Skip to main content
Loading video...

Nassau Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 7:14

at number four I have Nassau so this is the reworking of Stephen feld's rum and Pirates you know a re a new game for the um stepen Feld City collection um so if you're not aware of what Roman Pirates was it was one of stefen feld's first games that came out a long long time ago didn't really get much traction and I think critically it was quite hit or miss with a lot of people now I never played the original Roman bones so I didn't quite know what to expect so I went with an open mind knowing that I love Stephan Feld games and knowing that you know I like the pirate theme in general so this kind of segment is going to be a bit all over the place which I think is a good representation of the game itself because it's quite a disjointed game it's quite unintuitive I'm not to overuse that word but I'm probably going to use it a few more times in this segment so basically this is a game of two halves the first half you are going to be moving around this modular board which is kind of like a town of Nassau and you're going from spot to spot and placing workers on the roads between the action locations where you get certain resources which will basically stock you up and prepare you for the next phase of the game now to be honest this part of the game I actually really liked and I saw a lot of potential in I like the idea of when you place your when you place your workers and move the um the pirate that will dictate which actions your opponent can have so you don't really want to lay too much on the plate for them and leave leave them great opportunities um and

there are ways around that because you can spend these rum bottles in order to sit out for the turn and hopefully that the pirate lands on somewhere that's going to suep you better next time and you can even play coins to take a double turn but bearing in mind you do have a very limited capacity of pirates to spend so this one although it was a little bit frustrating and sometimes you could find yourself blocked out of things you really wanted to get you kind of have to act a little bit more tactically to try and hopefully make do and um set yourself up for the next phase which is where you are using your pirate ship to sail around the islands to fight off different you know monsters Krakens um set up fortifications and all the piratey stuff that you'd expect with a a pirate game so the the way the game works after the original part is that again you're going to be saving your boat around the more sales the more crew you have the faster and more efficiently you can sell you're collecting weapons to help you fight these monsters more efficiently uh the combat system in the game is a little bit weird you know I don't really associate Stephan Feld with having you know clean combat systems um because he is so eurom minded but this one was quite a strange one where you would match up your weapons with your crew that would show how many wounds you do to an animal and then the um the creature will attack you back based on their strength um which will basically weaken your player board by removing weapons removing crew um you know cargo that kind of stuff um but then you're rolling dice to try and mitigate those threats so it's kind of a a mix of or

hybrid of Euro mechanisms with some dice rolling and I must admit it didn't feel very intuitive it was quite a difficult can to portray and to verbalize to teach it to others because again normally with combat systems you can see how they work out this one is different and definitely in a category of its own I'm not saying I didn't like it but it definitely doesn't flow too well and you have to think twice and maybe read the rules a few times over to really get a grasp of it um setting up the fortifications was quite cool because you could kick people off and that would start getting your ingame points or in-game points um you'd also try and collect these um these Goods which you can try and bury if you have enough money at the end of the round um so as you can imagine there's a lot going on here um very mechanically driven some rules that don't flow too naturally um in particular there are these animals that you collect and all the animals come with once per round powers and production wise it wasn't the best portrayed because there was no symbology on the animal tokens and some of the powers were quite strong but again you'd have to keep looking at the book to remember what those Powers were so it was quite disjointed in that respect too um sometimes there was a mismatch on how long the turns were because if per some person had a ton of Provisions that they could they could keep taking turns or loads of turns in order to to keep fighting and setting up outposts and stuff while somebody else who wasn't fortunate enough to get

Provisions would take a turn or two and then sit out until everybody else has caught up so there is potential for some downtime the game did go a little bit longer than I would have liked you know this took us around 2 hours and we're generally quite quick players yes it was the first game and um again there are some clunky mechanisms but still it did drag its heels at times um but saying that I did like the the mix of the in-game Play points you'll get as well as all the Strategic choices you're making because there are so many different ways to get points here again collecting crew and the Animals collecting different weapons setting up outposts um you know fighting monsters all of these are very viable uh paths to Victory so um all in all this is a weird one um it's definitely one of the lowest Fel games I've played in terms of my personal uh ratings I think it's just too cumbersome and a bit too it puts a bit too much um kind of onus on the teacher of the game to make sure everything is working as it should um again lots of unintuitive rules very disjointed and yeah basically I can't really see myself ever wanting to pull this one off the shelf to play it again um but despite me making it sound like it's very negative I still did enjoy the game I thought it was a lot of fun but again is it going to have that gravity effect to make me keep coming back to it and I'm pretty well in fact I'm confident that is not the case I cannot see myself um Pi pulling this one

off the shelf again because it's just too it's just too much for what the game is trying to do um still really Charming aesthetic some cool mechanisms again in terms of the um I like this idea of at the end of the the round essentially you are going to be trying to cash in these um these pirate cards which will all kind of link to different things you've done during the round so it could be half this animal or um you know kill two of these types of animals and so on um and that kind of represented your your Epic Pirate Tales you were telling and whoever told the coolest story would get some bonus points it kind of reminded me of Merlin if you're familiar with that game and the and the cards that you're getting and trying to achieve um but at the same time by the end of the game you have so many cards in front of you it does feel a little bit random so still I think this game could have done with a lot of tightening up the bolts um it could have done with streamlining a lot of the stuff could be shaved off in my opinion but hey that's just my opinion it's not exactly what I want with a fil game um so hey take that for what it's worth it's just not one that I'm going to go back to explore anymore

Progress saved