A Study in Emerald Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About A Study in Emerald
A Study in Emerald, the 2013 game for two to five players based on Neil Gaiman‘s short story, draws a divided response from reviewers. The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast treats it as a favorite. The host ranks the first edition 40th on a top 50 list and says the hidden-role structure is the part the host finds most exciting in any game of that kind. Drive Thru Games takes a much harsher view. After playing it three times, that reviewer placed the game ninth on a list of disappointing releases from 2014, describing it as cumbersome and awkward while still calling it interesting to play. The two reviewers agree on the core appeal of the hidden allegiances, but they differ on whether the surrounding systems support that appeal.
Core Mechanics That Define A Study in Emerald
Hidden Roles and Team Allegiance
The game divides its players into Loyalists, who defend the status quo under the Old Ones, and Restorationists, who fight to free mankind. The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast explains that players do not know who is on their side at the start. Their actions on the board, whether they disrupt or support the Old Ones, gradually reveal their role and that of their teammates. Players then begin to coordinate more closely with the people they are fairly sure are allies, though the reviewer stresses that certainty is never complete because a deceptive player may be hiding among them.
Drive Thru Games describes the scoring twist that makes this structure unusual. Teams are judged so that a player‘s result depends partly on the teammate with the fewest points. The reviewer explained that if a teammate finishes last, nobody on that team can win, so a second-place player on another team may take the game. For the reviewer this created a sense of frustration, since a strong individual performance could be cancelled out by an ally‘s weak one.
Deck Building and City Control
Deck building forms the other half of the design. Players use influence cubes to bid for the right to draft cards and to take control of cities. Drive Thru Games notes that the game combines some deck building with area control over different parts of the city. Reviewers suggest that these two systems are where most of the game‘s complexity lives. The reviewer felt the deck building and control elements were each reasonable on their own but became crowded when combined with the hidden-role layer.
The A Study in Emerald Experience
Suspicion and Deduction
Reviewers repeatedly describe the early stages of play as the most engaging. Players are trying to read the table, weigh each opponent‘s moves, and decide who is trustworthy. The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast says the best moments come from asking whether other players are tricking you, and that this tension is "going on in this game in spades." The feeling is one of constant second-guessing, where even a teammate‘s loyal-looking move can be a deliberate deception.
Cumbersome Complexity
The opposite feeling runs through Drive Thru Games‘ review. The game is described as "very interesting to play" but also "really cumbersome and really awkward," and the reviewer says it never became satisfying over repeated plays. Instead of a smooth flow, play can feel like managing many overlapping systems at once. The reviewer also reports that a later revised version was reported to be more paired down, a change the reviewer hoped would make the gameplay cleaner.
What Makes A Study in Emerald Stand Out
A Sherlock Holmes and Lovecraft Mash-Up
The theme receives consistent praise as the game‘s distinctive hook. The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast describes a world where the Old Ones have already taken over and humanity lives in servitude, which gives the rebels a clear and dramatic goal. The setting draws on Neil Gaiman‘s short story and blends the logic of Sherlock Holmes with the cosmic horror of H.P. Lovecraft. Drive Thru Games notes that the design‘s difficulties led the publisher to lose some fans who came for the basic story, which shows how strongly the narrative draws people in.
Appeal to Fans of Hidden-Role and Team Games
Reviewers who enjoy hidden-role games see a lot to like here. The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast recommends the game specifically to anyone who likes hidden-role and team games, and the host‘s enthusiasm rests on the fact that the game keeps the suspicion going for much of its length. Drive Thru Games, despite its disappointment, still suggests that players at least try it, noting that the team structure is "very interesting to play." That combination of strong interest and mixed satisfaction is part of what makes the game a discussion point.
Potential Drawbacks
Overloaded Rules and an Awkward Team Structure
The most consistent criticism is that the game asks players to track too many things at once. Drive Thru Games says the design has "too much kind of thrown in," and the reviewer felt that the complexity made the experience awkward. The team scoring rule adds to the problem, since a player can play well and still lose because of a teammate‘s standing. Reviewers who value clean, streamlined play may find the rules and team logic more tiring than rewarding.
A Note on Availability
The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast notes that the first edition is hard to find, since it is out of print and the second edition has replaced it. Readers who want the version discussed in that review may need to look on the secondary market. The second edition is the more accessible option, although the reviews quoted here discuss the original design, so the experience may differ from the current release.
If You Enjoy A Study in Emerald
Players who enjoy A Study in Emerald‘s sense of narrative and mystery will find similar satisfaction in Tales of the Arabian Nights. Tom Vasel of The Dice Tower uses that title as a shorthand for a style in which players sit back, let the story unfold, and enjoy the unfolding of events. That experience differs in structure from A Study in Emerald, but it appeals to the same interest in story-driven play. Drive Thru Games also groups A Study in Emerald with Battlestar Galactica and Dead of Winter as the kind of hidden-information, social-tension games that the reviewer enjoys in principle, which makes those titles natural next steps for players who like the hidden-role tension but want a different balance of rules and drama.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"The exciting part is the beginning when you‘re trying to figure out where you sit in relation to the other players, what side they‘re on, who‘s with you and who‘s against you. And even more so, are any of them tricking you? That is going on in this game in spades, and that‘s why I love it so much."
— The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast
"It‘s really cumbersome and really awkward and very interesting to play and probably one I would recommend you at least try but at the end of the day it didn‘t end up being very satisfying."
— Drive Thru Games
"You don‘t know who‘s who when you start this is kind of a hidden roles game and that‘s the part I think is most exciting in any hidden role game that I‘ve played. You have a team member or two but you don‘t know who they are."
— The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast