure out maybe where you're going, it gets harder to steal these treasures if there are more police presence in that area. So if David has detectives in the area, he has these agents in the area, I start to have to discard more and more cards to a point where it becomes almost impossible to steal. So the benefit of like knowing where they're going, of piecing together the information, of following the trail is hopefully you can start to deduce what area of the board this treasure is in. Get all your guys over there. But meanwhile, you're doing that and I'm secretly sticking off to the other treasures.

Exactly.

So, you know, there's a lot of different ways you can kind of play the game. They even like give you some tips of like maybe one guy you just keep one criminal on the board, everyone sees him, they're all running over to find him, meanwhile the other one's sneaking. Like there's ways you can do it, I think, as the criminals to try to sneak in these like big plays underneath the eyes of the detective. But the detective starts out with a bigger presence on the board.

Yeah. And in fact, let's start there before we get on to sort of some of the actions you take. uh you're going to start the game by having the criminals are going to have one of the criminals hidden

and one of the criminals exposed. Now, they both start in the same location,

but from that point forward, you kind of have a sense on my turn as the detectives, okay, where they might be because he can move, but he can't move twice with any one of them. Yeah,

there's certain things you can do to kind of bend and break those rules, but I'm going to have a sense on my turn. Okay, he was there and now he could be in any one of these bigger casted nets that I might look at and go, okay, I could go here, investigate. There's some actions I can use to maybe investigate from a connected city. So, I can just check that city and then with my other investigator, go here and find out where he is, revealing him, that sort of thing. But revealing them is temporary because if he moves with one of them, even if they're revealed, they'll automatically hide when they move. So, they go back into hiding. My goal is to try to get them exposed when I can, but also put some of those clues out. He's going to be moving around on his turn. I'm going to be moving around my turn, but of course, he sees all of my movement. I have agents. I have my investigators. They're moving around.

He's got some of his hidden. His thugs will always be out there. And there are some interesting things in this game too that you can do to interact with uh more of the pieces than you can in a typical game. Like we said early, most of these games are I'm hidden. Find me.

Sure. Yeah.

This one is I'm hidden some of the time. I'm looking for these. You can find me, but you might not make the progress you need to win detectives. But you can go in, for instance, these thugs he can do a lot of stuff with, but I could go into those spaces and enact combat with those thugs, taking them maybe temporarily off of the board, things like that.

Yeah. And the same way with these agents and these detectives, like there's there's a lot going on as far as for a hidden movement game, I would say, because we talked about how the turn structure kind of works. On your turn, you get to do four different actions. They have to be different actions. So, like David said, I can't move twice. I can't steal twice. Uh, each criminal is going to get four actions. You know, it's a team. So you can kind of talk maybe a little bit, but like they're going to hear what you're talking about. And then you collaboratively like as a team get to control your agents and thugs. You can think of these as like I don't know henchmen or whatever. They're out there on the board. They have a limited pool of actions. Their whole goal is kind of just to mess up your opponent. Like you can move these thugs around to move these clue tokens and just keep pushing these clue tokens, which is like a big part of the game for the detectives to get those clue tokens.

Meanwhile, my thugs are like pushing them around. You're sending in the agents to deal with them, right?

Yeah. To be clear, those clue tokens, again, I want to stress this. Those are only to help me progress in my game. Those won't help me find Ryan. The only thing, in fact, the only piece of information that I can think of that really helps me find Ryan is just those movements. You know, I know if I know where he was at one point, I can kind of get some information about like, okay, he's taken a full turn. Here's a limited number of places some of his criminals could be or either one of his two. I can actually put some of these tokens out on the board. I've got three different types of tokens here. A two-sided question mark, an exclamation mark for like, oh, that's the last place I knew where I saw him. And these different roads and little lines are going to have different amounts of movement. So, if I knew he was in Belgrade, this red line is kind of like the railway. You can move on that. And if you do, you can move up to three of those segments. On these road type ones, the tan ones, you can move up to two on a move action. But these dotted lines, they take one full movement. Like, so if you're going to move from here to here, that's all you can do. You can't go one, two, or anything like that. So the problem for the detectives is if he's in a location that has all sorts of those extended from it,

you are going to have a lot of things to consider. Now, the other thing at the beginning of the game you need to know is he can't place his criminals within three or four spaces.

I have to be at least four spaces away from the

Yeah, the treasures have to be at least four spaces away from where he begins. So, if I knew he started in Bgrade, I knew there's a fairly actually fairly significant space down here where I know the treasures aren't. So, at the beginning of the game, I kind of knew they may be up here, they may be over here or down here. And sure enough, they were.

Yeah. Yeah. And so you kind of have to decide like knowing that information, you can decide if you want to chase me down. You can decide if you want to go for those clues. And I think the detectives having a bigger majority of figures on the board, they have more agents that they can bring out across the course of the game. Like maybe it's to like spread a net and then, you know, maybe close that net down or completely ignore the people and just go for the clues instead. Right. And the net itself makes it very problematic for the criminals because even if I'm not zeroing in on him, if I have a big net cast, when he gets those treasures, he'd mentioned earlier some of them take a different numbers of cards of different colors, they take even more cards.

Yeah, exactly. So, you don't need to ever know exactly where these are like where these are, but if you can kind of figure out where people are going, like at one point David knew that I was in Paris and it's like, well, which way did I go from Paris?

I figured it could be here or here,

right? and you you move the guys in there and hopefully you guessed right. But again, if you don't, it's not the end of the world because you're still progressing towards your victory condition. Right.

Right.

Either way you do things. So, we'll talk a little bit. If you couldn't tell, we've already talked about a lot of the different actions you're doing on your turn. And these are slightly asymmetric. Like the criminals are going to have actions that the detectives don't. Like stealing the treasures is something that just I can do. But things like moving, fighting, interacting and playing these DVC cards, which are something that you can draw into your hand. And then every color kind of does something a little different. It gives you some bonus movement. It gives the detectives a bonus investigate. It lets me kind of push things around this map.

This is actually a big part of the game is collecting these cards. And one of the things that like your thugs or agents can do, like your henchmen can do, is a action called planning that actually lets you take these cards and place them off to the side of the board. And then on your turn when you go to draw cards, you can always draw from the top of the deck, but you have kind of this offering of cards that you can draw from instead. It just gives you a little bit more flexibility because like I said, the detectives can use those cards to do their abilities. But I, as the criminal, have to have those cards to go for some of these treasures. And that information is face up. So if David sees that I'm getting like some purples or some greens, maybe he knows, well, I'm, you know, set to steal this. Whether you know where it is or not, it's a different question. But it's like, you know, you can kind of see if they're preparing to steal something. And that's a decision again that falls on these criminals because every time you steal something, you progress one step closer.

You have to steal five of those treasures. But every time you do, you have to pop up on the map and show them where you are. If you pop on the map, it moves this thing in extra space, right? So, and since you can only do some of these actions once per turn, do I move in and steal? And knowing I can't move out, or do I move in, take a turn, let this move a little farther and then steal next turn. It's a it's a race and you have to decide, you know, how to make those calls.

Yeah, there is some pacing involved particularly for the criminals. The detectives not so much like like you said earlier,

the detectives can do the waiting game. You know, it's up to the criminals to get their treasures before the time runs out. And the time is ticking, which is allowing basically the detectives to progress with their game. Yeah. some of the actions you can take. Ryan already talked about them. One of the interesting things is all of those different ways you can use these cards. Each the asymmetry of some of the things you can do there. Some of them are asymmetric, some of them are not, but some of these cards when you play them allow you to do some things like just move to an adjacent city in addition to the normal movement that you might take on your turn as well. Also, there's these special cards that come into play. Each the detectives and the criminals have a deck of special cards. This is a very small deck, but there's going to be some things that happen that allow you to maybe draw the top card of that deck.

And that's going to be something you have that you can use. That's a very specific and unique thing that you can do to

powerful. Yeah. Very powerful.

Certainly sort of turning the tide sort of level cards.

Yeah. And the other thing that makes these factions asymmetric is the powers of your actual characters. And this is interesting too. At least in the starter game, these characters can be on either side. So, at the start of the game, you choose your characters, and each player is going to have a character, and that character is a criminal if you're a criminal, or they're a detective if you're a detective. And those powers are designed such that they're usable by any side. Now, they've hinted in the rule book that there might be some characters released that can only be on one side of the other.

Yeah, I would think so. They have both icons on the bottom.

Yeah. And they say

kind of suggest that there even directly say like if it doesn't have that symbol, you can't use it. But the four characters we had could be used on either side. and they give you some special actions in addition to the actions you already have. Not to mention that our thugs and agents already have different actions, which makes sense. I mean, I don't have a reason to like investigate. I'm not trying to find anybody, right? So, the way these actions are designed to kind of help you do the specific thing you're good at. We've seen that in hidden movement style games before, but this is the first one I've seen. Well, we talked about the two different people moving around. Yeah. Yeah,

but also again I just want to stress how interesting it is to me that you you don't have to make finding it a priority. And in fact, I can lead you on a wild goose chase if I think you're spending too much time trying to find me,

right? You could you could run around like that. I and I'll stress it again further. If you're playing the detectives in this game, you really need to erase it out of your head that okay, where is he? We got to find the criminals.

You can find the criminals. And like I said, it does benefit you a little, but you really want to focus on the different things that this game gives you to do on the detective front to try to win the game because it's not just about finding them.

Yeah. So, you're doing your actions. You're doing your four actions on your turn. The criminals are doing their actions. The detectives are doing their actions. What's what's kind of neat here, too, is that you can do them in any order. Like, I can take my four actions, then my teammate can. Then, we can decide that we move our thugs. Or we can move our thugs first and then go in any order. You kind of go in the order that's going to work better for you. I'll do my actions. David will draw an event card, do his actions, and we really just do that back and forth until one of those in-game conditions is met. Either the criminals have found all five treasures. You can have two out that you can find. As soon as you find one, you replace it. So eventually, you can find all five or the detective completes all of that, the the full set of cups. And that's really that's those are your two things you're trying to do. Yeah, it really is kind of I think a unique twist on the hidden movement game for all the reasons we've just said. But if you have any questions at all about it, please make them in the comments below. We'll get down there and answer whatever we possibly can. Until next time, make sure everyone has fun at the table and we'll see you then.

Progress saved