Chiseled Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about chiseled which is a one to four player card game that takes about 30 minutes to play this one was released in 2020 after a successful kickstarter campaign now the idea of this game is that we are sculptors trying to make the perfect statue for the critics um and as you can see from the kind of tag line here it says a deck sculpting card game this is because it almost works in an opposite way to a deck builder where you would normally start with a basic hand of cards and build up to a stronger and stronger stronger deck this one everybody starts with an identical deck of cards like so made up of different um cards such as these arms here you've got these um torsos you've got heads and you've also got a load of these uh these trash cars that look like this which are going to be worth negative points at the end of the game and the idea is that we're going to try to be using all these different tools to get rid of all the fat from our deck to get the perfect statue and the way you determine to get a perfect statue is based on this criteria here so at the beginning of the game you're going to start with nine of nine torsos nine arms and nine heads and you're trying to get the perfect number of them left in your deck at the end of the game so for example to get the perfect amount of points for the torsos you need to make sure that you have four in your trash uh to get the perfect amount of arms you need to have seven in your trash and to get the perfect amount of heads you are going to have to keep them all basically so that's going to be your optimal amount of points
you've also got these critics that are going to be um give you end game bonuses based on different things say for example this one here gives you an extra four points if your final trash pile contains five or more black cards because as you can see here not only are they different body parts depicted on the cards you've also got different colors you've got gold black and you also have silver cards as well this one here for example you know if your trash pile contains more silver cards than black cards and this one here says if your trash bag has more black cards than gold cards so that gives you a bit of an incentive what to work towards as well as trying to get the most points based on these um based on these numbers here so how does the game actually play out so first off all you're going to do is um first off if these tools have been used you're going to flip them all face up but that's not normally going to be the case but what you're going to do from there on is you're going to pick one of these different craftsman tools to use in order to manipulate your deck um something i should say as well you see you're always going to have a hand of three cards for example here and if you ever have three or more body parts without this trash you are going to move your little score tracker down here and when that gets right to the end that's going to trigger the end of the game for all the players so that's something that's something you're going to have to bear in mind and the pacing of this game does change from game to game so once you've got your hand of cards you're going to select which one of these tools you're going to use and as you can see they all do lots of different things and for example here this one lets you trash all the cards from your hand which is going to be a good thing
if you have a handful of these um these kind of rubble cards because as you can see they're gonna be worth negative three points for each one of those cards i have in my hand at the end of the game so you want to make sure you get rid of as many them of them as you can they all do different things here such as reveal the top two cards of your deck of your draw pile a trash one of them and discard the other because not only are you going to have a trashing pile which means that they're out of your deck for good you're going to have a discarding power which is kind of where you want to keep the body parts that you want to keep for your final statue now this one here you know this heavy sled lets you trash two cards from your hand and trash the top card from your from anyone's draw pile so that could only be your part draw power but you can use somebody else's as well if you know they've manipulated their deck to have their stat maybe their heads on the top of their deck or something and basically they'll all let you do different things to either look at cards trash cards save cards in your discard pile maybe manipulate your deck a bit and line these moves up so that you um so that they can kind of work together but once you use one of these objectives or one of these um tools they're going to be flipped face down meaning that nobody else can use that until they've all been used and once they've all been used they'll all flip back face up you'll discard any cards you've got left in your hand into your discard pile um and draw back up a new hand to a new hand of three and that's basically going to be how the game plays out until as i said this um checking card goes all the way down to zero where you'll count up all the cards you've got left in your hand and score points based on these numbers
here so that's going to be how the game is going to play out so as you can see the the tools here do have a bit of manipulation and give you a bit of autonomy about what you have to do but of course you are always subject to what is available there um you know people are going to be taking probably the ones that you want before you do um meaning that sometimes you are backed into a bit of a corner and are forced to take cards or use cards that you don't want to take which can potentially cause you problems by maybe getting rid of pieces that you don't want to get rid of etc so it is a very tactical game where you want to react with your current deck and your current hand in order to um you know keep as many points prevalent as you can um so yeah that it's a very it's a very tactical and reactionary game um but of course you can make decisions based on what you think other players will want you know if you know well you won't know personally or exactly if a player has a handful of trash cards but you know if you want to take a certain tool to stop them doing that meaning that they might have to put more of their trash cards into the discard pile which can prevent them scoring lots of points at the end of the game um the so yeah decision wise is it's not the the deepest of games you know it's a very a very a simple game of trying to balance and keep the you know spin the plates and try not to um not to get rid of too many cards you want to get rid of but while getting rid of the the useless cards and again very very much a game of striking the balance and as you can see here the pacing of these points is quite different whereas the the torsos
start off with giving you no points but as you trash them it goes up but then it goes back down again so it's very much a delicate balance of those ones the hands you know fluctuating points scoring zero and then three and then zero then six so again you want to be very careful and precise about what you have at the at the end of the game whereas the heads are pretty simple where you don't want to get rid of any of them because if you do then you're automatically going to be losing points from rounds around so yeah there is um there is a delicate balance in terms of the decisions but you are subject to what is available at all times and of course you're trying to consider the end game bonuses as well um it's a relatively quick game you know only takes you know 20 30 minutes to play so it's not a game that bogs down too much in terms of its downtime or anything like that the turns tick by quickly and there isn't it isn't a game out stays as welcome it's relatively quick um the mechanically i do really love the concept of deck deconstruction i think it's very much an under used an under explored mechanism which i think there's a lot of potential for everybody loves the idea of deck building but the fact that everybody starts with the same thing in this game and has to work towards a better deck by shedding cards rather than gaining cards i think it's a really novel idea and something i'd like to see more this is a relatively simple example of that and i'd probably like to see something a bit more involved but i still um give it praise for giving that kind of genre a go um replayability there is um a lot of tools here as you can see not all of these are used in
every game i think there's only seven cards used in a one two or three player game and in a four player game use nine but there are lots of different things here so you've got variable games or variable things you can do from game to game all the critics are different as well you know you've got lots of different ones to give you lots of um end game things to work towards the player interaction really does lie with um snatching the tools before the other players grab them so it is very much passive um player interaction but some of the cards do um you know throw a bit of a spanner in the works for your opponents um you know by choosing opponents to do certain things or targeting opponents but it's very subtle and there isn't really much take that or anything like that um aesthetically i don't think it's the best looking game i think it's a unique idea and theme um you know the cards look okay they've got this very much almost computerized graphic look um and i do like this kind of marble texture the tools themselves some of them are a bit pixelated and don't look that um you know that high quality or resolution and the artwork of the characters is a bit of a disconnect as well because some of them look really modern some of them look a bit dated some of them are a bit of a bit futuristic so i think it struggles with a bit of what what it's trying to go for in terms of its overall aesthetic because there is a bit of a jarring disconnect between between all the different art types but the components themselves are of a good quality you know the cardstock is decent um you know all the actual cards are well explained and what they do
and the boards again they're quite a good reference tool in order to hold all the information you need them to and also these little round um these little um round trackers are good as well because they explain all the core um stages in the game so no real um no real issue with the components themselves but the artwork could have been better um the theme i think is really novel i know i love this idea of having to um build statues i think it's a different approach and i do like you know fresh ideas um so yeah i can't really complain about that i think there's a bit of another bit of a thematic disconnect here in terms of what tools you want because why would you want a statue to have uh five torsos and three hands and um you know and nine heads so it doesn't really quite make sense that way but um you know that's being a bit nitpicky um setup and tear down time is no issue either you know just set up the cars give each player a deck which is quite nice because everyone's got the same deck um and just set up a couple of these um these critics so yeah no complaints in terms of the setup time and the sense of progression is quite interesting because of course you are constantly shedding cards trying to keep the best cards in your hand or at least in your discard pile so there is this tension of just you know striking that balance just right and um of course if you start shedding um you know your your torsos early you're not giving yourself much leeway of making mistakes um because you um you know as soon as you go past that threshold you're going to start losing points so the pacing is quite interesting uh
the scalability is fine i mean there's no real issue here the turns are quite quick so you're not really bogged down by other players turns um and again it works fine at all player accounts i would say i haven't played the solo mode of this one so i can't really comment on that one but i imagine it would work quite well um and of course comparison wise um i haven't ever played another deck deconstruction game but um you know it's certainly an idea that i'd like to explore more um so yeah i'd only be able to compare this one to uh deck builders rather than other deck deconstruction games but overall um i thought this game um was a bit of a hit animus for me um again i like the fresh idea here i love the that i've got no other game in the collection that does this kind of thing you know starting with a deck of cards and shedding and shedding trying to get the perfect balance um but uh there are a few issues i have with it um not only because it's it's relatively light in itself i first off i find that these critics um don't offer enough autonomy and what you're going to going to go towards so i really find that if you are trying to go for these or or you get points from these critics at the end of the game it's very much going to be coincidental you know you don't really find yourself working towards them it's just um you might just get it or you might not you know for example you know you get plus four if your trash pile contains five or more um black cards you know you might just get lucky and get that you're never
gonna focus on it um and same with these ones as well you know if your trash pile contains more silver than black it just it just might happen and of course these are actually contradicting with each other as well so i do find that that is just one of the things either will work out or it won't and um that's just going to be how it works out rather than working towards it additionally i would have loved to have seen a better mechanism in terms of using these actual abilities of course this is a communal kind of bunch of cards where whenever someone's taking things they're flipping them over making your options smaller and smaller as the game goes on um and when they're all used they'll flip face up but i would have really loved to have seen a system where you could actually pick and choose which card you use maybe with a personal set of action cards um so you can really line up your moves and manipulate your deck and then use the trash card and know with more precision what you're going to get rid of now i understand that's part of the fun of the game you know when you end up trashing cars from the top of your deck and you're getting rid of all your heads and things but i think in terms of longevity and for more of a gamers game it would have been nicer to have seen as i said a more maybe a more interesting hand management system where you could use these um cards in a more precise and um interesting way maybe something like a concordia you know when you play your cards and you can use another action card to pick them all back up or something that would have been really nice to have seen but i understand it might have changed the whole scope of the game from a a simple filler game to maybe a more
involved game maybe more of a personal tasting there but um yeah despite that i don't dislike the game at the same time i don't love it either it just is what it is really um as i said earlier i would i really am looking forward to seeing a um a great deck deconstruction game because i think it's a real untapped market and i don't think um chiseled is going to be the game that um you know paves the way of being a great uh deck deconstruction game but nonetheless i still um i still applaud uh the the idea and i applaud taking a fresh approach to a card game but yeah if this appeals to you um give it give it a go because it's certainly not a bad game uh that is chiseled by uh copperfrog games so if you have enjoyed this review please hit like and subscribe my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye