Skip to main content
Loading video...

Opium, Trade, and Exploitation w/ Cole Wehrle | Board & Book #7

Transcript 46:57

Hey gamers, this is Liz Davis from Beyond Solitire. And for this board and book episode, I have a very special guest. I have Cole Worly, a longtime friend of the channel and friend of mine. Um, and he's here to talk about I know you're shocked. An infamous traffic. How you doing?

I'm doing so well. Thanks for having me on, Liz.

So, uh, for people who don't know what an infamous traffic is, tell us about it.

An Infamous Traffic is the second game I ever designed. Uh, it was designed way back in the Houseian days of 2016 and it is a game about the Opium Wars. And one of the reasons why I worked on it, I made it was because I had never played a game about the Opium Wars and I started learning about them and I was so fascinated by it and I really want to make a game that covered it. So, an Infamous Traffic is a business game. It starts in the 1820s. At that point, uh, opium had been coming into China for hundreds of years. Uh, and it was used medically and recreationally. And it it it was used it was used at pretty low levels, though. And it's it's a little it's a little interesting. I mean, opium was widely used kind of around the world at that time because it was one of the few painkillers that like actually worked. It's also one of the few recreational drugs that like really packed a kick.

uh and but in the 1820s um and actually through um the previous decades in China, it had been it had been uh for forbidden to trade. So it was it was done illicitly mostly on kind of small black and gray markets. And then in the 1820s things started to shift and they shifted because the East India Company realized that they had access to tons of opium production in India. And so they started commercializing the production of opium and trying to use it as a tool to get into markets they didn't previously have access. Now the East India Company, they had a relationship with China. They weren't allowed to trade opium because they didn't want to compromise the fact they were able to trade for silk and for tea and for other things. So they created a a little bit of a little bit of a a getaround where they would get the opium almost to China and then they would hand it off to middlemen. And these were firms owned by Americans, by Brits, by Indians, by Chinese folks. And those firms were responsible for kind of moving the opium into the country. They drop it off, you know, in these and do the do the trades and these little islands off the southern coast of China.

Those islands would later become places like Hong Kong, like these massive cities that were kind of born out of the opium trade. Uh, and the opium trade uh spirals out of control. uh theQing dynasty starts actually enforcing their the laws around its traffic. Uh this angers the British public and a bunch of these traders they went back to London like little babies and they whined and complained until there was military action played. So first Opium War happens. It forces open a bunch of ports called treaty ports on the coast of China. Sort of changes uh the political and economic landscape of China really dramatically. sparks a massive civil war and really shapes what China is going to look like in the in the in the 20th century. It's a fascinating story and it's a story that could have gone a lot of different ways depending on how a specific set of individuals asked uh acted which means it's the perfect subject for a game. So that's infamous traffic in a nutshell.

Nice. And uh you are an expert on this period in history. Um, you know, this is well trotten territory, but for people who don't know your academic background, can we get the quick rundown?

Sure. Uh, I was a literary studies student, but I worked specifically on, uh, the history of the British Empire and and the the literature of the British Empire, but I was I was focused on, you know, questions of communications and trade. And I I really was much more on the history side of literary history than on the literary side. Uh but an infamous traffic I think is one way to look about it is it's sort of like the last piece of this threeame tptic that I've been doing on the British Empire and and it it tries to look at the British Empire through like a number of different vantage points. So you know we've spent time thinking about the great game and the British Empire and how it how it kind of transformed the politics of these buffer statements uh these buffer states and things like Paxamir. uh we looked at uh institutionality and the rise of state sponsored trading companies and John company and with infamous traffic we're turning our attention to the little operators the small private firms that look to make a f a fortune right at the edge of the official line

Nice, and that also makes you the best person to recommend us some reading material about this game, so I'm very excited. Um, so, uh, this is Born and Book. For those of you who've not watched one of these episodes before, I make people who designed historical games tell me what the best books and media related to their games are, and then we can go check them out. So, uh, Cole, what is your first recommendation? We're going to get we're going to get reading about the

We're going to get reading. It's it's the brilliance of the series, Liz, because these history games, they're built of books. And and whenever you see a little bibliography at the end of a rule book, you know it's like the tip of an iceberg. So,

Oh, yeah.

Let's let's hop on the iceberg. So, the first one that I I dearly love is this book by Julia Lavell called The Opium War. Uh, this book is the best quick primer on why the Opium War happened, what it was about, and what some of its implications were. I think it's beautifully written. It's a very breezy read, and it's also the reason why Infamous Traffic exists because a little bit of backstory on the design. And Amab Holland had asked me to start working on a game, and I kind of flippantly said, like, "Well, here are three or four subjects I'm interested in." And she looked at them and said, like, "Oh, like the, an Opium War game? Like, that's kind of interesting. See what you can do with that." And so I had started thinking about it, and then when we went into the hospital for the birth of my second son, Autin, uh, I happened to put this in my backpack.

Like I, you know, I...and I...I just was sitting there. It was one of those, like, kind of long, uh, kind of waiting births that just took a...we...we were in the hospital for a really long time, and while my wife was asleep, I just, like, kind of tore through this book and wrote notes, and the whole game sort of leapt out. Uh, the thing that is really important about this specific book is that it talks about why the Opium Wars is a hard subject to talk about in China, because the "Century of Humiliation"which is a sort of catchall term that's used to refer to kind of the long 19th century in the Chinese political imagination uh, becomes sort of freighted as the the the origin story. It's the original, you know, it's it's the it's the prequel trilogy of like how um communist China thinks of itself and and what it reacts to. And so if you're going to talk about uh like the the rise of communism, nationalism, the Chinese civil war, everything that happens in the 20th century, the Opium War, the Boxer Rebellion, the Taiping Rebellion are all kind of like looming in the background.

And Julia Lavell does a really good job kind of like putting all those things together and showing how this is how and why this is a touchy subject. By the way, it's one of the things that's been really hard about uh the actual development of Infamous Traffic. Uh we have spent a long time on this game in part because we can't print it in China due to its subject matter. So this is a game that will be printing in Europe. We'll be uh has a big complex logistical backend because we're kind of bringing in physical components from lots of different areas to be assembled uh in in Europe. Uh, and that's in part because of the subject matter.

Whoa, that's wild. Um, okay. So, if you're gonna start though, this is the book to start with.

This is the one. This is the one. There there there's a there's a it's a there's a little bit of a tie because this book, Imperial Twilight, which I think came out after I had finished Infamous Traffic, I believe, uh, by Steven Platt, is very, very good. It's a little more zoomed in. So, you're gonna spend more time with British politics with the individual like firm owners in Imperial Twilight, but it's beautifully written. It's very funny. Like, it's funny. That makes it sound like it's a comedy. It's funny in that like rye way that only like scholarly histories get to be funny. I feel like

uh where you're you're watching like the early diplomatic uh missions off to China and they're just like the worst attempts to establish trade relationships and there's these amazing scenes where they're like building this like huge ory that they think is going to impress the emperor and it of course like lands flatly. Uh but but Platt actually the one of the reasons I want to mention him is uh he wrote a book before that that is really excellent which is definitely like my second big big recommend which is called autumn in the heavenly kingdom. Uh and this is a book that is not about the opium wars directly but is instead about the taiping civil war. And the typhing civil war is for me as someone who has like studied this period who had got a PhD learning about the history of imperialism and the British Empire was a subject I knew almost nothing about. Uh if if you had asked me when I was in graduate school, tell me everything you know about the Taiping Rebellion, I'd say it happened in China sometime after the Opium Wars. And I think some a lot of people died, but I really don't know the details. And the story of it is so fascinating. So, China has a reputation for being um or it's like it's really a caricature that happens in the west where people think about China as very isolationist uh in in the 19th century and earlier which is not fully true. They had a different way of thinking about their uh their diplomatic relationships.

Uh but it was a cosmopolitan place. You see a flows of cultures. Things are coming in and out. things are being shared. Uh, and the opium traffic accelerated that. So, you have more missionaries coming in and actually missionaries are really important part of the story of how opium gets into China because some of them have medical training. They're they're bringing opiums as a painkiller and they're handing it out to people. But in in in the Western tradition, often opium would be like dissolved in water and like you drink it like tea or something. Uh, but in in the East Asian tradition, it's often smoked and when it's smoked, it's it's about 10 times stronger. So that there are all sorts of like really interesting subtle cultural differences that were were leading to really different outcomes in terms of like what it meant for opium to be even traded in the place. Now these missionaries, they're not they're not just there to to make a buck. In fact, they're there to to to move Bibles. And there's a disaffected, uh, wannabe bureaucrat who keeps failing his, uh, his civil service exams.

And he, after after, and his family, the whole, the whole future of his family is rioting on this guy basically doing good on his SATs, which are a big deal in, in, in, in Chinese culture and education, especially at this time. And his name's Hong Xaan, and he, he fails like his second or third attempt, and he has a complete nerves breakdown. And look, I had a bad prospectus exam, like I, I, I I, I can feel that like, I I went up to the Garrett and and and wailed but; he he developed a fever, and he has a vision where, uh, he's addressed by Jesus, who says that like, "You're my younger brother, and you need to, like, leave, you need to lead China like out of the shadow," basically. And what, what was happening was, like, he was like deeply influenced by all these missionary pamphlets, and he leads what becomes the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, which is this, this state that emerges kind of back in the hinterland within China, and it is a completely remarkable moment. Uh this is a uh it becomes it becomes like almost a fully functioning state with its own bureaucracy. People are flocking to it and it's sort of like a quasi Christian protoist movement that was reacting really strongly to two things. It it was reacting against what they saw as the corruption of the west a little bit although it's also a Christian movement so it's complicated.

And it was reacting against the theQ theQ theQ theQ theQ theQ theQ theQ theQ theQ theQing dynasty which they saw as fundamentally like outsiders to China. theQing dynasty kind of their their their men choose ethnically. Um, and this this imagined itself like almost as like a protocommunist populist uprising. And in fact, the the typing rebellion gets appropriated by all sorts of different political actors and movements in the 20th century as like the true origin point. Now, this was a really big deal that this movement uh and and and the Civil War that that kind of erupted around it, it killed vastly more people than the American Civil War. And in fact, one of the claims that Platt makes in his book is that the British uh one of the reasons why they didn't intervene in the American Civil War is because the Chinese trade was worth more and they chose to intervene in China instead of the United States. But these things are basically happening co-currently.

So this book is amazing. It is a page turner. It is like an extremely gripping read and you just get introduced to like the most amazing collection of people who are sitting at this like incredible cusp. Like it's they're right in between um you know an eastern and a western order. Even to the degree that we can we can separate those things. Uh we're dealing with the religious and the secular. Um the I'll call it like the capitalistic and the socialistic. Although maybe that maybe that's not even an appropriate way to to use those words. It's it's really it's really something else. And it it it displays the incredible complexity of imperial politics. You know, often times when we do work on the the British Empire, it's really easy to fall into, um, I guess I'll call it like the concistador trap, which is that, like, we have an idea of, like, the worst excesses of imperialism and it's, like, a shiny metal helmet or, like, a pith helmet in a jungle. And those things definitely happened, but there's actually a whole gradient of outputs. And when you start getting into the individual case studies, you realize like, oh, there are these there's incredible diversity of situations that are happening here. So, in the in the Taiping Civil War, the the Second Opium War is sort of brought to a close early in part so that theQing government can then form a very quick alliance with the British to help put down the typing civil war.

And so, obviously, it's like a little more complicated than just like a war, a war of conquest. and And it was put down and, and quite violently not to. Not to spoil the story a little bit, uh, one of the most remarkable things is that we don't really have any images that survive of any of the leaders of the typing Rebellion. The typing rebellion is not that old. I mean, think about all the pictures of Robert E. Lee that you've seen. Imagine that we didn't know what Stonewall Jackson looked like. I mean, it's that level of like complete eraser that has happened since then. And then what ends up happening is you get you get sort of like heroic statues and things get put up, but but in terms of the actual like physical evidence of of this amazing movement, it's completely scanned. And so Steven Platt does this incredible job reconstructing everything. It's very gripping and extremely highly recommended.

That's really cool. Okay, so we're tight for time, but I have to ask, has continuing scholarship that you read impacted your game because you're reworking it after

Yeah.

a span of time. Like, how

you got to cut off somewhere, but I'm assuming things have got in? Well, it's...I mean, it's a it this...this is a great question, because it's every second edition that I've been able to work on has has allowed me to, like, more finely sketch certain, like, elements. And it really...I mean, it's like writing an article or something, right? You revise and resubmit. When when I was working on the first edition, the taiping were essentially like an auto game in trigger where if the trade like got a little out of control, the rules were like, "Oh, the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom has an uprising. The game ends." And when I when I started when when I I hadn't actually read this book yet. I I mean, I had learned a little bit more about the Taiping when I was working on the game, but like I hadn't read this book. And after I read this book, I thought, "No, actually the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom is sort of the back third of the story of this game." And so, even though we cleaned up a lot of rules and simplified the game in other places and made it a lot more streamlined and it plays a lot more more smoothly, we some of that some of that saved budget we then reapplied to saying like, "Okay, let's actually put the taiping in the game." They have these specific dynamics around it."And that's also true for things like uh earlyQing efforts at legalizing opium or policing it in a different manner that would have more things like tariffs. Like now theQing dynasty doesn't have to go right to like a harsh enforcement. There's a whole there's a whole like pop of things that that that might happen. That is all stuff that that that was put in the design because I was reading newer scholarship and also just like more

scholarship.

That's pretty cool. All right. So, speaking of more scholarship,

things of more scholarship,

what's the next what's the next recommendation?

Okay. Okay, cool. So, I'm going to I'm going to do a like a little strange pivot uh because I think this book is so interesting. Uh this is the opium war through Chinese eyes by Arthur Whe.

Uh this is a really neat slender book that is it it's fascinating both for its content and also its context. So Arthur Why uh was a very well-reggarded orientalist in the um in like the truest sense of that word. Like here is a Brit who like likes to translate poetry and he's really interested in eastern languages. Uh and so like all of the problems like Edward Sed's ghost you can you can put him up on your your video here as a little gradient. He's he's here being like Arthur Whe which is all all of those caveats are true. Like is Arthur Why participating in some kind of like um disciplinary dominance of the East in doing his studies? Sure.

But Arthur Why never wanted university posts and he always wanted to write for a general audience. So you have this really interesting dynamic in his writings where he loved the culture of of China and Japan deeply and wanted to to help be a bridge to get people into Chinese poetry and Japanese novels. So I think he's one of one of the early translators of the tale of Genji. Arthur Whe did it and he he has a book. It's called like I think 170 Chinese poems. It's like incredible. And he wrote this book about the Opium Wars in part because he felt like there was a very simplistic story and this was written in the 50s I, think uh about, you know, about dominance and, uh, the the opening of trade, the the celebration of free markets that was often getting told. Like, you can kind of imagine that, like, high British Empire way of reading the Opium Wars.

And he said,"Well, it's it's a little more complicated, and there are these, like, amazing figures."So, like, what was the experience of the Opium Wars like for the bureaucrat Lin Zexu, who was the one who actually enforced a lot of the the the opium policies? And so he goes through, and he is reading diaries and journals and, he he almost is doing like a people's history, where this is a very, like, primary document forward, like, groundup history that really emphasizes, like, the shared humanity of the Chinese and sympathizes with the challenge of trying to enforce this drug that is just sweeping over the country. And then the most remarkable thing about the whole book is that it is written for a general reader. So, normally when you get a book like this, it is not it's like not for someone who's never read a book about the Opium Wars. This this could be the only book you ever read about the Opium Wars, and you're really going to leave with like a lot of specific and interesting knowledge about what happened. So, highly highly recommend.

Interesting. So, this there's always questions. Um, so, you know, you you've got a game that you can't print in China. You've got, you know, reports of a deeply suppressed movement. um and a list of books that are clearly written largely by westerners.

Yeah, sure.

So, how do you approach this topic with sensitivity? And also, what

what can we actually know about something that is so brutally suppressed in its place of origin

for which the evidence is at least damaged? Oh, I mean when you read reports of like folks who go to the various commemorative museums that are kind of like uh trying to frame and understand the history of the opium wars, they are all they all exist for a reason. Like every museum is like an argument. It's like trying to make it's trying to make make a point and use that point. And look, I you know I I don't read Chinese. So I, I have to, I have to come from this, uh, acknowledging my own deficiencies. And I I, you know, this is something that you and I have talked about, but I feel like the greatest treasure of a graduate education is it teaches you to appreciate your own ignorance and to understand it and. that that's a really difficult, lifelong pursuit, just trying to understand the shape of one's own ignorance. I mean it's almost like a philosophical impossibility, right? Uh and and so I've been I've been very fortunate to draw on the works of some close friends who are academics who who work in this field who who can kind of like check my work. Uh but also we have to go in um kind of applying our same good research principles that I would use anywhere else. So for instance, I like the Arthur Whe book because the translations are very direct and he tells you he shows the receipts. He's like look I found this in a journal.

this is what what it says. And he has this amazing moment where he says that the only reason why he cites everything very specifically is so he can be fact checked. He said like please like go look these things up and if you feel like you can if my translation's wrong like please let me know. And so I try to find other people who are working in this area who are clearly like keeping the the receipts and also making sure that I don't fall into um I don't fall into the in into any of the ideological traps. And I fell into a really big one for the first edition. So the first half of the first edition, I had built it uh with the assumption that the opium trade was largely carried out by British firms and was being done like wholly like kind of for like capital I imperialism.

And that was because it fit my narrative, right? So like I I was like, "Okay, well I know the Brits. I heard something about like them being pushers and I kind of imagined them like the Sackler family or something."Um, and what happened in the middle of my research for the game is I started running into these little indications where I'm like,"Oh, there are there actually a lot of non-British firms." Oh, and actually like the way they talk about the opium, like they're really emphasizing it as like it's a it's a it's a painkiller. It's for recreation, too, but like lots of recreational drugs are trafficked and and and in fact, like the the Brits don't introduce it to China. There's like a really long history. like I was erasing all of the the detail. And so when you encounter things that disagree with you, you have to like re reassemble your understanding of something. And so sometimes I feel like, you know, one one of the the biggest jobs that like any researcher, a g a game designer or or even just someone writing has to do is like constantly be on the lookout for things that are challenging your preconceptions. And then if they get challenged, make sure to actually change your approach, right? Because I mean, this is the classic I I remember being in a in a graduate class many years ago where some student piped up and said like, "Oh, I'm like I'm having this problem because I'm like not finding evidence for my claim, but I've written a lot."

And the professor looked at him and said like,"Well, that means that like you might be wrong and you can either write an article about how you were wrong or maybe you you don't write the maybe you have to find a different argument."And it was amazing in that because it seems so obvious, but in an academic context, you you feel for this kid because they've been working on this project for two years and but but it took that much work to realize that it was a bunk idea. And like I've had that I've had to throw away. I made some crazy arguments as a graduate student which mercifully I was able to like kill in the cradle and not have them you know haunt me like that. Um but let me actually give you another like way to get um to get around some some problems. So so this is this is a re this is the other way to start which is with this book Amadev Gosh's Sea of Poppies. This was a Booker short list from like 2008 or nine or something like that. And this is a historical novel. Uh it's part of the Ibis trilogy. There's actually there's there's like a whole bunch of them.

I was really hoping there were going to be novels. I'm so happy right now.

Um Liz, you would love this book. You would you would just love it. Uh the audio book is also incredibly read and is is just extremely well voiced. Uh and I I I I cannot emphasize uh I cannot recommend the audio book high enough uh highly enough. Um this book is part of the uh it's called the Ibis trilogy which the Ibis is the name of a boat that used to be a a blackird like a slave ship that gets retoled to trade opium. And it is a deeply researched historical book. It oozes detail. You will learn so much about how these boats were sailed, how they were captain, who owned them, how did the owners relate to them, what was the connection between the East India Company and the actual Indians or plantation workers? In some cases, they weren't always they weren't always local farmers. Uh how did the opium come in? How was it processed? How were the like the Indian merchant and banking classes, how did they fit into this puzzle? How did it get back to the Americans? What happened when it got to China?

And the the trilogy covers like a lovely set of characters and goes basically until and and slightly into the first Opium War. And it is it is so well researched and so well built and just gripping. And it's doing to me historical novels always fall into into two categories. Uh there's ones that are like having fun with history like they're like ah remember wigs? What if we had a book where everyone was wearing wigs? And I love those. I'm happy to hang with those. But there are others or or like you know I mean maybe not just that there are like there are history books that are trying to humanize um like major events. I think like Wolf Halls is my classic example of this, right? Where it's like let's like really understand Thomas and and Henry and like really make them human.

Um but then there are these other historical novels which are actually trying to like capture a society. And it reminds me that there there's an academic book by George Lucash uh, Garrick Lucos, I never know how to say his first name called"The Historical Novel,"where he says like, the historical novel uses like the novel to help you, as a, as an, you know, an educated reader in your own time, see the past, connect into the past, and kind of like understand how the society, you know, would operate in in a different context, in a different time. And because the these books have characters from all sorts of strata, you get this like amazing picture of a machine.

And it is a very complex picture, but it is it's wonderful. And they're so beautifully written. I mean, the way that like anything that's on the book or short list is like going to be good.

This is this is good.

Well, I've read his um it's a traveal log in an antique land.

Oh, yeah. I've never read that. Is it good?

Really good. It's a great read. Yeah. like and of course I read it because I was digging in Egypt and I wanted to like

hanging out in Egypt. So like um yeah that I I will definitely pick that up because he's a great author. Yeah, I, um, and he wrote a I don't I don't have it with me because someone on staff is borrowing it, but he has a memoir called *Smoke and Ashes*, which is about how he researched these books, which is itself like very good; and, uh, and and just talks about, you know, when he went into the research, he didn't realize how deeply his own family and history be like tangled up in it, because it's one of those things that, once you start looking for who is connected to the opium traffic, like, the tendrils go everywhere. I mean, the thing I'm I'm I'm kind of like lightly worried about is in the new edition, everyone gets a starting card, which just like gives them their their starting enterprise, a starting action.

It kind of like gives them a face. And it was because, you know what, one of my like slight complaints with Premiere is I wish that players kind of knew who they were. It's tricky because in the game you're playing the connections between people, but as a player sometimes it's nice to just look down and be like, well, I'm that guy. And almost every player identity is like a name that people might recognize like Forbes. Like yes, that Forbes is like the that that fortune is like based, you know, in the opium traffic and just over and over again like these major uh I think almost every named character who is a playright ending the game uh still has uh like an ob like a going concern. It's some firm is related to them and you know maybe they're still involved in global commerce or maybe maybe it's just it's just money at this point. Uh but but it feels very like real.

That's honestly horrifying.

Oh yeah, it's scary stuff. It's scary stuff. Oh, I mean like Roosevelt's grandfather or dad was like an opium trafficker.

Whoa. That's um like see the things the past always comes back to haunt you, right? Even if it's just on cardboard. Yeah, it's true. It's true. Yeah. Feel feeling the ghosts. Uh so I've got like two tiny ones, two two little babies.

All right. Some little

um and and this actually gets to your question of like what do you how do you account for the things you don't know, right? Because like a book a book gets you partly there, but it's not the only way to like access access the past. Uh when I was in the UK in 2023, I went to the British Museum and they put on a exhibit, a special exhibit called China's Hidden Century, which was about the 19th century. And uh it was actually like I think even partially curated maybe by Julia Lavell. I'm not I'm not sure exactly who was who who the curators were. U but it was really remarkable and it was this amazing collection of of objects. And then later, mercifully, University of Washington Press put out uh a a museum guide. Basically, it was like a they had adapted the exhibit to a very large glossy book which is just like filled with the things that were on exhibit

uh but but actually like it's quite written too like you actually learn a lot about the history here. Now when we do historical projects uh at Worly Gig and and you know now now we have a larger staff because we're integrated with Barry Giant but it's really important that like I'm not just doing the design work and the the research I actually want to be helping with the look of the game. So I got to sit down with Patty and Megan and we like looked through these books in close detail. And what we were looking for was was not just the historical details, which are great in the book, but it was things like the color, the textures, pieces of art that we might want to see if we can get access rights to, um and, and tried to make sure the game, uh, could like fully capture the material history. And so, for instance, you know, this this like kind of blue teal, which you see on fabric and clothing, that's going to inform like the color of the box.

We started finding that like actually even though I had used like gold for a lot of the colors in an infamous traffic, I was kind of thinking about more late 19th century like ching flags, but actually the earlier things are like much more in blue. And so it actually shifted a bunch of the color spaces of the game in really like lovely ways. And then this book is supplemented by uh creators of modern China which they also published which basically anytime the larger kind of art book uh references references a biography it will like tag this book and then this book actually has like a lovely selection of biographies in it including like here are 10 business people. So, like, let's learn about, like, why, like why, so so much of the supply chain for opium was managed and operated by Chinese firms. Like, who are they? What were they trying to do? What, what were their interests in all this? And, uh, there is no better thing that you can do and, and you certainly know this, I'm preaching to the choir when you're working on a historical game, than look at some objects or touch some objects that are connected to the period.

Oh yeah. Yeah. Yeah, material culture is such a key I think underappreciated thing. Um, you know, I think I think we're maybe remain so, right, but we're very bookdriven culture when you want to learn something.

Yeah.

Um, but the objects that remain are important, too.

Yeah. There and and it's and it's a thing that like it's hard to get access to. So, I'm like very thankful that these books exist because I I walked through through that exhibit very very quickly when I was there because I was, you know, being stupid. I should have spent I should have spent I should have extended my trip. I should have spent extra days there. But I was so delighted when the museum published that special exhibit as a volume because it allows you to enjoy the work of all those curators. And I mean and the the British Library is such a it is a it is such a uh how do we even say it? It's like it's a treasure full of stolen treasures, right? Like just because they're stolen doesn't make them any less tre like more treasure any less of a treasure. And so when when you see them put on an exhibit like this, like it it is something that I'm so thankful I have I have easy access to all these textiles. But also it for for the um for the game, it has it has been a good reminder that like we have to spend time like looking at a wide set of collections including like everyday objects from the Victorian Albert and really get into the material the materiality of of the of of the period. Not just because I want to make sure like the map cartes look period appropriate. Uh, and not just because it would be nice if the tiles in the game were using like historically appropriate materials, but because sometimes when you examine those objects, you learn kind of like unexpected things.

Yeah. You know, there there's like a lovely detail in um in Sea of Poppies where one of the characters is exposed to opium smoking for the first time, and she like sees a pipe that she's never seen before, and it's like an East Asian like opium pipe, and it's this amazing detail. And I started looking up these pipes and realized like, oh, they're actually like those pipes were never really made in India at at that time, like they would they would have been imported. they would have come because sailors happen to have them,

right?

Uh, and it it just sort of like it grounds everything in in in the object. And like fundamentally, when we're making games, we are making objects. Like at the end of this process, I get to kind of like toss an infamous trophic second edition into the same like giant pile of refu that is all of history and it will add to the material culture in its own its own small small way.

Okay. So, this actually leads me to question. I mean, you play a lot of historical games as do I. Um, do you like to play the game and see what it teaches you and then do some reading or do you like to do some background reading and then approach a game?

I usually play the game first, but but games are always linked to books for me. Like I think I I remember when um I I well I don't know. I think I I've done a I've done it both ways. I I remember when Martin Wallace's God's Playground was announced and I thought, "Oo, what a striking title. I wonder if it's going to be about Vikings or something."And then I did some research and I was like,"Oh, no. God's playground is a book by Norman Davies about Poland and it's this like interesting uh study in nationalism and and I so I went to the university library. I think it was an undergrad then. So I I remember like walking up in the Wells Library and discovering that God's Playground was like a two volume massive history of Poland. And I so greedily read it. I checked that book out and I just I just hung out with God's Playground. And then when I got the game, uh, it all it all resonated. It was like all the notes, all the colors are so much brighter when you like see the work that goes into them. I had a similar thing happen when I read, I think it's Ian Tol's books on the Pacific War while I was learning how to play Empire of the Sun.

And it just like it really deepens the the experience. And then, you know, sometimes you stumble into a game and it sort of worms its way in your mind and you spend a lifetime reading books about that same subject because you just you get kind of stuck in it. Yeah, for sure. So, for people who play Infamous Traffic and maybe that's the only exposure they ever had the Opium Wars, what are you hoping they walk away with even if they read nothing from this list?

I hope they I hope they get a sense of the complexity of the story. So, I mean, well, there are layers to it. The first thing I want is I want them to understand the Opium Wars happened like that. I mean, it's so funny like I I mean, for a lot of folks who who maybe have never even heard the phrase Opium War or they're like, "Oh, Infamous Traffic, that's a game about drug sales." Fine. If that's all, you know, that gets you to the table, that's great. But what I want them to realize is like these were these were drugs that were moving into a country uh by not by CD elements, but by like the great philanthropists of their age and and and by by fortunes and commercial firms that still exist today. and they bent the the the two greatest powers uh maybe on earth at that time, the theQ theQ theQ theQ theQ theQ theQ theQ theQ theQ theQing Empire and the British Empire, they were they were the those empires were brought to to heal by a bunch of of of basically rich jerks.

I mean, if you walk away from the game with nothing else, I would want them to realize that all of the, all the propaganda, all of the, the kind of grandeur of the British Empire or theQing dynasty, it didn't matter because there were, there were people who wanted to make money and they were able to bend official policy towards pretty untored aims. And if that if they get nothing else from traffic, that's the main thing because it is it is remarkable that both opium wars were quite unpopular. They happened anyway and a lot of people died.

It's almost like we could have modern lessons for today.

I don't know. Maybe it's almost like the study of history is also the study of the present.

What? Uh so do you have any other books in that pile?

No other books in the pile. No other books in the pile. other books in the pile.

We made it. I told you we could do it.

Is there anything that you are afraid that you've missed or not read in preparation for Infamous Traffic?

That's such a That's such a good question. I um I want to learn. So, one of the things that happens to me, this happens to every every game that I do, I always think, "Oh god, there was a whole other game that could have existed about X that I that is just not here." And I was reading Arthur Whey's uh his book uh the open wars through Chinese eyes and reading about Lin Zexu and the the struggle of enforcement and how difficult like how how difficult enforcement was and just the internal politics uh in theQing dynasty. I thought that is a great subject that I would have to do so much more research about the internal workings of theQing dynasty in order for that to make any sense. and actually the broader story of uh theQing state's projection of power in the southern part of China. And this involves like I mean all sorts of colorful characters and interesting pirates. Uh and and it's really happening like in the late 18th and early 19th century which is slightly out of scope of the game. That is a great subject for for a game or for a book or for a movie or for all three and I am completely unprepared to do it.

So, and I've actually started and the game is is largely done outside of some development and balancing but I have started, uh, reading about the Boxer Rebellion and kind of like working forward because I'm finding that like there's just so much more to the story. And every time I like learn about some consequence of the of the Opium Wars, I wonder, like, is there a way I can foreshadow? Is where I can, I can kind of backwards project this just a little bit into an infamous traffic? So, I mean, the short answer is like so much like an impossible an impossible amount of of new detail. Um, and and and and you know, thankfully, uh, if they could make a hundred games about the Battle of the Bulge, I think we can stomach a few on 19th century China.

I I think that is very very much the case. Yes. Um, so you mentioned, oh, this would be a great movie. Are there any good kind of pop culture movie TV show um instances where this the period for infamous traffic is depicted that you think are worth watching

With some, so I none that I can recommend with firsthand, uh, like I haven't seen any. However, however, um, there are, there's a very like kind of interesting show about the East India Company and broadly, uh, like the the the kind of color of of the of the whole situation, which is: there's a TV series, um, which I think like Tom Hardy worked on called Taboo uh, which is which is pretty interesting, and it like kind of connects like I'll call it like Sidi Victoria with the East India Company in really compelling ways. Uh but I I actually have not seen any I haven't seen any movies that have like attacked the Soviet. I'm sure they exist. I'm sure they exist.

Like if no one has adapted Sea of Poppies yet, I don't I don't know what we're doing.

Uh probably another Spider-Man or something. Um uh and um I guess one more question I'll ask then is you know you said this is your little tripick about the British Empire. So what is the next project that you feel fully committed to? So, we are probably going to be doing Hellraisers next, which I'm very excited about. Uh, there are some like dev details and schedule things that we're still kind of sorting out. And then I am working on the reconstruction game in a real way. So, like I am I am finally ready to do it. And Liz, it every time I work on it, it gets bigger. So, currently the reconstruction game is like maybe three games and will also require like a multi-year engagement to get right. Uh, it's still early on, but like that's where I want to go. And then there are all of these other things about the British Empire that have not been covered. Like I actually have not spent much time dealing with what Robinson Gallagher would call like the official mind of the imperial state. Like the high imperialism of the 19th century. I haven't like touched and it's really interesting and strange and it would be it would be fascinating to start to peel apart the the complex story of of the the British and Africa and of Europeans in Africa generally. uh especially in the 19th century because it's extremely undercovered and it's a very difficult topic. And so I I'I would love to address it because it's it's that actually is very close to my to my research like to do a game that uh features Richard Burton in some

meaningful way would like really would really be a lovely thing to to try to tackle. But those are huge projects. So the priority is get my prototype of the uh reconstruction game working and and and firing on all cylinders. And hopefully that is the work of next year and beyond.

Awesome. Sounds like another board book in the future.

I know. So many book it's an impossible library there.

All right, couple salty questions just for fun. Uh what is a just a book that you've read recently that you thought was really good?

Uh what is a book that I Oh my gosh. Okay, panicking. Uh name a book. Um I I'm going to give a really weird suggestion, but uh we are I'm going to Essen in a few weeks as are you. I'm very excited. Uh and this time uh I'm taking the whole family. They're not coming to Essen, but we're going to like spend a little time in Germany together. And so we have been reading uh German children's books, not in German, books that were originally written uh in German. And

not just Triple Ger, I hope.

Yeah. No. Uh, but we we uh I've been reading The Never-Ending Story, which I never read, and is so good as a book. I I you know, I don't really even know what I think about the movie, but the book is beautifully written. And most recently, I've been reading a book called Emil and the Detectives to my children. And it is so winsome and so charming, and it's just highly recommended if you want like a short little novel to if if you have kids, you want to read a lot or just want to enjoy a YA novel. It's very very charming. I think it's from from the mid-century, but Emil and the detectives.

Hell yeah. And uh if you want to be found online, this is not you're not hard to find, but where do you prefer to be found for people who want to follow your work?

I think Blue Sky is best. My DMs are open and I check them uh somewhat frequently. D Yeah, I'd say Blue Sky next. You can also find me on Discord. Um we have uh the the the World League Discord because World League is essentially an imprint of Barry Giant. There's a lot of uh conversation that happens about our games there. And then also if you want things that are slightly more tilting into Berry Giant territory, uh you can find me on the Berry Giant Discord, too.

Awesome. Cole, thank you so much for coming on. This was awesome. And it's not like my TBR wasn't already huge, but it got bigger.

I cannot wait to chat about Sea of Poppies with you because I think you're going to love it.

Oh yeah, absolutely. Uh all right, everybody out there. Um I can be found anywhere online beyond solitire. Please like, subscribe, comment, ask questions, and most of all, happy gaming or in this case reading.

Progress saved