Andean Abyss Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Andean Abyss
Andean Abyss is a COIN series wargame about Colombia in the 1990s, where guerrillas, drug lords, and paramilitaries contest the state. The three video discussions gathered for this overview do not reach a single verdict. The reviewers range from openly hostile to genuinely curious, and the gap between them tracks closely with how much each person already enjoys war games.
The Brothers Murph sit firmly at the skeptical end. They open by saying they do not play war games and especially avoid COIN titles, and they describe the game as mostly for Mike, the member of the group who does play them. Their verdict is blunt. They call it their least favorite game ever made, and they are candid that they are not the audience for it.
Zilla Blitz takes the opposite view. The video is an interview with Volko Ruhnke, the designer of the COIN series, and Ruhnke treats Andean Abyss as a foundational release. Ruhnke presents it as the first volume of a line that has since grown through multipacks, expansions, and COIN-style games from other publishers. Watch It Played falls between these positions. The host has not played the game yet but places it on the short list of titles they most want to try, drawn by its look more than by a specific mechanic.
Core Mechanics That Define Andean Abyss
Card-Driven Operations and Events
The most concrete mechanical thread in these discussions is card-driven design. The interview traces the card-driven game lineage through Mark Simonitch's Hannibal, a Roman versus Carthage design, and Mark Herman's We the People. In that lineage, the operations and events sit on the same card, so a single play can do both. Ruhnke's point is that Andean Abyss rests on this foundation. Ruhnke states that there would be no Andean Abyss and no COIN series without card-driven games as an art form for historical war games.
Lessons Carried Forward From Earlier Designs
The second feature reviewers touch on is design inheritance rather than a single rule. Ruhnke says the game stood on other designs because the designer was learning from previous ones. The reviewers did not walk through the turn structure in detail, so this mechanic is best understood as the way the design was assembled: a historical war game built from proven card-driven ideas and then refined for a counterinsurgency subject.
The Andean Abyss Experience
The Pull of the Laid-Out Board
Watch It Played describes the appeal in aesthetic terms. Seeing the game played has a visual effect on the host, who says it triggers the things they like when a board game is laid out. For a viewer who has not yet sat down with the game, that appearance is the main hook. The host's interest is curiosity about the table rather than a claim about how the game plays.
The Weight of a War Game
The Brothers Murph describe the experience from the other side of the table. Their opening statement is a plain refusal: they do not play war games, and they especially do not play COIN games. That reaction points to the feeling of a dense, committed wargame, the kind of session that requires a player who is already comfortable with the genre. For this group, the experience is less about fun and more about enduring a format they dislike.
What Makes Andean Abyss Stand Out
The Foundation of a Long-Running Series
The clearest praise in these videos concerns Andean Abyss as the start of the COIN series. Ruhnke describes the first volume as the work that started something that is still flowing. The line continues through GMT's main volumes, multipacks, and expansions, and into COIN-style games that other companies such as Compass publish. Ruhnke presents the design as the seed for all of it.
The Designer's Own Measure of Influence
Ruhnke was asked to name the design that has most influenced the state of the art, and the answer given was Andean Abyss. The criterion was personal and tied to the designer's own sense of progress, which makes the answer a notable endorsement from the person who made the game. It frames the title as a reference point in the designer's own body of work rather than a footnote.
Potential Drawbacks
A Narrow Audience Within a Group
The most direct criticism comes from The Brothers Murph, who describe the game as mostly for one member of their group. That framing suggests the game asks a whole table to accept the time and attention of a wargame when only one person is motivated to play it. For groups without a dedicated wargamer, that mismatch is the central concern.
An Unwelcoming Genre for Newcomers
The same review shows how a genre barrier can end a game before it starts. The Brothers Murph state that these kinds of war games have always been their least favorite, and they say they hate this game so much. The concern is not that the game is poorly made, since the reviewer offers no complaint about its components. It is that a non-wargaming player is unlikely to find the experience worth the effort. Watch It Played has not played the game, so its perspective adds no evidence on this point either way.
If You Enjoy Andean Abyss
Readers who respond to Andean Abyss have a clear path forward, because the discussions point to a family of related titles.
- Other COIN series volumes. Ruhnke's interview presents the series as a long line of games that grew out of the first volume, with multipacks and expansions available. Players who like the approach can move through the series in order.
- COIN-style games from other publishers. The interview notes that Compass publishes games in the same style, so the design approach is not limited to GMT's catalog.
- We the People by Mark Herman. Ruhnke names this card-driven design as part of the lineage the series depends on, making it a natural precursor for anyone curious about where the approach began.
- Hannibal by Mark Simonitch. The interview places this Roman versus Carthage game at the start of the card-driven operations and events tradition that Andean Abyss builds on.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I don't play war games. I especially don't play like coin games. Andy and Abyss is all for Mike. These kinds of war games are always be my arcs. It's my least favorite game ever made."
— The Brothers Murph
"Now, Andy and Abyss stood on other designs, too, because I was learning from previous ones and and there would be no Andy and Abyss and no coin series if it wasn't for CDGs as an art form of historical war games, which means no We the People by Mark Herman, no coin series, right?"
— Volko Ruhnke, Zilla Blitz
"Andy and Abyss is currently on my list of games I really want to try out. Joel lady from driveth through review really sold me on that with his review video and I've seen it being played, it just kind of triggers aesthetically when I see it, like things that I like when I see a board game laid out."
— Watch It Played