Advanced Squad Leader Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Advanced Squad Leader
Advanced Squad Leader (ASL) is a World War II tactical wargame that reviewers consistently describe as a major, long-lived system rather than a single game. The reviewers in this overview treat it as a reference point for the whole hobby. Watch Review calls it a behemoth of the wargaming hobby and says it remains one of the seminal designs of its kind, a view that holds even though discussion of it on BoardGameGeek has become less frequent than in past years. Board Game Hangover points to the sheer size of the ecosystem, describing it as a hobby within a hobby, with a large body of expansions and modules that few other titles can match.
The strongest source of firsthand experience is Zilla Blitz, which has tracked a long learning journey with the system across several monthly updates. Early episodes describe starting with the Varville scenario and the starter kit rules before moving toward the full rule set. Later updates describe slow but steady progress, a missed promise to publish a dedicated ASL video, and a plan to bring the system into a regular play rhythm. That honest arc is useful context: the community view is that ASL is rewarding to learn but demands patience.
Core Mechanics That Define Advanced Squad Leader
The two mechanics reviewers return to most often are hex-based tactical combat and a modular, layered rule system. Both are inferred from how reviewers describe the play experience rather than from a formal mechanics reference.
Hex-based tactical combat with squads and leaders
Reviewers repeatedly frame ASL as a hex encounter game. Watch Review describes it as a hex encounter game built on unit movement and tactical resolution, and notes that its design ideas have been picked up by many later titles. Board Game Hangover describes the core loop in plain terms: a squad with an objective, moved hex by hex across the battlefield. Each game focuses on small units, from individual squads and leaders up to vehicles and ordnance, so the tactical picture is built from many small decisions rather than from abstract resource counts.
A modular system built from layered rules
The second mechanic is the modular structure. Zilla Blitz calls ASL a very complex World War II tactical combat system and notes that it has gobs of modules and content available, which makes it a lifetime type of game. Reviewers describe a ladder of learning: the starter kit introduces infantry and sports guns, the full rules add more systems, and individual modules extend the setting. Players can begin with a single scenario and expand from there, which is both the system's main appeal and the source of much of its complexity.
The Advanced Squad Leader Experience
Two vibes come through most clearly in the transcripts: a crunchy, detail-heavy feel and an epic, long-horizon feel.
Crunchy: dense rules and high decision weight
Rules density is the feature reviewers talk about most. Board Game Hangover jokes that the game has rules for sand, rules for rain, and then rules for the rules themselves. That humor reflects a real experience: each rule added for terrain or weather creates another decision layer, and the tactical choices are meaningful. Players who enjoy weighing options against each other tend to find that the detail rewards them over time.
Epic: a lifetime game with long-horizon play
The epic quality comes from scope and longevity. Zilla Blitz describes ASL as a lifetime game, and Watch Review places it among the defining war games of its era. Reviewers do not describe a single grand session. They describe a system that expands across years of scenarios, modules, and campaigns, so the sense of scale builds gradually.
What Makes Advanced Squad Leader Stand Out
Deep, modular content
Reviewers praise the breadth of material available for ASL. Board Game Hangover describes the system as a hobby within a hobby, pointing to players who play, players who paint, and players who build out the modular library. For someone who wants a long-term tactical project rather than a one-off box, that depth is the central attraction.
Influence on later tactical design
Several reviewers position ASL as a historical anchor for hex-and-counter design. Watch Review argues that its influence is visible in games discussed on BoardGameGeek and elsewhere, and that it is a huge force for that style of wargame. Few titles in the genre have a comparable claim to shaping how later designers approached tactical combat.
Potential Drawbacks
A steep and time-consuming learning curve
The learning curve is the most consistent concern across the transcripts. Zilla Blitz admits that progress has been hard and that getting the starter kit level down took repeated attempts. The same creator later says the project lost ground for a period and failed to deliver a promised video on schedule. Reviewers do not present this as a flaw of the design itself, but they are clear that ASL asks players to invest real time before the system starts to feel smooth.
Table space and session length
Setup and play time are the other practical barrier. Zilla Blitz explains that the difficulty was partly logistical: setting up a large game for a short session meant it was hard to make steady progress. The creator says a dedicated table would make it easier to learn in short, spread-out sessions. Players without a permanent play space, or with limited evenings, should expect the same friction.
If You Enjoy Advanced Squad Leader
Reviewers point to a short list of related titles. Watch Review suggests that the system grew out of earlier designs, and recommends exploring Tactics One and Tactics Two as the historical roots of the squad-level approach, even while noting that many players never encountered them. Squad Leader, the original system that ASL reorganized and redesigned, is the most direct companion. Players who enjoy hex-based tactical combat with squads and leaders should look at the original before tackling the full modular library, because the predecessor shows which core ideas ASL built on and which it expanded.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Advanced Squad Leader is a very complex World War II tactical combat system that's pretty much the standard, I would say, for complex, deep, meaty World War II tactical combat systems. And it's got gobs of modules and content available to it.
— Zilla Blitz
Advanced squad leader is a tactical war game where you get a squad and you have an objective to do and you will move those characters and why it has so much stuff because it has rules for sand. It has rule for rain, it has rules for rain and sand.
— Board Game Hangover
I do feel like Advanced Squad Leader is like this behemoth in the wargaming hobby. I do see people talking about it on Board Game Geek all the time, although I think that's diminished a little bit. So to me it seems like one of those real seminal kernels of game design now.
— Watch Review