Chants for the Old Ones Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Chants for the Old Ones
Chants for the Old Ones, published by Invedars in 2024, is still being discovered by most of the reviewers who have covered it. The available discussions come mainly from preview coverage and personal list videos, and the speakers are candid that much of their enthusiasm rests on the premise, the box art, and the rulebook excerpts they read before the game reached their tables. Board Stupid, which featured the game in a pre-Spiel most-anticipated list, admitted the title arrived as a surprise and that the hosts knew little about it beforehand, yet described its look as absolutely great and its theme as a reason to be excited.
Board Game Buzzz offers the most hands-on perspective. In its top 100 series, one host described having played the game only once, with a co-host teaching the rules, and said the session left a strong impression. Hosts on Board Game Buzzz also mentioned backing the game on Kickstarter, and the Essen preview framed the title as a welcome reversal of the usual cosmic horror setup. The consensus across these voices is enthusiasm for the theme and presentation, paired with an open question about how the game holds up across repeated plays.
Core Mechanics That Define Chants for the Old Ones
Worker Placement
Reviewers describe Chants for the Old Ones as a worker placement game at its core, but the workers are cultists. Board Game Buzzz explained that each player sends a cultist onto the board to take an action, such as gaining books or knowledge, collecting new followers, or sacrificing people at the center of the board. The host who had played the game said worker placement is a natural fit for the theme, since the mechanic mirrors the act of dispatching followers to advance a dark plan. Board Stupid also framed the design as building up a cult to summon the Old One, which keeps the placement decisions tied to the story rather than to abstract resource gathering.
Deck Building
The second mechanic reviewers highlight is deck building, which connects directly to recruitment. Followers collected during play join a player's personal deck, so the cult grows more capable as the game progresses. Board Stupid described the design as a deck building and worker placement hybrid, while Board Game Buzzz noted that collecting cultists strengthens the deck over time. Together, the two systems mean that every recruit both feeds the summoning plan and changes what a player can do on later turns.
The Chants for the Old Ones Experience
The Thrill of Playing the Villain
The most vivid description of the table experience comes from Board Game Buzzz, which emphasized that Chants for the Old Ones asks players to be the villain. Instead of the investigator trying to stop a looming entity, the player is the cult leader racing to raise it. The host called the sacrifice mechanic one of the favorite parts of the game, because the cultists are expendable and the player's real loyalty is to their own rise. Board Stupid reacted with open delight at the prospect of living out a cult leader fantasy, and that selfishness gives the game a wicked edge that stands apart from the usual cosmic horror experience.
Playful Dread
Reviewers also describe the tone as dark without being grim. Board Stupid praised the art for a cartoony style rendered in a darker way, and felt the presentation suited the theme. Board Game Buzzz described the game as spooky enough to sit comfortably alongside Halloween-themed titles, and the morbid humor of sending followers to their doom gives the table a playful unease. The result feels more like a wicked romp through a cult's ambitions than a slow, oppressive investigation.
What Makes Chants for the Old Ones Stand Out
A Reversed Cosmic Horror Perspective
The feature reviewers return to most is the change in perspective. In many cosmic horror games, players spend their time racing to stop the awakening of a dark power. Board Stupid stressed that Chants for the Old Ones flips this setup and places players on the side of the summoners. Board Game Buzzz's Essen preview described the premise as Cthulhu-themed while casting players as cultists trying to raise the creatures rather than banish them. For reviewers who enjoy the genre, that inversion is the main reason the game caught their attention.
Theme Carried Through Art and Presentation
Presentation is the second standout. Board Stupid called the artwork gorgeous, a cartoony style with a darker edge that looks phenomenal for this kind of theme. Board Game Buzzz's top 100 host noted that the spooky feel makes the game a natural fit for a Halloween table, and said an expansion is something the host is eager to learn once more base game sessions are behind them. The combination of art, theme, and room to grow gives reviewers the sense that the game is built to be revisited.
Potential Drawbacks
Thin Hands-On Evidence So Far
The most consistent caution is that many opinions are preview impressions. Board Stupid admitted the hosts knew nothing about the game beforehand, and the Board Game Buzzz Essen preview stated plainly that the hosts did not know whether the games they were highlighting would turn out to be good. Enthusiasm built on box art, theme, and rulebook excerpts is valuable for anticipation, but it does not yet tell a buyer how the game plays over a full session or how its balance holds up across multiple plays.
A Learning Curve Before the Game Clicks
The Board Game Buzzz top 100 host had played the game only once, and a co-host had to help teach it. The host said more base game sessions were wanted before moving to the expansion, which suggests that repeated play is part of how the game is meant to be enjoyed. Reviewers did not present this as a fault, but groups new to worker placement and deck building should expect a first session spent learning the rules and the rhythm of recruiting and sacrificing followers.
If You Enjoy Chants for the Old Ones
Players who enjoy the blend of worker placement and deck building in Chants for the Old Ones will find a similar satisfaction in Hogwarts Battle. Board Game Buzzz described it as a straightforward, approachable deck building game whose story moves through increasingly chaotic years. The shared appeal is the pleasure of adding stronger cards to a personal deck while a larger narrative pushes the whole table forward.
Players drawn to the spooky side of the theme should consider Ghost Stories. Board Game Buzzz described it as a long grind of holding back a growing threat, with villagers and ghosts constantly demanding attention, and noted that the host plays it every October. That cooperative tension differs from the competitive cult race, but it captures the same feeling of a table that is always scrambling to keep up with the darkness.
Players who enjoy the worker placement side should look at Mutagen. Board Stupid highlighted that its workers activate different actions depending on where they are placed and can be upgraded, which echoes the idea in Chants for the Old Ones that every placement changes what your followers can do.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"in a lot of games is always like trying to um to beat the culties before the old ones arrive try to punch culu in the face and kill it or set it on on fire this one you actually on the other side."
— Board Stupid
"In this game, you get to play as a cultist, and each person has their own individual creature that they're trying to summon to the earth. Because you want the glory and you want that evil power."
— Board Game Buzzz
"chance for the old ons is a game where like it's cthulu but instead of like being the ones trying to like banish the the creatures that are coming to the Earth you're actually a cult member trying to raise and you're trying to bring them you're trying to raise raise the demons so it's going to be I'm really looking forward to it."
— Board Game Buzzz