Reavers of Midgard Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm talking about the Reavers of Midgard now this is a twenty nine release by grey fox games and it's touted as the spiritual successor to champions of Midgard which is a game with the same kind of genre the Viking theme by the same company now champions of Midgard was a bit of a lukewarm kind of hit for me I didn't like a lot of the aspects of it because it was kind of a hybrid between Euro game ekam isms and kind of America a mirror thrash mechanisms and with a lot of dice rolling and roll to resolve and stuff like that which left me feeling a bit miffed really I didn't always feel like it kind of worked quite as well as I'd like it to however Reavers of Midgard was kind of touted as being the more euro equivalent to it so more strategy kind of more maybe autonomy of your decisions and kind of more kind of you know more control so naturally that kind of piqued my interest a lot more and I had a lot higher hopes for this one so I've got this game to the table and here are my thoughts on the game so much like champion Midgard this one is a work placement game however this one is kind of a single worker placement game so everyone going to have one worker that can change depending on whose first player and stuff but generally one worker and you're going to put them on one of I think it's like seven or eight spots and maybe blessing that six spots even and when you place that worker or denier spot you get you get to take the action first but you'll also get an additional bonus everybody else then
follows in turn taking that action but getting a kind of a kind of a bonus that's less powerful than the one prior to it so that's that's kind of how the game works so whenever someone takes an action you still get to do something and you're not kind of locked out of spaces as you are in a lot of worker placement games now that sounded quite cool I quite like that idea and there's quite a lot going on in this game as well so I'll kind of talk through how the how the game kind of works and then kind of give my thoughts on maybe in more with an opinionated manner so first off I I quite like the idea of a single worker thing is cool it kind of reminds me of things like Puerto Rico or Rising Sun or ti4 I like kind of ways that people could take their turn and you still be involved so that's a really nice idea I'm diggin running you still have to pay the resources and stuff that the person who goes they would have to pay to activate that spot but still it's a nice it's a nice way to keep all players on their toes and keep everyone involved at all times so I like that so one of the first spots you get is what's called a river and this is a part of game that I really do enjoy because what you do is you take one of these cards or take a stack of these cards called rivers and they have multiple uses so they could make first of all they give you dice which are going to be used for loads of things in the game they're going to give you the option to kind of discard them to get additional benefits like such as dice of your choice and stuff like that you can choose to put them as your leader which is a really cool concept because an all player boards um you've got the slot we
can kind of plug a leader into and you get instant bonus and then from then on all dice matching the color of that river or set and symbol acts as a wild so you've got a lot more kind of freedom depending on which leader you have so you've got the red leaders the blue leaders and the yellow dudes leaders I don't really like the idea second off or third option is that you can plug it into the bottom of your board meaning that when certain players go to certain different actions on the board you get a bonus so there's a nice little touch of engine building there that again really piqued me interesting kept kept my interest when when the game was being explained to me I thought this is so nice I can really sink my teeth into because you've got again you've got that engine building you've got that kind of you know that that mitigation of having a certain type of Dyson using the wilds and stuff like that so yeah really enjoyed that part of the game then there's other spots where you can kind of go to which I kind of would explain it as more of a kind of a lucky dip so you go to this spot you're trading in certain types of resources in order to flip these tiles over and get what's on the back and there can be loads of things and you can you're kind of picking them blindly you don't really know what's on the other side I mean there is a kind of chart but that shows what's on what tile but other than that you kind of you don't have a clue what's on it and also for each time you do that you get a kind of a curative bonus at the end of each round for each time you've done it so that is a nice way of getting points again getting these tiles and you know getting points
that way another one is to go basically fight at sea which again kind of reminisce back to champions mid guy where you're going out to the sea you kind of overcoming an obstacle and then fighting a monster at sea and you can either choose to do that by allocating a a specific number of dice or you can dedicate these kind of hammers which lets you roll dice and maybe wait a bit more the luck side of things so you've got that option of playing like champs to Midgard and kind of you know being a bit more lucky and rollers and dice or you can know for sure that you're going to win the fight and just dedicate a designated number of dice and you get points in return you get rewards and return and stuff like that so that that's again it's fine I think it's a slight improvement on the chambers of Midgard because as I said you can actually know for sure that you're gonna win the fight but you've still got that hurdle to overcome by that unknown monster that you're gonna face which is something I'm a bit sore and I don't like it I didn't like it from shambles Midgard and because it can just completely throw a huge spanner in the works but this one again it is slightly better than it is enchanted Midgard another option is you can go to this different location where you are getting bonuses based on cards that are adjacent to each other you're picking up cars and kind of getting more horns and stuff which like you've missed get your dice rolls you can kind of get rid of these negative I guess they're called like I don't know the curses or something where you the more you have the more negative
point you accumulate you at the end of the game so it's a bit like the Lords of Waterdeep or something like in terms of the corruption so it's kind of a sec lecture but negative in negative points and then you've got the other spot as well where you are kind of getting upgrade for your board such as I'm having these tokens which represent kind of a certain type of dice so it's kind of more actions you can kind of know for sure you've got or you can also got these artifacts you can plug in as well which kind of increases your capacity for dice and stuff like that and there's also you another spot for just kind of collecting resources or getting endgame scoring so that's basically how the different spots on the game and as I said if people go there you still get to do what they want they've chosen to do but I know a lower rate now it's kind of a very very confusing game because I think when it's being explained to you it does come across as a very heavy game because there's quite a lot going on there's a lot of rules loads different ways to score and stuff like that but when you actually start plainly and you start to realize that these spots are very very simple and you know a lot of them I'm I'm a bit kind of a bit miffed on on how simple the actual strategy behind it is compared to the kind of user interface of the game because when you go to certain spots a lot of the time you are just making choices that are very obvious to you or you are skimming cards off the top of the deck as you're kind of your bonus action or your incentive of going there first so for example if
you go to a certain spot you would get to get first dibs of picking the cars that pair together and Adam is your kind of tableau or your end game scoring and then you get to skim like two cards off the top of the deck which could be fantastic they could be completely useless and on some of those spots in particular the the set collection aspect of it is very dominant I think when I played this one of the players I played with got more than half of their points just from set collection and that's just three things you could curate along the way sometimes just through pure luck so for example you've got like armor which you know the more you get the more points you accumulate you've got your tapestries you've got your treasures you've got your I think is art see there's loads of different ways you can collect kind of points just by accumulating different cards and for a game of this kind of depth to all kind of heaviness to explain that that kind of way of scoring points is so gateway it's like one of the most primitive ways of getting points you can in a game and you know normally for a game of this you know euro feel and the density of it you would expect that to be a very small part of the game and just to get a few additional points whereas this it was very very dominant which did surprise me a bit as well also that aspect I explained when you go to the spot and you get to trading it good to get these tiles and forgive me I don't know all the different names of the different spaces I can't remember them but that seemed to be a part that
you really could not ignore in this game because if you go there first you get to do that three times and click three tiles and then at the end of each round you're going to get points depending on the amount of tiles you've got so if you really let someone run away with getting those tiles each time then they're going to accumulate a lot of points and keep jumping ahead and ahead and ahead and ahead so you cannot let anyone run away with that so for that reason you've always got to have a kind of a certain amount of resources in your pool to make sure that you can always kind of do what other players do when they go to certain spaces and because of that as well that really took away a lot of the tension of getting to certain spaces first because you're always going to want to do what other people do and so it didn't really matter about who went where where first or who you know the tension of getting to somewhere before someone else did really was weak at best you know and as weak that's because I said the bonuses are sometimes just skimming cards of the deck top of the deck and I say sometime it's a lot of the time there is so much top decking in this game to you know determine any kind of fate and even you know it's a difference making between the winner and the loser is basically what cards you draw off the top of the deck on a pure luck kind of basis which again it just didn't sit right for a game of this you know of this scope I mean the way it's being explained and the rules and the mechanisms I was like oh this is really interesting but the depth of the game and a strategy of the game is really wafer thin it's like almost like having like a Ferrari kind
of car with the engine of a go-kart it just didn't have the the guts of a euro game but it had the like user interface of a really interesting euro game again very very strange and I would completely hesitate to even call this like a heavy game or I think it's been tested I think maybe people have maybe more said it's more of a medium weight game which I would I would say it more is in terms of the way it plays but the scratch is pretty much a lightweight game which is again extremely strange why would you just play a lightweight game in order to get this kind of you know decisions rather than playing a game with so much kind of going on just to play a lightweight game underneath if that makes sense it's very very confusing and I kind of struggled to see how this is going to keep the attention of someone who wants a heavy euro game as compared to someone who wants to play like we're game they're not going to be willing to play something of this kind of rules overhead so yeah a very very strange what kind of feel of the game because it's just it's just the the depth and the complexity just are so jarring in the way they kind of fit together in my opinion so I think all in all this one is a bit of a Miss for me I did get me wrong I didn't hate it I was very surprised about the way it played and I was expecting the decisions to be a lot more tough and there really wasn't any tough decisions at all I was just kind of breezed my way through it at the end
of the game there was a very few points in between the winner and the loser and I feel like we all just kind of just went by our own business it different you know our own pace didn't really struggle over certain spaces I didn't think I played particularly well I just kind of hoped to get the cars that I wanted by drawing off the top of the deck and stuff like that I think we know the difference maker is sometimes pure luck I still don't like the fact that when you go to fight that and once does that see you have to you know you have to overcome something that you can't see so it could completely just shaft you with no fault your own the set collection was a bit too dominating for me way too much endgame scoring points some of the additional kind of set collection around game scoring was just completely tacks on and yeah I think all in all it just was not a great game for me decision is just not enough so promising in some aspects again I love the the player boards they're really cool you know you got a certain allocation of dice on there you can choose your leader which make the dice wild you've got the artifacts which increase your capacity and give you other powers you've got the engine building by using a brevis on the bottom to get accumulative bonuses when people go to certain spots and also you've got the the additional items you can use as kind of reserves such as getting additional hammers or additional shields and stuff like that but yeah I love that part of it I think that's absolutely brilliant and that should be used for another game with more thoughts and decisions to go behind it so yeah this is like almost
like half of a really promising game and then half of a game that's so limp that it just completely baffles me so yeah I can't really recommend it in terms of its strategy and depths of decisions and stuff like that balance of the game I think it's too reliant on top decking as I said so yeah I don't really like that part as well where you go to get the tiles too much luck in that mechanism wise I said the user interface is really good but they gain depth nowhere near as good time frame is actually relatively good I think it takes about an hour and a half on the spot to play which is quite a nice time frame for something like this because again there is enough going on to keep you interesting interested but I think if went any longer then I think it kind of stays welcome up time as we always absolutely fine because as I said you're piggybacking on other people's actions all the time replayability I think it's relatively low in this one I think when we played the game we went through pretty much all the cards and the decks which kind of means you've explored everything so yeah not loads of strategies to try and stuff like that because every time you're going to be going to everything and almost exhausting every pile so yeah not loads of different things to explore and stuff like that so again relatively limp in terms of how much you can play this game player interaction nowhere near as good as I'd like it to be I said there's no competition over this worker placement spots in my opinion the use of
that kind of corruption I forget what it's called in this one you can kind of a bit of take that buy some cards that you give those tokens to other players to give them more negative points don't really like that to be honest and I try to avoid that or costs visually absolutely beautiful game the artwork is fantastic the components are great I mean the dice are fantastic custom bright nice clear symbology all the cards and symbology are really nice yeah no problem at all with the play balls in particular I really enjoyed I've seen artwork production-wise top tier the game trades that come in the box are fantastic really good for storage and again the board itself is really quite nice looking so and the theme as well it's it's decent I mean you know you're going to see fighting the monsters and going to pillage towns and stuff that so I quite like the theme but for a more kind of Euro feeling game I mean you know I think it's as good as it can be as setup and teardown time as well is absolutely proportionate so yeah overall so such such a weird kind of fitting game for me I can't quite put my finger on why it was designed like this I can see what they're trying to do it's like they they want to really kind of play up that euro feel to it but you need not only do you need the mechanisms that you're away you need this decisions and you know you need this kind of brain kind of straining you know decisions to make and you need to you know do your kind of minimum and/or
optimize your moves as much as possible wearing this there Worley wasn't much of that wherever you go is absolutely fine decisions are very obvious and again too much dependence on top decking and just lucky dips and stuff like that so yeah I can't recommend Reavers of Midgard bigger I don't hate it I would play it again didn't I think my expectations were a bit too high because as I said it was so touted as a more euro game and I love more euros this one isn't really a euro feeling game it so there's two lights in terms of a strategy so yeah it gets a mediocre verdict from me which is about 5 out of 10 again not a negative review I don't I didn't hate it but again I can't recommend it and I wouldn't ever kind of ask to play it again if someone really offered to play it I would and you know I'd kind of enjoy it too my best I can but again not quite for me this one if you have enjoyed this review please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye