Cave Evil Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Cave Evil
Cave Evil, the 2011 game about rival necromancers digging toward the Darkest Pit, is known mostly through enthusiasm rather than broad acclaim. On the Going Analog show, the host brings it up alongside Postcards during a conversation with Double Fine founder Tim Schafer, and the host is openly delighted by it. The host found the game after starting with Sushi Go, then searching for heavy metal board games, and describes Cave Evil as the most heavy metal board game available, saying it is "really unapologetically black metal and it's just great." Tim Schafer adds that the game has a lot of Brutal Legend in it and that it would be a fun way to explore that world. The conversation treats Cave Evil as a passionate fan favorite rather than a mainstream hit.
The Dice Tower coverage is much lighter. In a list-style mid-games episode, Tom Vasel admits to knowing little about the game and says it has its own small following of people who enjoy it. Tom Vasel's comments offer a shrug of recognition more than a verdict, so the community picture here is mostly one of a cult title with a loyal, opinionated core.
Core Mechanics That Define Cave Evil
Digging Lairs and Summoning Minions From the Mud
The Going Analog host describes the game as one of excavation. Players dig out a cave, and evil wizards summon forces out of the mud of the cave being dug. That digging is the thematic engine behind the army-building the game is known for, where resources and body parts are gathered to raise minions. The host emphasizes that the artwork across the cards shows these wizards and their creatures in the middle of the summoning, so the mechanic and the theme reinforce each other.
Last Necromancer Standing
The win condition gives the game its escalating, mean-spirited finish. The host sums up the goal as trying to kill all the other necromancers and jump into the pit, and notes that an evil goat or a horrible lich king can eventually pop up to end the game. Defeating rivals in combat is the obvious route to elimination, and the second route, having a minion crush your Chthonic Crystal, keeps every player's defenses under pressure. Reviewers treat this blunt race to be the last one standing as part of the fun rather than a flaw.
The Cave Evil Experience
Unapologetic, Over-the-Top Horror
The most consistent feeling in the discussion is that Cave Evil commits fully to its horror and metal aesthetic. The Going Analog host calls it a very evil game and says it is still really fun, with the grotesque tone treated as the point rather than a veneer. The host places it within the designer's run of horror portfolio games, including Freakface, Don't Let the Walls Eat Our Baby, and See Evil, describing that family of titles as horrific but really fun, over-the-top grotesque adventures.
A Wargame-Adjacent Table Presence
Going Analog ties Cave Evil to the tactile culture of wargames. The host describes classic wargames as hex maps with cardboard pieces and stat cards, and says the designer's games arrive in slim portfolio magazines, where players lay out a paper map and punch out a great deal of cardboard. That hobbyist, hands-on feel is part of the appeal, and the host says it opened up a whole subculture of board games. Tim Schafer frames the same kind of appeal through world-building, suggesting the game rewards players who enjoy stepping into a dark, specific setting around the table.
What Makes Cave Evil Stand Out
Art That Never Lets Up
The Going Analog host points to the sheer volume of art, saying that across hundreds of cards, every single one carries a unique piece of grotesque evil artwork. The style is deliberately rough. The host jokes that it looks like a stoner friend drew it in a geometry book, and the remark reads as affection for an unpolished, committed look. The result feels like one consistent piece of black metal art rather than a generic stack of fantasy cards.
A Gateway Into a Heavier Corner of the Hobby
The Going Analog host came to Cave Evil from lighter fare, having started with Sushi Go and then searching by theme. That path is part of the game's standout appeal: searching for something that matched a taste for heavy metal led to a title that opened the door to heavier, wargame-adjacent board games. The host's enthusiasm extends to the designer's other grotesque portfolio games, which makes Cave Evil feel like an entry point into a small but passionate corner of the hobby.
Potential Drawbacks
A Small, Devoted Following
Cave Evil is clearly a niche title. Tom Vasel on The Dice Tower says the game has its own little sub cult of people who enjoy it, and the Going Analog host similarly frames it as part of a subculture rather than a mainstream favorite. Players who want a game that most of their friends already know may find few people at the table who recognize it, and neither channel presents it as a crossover success.
Rough Production and an Extreme Tone
The art is a double-edged feature. The Going Analog host finds the stoner-doodle look charming, but someone who expects polished, clean illustration may read it as unfinished. The tone is similarly intense: the host describes the game as very evil and leans into its grotesque imagery without apology. Groups who prefer lighter themes, or who have players uneasy with extreme horror, should expect a table that is intentionally over the top.
If You Enjoy Cave Evil
Brutal Legend is the most direct comparison in the discussion. The Going Analog host says that Brutal Legend the board game is a lot like Cave Evil, and Tim Schafer makes the same link, saying the game has a lot of Brutal Legend in it.
Freakface and Don't Let the Walls Eat Our Baby are the other comparisons the Going Analog host raises, presented as more games from the same designer's horror portfolio line. The host recommends them as horrific but really fun, over-the-top grotesque adventures. See Evil, which the host describes as being about an evil ocean, is grouped with that family too. Players who enjoy Cave Evil's tone will likely find these titles a natural next step.
For a contrasting evening, the Going Analog hosts joke about pairing Cave Evil with Postcards on the same night, a light and beautiful game about traveling through France that makes a deliberate counterpoint.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"It's really unapologetically black metal and it's just great."
— Going Analog
"I don't know much about this game but I know it has its own little sub cult of people who enjoy it."
— The Dice Tower
"All the art in it looks like it was drawn by your stoner friend in high school on your geometry book."
— Going Analog