Skip to main content
Loading video...

Plastic Versus Metal Miniatures

Transcript 9:34

In this video, I'm going to explain the differences between plastic models and metal ones. So, I get people that ask me all the time, well, what's the difference between plastic models and metal models? What which one's better? Which one, you know, if if if a company makes models that are out of both, which one should I pick? You know, I mean, how's that work? And it's really kind of a personal preference, as are most things in life. There are some pretty fundamental differences between uh the two types of models. As far as detail is concerned at this point in time, there's pretty much no difference. It used to be back in the day that when plastic models first came out, the molding process was pretty janky. And so plastic models had a pretty soft detail, you know, and just didn't have real nice sharp uh detail.

So people preferred metal models and didn't really like the plastic ones. But now at this point, the technology's gotten to the point where really, you know, there's no big difference between the two in detail. However, if you like to convert models, and by convert models, I mean take a model the way it's supposed to be built and modify it to make it be built a different way, changing leg positions a lot, um swapping out weapons, getting rid of, you know, the head and putting a different one on, that kind of stuff. Plastic's a lot easier. And the reason is is because it's just so much easier to take a clippers to a plastic model and just cut off the parts you don't want than it is with a metal model. Metal models are difficult sometimes to convert because there's a lot of filing and sanding and all kinds of stuff. And getting bigger, thicker chunks off of the model are just it's just very difficult. You end up having to use maybe a jeweler's saw or something like that. And with plastic, the clippers that I use to clip my models off of um the sprew, that's normally the mo the the the main tool I use if I'm converting a plastic model. Gluing the models is very different between plastic and metal. With plastic, many of the glues that we use in the plastic are actually designed to just slightly melt the uh the plastic where they touch, specifically with plastic cement. But even with CA glue, there's just a little bit of that going on. So, they're really more actually kind of melting the plastic and kind of sticking it together. Whereas with metal, it's very non-porous. The glue itself is having almost no effect on the actual metal itself. So, you have to really scrape up the two surfaces like with your hobby

knife, so that they've got a little bit of kind of purchase when they glue together. And more often than not, if it's a bigger, heavier model, um if it's an arm on a war jack for War Machine or Hordes or something like that, you're probably going to have to pin it. Pinning is when you you drill a hole on one side where the two parts are going to go together and then you have to try to drill another hole exactly in the same spot on the other side and then actually put a piece of wire or you know clip a piece of um thicker like paper clip something like that and put it in there as an added kind of connector between the two pieces because again of the weight of a metal model that arm that's being held up with the big club is just it's putting a lot of stress on this joint where it's being glued to the torso and because of that you you you can easily knock limbs off and it happens quite frequently. So you need to pin specifically with bigger heavier models. You just have to pin and probably want to use epoxy as opposed to your normal CA glue or um you obviously don't use plastic cement.

Now of course there's the weight as well. Some people prefer the heavier model. They just like the feel of it when they're moving it around on the table. Some people have no real interest in having a a heavy model and they are fine with having a lighter model. The differences also in that situation are that a heavier model is a little bit more likely to chip because of the inertia. Like if you knock it over, a very very light plastic model doesn't have a lot of inertia behind it when it hits the surface that it hits and possibly chips off some paint. But a metal model, yeah, you're going to have some inertia and you're going to probably get a little bit of a paint chipping problem going on, especially if you drop it on the floor. A plastic model dropped onto a non-carpeted floor, eh, you might pop off an arm if you catch it just right, but you're probably not going to chip too much paint. But a metal model, yeah, I've done that before. A lot of paint, a lot of paint can come off in one single drop. One of the great benefits of metal models is they're much easier to strip paint off of. If you buy some used models, some propainted models uh on eBay and you want to strip all that prop paint off of that model, it's much easier to do with metal models because you can really throw some, for lack of a better word, nasty chemicals onto those models and you're not going to melt the metal.

You're not going to melt the the the the material that makes up the model. You have to be much more careful when you are finding a fluid to strip plastic models with. And god forbid that you use resin models. Resin is kind of a form of plastic, but it's not quite the same stuff, but it is even more delicate as far as stripping is concerned. So, with metal models, you can throw um liquid uh you know uh fingernail polish remover directly in there, which is basically acetone, and you can take that stuff off. If you do that to plastic, you're going to have a pile of mush when you're done. So, that's a real benefit for metal models. One of the last things I'm going to talk about is cost. Generally, there's not a huge difference in cost. The new um line of Reaper Bones miniatures that Reaper puts out, they're very cheap because they're plastic, but it's because they're a very cheap bendy plastic. There's lots of different gauges of plastic, uh, you know, out there, toughnesses and and and flexibilities and such. So, the majority of the models that you're going to buy that are made out of injection molded plastic these days are a harder plastic, so they don't bend very easily, but that's also a benefit. Sometimes it's like a bummer if they don't bend, but on the other hand, the sword that they're holding is probably going to stay pretty straight. Whereas most Reaper bones, if you look at them in the package, they're already kind of pre-bent, so you have to be a little careful with that sometimes.

But the very inexpensive bendy plastics like that are a good deal pler than metal or even regular hard plastic. Regular hard plastic and metal are generally about the same cost. It's just that bigger companies can make hard plastic models a little bit cheaper. And the reason is is because the mold for a hard plastic model is very expensive to produce. Anywhere from $5 to $50,000 American to make a good injection mold. They're made out of steel. Okay. So, um, the trick is is that it's very expensive upfront, but then putting the plastic and injecting the plastic in there is relatively inexpensive. And because that model is so strong or that mold is so strong, you're going to be able to crank those models out for years and years and years and years to come without having to make a new mold. On the other hand, metal uses almost like a rubbery kind of material for the mold, which doesn't last nearly as long. It's very cheap to produce if you're making low numbers. If you're an indie game company or something like that, most of them are going to be making their stuff out of metal because they can crank out lower numbers more effectively, more cheaply.

And if they have to make a new mold, it's not that big of a deal. Big companies like Games Workshop and a lot of the other companies that are moving in that direction, like Weird Games, they're they've pretty much all moved to hard plastic. Um, you're starting to see it now also with, you know, uh, War Machine and Hordes. They're starting to move to hard plastics. So they're doing this because they've got the money to put it up front, but then the per unit cost is much much cheaper. Once you kind of spread it all out, it sort of comes to the same. But for a small company, let's say, you know, somebody who's an independent, they're working predominantly in metals because they don't they're not making more than maybe a couple hundred or maybe a thousand of a specific model as opposed to thousands and thousands of a big company. So for us as the you know person buying the models there's not a huge difference in cost but um you know it depends on the size of the company and kind of like that but then when you go to Reaper Bones or you know god forbid something like her clicks or things like that which are very bendy that plastic is a good deal cheaper. So really the differences between metal and plastic they all kind of come down to to to preference to individual preference. I myself prefer plastics because I find them easier to build and easier to convert and do things like that, but yet I've got metal models on my paint uh desk right now. So, you know, it depends on the size of the company. It depends on the how many models they're making.

But as far as the final product, detail versus detail, they're basically identical. So, let me know what you think, what your preference is down in the uh comments below. If you've got any tips for working with maybe metal models to make them a little bit easier to glue together, let us know. If you've got some things about, well, you know, but maybe you didn't say this about plastics because plastics can really beat this kind of problem, let us know. I always like to kind of keep an open channel and and and hear from the audience. And I hope that you guys read the comments and then also learn as well. But yeah, either way, you're going to get a good final product. It's just sort of uh depends on the path you take to get there.

Progress saved