Gorinto: A Non-Review
Transcript
hey gamers this is liz davidson from beyond solitaire and i am kind of posting an unusual video today i am going to tell you about a game that i've received for review and am not now really able to review and that game is grinto it's published by graham gamer's guild it's designed by richard gainer and this is a game that i actually played at pax unplugged in 2019 i played a demo copy i very much enjoyed the gameplay so i asked mark spector for a review copy the review copy came i was actually doing plays in preparation for writing my review and it was going to be a positive review however it was not to be because on april 27th richard under the designer of this game published a designer diary that was upsetting on a number of levels it has since been removed from board game geek but i kind of knew that was going to happen so i did a printed pdf and it's not perfect but i am going to show you what i do have so i think you can see the first issue is that it's called garento or five facts about indonesia number five will surprise you so basically the designers telling the story of being asked to make a game about indonesia with uh mike fitzgerald and he basically starts researching indonesia looking for something to make a game about and i mean this is obviously a joke like now thanks to my research i'm about as much of an expert about indonesia as an hour of ghoulie googling can get you but you know why i do realize that's obviously a joke he's obviously being sarcastic that does not inspire confidence in me that he approached this topic with the amount of respect and
sensitivity that making a game about another culture should entail and of course he goes on in this post to prove that theory right so some of his facts about indonesia include the residents of one of the islands filed down their teeth and he also brings up a fact about cat poop coffee he then makes a joke about making a menkau game that would require you to file a tooth down at the end which again like it's obviously a joke but it's also really putting a lot of focus on kind of the freakiness and exotic nature of indonesian culture instead of something that people would feel interested in in a more respectful way the fact is that look look how weird this is that's not really an appropriate way to approach somebody else's culture especially if you have never been to the place and you've just spent an hour on google and you are looking at someone else in another country and passing snap judgment on them for most of the rest of the post things are kind of innocuous he's talking about his katan prototype like this is all pretty normal stuff but then you find out that he no longer was working with mike's with mike fitzgerald and he says i'm no longer tied to the indonesia theme so he then immediately looks for something else and it's just apparently a random search for things with five objects and so he chooses as his thing with five objects a five element philosophy of
buddhism from japan and this of course evolves into gorinto the game and i want to talk about that more in just a moment but then by the end of the post after some more relatively innocuous stuff he brings up one more fact about indonesia so he wasn't tethered to the theme but apparently he was tatted to it for this post and he says in indonesia paso is a harvest festival in which two teams of spear-willing horsemen gallop at each other hurling their spears at rival riders so we go from tooth filing to throwing spears at each other these facts were maybe not intentionally but as it turns out they were chosen to make indonesia look less civilized and less respectable and more like oh look at that and actually jason perez has a really good video about this on shelf stories where he explains why it is so messed up that you would choose these particular facts and present them in this particular way so i'm going to leave that part to jason and link him in my show notes and of course this post very obviously received angry comments and then the designer asked that it be taken down and it was so he's apologized this post is no longer just normally available on boardgamegeek and that's probably for the best but having read it i as a reviewer can't turn back and that's actually why i made this video i normally will cover any review copy that comes through my hands i feel like even if a game is bad it is important to me that i cover it because i kind of feel like passing on a bad game is ignoring part of my job as a as a critic i review games whether they're good or
bad if i'm sent a review copy at some point even if i have a huge backlog i will get to the review copy and i'll review the game because i'm a reviewer i kind of feel like it's dishonest to pass on games just because i don't want to hurt people's feelings or because i don't want to say something bad and so if this had been a kickstarter prototype which is why i don't do very many kickstarter previews anymore then i might have just passed it on to somebody else and not said anything because i think that before a game is published it's not fully fair game for a reviewer like me however a fully published copy of garento was sent to me and i don't typically pass on those especially because i asked for this one and so it's important to me as a reviewer to be transparent about what's going on because i think that you as my audience deserve that and i also think that it's important for me as a reviewer to make myself be upfront about that so basically how it shakes is that i was enjoying grinto it probably would have gotten a high score for me if i had not really thought about the theming and how problematic it ultimately was however i don't know how you give a score to i am culturally insensitive and probably did not show enough respect for the thing i themed my game around and that's the problem that i think we're dealing with here garento itself it's not a game but indonesia it's a game that takes some theming from japanese buddhism the game itself is very abstract like you could probably convince yourself and i really did that it was abstract enough that the theming really isn't that big a deal
and i honestly did not think too much deeper into it after the first time i played and it's easy for me not to worry about how a game about japanese buddhism might make other people feel and so i didn't think about it and i now regret that because the thoughtlessness of this designer's post really tells me that i should have paid more attention when things didn't seem right the first time because just because it's an abstract game that doesn't do anything bad that also doesn't mean that borrowing from somebody else's culture to theme your game to make it seem a little sexier is good and that's something that i have to own and that i have to think about harder going into the future but you know given that grinto is something that's inspired by buddhism i mean i'm an atheist i study religion academically but i do not spend a lot of time thinking about religious feelings anymore it's been a long time since i did that outside of a scholarly context that said i would be really interested but probably appalled to see a game that somebody did about christianity with very little knowledge of it and googling it for one hour like what would you even make what would that look like would that be something that was sufficiently respectful for a christian audience which is a lot of board gamers in america i'm gonna guess no and so applying that same standard to garento it probably was not appropriate to just google it because i had google it go with it because it had five things and then make a game about it even if that game seems to me pretty innocuous and i think that's
something that we can all do better with going forward you don't need a shallow version of somebody else's culture to make a game good or to make the gameplay more exciting so i as a reviewer feel that i can't do a standard review of this game because my score be compromised by what i know and how upset i was by it therefore i'm covering the game in this way and i'm making a video about it so that you know i know and everybody knows exactly what was going through my head when i decided to ignore this rookie copy and i'm gonna end up passing it on to somebody else i do also think that this topic and i don't want to do a big video about this right now but i do think that this situation brings up an important topic which is under what circumstances is it okay for someone to make a game about a culture that's not theirs and i do not think that people should not be allowed to make games about cultures and time periods and subjects that are not native to them i think that exploration and research are good and that it's absolutely possible to make games that are about cultures other than your own that are sensitive thoughtful and high quality however i also think it's the height of rudeness to just kind of glance at another culture grab something that seems to work and slap it on your game because it sounded like a good idea and that's something that is very easy for us the united states to do we're used to understanding ourselves as the center of the world and to most the rest of the world we're not and that's some work that we have to do
so i can't score garento i can't fairly review it but i am leaving this here for posterity to tell you why that wasn't possible that said i do generally like grand gamers guild mark spector who sent me this review copy is a friend of mine hopefully this game is just one unfortunate episode in the history of an otherwise good publishing company thanks so much for listening if you disagree that's fine i think that this is something that we're all kind of personally dealing with if we are people who are playing games and also caring about the people that games are made about and i appreciate you taking the time to listen happy gaming everyone
you