Skip to main content
Loading video...

Interview: David Thompson on Pavlov's House and Other Valiant Defenses

Transcript 23:27

hey gamers this is Liz Davison for beyond solitaire and I'm so excited to bring you an interview with David Thompson designer of Pavlov's house how are you doing David I'm good how are you I am alright so for those who've not played Travis house you want to introduce the game really quickly for us yeah sure so like you said it's it's obviously a solitaire game right so in this case it's it's one two three players but really it's designed primarily a solitaire or co-op Pavlov's house was the name of a location in Stalingrad so it takes place during the Battle of Stalingrad World War two and as the solitaire or co-op players you take the role of the Soviet soldiers who defended this single apartment building against German attack for a couple of months that's the goal of the game is to hold out for a couple of months against constant attack yes this game yep so do you solo give yourself yeah so I actually don't do a whole lot of gaming at all and the reason is because I'm either at work doing dad duty or designing right so almost almost most of my gaming and especially most of my solo gaming is design work and then what I am doing any other gaming it's usually with my kids so but I do I mean I do some for sure right mostly lighter stuff but but like space core which just came out recently is fantastic and I've been soloing that so there are exceptions but yeah games you

want to plug since we're here oh goodness um let's see what else would I say I mean just simple stuff like there's a game called airborne commander which is great super light card game and it's like classics like Friday and stuff are just awesome right like something you could just grab at lunch or something to pull off yeah first published war game yep that's right you've post a number of games in other territories what has led you to war gaming recently yeah that's a good question so I started designing games seriously about five years ago and around the same time I moved to England and so when I moved to England one of the first things I did was take a trip to Normandy right so it was around this time I'd started flirting with a different a different design for games coming out soon but that really like I mean I went from like zero to 60 with were just like military history overnight and so during that period I started researching different things and I slowly one thing led to another and I started really hanging out in the war game forums on BoardGameGeek which led me to a design competition which is where I designed Casa later yes that's right so I backed it I'm excited to get it but so basically you discovered a

historical passion and that passion has led you that's right exactly that is really interesting it okay so you did a lot of research from Pavlov's house so much so that you actually wrote a companion book for it did you expect your research of this game to get that intense No so it's here so here's the thing so I I did Casa later first which was a much more straight for from a research perspective and when I was done with that I asked onboarding via I was like hey what should I do next and a lot of people gave me ideas and one of those was Pablo's house and so I started researching but what I found was there so most of what was known about Paula's house came from either of the German account which obviously is very one-sided or Soviet propaganda and so what you have is like this actual story that's not really told almost anywhere and I just thought it was really cool story and so much of the game was based on that that I started keeping design notes and then that turned into the the history right and I thought was important to tell the story for players so they really understand what's going on in the game so if I'm really interesting that you bring this up so when my favorite parts of your companion book is the part you're talking about trying to separate reality from do you actually feel that you designed a game that sort of offers your own perspective on history yeah it's interesting so what I tried to do and hopefully I was able to accomplish this is you know there's some things like who

actually was even in charge of the house right so if you look at the game it offers you the ability to kind of play you you will definitely be able to recreate history regardless of how it was actually historical because I provide all of those different opportunities and so I try to present hopefully the most objective view possible based on as many primary sources and then just leave it up the players hey you know who do you want to let lead the defense interesting so in terms of people being in the house I noticed so you made some comments that indicated that some people had actually been kind of almost erased from the history of the house including for example the forward observers who were coordinating with artillery across the river so how did you end up kind of discovering that they were there what kind of lead to your inclusion of less celebrated people in your game yeah so that's a good question so fortunately after the end of the Cold War Russia or Russia opened up its a lot of its universities etc to the Western world for the first time and so we were able to access a lot of some original material that he hadn't been able to use in the past and during that same time period a couple of authors did some interviews with people who are actually there to include Ford observers who are actually in the house and it what actually was was came to be revealed was

that calling an artillery strikes against the attackers was actually a very important part of the defense but that didn't fit the propaganda right because the Soviet propaganda was do you know if she sees riflemen that held off by themselves with no help and that's just totally not the case you know they were resupplied there were all sorts Hillary helped all sorts of things that were going on that'll facilitated them holding out or whatever is propagandistic Li like a bowl but it's not realistic exactly right that's right so have you had anyone challenge your perspective on Pavlov's house it has anybody played your game and felt that you didn't represent history well or like wanted to challenge your viewpoint no no not at all and if they did you know I would not purport to be a you know a scholar right so what I would say is hey you're let's just take a look at the sources and see you know and well we'll see what happens but I certainly wouldn't say that it is the truth right it is it is a what seems to be correct based on a variety of sources you know I like a game telling a version right argue about history through making right yeah absolutely so I actually looked do you Russian I don't I don't read so I can kind of read

it a little bit I certainly don't speak it at all there was a lot of machine translation and there was a lot of asking calling in friends you know it's like own a friend hey can you can you help me out so yeah because you know there were a couple of sources that were by people who were in the house at the time and that's I thought that was important to get those firsthand accounts yeah so what is the most interesting thing that you learned in the game oh that's a good question that the defense of the house actually doesn't end when the game ends or when the Soviet said it did so what actually happens is all the defenders are ordered to go storm a different building and they all go out and they mostly get wiped out and that's what actually ends the propaganda end of Paula's house defense and that's what ends the game but in reality they regrouped Pablo himself was injured lots of guys were injured and killed and that the defense of the house continued on until the Soviets fought back and took Stalingrad that's really interesting so the storm groups that you can play us throughout the game where do those all represent actual events or just sort of potential events that might have happened as people install and grad we're fighting over choice territory within the city yeah so those were all actual buildings that were taken or

attempted by the Soviets they were not all buildings that were taken by the defenders of Paula's house necessarily so if you go and you look at the in the very back of the book I have like all the different units that participated to the defense and some of those were only is sort of tangentially related those units were the ones involved with all the storm group assaults and so you know that that is a debt right there is probably the biggest stretch of the game as far as historicity is the the defenders of Paula's house being involved with all the storm group assaults interesting special is a lot of the tokens for soldiers who are in the house have actual images right but they're pictures of some people were those straight forward in my image identifications or it was actually kind of hard sometimes to tell who's who or find pictures of various soldiers most of them were easy there were a couple that were actually mislabeled and it took a lot of reconciliation to figure out who was actually who look but I would say probably 80% of them were pretty straightforward you know single source and a couple of different sources validated it but but yeah there were a couple of people that were really difficult to try to get at so for you is doing a historical research part of the pleasure of designing a game like this yeah for sure absolutely yeah I didn't realize it would be right like

it like it when it began as a means to an end like hey I don't and here's the truth of it all you know you don't really want to design a war game for war gamers because they are gonna almost certainly know it better than you do the material so I'm terrified of getting it wrong so it's really like oh I better do a really good job researching it so I don't get called out but that turned into just really loving it loving the process that's fantastic okay so the other thing is interesting at Pamela's house and speaking of historical research is that it's not ended up as the first in a valiant defense series of games so do you want about what that series is meant to communicate and embody as experience for players yep absolutely so I mean it is absolutely designed to to demonstrate and sort of the courage of like the last stand or these you know against all odds type and the first design in the series was actually Casa litter but the first published was Pablo's house which is kind of funny how it worked out that way so what in the series you know there I'm not necessarily constrained by time period or whatever but it's always going to be about sort of a small group of people probably holding out against a much larger force against you know I'd said are not in their favor so what has attracted you to that style of battle as something to be in a game I think you know I think that I really enjoy like the human story right the the size and

so like you mentioned the counters it's important for me to be able to relate to as close to an individual level with each of the defenders as possible so in the case of Pablo's house or Casa later or the the next game that I'm working on you know down to its individual counters and understanding those stories and how each defender contributed so do you feel like researching the story if castles more straightforward researching Pamela's house yes absolutely and thankfully it was the first one right so because there's one primary source in this case real there's one book that kind of tell us the story and that's you know that's both a pro and a con right because I'm largely limited to one author's view of the story and there's tons of I did go and find some original articles at the time and some some other sources but it's it's probably 90% of the back story the game came from one book in this case interesting so pebbles house also represented a big leap for you in terms of the kind of legwork that you're doing yourself as part of game development yeah absolutely yeah yeah so very different very different experience because that the partnership I have with DB G is unlike any other game that I've done right so I did the design the development all the art so everything basically and then DB g is doing all the publishing and of course the customer service and stuff which is a very different relationship that I have with any other publisher that's interesting okay so the next game in the series

called soldiers uniforms yeah so kind of in there what I what I mean by that is soldiers so when I first started working on the series it wasn't a series and Pablo's house was with DB G and soldiers and postman his uniform had already been signed by phalanx so it uses the same system it's very similar but it technically won't be part of the same system because it won't be published by DB g that's right yeah so it was with victory point games for a few years and it just it wasn't a once it expired the contract that's pirated I just went to DB g and they were super excited about doing another game in this series

anybody I haven't I think what I'll do is because I can't get out of mind I'm obsessed with it is the Battle of Martine which is it is sort of the extreme southern extent of Normandy and it was during the US invasion right during World War two so it's another really exciting sort of you know a group is cut off it's one of the massive German counter-offensives so you'll have a position that'll be you know Americans holding out against the German attack and the reason I'm obsessed with that one is my grandfather was in the 30th Infantry Division he was there at the Battle of more taine it's something i've studied a lot and so I really I kinda wanted to not do it like I like how I was looking for other things and I'm just obsessed and I keep coming back to it so I kind of need to get out of my system and then I can look at you know two other options fantastic so is that battle also sort of a big part of your family lore did you grow up Dundas really Ben yeah not necessarily that battles specifically but just my grandfather's I'm with a 30th Infantry Division so he went from basically Normandy until the end of the war is this partially why world war ii seems to be your area of historical focus so yeah I mean of I would say my favorite history like the military history

periods would be Cold War slash post Cold War from a political perspective world war one certainly number one and also I'm a big fan of the French and Indian War but the other the other issue is when I talk to people about designing games especially in this series like I mentioned it needs to be a small enough scale that you can get down to the individual defenders but it needs to be recent enough that you can get detailed information about them and I don't I don't feel comfortable doing games about people that are so alive and said my win though is really really small about games that kind of work and suggest that happens in world war two has tons and tons and tons of material to work with right so it's a good sweet spot but I'm not limited to that interesting so what are some potential battles from other wars that might fit so the one that I would be really interested to do have you ever seen the siege of Joe de Ville which is absolutely a Netflix original movie it's so it's in the 1950s and it was a Irish unit that was in Africa and it's they're defending a small area so it would work really well with the system it's almost old enough to probably be okay there's a couple of guys that are still still alive it's just a really cool story so you should check you should check that out because the movies really good too for cjabroad oh no all right so what um what makes you I mean I can see why this

would be right but what specifically makes you uncomfortable about designing games about events where some of the witnesses are still alive yeah it just hits close to home cuz I work with military I mean I'll try our military work with military still I just wouldn't feel comfortable basing it on guys that you know I could conceivably have worked with right that's right that's very expected maybe you'll hear from family members or from you know people who kind of celebrate family histories like yours down the line in relation to games that you've made yeah maybe maybe right so obviously the more games I designed that have a Western like you know Pablo's house is almost certainly unlikely but maybe with Casa later or with the more tane game or something potentially right so with soldiers in postman's uniform I'm actually working with the guy who's doing a lot of the historical research we met in Gdansk in Poland to do the initial research and he's got some family ties to the game right so we'll see that's super interesting yeah so do you work with research partners on other games or is this also a first for you in terms of yeah so this will be the first there's one other partnership I have going it's about a Italian human torpedo game which is not defense it's totally different right so so one other sort of historical partner if you will so yeah

now on the non war game side most of my designs our code is eyes yeah yeah I've noticed that you you've actually done a huge variety of different types of games yeah so do you feel like do you feel like that's something that's gonna continue for you or do you feel like you've really hit your stride with these with wargaming and that that's where you want to be and you've like found your voice or something yeah I would say I would say that um I won't stop doing other designs right if there's co designers that want to work with me and they haven't I or if I happen to have something but I would say that wargaming's probably this the primary focus for sure yeah all right so is there anything you'd like to add I know that castle tears coming up soon I do their games are in the pipeline yeah so let's think about this so I have one that's coming out soon from phalanx that is called Europe divided and it's all about post Cold War sort of the battle between for Central and Eastern Europe between Western Europe and Russia right so the post Cold War think European expansion NATO and EU expansion and then resurgent Russia so that's that's coming out I don't know it'll be on Kickstarter from phalanx and probably the next few months and then at Gen Con I'll have a game called undaunted which is a deck building sort of light war game so two player deck building game

yep all right no so there is no solo option so I'm like man maybe maybe out maybe I'll go back and try it because you know that well and there's one other game actually that that's I've just been talking about recently on the board game Facebook pages and stuff and that's it's a post apocalyptic war game that is two-player but also solos right so I'm working on the solo system now for that and actually that was my first ever design that was a game I had started designing before I even started getting into gaming so really yeah so it's been in work for literally about 10 years interesting to go back to one of your early projects and kind of rework it and yeah you know what you know now yeah totally reworked I mean it's like completely morphed you know and then I've brought a lot of wargaming sensibilities to it so yeah it's totally different but yeah I'm working now on the solo system so trying to integrate that you know I'm not you know a word gamer I'm a solo gamer and I found problems has to be very accessible yeah is that something that you were deliberately going for what other kinds of games are you sort of mixing yeah yeah Pablo's house is an interesting one because I specifically wanted the co-op experience to feel super asymmetric for the two people that were co-opting it right so a one side you have a very resource management like

if you're playing the operational side that's not a war game at all right you're doing all this resource management so yeah I don't you know I try to borrow across the genres whenever possible and I would say I'm a war Oh primarily if you know that term which is like war game euro hybrid okay right that's my happy spot when I'm playing so I am definitely a big fan of reaching across the to to kind of blend when possible well we appreciate that you have come on here talks as much a game but the research that goes into this I'm sure that my viewers do too guys feel free to leave questions for us in at the comments and again thank you so much yeah thanks for having me I had a good time happy game you guys

Progress saved