Skip to main content
Loading video...

Secret Societies: My Favorite Mechanism

Transcript 5:58

Hey, Jimmy from Stonemaier Games and today I'm going to share my favorite mechanism in the game Secret Societies. This is from Garfield Games and it is an auction game, probably the heaviest auction game I've ever played. Uh but I really like how they leaned into the elements of progression in the game. Each player has a player mat. Not shown here, but it is in the actually you can kind of see it in the background. Each player has a player mat where they can improve their ability to participate in the auction. They improve uh they they gain land mass that they can use in the game. They're gaining population because players are playing as secret societies auctioning off the different countries around the world. Um it's kind of a love letter it may not it's may not sound like this, but it is actually a love letter to geography and it really is. Like it's neat to see these different countries come up and see which countries have bigger land masses, bigger populations, which countries are islands or not. That is an aspect of the game. Um that matters because you actually want to try to get countries that are adjacent to one another as you're playing.

Um Before I get to my favorite mechanism, I guess I'll mention a few quick things about the game that I really appreciate. One is you can see in the background here there are these green tokens. I don't know how up close you can see them. Yeah, here's here's a few of these green tokens. These are tokens. And in many games where you are indicating um things that you've completed or progress, the game will give you something to use to to keep track of that. Like it'll give you some tokens that you put on a track. It'll give you some cubes that you can just grab from the supply whenever you want. Secret Societies does something a little a little twist on this and they say if you want to track your progress, you need to have this resource. You need to have the land to use. These tokens represent land. You need these tokens. You need to earn these tokens before you can use them. Even though land is not a uh is not a resource to spend in the game. It is a resource to use to track your progress. But if I want to put these green tokens right here, I need to spend uh technology. I need to spend a different resource. If I want to put them down here to improve my ability to participate in the auction, I need to spend population. So, you're actually spending something else, but you need to have you need to have already earned or gained these land mass tokens to use to track your progress, to actually activate these different abilities that you want to spend resources on. So, I thought that was kind of neat and a neat little tweak.

Um one other little thing, let's see if I have a photo of this. Yeah, right here. This looks like a spiral-bound notebook, but in reality this is actually just a series of cards in a specific order that walk you through the game round by round. I believe it was a seven-round game. I might have that wrong. Either six or seven rounds. Um and these are actually really really helpful because there are different things that you're doing each round and I like that the game just gave you a uh uh you know, some cards that tell you exactly what to do round to round and when you are finished with one card, you flip to the next page in this book and you do the next thing that step by step that it tells you to do. Really really helpful resource for all players to use in the game. Now, my favorite mechanism in the game is just a general tweak on auctions that I thought was very very clever, which is uh when you lose an auction you actually gain something. And this is really important because when you auction when you use one of these cards, these are cards that you use to auction in the game. And you can do a different couple different things with them. So, for example, if I use this four-value card, if I put it in an auction and I don't do anything else, I just have it face up, it is a four-value card in the auction that means that if I win that auction, I need to spend four gold if I choose to actually win the auction.

This is where you're auctioning to try to win different different country. I need to spend four. I could, however, as I play this card, I could put a few different I could put up to three coin tokens on it. And if I lose the auction um win or lose the auction, I need to spend those three tokens. If you lose it, I spend them I spend those three tokens even if I lost the auction. And so, the game needed to give you in addition to that, the game needed to give you a some sort of compensation if you lose an auction. There's also actually one other thing you can do with these cards, you can put one of them face down per round. But when you do that, you can put fewer extra auction tokens on them, which I thought was clever. But with these the other thing this card tells you is when you lose an auction with this card, this little thumbs down icon, you actually gain in this case a population. Every card for each different secret society has a different benefit that you gain when you lose that auction. A few of the cards have actually something that you gain when you win the auction. But I thought this was really clever because there are moments in the game that you A wanted to win an auction and you didn't. And so, it is a slightly feel-bad moment, and but the game gives you something to work with. There are also times in the game where you simply don't have the money to spend to win an auction or you really want to focus on winning one auction but you have to put out two of these cards per round. And so, you'll just toss another card on a different auction that you know you can't win because you get the losing benefit. That is really clever.

Giving players a reason to purposely lose an auction simply to get a little benefit that they need is another way to collect a resource that they don't otherwise have access to. I thought that was really really clever in Secret Societies. So, yeah, that is my favorite mechanism mechanism in the game. A reason to lose an auction and or a compensation that you gain when you lose an auction that you didn't actually want to lose want to use. And the cards themselves have different lose benefits on them. So, not only is it a choice as to which auction do I want to lose or am I am I okay with losing, but which card do I use to lose that auction when I do. Those are some of my favorite mechanisms in Secret Societies. I'd love to hear your thoughts if you've played the game or if you can think of another auction game where you A have engine building and progression or B have a active reason to lose an auction. I'd love to hear about that in the comments below.

Thanks.

Progress saved