Suburbia Board Game Review - Still Worth It?
Transcript
hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews play throughs unboxings which i really like to talk a load of bollocks about table top gaming in general and in this video we'll be talking about a city building game we're going to be talking about suburbia and in this game you'll be laying tiles in front of you that will give you income they'll give you a bit of reputation and they'll increase your population that will give you points that will allow you to win the game so in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules we'll be telling you what we do like what we don't like then we'll come back and we'll tell you we've all not suburbia it's still worth playing was it released i should check this before i even do this stuff right was it released it doesn't say i'm going a long time ago so remember if you knew it please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below and we'll see you after this bollocks so suburbia how did you play this game so suburbia is a tall laying city building game the first thing you're going to do is going to put a player board in front of you and you'll notice you've got an income track and you've got a reputation track you put your little cylinder on the income track and you put your little marker on the reputation track on the required numbers at the beginning of the game right you'll also give yourself a heavy factory tile a community park tile and a suburb
tile and you place them on your little player board that's comprised of little hexes right you'll make three stacks of tiles you see on the back of them they are lettered a b and c and depending on how many players are playing a game you'll put a certain amount of tiles in a stack you'll also look for the one more round tile you'll place that towards the bottom of stack c each player will get 15 million dollars in coins and then you populate the real estate market with seven tiles from the a stack if you look at the real estate market board you'll see that the further to the left hour the more expensive the tiles become to purchase and the further left you go the cheaper they are the last two are going to cost your deadly squat everyone will place their population marker on space number two of the population board and also take three investment markers which are the little hexagonal tiles with the times 2 number on it so when your turn comes around in this game you will get two options you'll be able to take and place a tile or you'll get the option of placing an investment marker on a tile that you've already played if you're taking place at all you do select a tile either from the real estate market or you'll take one of the heavy industry community park or suburb tiles that are always available but finite in nature right and you'll pay the relevant cost which is comprised of the money that is displayed on the tile itself and also the money that is displayed in relation to the position it is on the real estate market right if you're taking one of the community parks or the suburbs or the heavy industry you'll just pay the amount of money that's on the tile right if none of those options are viable for you or you just fancy
going for a swim or something then you can also turn a towel into a lake what you'll do you'll select a tile from anywhere on the real estate market and you'll flip it over and then you'll place it into your city so all these tiles have different effects you'll see that on the top right of the tile you'll get a bonus and this could be maybe extra income in which case you'll move your income cylinder up that many spaces it might affect your reputation in which case you will move your reputation up or down right if you place a lake tile then every single tile that's adjacent to a lake will give you two dollars you'll take that from the supply and put it in front here so there's four different types of tiles the yellow tiles are industry tiles you've got the residential green tiles you've got the commercial blue tiles and you've got the civic gray tiles right so some of the industry tiles you might have you might have the salt house in which case you will lose -2 reputation when the tile is placed and you'll get plus one income for every fancy restaurant and fast food restaurant in play in any borough that includes other players borrowers right or you might add the freeway in which case you'll get minus one for each adjacent residential area and you'll get plus one income for each adjacent commercial district so in general the industry tiles generally don't get placed next to residential areas because nobody wants to live next to a rubbish done today so some of the commercial tiles that you might have you might have the convenience store and it simply gives you a plus one income when it's placed you might have the business supply store in which case you'll get plus one income and then plus one for every office tile
that you have in your city some of the civic tiles you might come across you might have the mint in which case you'll get plus free income and plus two dollars for each of your civic tiles or you might have the power station in which case you'll get plus one income for each of your industry tiles so all of these tiles are sort of very varied as you're working your way through stack a b and c they get more expensive they get more powerful and also get more deadly if you're placing them in the wrong place so one thing that we haven't talked about is the bonus tiles what you do at the beginning of the game which i forgot to mention stupid at the beginning a game you'll get two gold tiles will choose one the skydll one it also place a number of gold tiles depending on how many people are playing the game on the real estate broadway and these will generally give you basically points at the end of the game if you fulfill the requirements on the gold tile so you might have the air traffic controller in which case you get plus 10 population if you've got the most airport or you might have the aquaphobian in which case you'll get plus 20 population for the fewest lakes or you might become the public official in which case you'll get plus 15 population for the most contiguous civic tiles that you've got right so these are very very lucrative if you can get the right ones and they do have a habit of swapping out the leader at the end of the game so if you don't fancy your place in eighth order board you can place one of your investment markers on the board and this will basically activate the tile again and then it will grant you a double bonus every time that tile is affected so once you've done that choice you'll take the amount of money out of bank depending on where your income cylinder is on your player
board and then you'll adjust the population based on your reputation you might have to pay a cost you might have to pay some money or you might have to pay in population if your reputation is in taxes which sounds a bit like my life right and then you adjust the real estate market by sliding everything down to fill up the empty spots and you'll take a tile from the supply and you'll dump it in the furthest left spot so you've also got to be mindful of the red lines when you're pushing your points on the board when you cross a red line you will lose both one income and you'll lose by one reputation because your city has grown too quick and you basically haven't got the resources to keep paying all them benefits out to all the slops have you so the game will end once the one more round token is flipped everyone will have one more go right and then you'll do a bit of final scoring you'll check to see who fulfilled any of the goals you'll add your points up and then you'll get one point for every five million dollars that you still have in the bank and the player with the most points will be the winner of suburbia so what do we like about suburbia so the first thing that we really like about it is the red line penalty really does make a little bit of sense now it sort of limits people from just going out too quickly and you're always mindful about that little digging your arm when you cross over that line right that's basically a way of stopping everyone from just bolting out the gate as quickly as possible and it does sort of pay to sort of hold back a little bit build up your city and then cross the red line later on so the second thing that we really like about suburbia is that the goal tiles are not only very rich and varied but like we
said before they do tend to alter the final scoring in quite radical ways it's really quite exciting waiting to see if your opponents have fulfilled the public goals and whether or not you've done enough to to beat them in that regard but then you've also got your private goal that might let you pull the cat out of the bag when it really matters so yeah we do like the fact that a there are loads and loads of gold tiles to choose from and also that it does give you a bit of a hidden in-game scoring that we really like in games like carcassone with the farmers that sort of thing is present in this one love it so the next thing that we really like about this game is that some of the tiles you're gonna be placing in your city directly affect your opponent's ability to gain or lose income right and if this wasn't in the game then this would be just one of them mind-numbingly depressing multi-player solitaire games right but the fact that you've got that little bit of player interaction there not much but it is there does sort of pull this game out of the abyss so the final thing that we really like about this one is that the income and reputation rewards do seem to be quite well balanced if you're going all out trying to get your income up then more often than not your reputation is going to suffer and vice versa if you're going full reputation you're not really going to be able to get your income up to where you need to be so it doesn't pay you to find a balance if you possibly can with the random told you and all that sort of thing but it really does pay you to find a balance between are you going to be a greedy capitalist why are you going to be a
caring sharing community warden so what don't we like about suburbia so the first thing and the elephant in the room here is that this game looks complete and uh crap it looks bloody terrible done it it's washed out it looks like it's stepped out of robocop's copy started it's horrible the theme is sadly lacking in this one there's nothing on the tiles that anchor the theme down and the choice of these horrible yellows greens grazing that horrible bluish steel type thing is is vile there's there's nothing in this game that really makes me think oh that looks really nice because it don't it looks like so the second thing that we don't like about suburbia is that the tiles do seem to be a little bit uninspiring right i mean you've got an airport you've got all these anonymous business tiles that you've got to deal with you've got a couple of restaurants in there but i really can't sort of think off the top and wired about any of the tiles being that interesting that i can actually think of what they are i know there's like an old fog simon here that gives you some population or anything but this game lacks those moments to tell stories it would have been nice had there been some sort of thematic link on the tiles that could prompt you into making out a few stories and played this bloody billions of times but we've never really been able to sort of connect with what's going on in the city and i think that's that sort of lack of human aspect is problem in quite a few
games i think in our review of dinosaur island we did say there's no real human connection with what's going on the board made the game suffer that is readily apparent with suburbia and that's a real shame so the next thing that we don't like about suburbia is that the lakes seem to be just a bolt-on to try and mitigate that incessant feeling of there's nothing i can do i can't afford to buy anything in the real estate market i might be able to afford a community park but if i place it anywhere i'm going to get absolutely mullered it seems to me that when this game was designed it was like oh we've got like a problem here there's gonna be a period in the game where you ain't gonna have enough money your income has taken a battering your reputation's taking a battering we'd better put something in there that basically for no good reason gives you money and lakes do seem to be a bit of a get out clause for that right so a final thing that we don't like about suburbia is that whilst this was quite innovative and new at the time but the slide down and refill mechanism on the real estate market is really starting to feel a little bit tired right i mean when we first played this many many moons ago it was quite an interesting mechanism because you knew that over time things might get a little bit cheaper not guaranteed like other games and you knew that the title was going to come out was always going to be more expensive but now this has been copied 100 billion times we've seen it in so many other games and the shine of that innovation has definitely wore thin so to summarize is suburbia still worth your time and
bother today and in the future so we're going to say probably not it is a truly ugly toll lane game that relies on a complex web of triggers to sort of remain relevant and i don't think it succeeds the mechanisms in this game have been copied more times than i've had or dinners and as a result playing this feels like you're staring at 1970s wallpaper in a modern new build house add to the fact that the two expansions turn this into a complete dog's dinner and suburbia feels like you're wandering through one of them soulless housing estates trying to find the meaning to your sad pathetic existence right so there's plenty of better games that you could play i mean i haven't played every single city building game but you think about quadropolis that does seem to have just that little bit more for my link and a little bit more interesting choices rather than just pick a guitar chucking it down there's seven wonders which strictly isn't a city building game but it's more civilization building going but that is very very quick half an hour's play and it does power the seven and it really does condense down that feeling of creating a city civilization type thing it is fantastic and if you're looking for something that is a simple affair in carcassonne i mean that's laying tiles building a city and it's also got that hidden scoring thing at the end which we love so dearly with the farmers mechanism right so sadly we can't recommend suburbia in this day and age so basically we're going to use it as really really uncomfortable toilet paper so there you go that's suburbia remember if you knew it and
please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below i'll see you next time
you