A Game of Cat & Mouth Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About A Game of Cat & Mouth
Reviewers tend to agree that A Game of Cat & Mouth is a loud, quirky flicking game with a strong look, but they disagree about how well it holds up over time. The BoardGameBollocks channel placed it in a revised top 50 dexterity list and called it a decent flicking game that is cheap, nice to look at, and highly recommended. In a separate video the same channel took a harder line after playing it heavily with children over the holidays. Its verdict was a hedged "possibly not" for anyone who mainly wants a disc-flinging game, with a cheap Le Pass Trap clone suggested as the more practical choice.
Watch It Played approached the game from the perspective of a reviewer who usually struggles with dexterity titles. That reviewer described it as the most fun dexterity game they had played and praised the magnetic launcher as a genuinely clever piece of design. The contrast between the two channels is useful: one is weighing durability and value for a family table, while the other is focused on the simple pleasure of making the ball fly.
Core Mechanics That Define A Game of Cat & Mouth
Magnetic cat paws that fire without elastic
Each player locks a magnetic cat's paw onto their side of the open box, then pulls it back and releases it to shoot a yellow ball through the openings in the cat's head. Watch It Played was struck by the fact that there is no elastic band involved. The magnetism of the base snaps the paw back and sends the ball on its way, which the reviewer found more impressive than expected. BoardGameBollocks was similarly impressed that the paws held up under hard shots, staying magnetized and in place rather than sliding off or launching themselves across the room.
Three ways to win around the nose and the teeth
The single black ball sits in the cat's nose and the three white balls sit in its teeth. A player can win by emptying their own yellow balls, by knocking out the black nose ball, or by getting all three white teeth balls onto the opponent's side. BoardGameBollocks noted that the black ball is set to a slightly tighter fit than the white ones, so it does not drop out as easily, and that this detail makes the game feel more distinctive than the basic disc-through-a-hole games it resembles. A round is decided as soon as one of these conditions is met, and the winner of that round is the player who achieved it.
The A Game of Cat & Mouth Experience
Frenetic and chaotic, with a stop-start rhythm
BoardGameBollocks described the gameplay as frenetic and genuinely manic, comparing the energy to the Le Pass Trap and Pucket style of play but adding more routes to victory. Balls fly in every direction, and the game is at its best when both players are firing quickly. The same reviewers felt the flow was interrupted whenever a ball left the arena, because play had to stop so someone could retrieve it from the floor. That interruption, along with the small balls being fiddly to pick up, turned out to be one of the main frustrations of a game that otherwise wants to be fast.
A bizarre, colorful look that gets a reaction
The cat's head is the centerpiece, and both channels returned to its appearance. BoardGameBollocks said the table presence is striking enough to feel like stepping into a psychedelic nightmare, and recalled the first remark from their children, who asked what the cat had dragged in. Watch It Played was more focused on the mechanism than the art, but still found the game a delight to flick around. The overall feel is playful and a little unsettling, which seems to be exactly what the designers intended.
What Makes A Game of Cat & Mouth Stand Out
A design that rewards a second look at the win conditions
BoardGameBollocks argued that the most interesting part of the game is how the three white teeth balls and the black nose ball change the decisions players make. Because there are multiple paths to victory, the game can suit players who want a more involved experience than a simple empty-your-side race. The reviewer was clear that this extra layer is what separates A Game of Cat & Mouth from cheaper imitators, even if the white ball rule has its own weaknesses.
Affordable, compact, and easy to set up
The box itself serves as the board, so there is very little to set up beyond placing the cat's head, the cardboard borders, and the balls. BoardGameBollocks described the game as pretty cheap and easy to get on the table, and Watch It Played noted how quickly it could be opened and put into play. For households that want a dexterity game without spending much, that combination of low cost and quick setup is a major part of its appeal.
Potential Drawbacks
The white teeth balls can become a shortcut to victory
BoardGameBollocks raised the most detailed criticism of the rules. Once the three white balls have been pushed out of the teeth, the win condition for getting them into the opponent's area becomes much easier, since a player only needs to move three balls rather than the full set of eight yellow balls. The reviewer felt this made the white ball mechanic feel redundant after the early game, and described the shortcut as a bit of a cheap way to win. The black nose ball, by contrast, was seen as fine because it takes only one or two hits to dislodge.
Build quality that may not survive heavy play
The biggest concern from BoardGameBollocks was durability. After extended play with children over the holidays, the flimsy cardboard sides had already started to bend, the box showed wear from being opened and closed repeatedly, and scuff marks were appearing under the cat's paws. The reviewer felt the striking visuals were masking a cheaper build, and was unsure whether the game would hold up to the same level of use. Watch It Played did not share this concern in their video, but the other channel's experience suggests that buyers who expect heavy use should consider the sturdiness of the components.
If You Enjoy A Game of Cat & Mouth
- Le Pass Trap fans will recognize the core flicking-into-a-hole idea, and BoardGameBollocks suggested that a cheap Le Pass Trap clone is a decent alternative if the cat's head design does not appeal.
- Pucket players who want a heavier, more stable version of the same style should look at the reviewers' comparison, since the weighty pucks in those games stay put more reliably than the lighter balls here.
- Exploding Kittens fans may enjoy the design pedigree, since both channels linked A Game of Cat & Mouth to the team behind that card game.
- Dexterity list browsers who want more flicking variety might also check Flip Ships, which BoardGameBollocks recommended for its space invaders style disc flicking, or Fubi, which the same channel described as a very simple and quick table game.
- Families with kids will find the game draws the whole table in, as one reviewer put it, with their children enjoying the chaos enough to calm down their sibling rivalry for a while.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I'm usually garbage at dexterity games and this one is no exception. It's by far the most fun one that I've ever played though."
— Watch It Played
"The frenetic gameplay is actually really really manic."
— BoardGameBollocks
"A game of cat and mouth is a decent flicking game that is pretty cheap it looks nice and yeah it's highly recommended."
— BoardGameBollocks