TDG: Coalitions
Transcript
Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, I don't mean to brag or anything but I recently beat our local chess champion in just five moves. Those karate lessons are really paying off. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at Coalitions from Phalanx.
In Coalitions from Phalanx, one to six players take on the roles of the various belligerent nations of the Napoleonic Wars. You can play as Britain, France, Prussia, Russia, Austria, or the Ottoman Empire. Now, before I get started with my review, I just want to note this is a game that I actually did a crowdfunding preview video about six years ago for this game. Normally, I don't do reviews of games that I have done crowdfunding videos for in the past. I realized this is about 6 years ago and the good people at uh Phalanx Games actually just sent me my copy, which was part of my original deal to do the um crowdfunding video. They just sent me this copy as well as expansions and minis and stuff like that. So, I'm going to go ahead and I'm going to review the game based on that. This review has not been is not being influenced by Phalanx at all. These are just my genuine opinions on this game.
Now, there are a number of different scenarios you can play. You can play a longer scenario, shorter scenario. They represent kind of the historical setups of that time period. Now, in your map of Europe that you have, you uh can either play on one side of the game board or the other depending on the scenario. You have kind of like the revolutionary side, which is some of the earlier French revolutionary scenarios, and then you have the kind of Napoleonic side, um the empire side that has stuff that occurred during Napoleonic's tenure uh Napoleon's tenure here. But, you have various home regions in the colors of those countries, but then you also have kind of disputed regions. And these are striped regions that contain stripes of various belligerent nations. Uh those nations can score if they occupy those and more on that later. Now, in addition to the actual geography of the board, you're going to have a morale track on the right at the bottom of the board. You're going to have a kind of a combat strength track.
And then you'll also kind of have your your influence, your victory point track that runs along the bottom and the side of the board as well. There are a number of ports and it's kind of sea lanes that Britain and its allies can use during the game. Now, critically in the upper left corner, you kind of have your diplomatic area. Now, you kind of have, you know, the red space for Britain, the blue space for France. You have the couch, meaning you're neutral, or you have the cannon, which means you're expansionist. And what this means is during the diplomatic phase, you're going to use that to track kind of which coalition you're a part of. Now, the very first thing you do every round, although you skip it on the first phase cuz the first phase everything's set up for you, is you're going to have the diplomatic round. Now, what you do here is everybody can kind of discuss what coalition they want to be a part of. Now, critically, Britain and France are always at war. They are always kind of they're on their own side. They are always fighting each other.
They don't have to choose anything here. But, the other belligerents will have to make a decision. They have a number of tokens that on the reverse side indicate whether they're going to join the French, the British, whether they're going to be neutral or expansionistic on this turn. So, they all reveal at the same time which coalition they're going to join, and they place their marker in that spot on the on the track. So, you will all know for that round you are allied to anybody else in that. So, for instance, if you know, the the Prussian player and the Russian player both join the British coalition, they would be allied for that round. Now, on the board players have units. Now, units are little kind of cardboard chips that indicate, you know, infantry, cavalry, whatever. Although, that doesn't really matter. It's just it's just the strength of the unit is depending on how many of these counters that you have. You will also have either a wood token that comes with the basic set or the minis, which I have the miniature set, so we're using the minis here. Um to kind of put on top of those to represent your generals.
Now, critically, too, at any time if a general moves into a space or out of a space, they can flip over one of these one of their units to become a garrison. That shows that that power controls that space, and that's going to be very important for control for taxation or scoring purposes later in the game. Now, according to the player scenario, you're going to start with a number of battle cards in your hand. You may actually start with some money in your hand as well. Now, you have a number of actions that take place, and you look at your color, and you have a rondel. You look at your color on the ron- rondel, and when you start the action phase, you're going to actually twist the rondel to the to its next area, and you're going to take whatever action your color is on. And you're going to do these things simultaneously. Everybody can do them at the same time except for the player that moves. Movement is handled a little bit differently after every other player goes, but essentially you're going to go ahead and do whatever your action is.
Now, if you're at the top spot, which is muster, all that means is you can draw a new battle card and then discard one in your hand. Next, you can tax. Now, essentially how taxation works is you can take uh taxation from all of your home territories. All of your home territories have a number on them. That is the number of taxes you will gain from those territories. But, also you can gain taxes for any territories that you control that are not uh yours. If you control uh disputed territories that have your color on them, you will not gain taxes for them. Um but, if you are control disputed territories that do not have your colors in them, then you can gain taxes from them. Now, Britain also gains from trade. So, you've got, as I say, a number of ports on the board. And so long as these ports are not occupied by a member of the opposing coalition, then uh Britain will be able to take the money for those ports. And uh that's another important way that Britain is going to raise revenue. Next, you have leadership subsidy and Napoleon movement. There's different things you can do here. Now, for the leadership, uh one of the things you can do is if you have any off-board generals, you can put them on the board. Or if you have generals that are on the board, you can take them off the board. This is If you've got off-board generals, that will let you draw more um battle cards, so you may not want them on the board, but you may want them on the board to fight these wars. You can also choose to take one battle card during leadership, or you can choose to gain one morale during leadership. Now, the British player at this time can also do subsidies. They can actually give a member of their coalition. For every three monies that they give to one of their uh coalition partners, they can gain an infantry uh uh influence point, essentially a victory point. So, this is a way they can use their wealth to try to buy points and help out their coalition partners at the
same time, but they can never gain more than one point per player per turn. Next, Napoleon gets to do a special movement at this time. Napoleon can actually move his forces to an adjacent area. And once he's in that adjacent area, he can engage in More on combat later. Next, you've got mobilization. Now, during mobilization, you can actually purchase things. You can spend your money to buy things. You can buy a fortress, you can buy military units, you can buy morale points, and you can buy battle cards. Now, everything costs you just $1, one money. Uh but, the fortresses will cost you five, and you place them in somewhere on the board where you have a general and no other unit. If you would get uh military units, you can place them in areas with your generals, but you can never have more than three uh units in an area with a general. Next on the rondel, you can gain influence. This is where you're going to score.
Essentially, you look at all of the disputed territories with your color that you control, and you gain the victory points for those. So, you start to move up the victory track depending on how many of those you actually control at that time. Next, you have movement. Now, your standard movement action for a land unit is to simply move one space, one adjacent space. But, there's a little bit more to it than that. Essentially, every time you move, you have to name an envoy. Every round you move, you have to name an envoy. And that is you have to pick somebody who is not a member of your coalition, and you tell them, "You are my envoy." Well, you move the first time for free, you can always move one unit, and then that person who is your envoy gains a morale point. Now, you can say, "I want to move again." And you can move that same unit again or any other movement again any other unit again. But, this time the envoy has to give their permission. If the envoy doesn't give his permission, you don't get to move a second time. If he does give his permission, then the envoy will get two morale points. Then, you can ask permission to move a third time. Again, the envoy doesn't have to give permission, but if he does give permission, the envoy gets three morale points. Theoretically, an envoy could gain six morale points if he is chosen during your movement turn.
Now, in addition to your standard movement, there's also a strategic movement, meaning you can move up to three spaces through your own or allied controlled territories. Although, if you do move through allied territories, you must ask permission from your ally. Uh but essentially, that's a way to kind of quickly move forces around the board. Now finally, there are sea movement. Now sea movement may only be done by the British or by their allies with British permission. Essentially, you have kind of sea uh the ports and the sea lanes along the the the coasts. And the British unit for for one movement point, they can essentially move their units along these these from port to port. The allies can do the same uh as I say, if the British give permission for them to do so. During sea movement, you can move a total of three sea lanes. Now if at the end of the movement phase, you have belligerent nations in the same location. That is to say, nations that are not part of a coalition. If they are in the same space, they're going to do battle. Now how battle works is essentially, you're going to add up the total initial strength. So you're going to get one strength point for each unit there and one strength point for your general. If there is a fortress there, I think that's an additional four points.
If there's a garrison there, that gives an additional point to whoever has the garrison there. But you're going to go ahead and put your your initial strength down. Now in addition to the units that are actually in the battle, any units from the same nation or allied nations that are adjacent to that space, they can also choose to participate in battle, but they have to mention that right at the beginning. How you're going to do battle is by playing battle cards. Now you can only play the number of battle cards equal to the number of of combat tokens you have. So the combat tokens you have, I believe the garrison can contribute them, and then combat tokens from adjacent units. Now these adjacent units, they don't contribute to your initial combat strength, but they can bring in unit cards. So if I've got a Frenchman here and a Frenchman there, and they've each got three units, I could potentially play six cards. If I've got a Frenchman here and I'm allied to say the Austrians, um and they've they've each got three, then I can play three and my Austrian friend can play three as well with me. Now, the aggressor plays a card face down and then the defender plays a card face down. Now, you keep doing this and every time you do it, you must spend a morale point. This is why it morale is important because if you don't have any morale, you can't spend battle cards.
So, you go ahead and you spend the battle cards as you're putting them down. Now, some of these battle cards have some some special conditions on them. One of them lets is played face up and you can see what your enemy is playing. One of them, if you lose the battle, you'll you'll lose morale. But, you go ahead, you place all those cards out and then you reveal them. You add up all the cards and whoever has the highest number wins that battle. The player that lost, of course, has to either put his general back in his capital or take him off the board. The units are lost. The winner and any other units that participated in combat also lose one unit. The victor will also be given a chance to flip over one of his units to create a garrison in that space. Critically, if you defeat an enemy general in battle, you gain one influence point. Now, what everybody's trying to do is get to 25 on the influence track. It's kind of a race to be the first to get to 25. So, players are going around and around. They are moving their units. They are building units. They are doing diplomacy. They are engaging in battles. And they are trying to gain more and more influence.
So, the point of the game is to gain the most influence points. Essentially, you want to get to 25. It's a race. The first player to get to 25 influence points will win the game. The game can also be won if Britain or any of its coalition partners can occupy Paris by the end of the turn. So, if you can fulfill your victory conditions by being the first to get 25 points or by occupying Paris if you're on the opposing coalition, then you win. Coalitions. We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel, that is Cody Carlson PhD, where we talk about history, books on history, military history. I even post some of my lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel. And now, back to the review. All right, ladies and gentlemen, there is a lot more going on here. There's a lot of stuff I really didn't get into.
Um there there really is um you know, a lot of of of of little things here and there in this game that kind of contribute to it. And I'm not I'm not going to get too much into that. There's also like a if you play with less than six players you have a bidding system where a player can control a one of the players that they're not in the game and you essentially will gain their influence, right? There's also a again, there's that idea that if you're if you're allied with Britain, you can get subsidies potentially, you can use sea movement. Whereas with the French you don't get any direct benefit, but the French maybe won't steamroller you, which is always good. So as I say, this is a game that I played six years ago and I played it a couple times. They were actually working on it when I played it. In fact, I had played it and they said, "Oh, Cody, we we've kind of tweaked it. We're going to send it to you." So they actually sent me a um some new um components of the game and played it.
Essentially, it was you had it before the rondel and then with the rondel. So I played it where everybody just took their turn and it was a longer game. And then they sent the rondel and everybody can pretty much go simultaneously except for the player that is moving. And I got to tell you, this was a game that I played that I was really excited for uh when I when I did it. In fact, if I remember correctly, you know, oftentimes when I do preview videos and I'm very I'm up front about the paid preview videos, um I do receive a fee and then a copy of the game, right? And for some reason, I I I I can't remember what was going on. I didn't take a fee for that one. I I really wanted to play it and uh I think I I can't remember what was going on, but I didn't take a fee. So I I did I have gotten the the the Kickstarter stuff now, but um I didn't take a fee at the time because I was just really excited about the game. I thought it looked really cool. And I played the game and I really enjoyed it.
I thought it was a lot of fun. And getting this kind of fine finished edition here, there already some some tweaks they've made to it. Nothing major, but a few little things here and there. The biggest change that I can recall is when I played the game before, it was the first one to 40 influence points. And now it's 25. So, it's already a shorter game, okay? So, we played this game the other night and it was probably just shy of 3 hours. And that was one of the longer scenarios. So, this is a game that I think is very easy to learn. It's not a hard game to learn. There's a few little things here and there we're looking up in the rules, but generally, I think it's a very easy game to learn. But there is some deep strategy here. And what I like about this game is it is not just a war game. It's it's it's a war game. It's got war game DNA throughout it, but I would say more than a war game, this is a diplomatic game because there can be changes on a dime. One round, you and you and somebody are working together, and then the next round they can completely screw you over. They can choose to be neutral, right? Or they can choose to be just in it for themselves and they're at war with everybody if they're expansionist.
Or they can go to the opposite coalition. So, from turn to turn, you kind of don't know who your friends are. And that's what I really one of the things I really love about this game is I really love that sense of Oh, I don't know. Just just you don't know who you can trust. I always like diplomacy games. I always like games of negotiation. In fact, negotiation is probably one of my absolute favorite mechanics in a game. But here the negotiation is a little more subtle because it's like Yeah, the British can offer you money with the subsidies, and they can offer you sealants. The French really can't offer you anything except not to destroy you, right? Maybe you want French security there. Now, one of the things that really impressed me when I first played Coalitions, and one of the things I still really like about it. And this is something I've commented on about a few Napoleonic games over the years.
It used to be that pretty much every Napoleonic game I played, it was a war between Britain and France, and then all the other countries, Prussia, Austria, Russia, um the Ottomans. They were all just kind of adjuncts of the others. They they they and and it just seemed like they weren't as fun, and they weren't as interesting, right? They couldn't do the things that that that France and Britain could do. And so that was always a little demoralizing. And this is the first kind of grand big map Napoleonic game that I played where I felt like that didn't matter. Because you've got this abstraction of the influence track, and everybody on the board has access to disputed territories where they can claim points. And everybody on the board can make a decision at any time they want to go to war with somebody to try to claim one of those those areas. And so I thought that was very cool, because everybody is interesting in this game. All the players can do a cool things in this game. I really really like that. And I played a few games since that have had that same dynamic where the other players are not just adjuncts of Britain and France, but can do their own things, and they're cool. I'm actually, you know, thinking of Alliance from Columbia Games, or Fellowship of Simulations, um Napoleon's Conquest does it very well.
But this one uh I think just really handles all of the nations, gives them all fun and interesting things to do, and a realistic chance at victory here, which I really really enjoyed. Now I should point out too, the game comes with the wooden cubes. We're playing with the miniatures. We also got the the diplomatic bust miniatures that that go on the in the diplomacy area. Um the the game comes with wooden components, which are actually pretty cool themselves, but but we do have the miniatures here that I'm that I'm using in this game, and we'll continue to use, cuz I they're awesome. I like them. Um but overall, I have to tell you, I really really really like Coalitions. This is just a great game. It's been, I think, what, 6 years? People have been waiting for the Kickstarter. I know every now and then people would watch my preview video and they're like, "Come on, when's it going to happen?" Well, I believe they'll be shipping soon if if if they haven't already and I'll tell you it's worth the wait. This is really really a great game.
The game actually they sent me the expansion The Ancien Régime, which I'm looking forward to playing and hopefully I'll have a review of that before long. Um I know there's it comes with like a solitaire mode, but I know there's like another La Patrie en Danger or whatever, which is um kind of an advanced solo mode, I think, if I understand that correctly. Now, they also have the Realpolitik and Raison d'État, which are two other Essentially, they look like they're I haven't really looked at them too closely, but they look like they are games in the same system, but maybe a different time period, like the late 19th century or the I don't know if the other one's the Renaissance. But but I'm excited to play those, too, because I just had a lot of fun here. Now, having said all of this and sharing with you my joy and my love for this game, which is deep. I will say this.
Um my friends, some of them liked it, some of them liked it a lot. Ray did not care for it. He thought it was okay, but he didn't care for it. And part of that is Ray is just not a big fan of kind of negotiation games and diplomacy. They're not his cup of tea, which I totally appreciate. Um he he thought the game was all right, nothing special. Um but for me, this kind of game is perfect. You know, I like a game like this that is that the strategies are deep enough and interesting enough that can really grab you in, but it's not so deep that you get lost in the weeds. Not a hard game to play, not a hard game to learn, not a hard game to teach, but deep strategy and a lot of fun. And it's a game that is political as diplomatic as much as it is military. I really love Coalitions. This is just an absolutely fantastic game.
On the Cody scale, right now I'm going to go ahead and give this an 8.5 out of 10. Uh I'm thinking with more play this this is going to go up. I think it's a fantastic game. Thank you once again for joining us today on the Discriminating Gamer. As always, we'd ask you to please leave a comment for us here on YouTube, on BoardGameGeek, on our Facebook page, on X. We'd love to hear back from you. Uh please go ahead and like uh this video and subscribe to our YouTube channel if you haven't done so already. Now, if you really like what we do here on the Discriminating Gamer, I would humbly ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about history, military history, books on history. And it mean the world to me if you'd subscribe to that channel as well. And again, if you really like what you see here, I would humbly ask you to click on the Super Thanks button and leave a tip. You know, I recently read a study that said cows produce more milk if you talk to them.
It's just in one ear and out the other.
[screaming]
Like if it benefits
Looking for a good ally. Looking for somebody that's got my back. And you know, I'm going to like you with that.
So far, you've been kind of everywhere. So