Skip to main content
Clans of Caledonia box art

Clans of Caledonia

Game Info
Year
2017
Players
1-4
Age
12+
Playtime
120 min
Publisher
Collection
Ratings
Mechanic profile
Percentile rank vs. all games
Vibe profile
How this game feels to play
Description

Clans of Caledonia is a mid-to-heavy economic game set in 19th-century Scotland. At this time, Scotland made the transition from an agricultural to an industrialized country that heavily relied on trade and export. In the following years, food production increased significantly to feed the population growth. Linen was increasingly substituted by the cheaper cotton and raising sheep was given high importance. More and more distilleries were founded and whisky became the premium alcoholic beverage in Europe.

Players represent historic clans with unique abilities and compete to produce, trade and export agricultural goods and of course whisky!

The game ends after five rounds. Each round consists of the three phases:

Players' turns
Production phase
Round scoring

1. Players take turns and do one of eight possible actions, from building, to upgrading, trading and exporting. When players run out of money, they pass and collect a passing bonus.

2. In the production phase, each player collects basic resources, refined goods and cash from their production units built on the game map. Each production unit built makes income visible on the player mat. Refined goods require the respective basic resource.

3. Players receive VPs depending on the scoring tile of the current round.

The game comes with eight different clans, a modular board with 16 configurations, eight port bonuses and eight round scoring tiles.

Description

Clans of Caledonia is a mid-to-heavy economic game set in 19th-century Scotland. At this time, Scotland made the transition from an agricultural to an industrialized country that heavily relied on trade and export. In the following years, food production increased significantly to feed the population growth. Linen was increasingly substituted by the cheaper cotton and raising sheep was given high importance. More and more distilleries were founded and whisky became the premium alcoholic beverage in Europe.

Players represent historic clans with unique abilities and compete to produce, trade and export agricultural goods and of course whisky!

The game ends after five rounds. Each round consists of the three phases:

Players' turns
Production phase
Round scoring

1. Players take turns and do one of eight possible actions, from building, to upgrading, trading and exporting. When players run out of money, they pass and collect a passing bonus.

2. In the production phase, each player collects basic resources, refined goods and cash from their production units built on the game map. Each production unit built makes income visible on the player mat. Refined goods require the respective basic resource.

3. Players receive VPs depending on the scoring tile of the current round.

The game comes with eight different clans, a modular board with 16 configurations, eight port bonuses and eight round scoring tiles.

Ask a Rules Question
All mentions
Browse transcript mentions, sentiments, pros/cons, mechanics, topics, quotes, and references.
Total mentions: 71
This page: 50
Sentiment: pos 42 · mix 2 · neu 3 · neg 1
Mentions per page
Showing 1–50 of 71
Video -nPCICIryRo All You Can Board Discussion at 16:23 sentiment: positive
All You Can Board - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 16:23 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Why are these games still here? Why do we still own these?
  • The longer you've been playing games, the more games you've played, the further into your...personal board game quest that you get, the standard is kind of always going up.
  • Why do we cling to games? And do you think that it can be boiled down to something as simple as like like hope, you know, opportunity, stubbornness, sentimentality?
  • There's this nostalgia aspect. And it's nostalgia is the wrong word, but it's it's sentimentality, I think is what I'm looking for, where it's it's a game that I felt like I kind of stumbled upon, really liked, was able to highlight it on the channel.
  • I feel like is is worth discovering because it's sort of this undiscovered gem for a lot of people.
  • it was also pricey, right? It's a more expensive game, so there's also that like Have I given it a fair shake yet?
  • Like, am I ever going to really be someone who actively plays Vital Lacerda games?
  • I think the question I want to ask is one that Dylan has been asking and saying throughout this episode is like what are you what are you missing if you don't have it?
  • I think I feel will will feel better getting rid of games that I'm not playing because Yeah, there there is always going to be like these scenarios where But like if there are if there are I'm going to have games for those scenarios.
  • really just being real with yourself, I think.
  • Like the closest I have, and I brought it up already, to like a regret of a game I got rid of is New Fjord
  • So I'm not losing any sleep over it, I would say.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video dD-bT0uYZoM Chairman of the Board Review at 0:03 sentiment: mixed
Chairman of the Board - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:03 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Well-designed and put together
  • Clean and simple game mechanics (aside from one scoring element)
  • Strategic depth with multiple elements to consider (market, contracts, objectives)
  • Unique player powers add replayability
  • Good pacing for individual turns, though overall game pacing can vary
  • Nice aesthetics and artwork
  • Good incentives for board exploration
  • Doesn't allow players to do everything, forcing specialization
Cons
  • One scoring mechanism (goods popularity) felt overwrought and convoluted
  • Game arc felt flatlined with a lack of highs and lows or memorable moments
  • Player interaction is loose with limited direct conflict
  • Components are a bit small
  • Solo mode is described as bland, competing against previous scores
  • May not offer a lot of scope for exploring different strategies
  • Can be frustrating if players are much slower than others, leading to long waits
Thematic elements
  • euro farming
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Majority — Scoring is influenced by controlling clusters of farms within shipping distance of each other.
  • contract fulfillment — Players aim to fulfill contracts to gain points and rewards, with rewards often being money, upgrades, or advancements on scoring tracks.
  • Resource Management — Players manage a budget of resources like wheat, cows, and sheep, and can produce milk, beef, lamb, alcohol, or bread.
  • Set Collection — Collecting and delivering specific sets of resources is required to fulfill contracts.
  • Stock Market/Commodity Market — An active stock market allows players to buy and sell resources, with prices potentially fluctuating based on supply and demand.
  • Tableau Building — Upgrades can be made to a player's unique player board.
  • Variable player powers — Each player receives a unique ability at the start of the game that influences their strategy.
  • Worker Placement — Placing workers on the board can increase income each round.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • The clans of Caledonia which is a euro economic start board game for wonderful players picks for an hour and a half to play.
  • It's pretty much about your management of money you know how you're going to spend your money most efficiently and to ultimately fulfill those contracts to get the points.
  • The end-of-round objectives are very varied.
  • The game kind of works in this aspect where you going to keep taking actions until you run out of actions or run out of money and you pass and the first person to pass is going to take more income.
  • Personally I thought it was a little bit all that part of the game of though it was a little bit overwrought and maybe could have been simplified to you know just just streamlined a bit more because it just seemed like it a little bit convoluted for the sake of it.
  • I wouldn't play this with more than three players because again just up down time I wait for other player's actions.
  • It falls at about a 7 out of 10 for me where if I'm looking to play an hour and a half to two hour game I want to pay you know an 8 or a 9 out of 10 and also your 10 out of 10 at this point.
  • It felt like it didn't have the highs and lows of what I won in the game it's very much quite as I said quite flatlined and there was no real memories of excitement.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 7cEWZa9yTL0 Board Game Sanctuary Analysis at 21:25 sentiment: positive
Board Game Sanctuary - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 21:25 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I had a really interesting thought I thought what if I rated my entire board game collection by sight
  • 4 out of four would be like a really fantastic game that really does well in what it sets out to do
  • Empires of the Void still yet to dive into that probably a 2 out of four for me at this point
  • um not much of a fan of agricola unfortunately
  • forcing myself to do that was probably therapeutic in itself
  • it kind of made me my mind think okay really love these are my top t one games and these games are kind of like on the CP for
  • I do all of this uh on the lowest of budgets
  • it's just purely out of passion that I do this and it brings me so much enjoyment
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video bCafx8zrTP4 BoardGameBollocks Discussion at 0:29 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:29 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Really good
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • farming simulator, empire building
  • 19th century Scotland
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Harvesting and Exporting — Players are trying to harvest stuff on the land and send it out.
  • Modular Board — The game features a modular board.
  • Special Clan Abilities — Players have special clan abilities.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is a very odd you are going look so good Drewry dick thing
  • everybody's got an alien ability and it's yeah you know you know what cause making careful is don't you
  • throwing your comrades under the bus when you need to
  • this is an early early early kids going by the Games Workshop and it even comes with a silly songs tape which we have actually listened to
  • If you haven't played dr. war you need to play this
  • It's a bit like something doing a wet fart
  • It's a wonderful two-player game where one person is trying to fend off the other person from broken into their stronghold
  • It's really weird but it's it's so good it's so good so good
  • you've got the shifting maze going around moving as far as you can in the maze and then you'll be taken at all and replacing at all with an avatar
  • so Legos part free I would carry on a little bit but my knees I can't because I'm quite old
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video fcvhWbdOR8g All You Can Board Discussion at 2:19 sentiment: positive
All You Can Board - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:19 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Host is really digging it and wants to try it with four players.
  • Host feels it will be a favorite version of the Terra Mystica-esque system.
  • Host anticipates it will feel like a tighter, cleaner design.
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Player Count Experience — The host discusses wanting to try the game with four players to experience the contention on the board and compares it to Terra Mystica.
  • Solo Play — The host mentions playing the game a lot solo and digging it, but wanting to try it with more players.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I'm learning that I have to be better in tune with differentiating what is novel and what is a gimmick.
  • It's hard to sometimes differentiate and sometimes it could take many plays before you realize that okay now the the rose-color glasses are off to like this interesting concept and now do I act how do I actually feel about this?
  • I find that like I have to get through the process of like my interest in the newness or the unexpected before I can truly know how I feel about it.
  • But games like Hot Streak and Magical Athlete, I I I will I like I I enjoy the experience of them, but I don't think I I think I have like really cooled on them.
  • It's just there's other games I would rather play.
  • It's hard to remember specific little variances of something familiar whereas that novel experience especially in a big group.
  • novelty in a hobby like this is subjective. It matters what you played first, right?
  • But it makes me think of it as a slightly less novel game.
  • I don't necessarily in my head equate Rhino Cana anymore with being a novel designer. I I almost equate him with being sort of like an expert designer that he knows what he does well.
  • I don't expect a ton of novelty from him these days.
  • And it's like, you know, when musicians do a new album and come up with a completely new style because they're just like so sick of doing what they're known for, right?
  • But I think iteration is essential for game design to continue to progress in the way we want it.
  • I value novelty more whereas in video games I'm like getting closer to valuing novelty more but for a long time I valued nostalgia more.
  • I want to discover the next Hades, the next Hollow Knight because they're phenomenal and the next Elden Ring, right?
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video plM_1KzGQo4 BoardGameBollocks Review at 0:15 sentiment: mixed
BoardGameBollocks - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:15 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Small box size
  • Infinite replayability from modular board
  • Varied and balanced special player abilities
  • Wonderful and simple market mechanism
  • Resources are always available
  • Tasty choices between marketplace and own production
Cons
  • Components (tokens) are too similar, causing confusion
  • Too similar to other games like Terra Mystica and Agricola
  • Rulebook is poor, with hard-to-find information and unclear explanations
  • Port placement is unbalanced
Thematic elements
  • Economic engine building
  • Scotland
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Expanding units on the main board and considering shipping distance.
  • contract fulfillment — Obtaining and fulfilling export contracts.
  • Engine Building — The core of the game involves building an economic engine.
  • Marketplace — A dynamic market where prices fluctuate based on player actions.
  • Set Collection — Collecting goods for export contracts and endgame scoring.
  • Technology upgrade — Players can upgrade their technology for benefits.
  • Worker Placement — Players place merchant cubes on market spaces to buy or sell goods.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • hello welcome back to the ball games 4k YouTube channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings and we generally talk a load of bollocks
  • we're here in the wonderful Langston Harbor just by olive so let's crack on with this review
  • everyone will take one action until everybody's past
  • easy peasy in it
  • so the last thing that you can do is you can pass and what you do when you pass your movie mark on eternal track to the next available space to take the money based on that spice world be 16 14 12 10 and that means that you will go first in the next round
  • you'll get twelve richer points if you've completed the most export contracts you get six fix your points have you completed the second most number of export contracts
  • and the player with the most victory points will win clans of Califonia
  • we do enjoy this game
  • remember if you knew it then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video P5FA9cDt14I The Dice Tower Top List at 0:12 sentiment: positive
The Dice Tower - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:12 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Clan abilities offer special abilities
  • Satisfying economic engine
  • Market fluctuates with every transaction
  • Enjoyable end-game scoring for import goods
  • Depth of strategy
  • Low randomness
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Competing historic clans expanding wealth and influence
  • Scotland in the 19th century, transitioning from an agricultural to an industrialized society
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — On a player's turn, they're going to do one of the possible eight actions from building to upgrading, trading, and exporting and importing.
  • Area Control — Players represent a historic clan competing to expand their wealth and influence through trade, production, and export.
  • economic engine building — Players are going to be expanding their production ranges to collect more raw materials to proc them into items to hopefully export.
  • market fluctuation — The market in this game fluctuates with every transaction by the players.
  • Variable player powers — Each player gets their clan, which will allow them to do a special ability for one portion of the game.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • The theme for this one is definitely a little on the weird side. Interesting, but weird.
  • It's this whole dice management piece that I find so engaging for this game, looking at what is rolled and figuring out the best way to use my actions.
  • It's an incredibly tight game where every single action and coin earned or spent needs to be thought through thoroughly to make sure it's the right move to be making.
  • The game is so tight on resources and actions that you cannot afford to make any improper use of your current resources. You cannot afford to make any mistakes.
  • This is just what I'm looking for when I have my mind set on a, you know, really thinky heavy game.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 8E-wlqJ0R5M Top List at 10:20 sentiment: positive
Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 10:20 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Variable clans provide direction
  • Map interaction creates tension without conflict
  • Volatile market adds depth
  • Interesting scoring based on rarity of goods
Cons
  • Could feel overwhelming without clan direction
  • Rigid plans rarely survive first contact
Thematic elements
  • Clan development and trade
  • Scotland (implied by name)
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Majority — Encouraged to build next to each other for bonuses.
  • economic engine — The market aspect... Everyone is buying and selling.
  • Resource Management — Trying to scrape up enough coin or goods.
  • Set Collection — Fulfilling contracts provides imported goods (tobacco, cotton, sugarcane) that score points based on rarity.
  • Variable player powers — The variable clans are huge for me. They give direction... It's often going to help you determine your initial placement and set your strategy.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This was my number one game for a couple of years, and it could absolutely reclaim that spot.
  • The shift from canals to rails is one of the most satisfying arcs in board gaming.
  • It's not cooperative, but it's also not cutthroat. It's symbiotic.
  • This is one of those games where every time I play it, I'm reminded just how elegant the design is.
  • The multi-use cards, and I still think they're one of the smartest implementations of that idea.
  • The deluxe version uses multiple colors which is a big step up.
  • the combination of depth, elegance, and sheer enjoyment is why Lronha sits at number one.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Ow3V4zWB82o Stonemaier Games Analysis at 8:36 sentiment: positive
Stonemaier Games - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 8:36 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • I think that's a clean system. Just have a single resource that that does actually persist unlike some of these other examples that I I've given.
Cons
  • You're giving up all those turns and some probably some sense of progression.
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Money as primary resource — Players receive a large amount of money at the beginning of each round, which is then spent on actions.
  • Persistent money — Money can be carried over between rounds if not spent.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Hierarchy may have been a better example because in hierarchy the goal of the game is to simply play a higher numbered card than the other player.
  • And what they do is they let you play almost any card face down. And that card is used as a resource from then on.
  • Terra mystica is a great example of a game that gives you a um a miniame to generate resources.
  • Patchwork is the game that I referred to that uses time as a resource.
  • Forced Shuffle and Finsspan are two games that say you get to spend any card from your hand as a as a resource.
  • And the last example, I think one of the most clever resource systems I've ever seen in a game, and it isn't even exactly a resource system, but this is Keyforge.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Fl6FGvhzaxU BoardGameGeek Top List at 18:20 sentiment: positive
BoardGameGeek - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 18:20 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Surprisingly deep economic system.
  • Interesting supply and demand market.
  • Satisfying production chains.
  • Classic Euro look and feel.
  • Variable clan powers.
Cons
  • More economic than expected.
Thematic elements
  • farming, economic, clan development
  • Caldeonia
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — on the kind of shared main board. you're going to be putting out various like farming industries.
  • contract fulfillment — on top of that, you're fulfilling contracts.
  • economic simulation — there's like a little market with not stocks but basically like a supply and demand type of thing.
  • production chains — You can put out wheat farms and those wheat farms will give you two wheat. You can turn those wheat into beer or you can turn those wheat into bread.
  • Variable player powers — Each clan is going to have some kind of little bit of a special power.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I really want to be a farmer, but I don't want to like get dirty and stuff.
  • What do I What do I do? Play a farming game.
  • What's up everybody? My name is Nick. I'm Mike. We are the Buzz Murf. Today we're talking about our top 10 farming games.
  • I feel like farming games are such a trope in board games.
  • Viticulture. Uh classic uh I guess you're running a vineyard which is a sort of a type of farm.
  • So, you're trying to kind of build that infrastructure, you know, get your sellers built, get wine production going through those vines, uh, making use of some of those visitor cards as you go, uh, and then start selling those wines to produce those bigger hits of points and kind of execute that that back half of the game.
  • super duper fun, you know, modern classic.
  • Our number one is going to be Kverna the cave of farmers.
  • Kverna is one. I got a huge affinity for dwarves.
  • So it's this kind of dual game where you have your outside farm and then you have the inside you're kind of dwelling your cave dwelling which is hence the cave farmers.
  • the game is a big Uve Rosenberg game, but you don't have all the actions at once.
  • Kverna in terms of farming games. It's kind of like that ultimate farming game to me.
  • We wouldn't be here without a Gricola.
  • I would prefer to play Kver. That's all it is.
  • Let us know your top 10 farming games down there.
  • There's a lot of different ways you can look at farming.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Mtz386BxJ_c JestaThaRogue Analysis at 3:50 sentiment: neutral
JestaThaRogue - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 3:50 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
neutral
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Scottish
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • 81% of the top 100 does not line up with the community opinion.
  • Almost every game on the most respected board game ranking in the world asterisk has a gap between what the box says and what thousands of players actually think.
  • The box time is more accurate than the player count, but it assumes you know what you're doing.
  • First play is almost always longer than the box suggests.
  • The box minimum time appears to be collaborating for two players, not solo.
  • The box time, were accurate at all, is based on experienced players playing with the optimum player count.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Mtz386BxJ_c JestaThaRogue Analysis at 8:54 sentiment: neutral
JestaThaRogue - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 8:54 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
neutral
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • 81% of the top 100 does not line up with the community opinion.
  • Almost every game on the most respected board game ranking in the world asterisk has a gap between what the box says and what thousands of players actually think.
  • The box time is more accurate than the player count, but it assumes you know what you're doing.
  • First play is almost always longer than the box suggests.
  • The box minimum time appears to be collaborating for two players, not solo.
  • The box time, were accurate at all, is based on experienced players playing with the optimum player count.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 8jjgRsDVt8Q Top List at 10:28 sentiment: positive
Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 10:28 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Has everything the reviewer loves in games.
  • Super thinky and strategic.
  • Great economic mechanics.
  • Great Scottish theme.
Cons
  • Seems to be lower on the list because it's a friend's game and hasn't been played enough personally.
Thematic elements
  • Building a Scottish clan/economy
  • Scotland
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — it is like some of the other games it's area control
  • Market manipulation — when you buy something the value goes up because of demand and then when you sell to the market the value goes down because of you know it's supply and demand
  • Resource Management — you're also um producing different main resources like milk and wool and you have livestock and things like that but then you can also refine those resources to make cheese and make whiskey and things like that
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • super fun I love pulling these out around the table and just hearing people scream when they're when they're getting close to exploding and trying to decide if you're going to push your luck or not
  • I have a LoveHate relationship with Concordia
  • Ford is very cute
  • for me the reason why I like it over most deck building games is that it really imp implements the Star Wars theme into it
  • it's beautiful it's relaxing
  • it's interesting that's to and interesting
  • I like how you go this way and then you can come back whereas in Parks you go to the end and then you refresh this when you just keep going back and forth
  • this is really my my go-to solo game
  • it's so cute
  • flam Rouge is a bike racing game
  • it's kind of come down to the last two turns you never know who's going to win
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video y8zxARCqgiI Top List at 12:18 sentiment: positive
Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 12:18 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Sense of progression.
  • Dynamic market where prices fluctuate.
  • Clever balancing act with variable goods scoring.
  • Unlocking better shipping and more merchants.
Cons
  • No extra space in the box for expansions.
Thematic elements
  • Economic development and trade
  • Scotland
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • contract fulfillment — using those goods to fill contracts
  • Map Movement and Building — you'll be moving out across a map and putting out things like workers livestock and production buildings
  • market fluctuation — where you can buy and sell goods and cause the market to fluctuate
  • Resource Production and Refinement — Each round you're going to be producing or refining Goods based on what you have on the map
  • Variable Goods Scoring — the amount of points that they will be worth depends on how rare those goods are so the more of them you import the less scoring potential they have
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • my top 10 games of all time
  • Thanks to everyone who have liked and commented uh on these videos
  • I wanted this to be a community focused Channel
  • I'm pretty happy with my old tasty minstral deluxified Edition
  • The way the card play works in this game is that players will have a hand of the same 15 character cards and you'll choose a hand of cards at the beginning of the round – five cards – and if you play a card on your turn that no one else has played, you get to take both the abilities on that card; but if anyone else has chosen the same card for that round, they will get to play that card on your turn and you'll each only get to take one of the card actions.
  • These resource wheels are essentially large dials and instead of taking tokens to represent your available resources, you're going to move them around this wheel. The catch is that whenever resources move away from the arms of the dial, the dial will move to, meaning that you will automatically spend resources to produce one of the premium goods either brick or glass.
  • Glenmore 2 I just added so many cool new ideas with all of the Chronicles that you can swap in and out of the game that will change up the game sometimes in subtle ways sometimes in really big ways.
  • but holy crap did I fall immediately in love with this game.
  • one of my favorite things that he does is take a relatively simple action selection mechanism and gives you a lot of interesting decisions to make.
  • The special edition from awaken Realms which is absolutely gorgeous. It's got beautiful art amazing Castle pieces and even includes a new Vineyards expansion which gives you even more options to score points.
  • This game gives you a lot of opportunities for some major combo turns which are all super satisfying and make you feel like a board game genius even when you are definitely not.
  • The first player rolls dice twice the number of players plus one then players take turns drafting those dice and depending on the number on those D on the die that you choose you're going to be taking an action associated with that number.
  • The biggest reason I love this game so much is all of the positive player interaction. It's very difficult to do well in this game just being off on your own on your own little corner of the map doing your own thing.
  • The production of this game is in my opinion absolutely beautiful. Whether you use the day or night side of the board.
  • brass Birmingham is my favorite game for another year although L granha might be coming for it
  • well we made it that's 100 of my favorite games
  • stay tuned for that and until next time let's get another round for the table
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video uS5UgiFV3cw Board Gaymes James Review sentiment: positive
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Building something on a general board with other players and competing for space is enjoyable.
  • The contract and production phases are very well done.
  • The money components are awesome.
  • The market mechanics are interesting.
Cons
  • Cheap foam core for DIY inserts is exhausting and can lead to injury.
  • Missing contracts and end-round scoring can cost a lot of points.
Thematic elements
  • Vying to expand your empire
  • 19th century Scotland
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Players compete for space on the board to build settlements.
  • End-game scoring — Specific scoring phases occur at the end of each of the five rounds.
  • market — The price of goods changes based on buying and selling actions.
  • Pick-Up and Deliver — Players produce goods to complete contracts and can buy goods from the market.
  • Set Collection — Players complete contracts which award points if they are in the majority.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • foreign
  • we're gonna go to 19th century Scotland
  • and play clans of Caledonia
  • by karma games
  • designed by Juma Al Juju I think
  • and illustrated by Clemens friends
  • this is the kickstarter Edition
  • so it comes with beautiful beautiful metal coins
  • and a lot of bags
  • so many bags
  • so this game can definitely benefit from a custom insert
  • which I'm going to show you how I go ahead and build one
  • and then cut my finger and throw the whole thing in the garbage
  • what you need to build a custom insert is some foam core a cutting board a very sharp knife that can actually go the depth of the foam core because I screwed that up a couple of times and smooshed my foam core and ended up creating really ugly lines as well as a ruler or a guide something to keep your lines straight because I really suck at keeping things straight
  • however I used really cheap foam core
  • it took me like two hours and I got exhausted and ticked off by the end of it and then I cut my thumb and so I was like no I'll just go buy one instead
  • I ended up going with one of these which they call a hardware organizer or a Plano box to that effect
  • and so this keeps everything intact so I've eliminated some of the bags
  • I can just pull this out of the box and keep it on the game table and when someone needs to get a milk because they've produced a milk and they can just grab them right out of these
  • In clans of Caledonia you are different Clans vying to expand your Empire on the board you want a cross shipping channels so you can get a larger settlement scoring at the end of the game and that's something to definitely watch out for is that settlement scoring so always up your shipping because it's a great way to hide the amount of settlements you have until the end of the game because most time people forget to track it
  • You're going to be vying to build these settlements so you can produce Goods to complete contracts
  • Completing these contracts will award you points at the end of the game if you're in the majority
  • always make sure you can get them as fast as possible and continue to do them otherwise you're going to fall behind
  • What I really like about this game is that I do get to build something on a general board with other players and compete for space
  • The contract and production phases are very well done
  • The money components are also a little bit awesome
  • and you can get actually acrylic trays to go on top of the player boards so that you can keep all of this stuff in order instead of being on a spot where it could potentially fall off
  • The other thing I really like is how the market works
  • On the market when you want to buy Goods you're going to move the price up after you've finished goods and when you sell Goods you're going to move the price marker down
  • Price marker is this really cool transparent disk here
  • Let's go move it up and down keep an eye on the market during the game because sometimes it's cheaper and faster to get goods from the market to complete your contracts than it is to produce them yourself
  • The game will last five rounds and each of those five rounds will be a specialized scoring thing make sure you pay attention to this as well missing contracts and missing the end round scoring is going to cost you a lot of points
  • That's it for clients of Caledonia
  • Shantae it stays
  • I guess nothing changed the way yet does it
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video IfmTa0MBkjU Board Gaymes James Discussion at 1:15 sentiment: positive
Board Gaymes James - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:15 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • The new expansion adds trains which is really cool.
  • Holds its space of weight on the shelf.
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Economic/route building with industrial elements.
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Resource Management — Describes using created and farmed resources.
  • Route Building — Typical route building within the game.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • These are games that I think actually are worth the space that they take up on the shelf because they are packed full of content.
  • This is how you get views. Have dog.
  • I know, yes, I know.
  • Although I wish it came with a stain.
  • Are you singing me the song of your people?
  • My games only get played once, two, three times.
  • Bo has decided he's had enough treats and his tail is destructive.
  • Let me know down in the comments below which is your physically largest game that is taking up the most space but totally worth it.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video DR5mhcjhkuY Board Games UnLocked Discussion at 4:57
Board Games UnLocked - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:57 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • So, 10 seconds. Uh, three points for the game title, one point for the designer.
  • What do all these have in common? They're designed by Uve Rosenberg.
  • And man, 10 seconds. That really puts it on you.
  • All right. So, that's five points.
  • So, I'm at 14 points.
  • So, I got 17.
  • So, I got 21.
  • So, 24.
  • Okay. Hey, I'll take four points.
  • Okay, 35.
  • So that's four points there. So I'm at 73.
  • Okay. I am at 76.
  • That is uh 76. That is how well I did.
  • So if there were how many questions were there at the very 20 20 total questions.
  • So not bad. I I definitely don't think that was too terrible.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video kpGtzJpoER4 Getting Games Discussion at 13:20 sentiment: positive
Getting Games - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 13:20 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • strong asymmetric powers
  • engaging market dynamics similar to Terra Mystica but distinct
  • high production and resource management potential
Cons
  • not sure if it will be a top 20 game for the long term
  • some may find it heavy or overly mechanical
Thematic elements
  • asymmetric powers and market-style economy
  • Scotland, with Scottish clans
  • Euro-style economic strategy
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Asymmetric powers — each player has different clan abilities and power dynamics
  • contracts and endgame scoring — contracts provide points and shape scoring near the end
  • supply and demand market — market mechanics drive resource production and pricing
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • "I am officially going pro at this"
  • "I’m going to be running a February pledge drive"
  • "two videos a week"
  • "this is one of the best board gaming experiences of my life"
  • "the game ends once somebody gets all of the tiles out"
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 8j2K3wm9DYI Brains On Games Top 5 List at 13:09 sentiment: positive
Brains On Games - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 13:09 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • fantastic marketplace mechanic
  • strong thematic components and modular board
Cons
  • longer learning curve and setup
Thematic elements
  • economic engine-building with trade and farming
  • Scotland; agriculture-based economy
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Modular Board — board shifts; each player controls a clan with unique abilities
  • modular board and asymmetric clans — board shifts; each player controls a clan with unique abilities
  • Resource Management — produce dairy, crops, and crafts; fulfill contracts for points
  • resource management and contracts — produce dairy, crops, and crafts; fulfill contracts for points
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Earth is a Nexus of possibility and all of these different creatures are coming to siphon possibility energy away from Earth
  • Cooperative Heist game with artwork that is fantastic
  • it's a game with tension that ramps up as you play just like pandemic but the theme is way less serious
  • Thrones of Valeria is a fantastic game such a surprise
  • I swear I've played this game over 100 times now
  • Marketplace is fantastic because the prices vary every turn
  • Praga Caput Ragni... there are a lot of things praga is a game where you've got many different paths to Victory
  • Scythe is my number four favorite game
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 8u3vPAC8AA8 Board Gaming Ramblings Analysis at 19:54 sentiment: positive
Board Gaming Ramblings - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 19:54 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • fantastic game
  • good for player who are good at it
  • expansion added viable clans and train aspect
Cons
  • can be hard to wrap your brain around
Thematic elements
  • economy
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • contract fulfillment — or fulfill these contracts
  • economic engine building — it's a very tight economical puzzle where you are placing your production on the board trying to place it where it's both cheap and makes sense and you can build like in your network
  • network building — trying to place it where it's both cheap and makes sense and you can build like in your network
  • Resource Management — you're trying to then uh trade those resources for money or buy the resource that you need or fulfill these contracts
  • Tile Placement — placing your production on the board
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's a very tight economical puzzle where you are placing your production on the board trying to place it where it's both cheap and makes sense and you can build like in your network
  • my number two is going to be clans of calonia because it's a fantastic game
  • my number one is going to be another prototype it's going to be sweetlands
  • the artwork is amazing the gameplay is so brain burning and cool
  • it looks so good it looks like a finished game
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video ru_VhUgx_fQ Board Gaming Ramblings Review at 0:07 sentiment: positive
Board Gaming Ramblings - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:07 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Adds significant variability through new Clans, Port Tiles, Scoring Tiles, and Maps.
  • The insert provides excellent storage for both the base game and expansion.
  • New Clans offer diverse and enjoyable playstyles.
  • The contract display adds a strategic planning element.
  • The train board, while complex, offers rewarding bonuses and new strategic avenues.
  • Farmers Market module adds an interesting twist to resource selling and economy.
Cons
  • The expansion is 'a bit more symbol heavy' with new iconography.
  • The train module can be overwhelming and potentially detrimental if misplayed early on.
  • Some modules might be too much for new players, suggesting playing without them initially.
Thematic elements
  • Scotland
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Majority — Mentioned as a scoring method on the board and for contracts.
  • contract fulfillment — Contracts are used to gain resources and points, with a new display showing future available contracts.
  • End-game scoring — New endgame awards are introduced for categories like most money, most resources beside the river, most basic resources, and most points.
  • Resource Management — Players manage basic and processed goods, transforming wool into kilts (joker resources) and selling resources at the farmers market.
  • Set Collection — Achieving specific Milestones on the train board to unlock bonuses and points.
  • Variable player powers — Nine new Clans with special abilities that offer different ways to play the game.
  • Worker Placement — Mentioned in the context of placing workers adjacent to resources to transform them or gain benefits.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • clans calonia industria this is the new expansion for clans of calonia which is one of my favorite games of all time
  • this is going to be for people who have played the game quite a bit and who wants more basically
  • for me this is a musthave expansion and not because it fixes the game in any way because I think I could have played Clans sconia 50 more times and still really enjoyed it but the added variability so of course if you play this one time and you have it on the shelf and thinking should I get the expansion it's not going to fix the game but if you love the game and you like us need like an excuse to play the game again maybe you should but the added variability is just amazing
  • the must have for me is the variability of the Clans and and this this is of course very easy to just play in the base game if you have it you just put out this house on the board but other than that like this I really like it but it's not like oh this was what was missing from classic cedonia it is great but it's not like you have to run out and get it because of the train module but it's very good
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video tVEzdRoK--Y Man vs Meeple Review at 23:36 sentiment: positive
Man vs Meeple - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 23:36 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Solid game
  • A lot of game in a small box (original)
  • New organization solution is nice (Industria expansion)
Cons
  • Gets overshadowed by comparisons to Terra Mystica and Gaia Project
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I do I haven't sent anyone I haven't gotten the guts to send them yet yeah but I do want to send them letters and they're old school letters I've written them out in cursive by the way and my handwriting is awful
  • So I was without without Diet Coke for the last two weeks that's been terrible
  • The thematic elements are on point, I mean this is incredibly thematic.
  • That feeling you're getting of burning those metals and just the fact that they really like the card effects really tie into what these Metals actually do in the book series is very interesting.
  • I think I got lucky in that last turn, you built up to that turn.
  • It's a good thing you healed I'm just telling you that right now cuz I'm bringing Out The Inquisitor.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video VHoNQZOkFq8 UndeadVikingVideos Discussion at 12:34 sentiment: positive
UndeadVikingVideos - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 12:34 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • The host is very proud of their hand in its creation through playtesting and development.
  • Hits the niche of negotiation games perfectly.
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • draft and write — Mentioned as a niche the game hits.
  • Negotiation — Mentioned as a niche the game hits.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it is food it is laughs it is Brotherhood uh it is it is something that uh uh uh fills a part of my heart and a part of my soul that I can't get anywhere else
  • to everything there is a first time and that was the first one and so I I'm thankful that it exists and I'm thankful that I got to be a part
  • I I should just crack that open and play it uh at some point
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video U11v8pu0gEo Board Gaming Ramblings Top List at 20:29 sentiment: positive
Board Gaming Ramblings - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 20:29 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • One of the better games ever
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Economic
  • Scotland
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Set Collection — Implied through economic theme and ranking discussion.
  • Worker Placement — Mentioned in the context of comparing game rankings.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • For me, this is an S. This is one of the better games ever. I love it.
  • Um Tor Mars I've spoken about this many times. Hate love it. H I love to hate it and I hate to love it.
  • It's just like F plus for me. This is boring.
  • If this wasn't Marvel, if it was just called Champions, wouldn't be the same same wouldn't be a top 100.
  • We like lordas but like boa and kban ee is my favorite ones.
  • And then we're going to have Mara Kybo. Oh, Marbo is good. Uh I really like it still. Even though that Pirates of Marbo kind of did the same goodness in shorter amount of time.
  • I would place Marbo in B or C.
  • What? D.
  • And uh lastly for this part of the video, we're going to have come down EV S S. Yeah, that's an easy one to end on. We like lordas but like boa and kban ee is my favorite ones.
  • That was way more fun than I thought it would be.
  • I think this is fun because well we kind of have this thing in top 10 or especially in top uh when we make top 100 and top 50 because she's like oh you picked this so low or this is so high and we get like to kind of see our differences a little more clearly.
  • Also when we do the keep and we disagree we kind of I think that is fun and I thought that we we're going to agree more. So, but but it's nice that we don't.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video bjB0N5jxFg4 The Brothers Murph Playthrough at 0:31 sentiment: positive
The Brothers Murph - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:31 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Interesting strategic depth.
  • Satisfying engine building.
Cons
  • Can be overwhelming for new players.
  • Expansion is hard to find in America.
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area management — Players manage the placement of buildings and workers.
  • economic engine building — Players build industries and manage resources to create an economic engine.
  • Resource Management — Players manage various resources needed for production.
  • Worker Placement — Players use workers to take actions.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • If you don't know what you're talking about, it just sounds ridiculous.
  • So blow so addictive that Slay the Spire for me.
  • It's very slay the spire but with dice.
  • The game itself in terms of the rules overhead is not that high.
  • But then yeah, figuring out how you want to do it and then how you manage constantly getting more and more and more of these cards is tough.
  • The artwork is a slight disappointment in this board game.
  • It's very interesting the way it all works.
  • I get why people dig it.
  • We really like Speak easy a lot, but could very well be our favorite Lera.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video dkViBAwawoY The Brothers Murph Top List at 3:36 sentiment: positive
The Brothers Murph - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 3:36 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Teaches you the meaning of extracting every possible ounce out of each round you play.
  • The way the player board shows what income you gain when you remove pieces is real smooth.
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Income Gain Display — The way the player board shows what income you gain when you remove pieces is real smooth.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Through the Ages: A New Story of Civilization is the engine builder to end all engine builders.
  • In Twilight Struggle, one of the more interesting times in history is played out. And I love that each card is a real event that happened.
  • Gaia Project built on Terrammystica and perfected the form. It's the best one.
  • Gloom Haven: Jaws of the Lion has the best tutorial system I have ever seen in a game, and I think it legitimately creates new board gamers constantly because of the way they make it so approachable.
  • Each Spirit in Spirit Island can be played over and over as you learn how to master their abilities, and there are so much content in the box. It also just plays amazing solo.
  • Dune Imperium Uprising took Dune Imperium to a whole new level of scale and scope, and it's got them worms.
  • It's impossible to have a bad time playing Star Wars Rebellion, especially if you love Star Wars. Okay, mostly only if you love Star Wars, but it's really fun. It's Lord of the Rings in a box, and it's perfect.
  • For a solid like 6 years, Terraforming Mars was absolutely the king of the board game hobby. Unreal staying power.
  • Dune Imperium uses art based on the movies, but it doesn't feel at all like a movie tie-in cash grab.
  • The scale and epic stories that come out of Twilight Imperium fourth edition make it everlasting. Every time you play, you get a permanent memory and story. It's truly impressive.
  • The sheer amount of content in Gloom Haven and the card play makes this dungeon crawler a Eurogamer's delight.
  • Ark Nova takes Terraforming Mars' cardplay in Civilization's action card mechanisms and put it into a theme we're just way more interested in. just the absolute pinnacle of mashing up mechanisms into a masterpiece.
  • Pandemic Legacy Season 1 has deserved every single ounce of acclaim and accolades it's received over the years. It was an absolute phenomena when it came out.
  • I don't want to say anything nice about this game. I don't want to say anything nice about this game. I don't like this game though.
  • Fine. Fine.
  • Brass Birmingham is objectively a board game. Done. Easy. That was nice. Words that are written.
  • Brass rhymes with ass. Got him. You're done.
  • Brass Birmingham has one of the best examples of positive player interaction and a game I'd actually seek out to play for a player. Was that so hard?
  • So, that was one nice thing about every single game in the Board Game Geek top 100. Many games that we actually don't even really like, but there's always something nice to say. Exactly.
  • Just engage.
  • We had a lot of fun making it.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video XESHZMmDPT4 Stonemaier Games Top List at 10:17 sentiment: positive
Stonemaier Games - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 10:17 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Heaviest game on the list
  • Packed with components
  • Highly replayable
  • Noticeably smaller box than expected for its weight
  • Great engine building
  • Unique take inspired by Terra Mystica
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Scotland
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Engine Building — Described as a 'great engine building game.'
  • Variable board — Features a 'vastly replayable um variable board.'
  • Worker Placement — Involves 'removing tokens from your mat and putting them on the board.'
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I'm very grateful that they are full of games. um but how I want to continue to explore many more games in the future and I just don't have room for them. And so I am valuing more and more games that fit into a smaller space.
  • And uh and even better for the publishers, smaller games mean that you can put more games in a carton, more games on a pallet, more games on a shipping container or a or a truck or a train, however you're transporting them around the world, and so it's uh more cost-effective to freight ship these games, too. Better for the environment, too. You're using fewer components to make these games. Um and less materials, basically.
  • It's kind of a miracle of a game how well this game works and how long it came out.
  • This to me is not a filler trick taking game. This is a a really substantial trick taking game.
  • I am completely enamored with this game.
  • I love the card row in the middle and how you can either buy a card or remove a card so your opponent can't get it. I think that is such a clever mechanism.
  • Every card is two cards. It isn't just one card. [...] It's brilliant. It is so so clever.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video H3Q4Yw-xNCo BoardGameBollocks Top List at 8:44 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 8:44 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • The original core game is still an absolute blast
  • Scratches an itch that many other games do
Cons
  • Expansion probably isn't necessary
Thematic elements
  • Players take on the role of a Scottish clan, producing goods, generating money, and fulfilling contracts.
  • Scotland
Comparison games
  • Catan
  • Stephen Feld games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Putting out different victories.
  • Resource Management — Producing goods and generating money.
  • Set Collection — Fulfilling contracts that give victory points.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • So, this is number 80 down to 71. So, this is still in the dog [ __ ] ended part of the sticker territory.
  • Remember, if your top 100 games aren't on this list, then that's because A, we haven't played them or B, we think they're complete and utter dog [ __ ].
  • It is long. It's 4 hours plus. Yeah, I know there's going to be people out there saying it's not that long, but I don't care what you [ __ ] think. [ __ ] off.
  • It's almost as if Peter Hall has uncovered the simplest equation to how the brain interprets fun. Yeah. Albeit by using some stuffy old cubes that have been pulled out from under someone's foreskin. Yeah. Not literally.
  • If you've got Zo Legends of the Drift system and you ain't own that expansion, then you're a [ __ ] fuckard.
  • Sometimes you roll a D20 in this game and it's going to put a cucumber up your bum bum, which isn't always welcome depending on what day it is and what time it is actually.
  • No [ __ ] [ __ ] Right. Newer trains that you build are going to cover greater distances cuz they're obviously more efficient technologically, right?
  • This is one of them games that's like a hybrid game. It borrows a lot of mechanics from other games. You see elements of katan in here, a lot of Stephen Feld [ __ ] going on. And it's almost as if it just blends it all into one big massive [ __ ] dough pile and then lets you gorge on all of your favorite mechanics at once.
  • It's one of them rare occasions where the hype is real.
  • If you are struggling for a free player game and you don't mind trolling through a relatively heavy rule book, then Maria is possibly greatest free player war game ever made. I know some people are going to say that Churchill or one of them games is better, but I ain't played it so you can kiss my ass.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 0Hs24UiW2M0 Hungry Gamer Discussion at 31:57 sentiment: positive
Hungry Gamer - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 31:57 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Good production
  • Tight economy
  • Fast-moving turns
  • Satisfying asymmetric clan powers
  • Lots of replayability with double the clans
Cons
  • Can be dry
  • BGA implementation is slow and hard to see the map on mobile
  • Some advanced modules might cause analysis paralysis
Thematic elements
  • Farming and producing goods
  • Scotland
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Asymmetric Player Powers — Each clan has unique benefits and encourages different playstyles.
  • economic simulation — Buying and selling in a market where prices fluctuate.
  • Set Collection — Fulfilling contracts.
  • Worker Placement — Placing units on a hex-based map.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Try new things. That's my wisdom.
  • Be conscious of that in gaming and in life.
  • I I need I need those whiskey barrels. That's that's a need.
  • There's a little bit of take that in the sense that other players get to move these guys.
  • It's one of those weird dry games that's just very satisfying.
  • Each clan has some kind of benefit that you're going to get. And you have to lean into whatever it is that your clan can do.
  • It's just that's that's tongue and cheek. But no, I don't I don't really have complaints about this game.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video uZMiQry01bE Hungry Gamer Discussion at 38:49 sentiment: positive
Hungry Gamer - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 38:49 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Great with expansion content
  • Engaging asymmetric clan powers
  • Strategic depth
  • Industrious theme
Cons
  • Can be perceived as 'dry' without engaging with clan powers
Thematic elements
  • Scottish clans, industry, agriculture
  • Scotland
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • economic engine building — Producing goods like whiskey and cheese, sending them on trains.
  • market — Implied by sales and purchases.
  • Tile Placement — Implied by building out a player board or area.
  • Variable player powers — Each clan has a unique ability.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • That game makes me happy every single time.
  • I enjoy what's going on because the little stories and the stories are just my kind of kind of weird and whimsical and silly.
  • I have a lot of joy teaching that game and so it was the most joyful to say, listen, I love these newspapers and we put the um my favorite critic is the Chimera because it brings two critics.
  • It's definitely a top five game for me. I will never not play it.
  • I want to say that if Mark Dainty, Luke Lori, and Will Brown had not had not gone through this procedure to bring recall to a table, there is no way I would have picked this game up.
  • Kudos to whoever like the rule book is 16 pages.
  • This game blew me away.
  • I mean just smashed it and it was like two days before the con and I was like well here we go. And I loved it.
  • It's just a joy. It's always a joy to get to the table and playing with the new expansion content was a lot of fun.
  • The amazing thing that happens with games is how much they grow over time and how much fun I had playing on TTS. That is not a fun medium, people!
  • This is not I mean it is it is a baguer and it is uh probably up there with the weight of people have been debating if Andromeda's Edge is heavier or Whisperwood's heavier.
  • It has turned out to be uh the best moment of the year. Uh I I just appreciate that that gaming time with some friends.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video uZMiQry01bE Hungry Gamer Discussion at 1:07:07 sentiment: positive
Hungry Gamer - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:07:07 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Joyful to play
  • Fun with new expansion content
  • A reliable enjoyable game
Cons
  • No new insights to add due to familiarity
Thematic elements
  • Scottish Clans
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — players are vying for control of territories.
  • economic — Playing with the new expansion content was a lot of fun.
  • Resource Management — managing resources is key to success.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • That game makes me happy every single time.
  • I enjoy what's going on because the little stories and the stories are just my kind of kind of weird and whimsical and silly.
  • I have a lot of joy teaching that game and so it was the most joyful to say, listen, I love these newspapers and we put the um my favorite critic is the Chimera because it brings two critics.
  • It's definitely a top five game for me. I will never not play it.
  • I want to say that if Mark Dainty, Luke Lori, and Will Brown had not had not gone through this procedure to bring recall to a table, there is no way I would have picked this game up.
  • Kudos to whoever like the rule book is 16 pages.
  • This game blew me away.
  • I mean just smashed it and it was like two days before the con and I was like well here we go. And I loved it.
  • It's just a joy. It's always a joy to get to the table and playing with the new expansion content was a lot of fun.
  • The amazing thing that happens with games is how much they grow over time and how much fun I had playing on TTS. That is not a fun medium, people!
  • This is not I mean it is it is a baguer and it is uh probably up there with the weight of people have been debating if Andromeda's Edge is heavier or Whisperwood's heavier.
  • It has turned out to be uh the best moment of the year. Uh I I just appreciate that that gaming time with some friends.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video qGCijP0hoEo Board Gaming Ramblings Top 10 List at 28:26 sentiment: positive
Board Gaming Ramblings - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 28:26 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • high replayability
  • easy to teach with good player aid
Cons
  • not for absolute beginners; heavier than gateway games
Thematic elements
  • economic/resource management with animals
  • Scotland/European economic themes
  • economic strategy
Comparison games
  • Castles of Burgundy
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • market/auction-like dynamics — buy and sell resources to optimize cash flow
  • Resource Management — produce and fulfill contracts using resources and money
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It's basically a push your luck game where you see if you think you're able to get to a higher scoring planet or star later or if you should save and hop out now while they still can.
  • Doodle Dash is a really funny game. It's a drawing game.
  • Lost Ruins of Arnack is heavier but has a great potential to grow with you.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video C69jLxyl1_s Gaming Rules! Discussion at 5:10 sentiment: positive
Gaming Rules! - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 5:10 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • First game ever. Finally rectified that. Which is good.
Cons
  • Did not play with the big choo-choo train.
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I spent the last 20 years saying that Talisman is one of the worst games ever designed.
  • The thematic connection of that ability doesn't mean mean anything to me because it was the guy in episode 14 of season 3.
  • So much theme in every single one of the lines of text.
  • It is an utterly fantastic game. I love it.
  • And it was the most tense and epic game that I've ever had with War of the Ring.
  • The dark forces need 10 points to win, and the free peoples either destroy the ring or they get four points.
  • The base game alone is still an utterly fantastic game.
  • It's completely random.
  • It's a very highly asymmetric game and it's you know, the the way you learn it is here's a rulebook each and you also get your own faction rulebook. You need to read it.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video CNl2wKKbDWE BoardGameCo Analysis at 3:01 sentiment: neutral
BoardGameCo - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 3:01 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
neutral
Pros
none
Cons
  • expansion not played yet
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I made three videos earlier this year. Three videos where I cover the different games I want to play, some games, some expansions, some games in 2024, all the various categories.
  • Now, I've shown off some of the things they have in the past. I have this kind of messily over here right now. Just the various uh bits and bobs of various ways you can track 10 by 10 lists or you know uh the 5x5 lists or any different kind of challenges using fun little uh blanks that go in here and then you use little meeples to track the various uh scores you the various games you've played in order to see how well you're doing on your personal challenges.
  • Um, I mean, I've played a bunch of games and I have various games I will want to play, but stick around to the end of this video and you'll see me uh put together on the fly with subject to change a challenge board for me to go through separate from my uh current challenge.
  • Speaking of my current challenge, I have a package from him that just showed up over here.
  • As much as Vegas Geek 3D does fun little magnetic boards, if you want a fun place to put your fun little magnetic board, check out these shelves behind me from Allplay, the table from AllPlay.
  • Long story short, uh he saw that I have this challenge for myself of games I want to play. And so he said, "Hey, what if I think a challenge board for you?" And I was like, "That would be awesome."
  • Do I actually have 35? 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10. No, this is a 50 challenge board. Oh no, I need to add 50 games to the mix.
  • I'm going to go ahead and open up the tokens and simply see how well we've been doing.
  • Middle Ages is one of the games that I wanted to play and I have played Middle Ages.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 5mDVBSac19k JestaThaRogue Analysis at 16:41 sentiment: positive
JestaThaRogue - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 16:41 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Mentioned as a game that is different enough to fit into the collection.
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Every game I've ever bought, I've bought for a good reason. At least that's what I tell myself.
  • I don't watch playthroughs cuz playthroughs tend to be too long.
  • I think it's just the hype and how much money this project's making and all this buzz around it was making me think I should get on this now, and I just know that I'm going to get the cards, maybe play it twice, and then never play it again.
  • If it can fit in this 4x4 Kallax, then it will stay. If it doesn't fit, then something's got to go.
  • Will I still enjoy the game after 10 plays? It's not a question I ask myself.
  • Those are the 10 questions I ask myself before buying a game
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video YJqiNnqJnpk Top List at 34:52 sentiment: other
Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 34:52 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
really fun
Pros
  • preferred over Gaia Project and Terra Mystica
  • unique market mechanism
  • cozy and inviting theme
  • asymmetric player powers
Cons
  • waiting for expansion
Thematic elements
  • farming and market
  • Highlands of Scotland
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Asymmetric Player Powers — It's got asymmetric player powers as well
  • economic engine — pick up these and you're um allocating resources onto a shared board based off of money.
  • market — unique market that you have in this game where if you buy a certain resource, you know, the you move the dial or sell it and you move it up and down
  • Order Fulfillment — order fulfillments
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I really liked how uh bombastic the cards get in allowing you to do, you know, things on your own board and how to explore it.
  • Uh especially with the military aspect and, you know, creating or increasing the military might that you have to um impose on other opponents and when these battles really made our games uh come down to these in addition to uh the just straight-up deck building and um you know, playing cards from your hands and worker placement aspects that has a lot of good mechanisms that I enjoy.
  • This game I really enjoyed for the theme. I like the the thematic story and the arc of this game where the plague gets pretty bad uh during the game, uh but then slowly as you start to unders- or, you know, uh combat the disease, you start to uh rely less and less on taking out the plague and more and more coming back to repopulate Messina.
  • it's still a game that is is tough for me to play sometimes just because um you know, I if I think I know what is going on with the strategy of this game and and and you know, the the more that I have to learn from it and so it kind of deterred me from playing it more
  • But yeah, uh as as bland as it looks, it's actually really fun order fulfillment game.
  • Um it's not as deep or complex as Magic or Hearthstone or some of the other card games are, but it probably will get to that point at some at some point.
  • I wish that the meta game was more diverse. It hasn't been so since the start of the game.
  • And Wingspan for me, while it's a masterpiece of of a design um in my opinion, I really was really drawn to all of the birds and the individuality of these cards.
  • It does take a while to play, I think if you're playing with new people, which was kind of a deterrent for me for bringing this game out more often.
  • So, this is one of the latest Uwe Rosenberg games back in 2022, one of my favorite games. One for the solo version of this game. I think that is the peak way to play this game.
  • And so I I hold it in high esteem.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video OBReDWl5Ai4 Discussion at 0:02 sentiment: positive
Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:02 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • one of my favorite games of all time
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • in 2017 there was a game coming out called clans of calonia and it decided to be one of my favorite games of all time
  • and it also has trains because every game needs more trains
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video OBReDWl5Ai4 Discussion at 0:13 sentiment: positive
Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:13 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • new expansion
  • includes cards for solo play
  • includes a scoring sheet
  • big box with space for everything from the base game and expansion
  • includes punch boards
  • includes new map tiles
  • includes trains
  • includes a whole new board where you can run around with trains
  • includes an insert that will fit everything
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • in 2017 there was a game coming out called clans of calonia and it decided to be one of my favorite games of all time
  • and it also has trains because every game needs more trains
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 0nK_BlKITFM Discussion at 12:39 sentiment: positive
Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 12:39 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Sold out of deluxe copies
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Draft and write
  • Midgard world
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Draft — Described as a 'draft and WR' mechanic.
  • Write — Described as a 'draft and WR' mechanic.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • the convention changes so you don't kind of notice at that old Wes tale idea that if you put a frog in water and slowly turn up the heat it doesn't notice the change and it dies
  • I feel like I'm able to like condense a a hourlong game into a one minute this is how the game works and this is why you may or may not like it
  • There's so many board games coming out right now that people can't keep track of
  • Thousands of people coming into the hobby all the time um that means that I'll have a job because there's stuff we can make right
  • I did my how do you prep for Gen Con hydrate and stuff which is stuff I did but like taking vitamin C tablets or emergency I did that every single day and I came home with no conrod
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Wn1QK23oEwY Rules Teach at 0:01 sentiment: positive
Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:01 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Modular expansion allows for customizable gameplay.
  • Engaging engine-building and economic simulation.
  • Strategic depth with numerous options.
  • The train module adds a new layer of gameplay.
  • Solo mode provides a good challenge, with the automa closely matching the player's score.
Cons
  • The final score was very close (156 vs 157), suggesting a high level of balance.
  • Can be expensive to build out settlements early on.
  • The host mentions some missteps in planning, indicating a learning curve.
Thematic elements
  • Industrial revolution
  • 19th century Scotland
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • automa — A solo mode opponent (automa) plays with a deck of cards to simulate another player's actions.
  • End-game scoring — Points are awarded for various achievements such as contracts fulfilled, settlements, goods delivered, and settlements size.
  • market — Players can buy and sell goods on the market, with prices fluctuating based on supply and demand.
  • Pick-Up and Deliver — Using a train to deliver goods to cities and gain rewards, or delivering goods to fulfill contracts.
  • Set Collection — Collecting specific goods to fulfill export contracts and achieving milestones based on unit diversity or quantity.
  • Variable player powers — Each player has a unique Clan tile granting a special ability.
  • Worker Placement — Players place units like workers and farms onto a map to generate goods and take actions.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • The expansion itself is a big box solution for the game with trays and things. The expansion has loads of different modules that you can mix and match to your liking.
  • It's 19th century Scotland we're having an industrial revolution, we're placing units onto a map whether they are workers different types of farms, we're generating goods through either the things we're putting down or wheeling and dealing on the market, we are using those goods to fulfill contracts.
  • The Automata is not interacting with this train board at all.
  • One fewer misstep could have turned the whole tide there. I lost by one point. Oh well, I'm happy with that win or lose.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video dx56PMR_rXY Analysis at 0:04 sentiment: positive
Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:04 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Improved setup with storage solutions and a setup guide.
  • Addresses criticism of the export market with a refill board for better planning.
  • Adds new scoring opportunities through scoring tiles.
  • Introduces new clans that offer unique abilities and break game rules.
  • The train board (Industria module) feels like a significant expansion.
  • Provides more options and strategic choices for players.
  • Modules can be mixed and matched with the base game.
Cons
  • Adds visual complexity which might seem daunting initially.
  • The train action requires careful planning as you can't take the action without being able to deliver.
Thematic elements
  • Industry has come, and railroads are built for making deliveries.
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • area influence — Building settlements near farmer's markets and placing train stations to block opponents or gain benefits.
  • Contracts — Players fulfill contracts to gain special goods and points. The expansion improves this by revealing upcoming contracts.
  • Drafting — New variants for drafting clans, including basic and auction drafts.
  • Resource Management — Players create and use various resources to fulfill contracts and make deliveries.
  • Set Collection — Collecting goods to fulfill delivery demands and achieve milestone bonuses.
  • Tile Placement — New map tiles with features like waterfalls are added, and farmer's market tiles are placed at the start.
  • variable setup — The expansion introduces variable starting conditions for products using dice rolls and different market setups.
  • Worker Placement — Implied by building settlements and placing workers near farmer's market tiles.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is the clans of calonia expansion called industria
  • one of the biggest criticisms that I think that this game has ever had and that is the export market
  • this train board out here this is what I was saying earlier definitely feels like more of an expansion to the game than the other modules
  • it is still clans of calonia for sure and I do think this feels like we said several times now this feels like the expansion
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video dEOi-7kQf2g Other at 16:10 sentiment: positive
Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 16:10 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Whoever has the most monies at the end of this pop quiz will be employee of the month.
  • This game is broken every other Wednesday.
  • This is so bad for me, y'all.
  • I'm so bad at this.
  • My brain doesn't do these.
  • I guess I can give you a little clues if you want to.
  • So, this is uh this is from the teens.
  • This is the worst round of I've ever done in the history of these kinds of games.
  • The problem is these aren't helping because it's just flavor text from Lord of the Rings.
  • I was like, Lord of the Rings doesn't have flavor text and I was like, oh, what would have a ton of flavor text is the card game, of course.
  • So, we each have a strike. Strike.
  • Gosh, man.
  • Yeah. So, what's what's our current score right now?
  • So those are all basically fake on West but they were still number one.
  • Mike is the employee of the month.
  • Nick, you will be our next pop quiz master.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video RvpyyYn4ETI All You Can Board Analysis at 23:21 sentiment: positive
All You Can Board - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 23:21 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Deep, satisfying puzzle; excellent heavy solo experience
  • Interesting asymmetry; maps & clans provide variety
  • Automa adds competition and tension; plays faster over time
Cons
  • Setup is fiddly and time-consuming with many components
  • High complexity might deter new players
  • Some modular additions add overhead; not all are essential for solo
Thematic elements
  • Economic engine-building with resource production and contracts
  • Scottish clan-based economy on a modular map
  • Economic simulation with asymmetrical clans
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Asymmetric clans — Each clan has unique abilities that shape strategies.
  • Automa expansion (Industria) optional — Automa AI adds a competitive opponent to solo mode via expansion.
  • Engine Building — Money is central to actions and expansion; scoring separate from money.
  • Modular Board — Players expand on a modular board, building production and markets.
  • Modular map with expansion — Players expand on a modular board, building production and markets.
  • Money-focused engine-building — Money is central to actions and expansion; scoring separate from money.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Everything about Cozy Sticker Ville is supposed to be a relaxing activity.
  • There is no way to win, there's no way to lose.
  • I won't be playing this game solo or multiplayer again.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video ixOjAYfvew0 Neon Gorilla Top List at 4:15 sentiment: negative
Neon Gorilla - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:15 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
negative
Pros
  • Engaging for players who enjoy resource production and engine-building
Cons
  • Relatively low interaction and friction on the board
  • Not as network-building as expected for its ranking
Thematic elements
  • Economic engine-building with resource production and goals
  • Highland Scotland resource production and map-based development
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Engine Building — Develop a production engine across different terrains and resources.
  • engine-building — Develop a production engine across different terrains and resources.
  • market dynamics — Prices fluctuate, affecting purchases and production decisions.
  • Market Pricing/Manipulation — Prices fluctuate, affecting purchases and production decisions.
  • Tile Placement — Populate a map with meeples to generate resources and fulfill goals.
  • Tile/board resource placement — Populate a map with meeples to generate resources and fulfill goals.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Agricola is dated; it shows its age.
  • The Crew I just can't recommend.
  • A Feast for Odin after quite a few plays is a pretty decent game.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video YWvn46Rf0uY The Board Gaming Doctor Top List at 9:23 sentiment: positive
The Board Gaming Doctor - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 9:23 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • deep resource management and market interactivity
  • strong thematic cohesion with farming life
Cons
  • heavy and not beginner-friendly
Thematic elements
  • cattle, sheep, wheat, and dairy evolving into cheese and bread
  • Filling contracts and resource management in a Scottish-inspired market
  • deep strategy with interactive market dynamics
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • contract fulfillment — Convert resources to points via contracts.
  • dynamic market pricing — Resource prices rise and fall based on selling and buying activity.
  • Market Pricing/Manipulation — Resource prices rise and fall based on selling and buying activity.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • there seems to be an element of farming or agriculture to most of his games
  • cozy to the farming theme… with bluegrass music in the background
  • nostalgic part of me… Harvest Moon
  • Rosenberg isn't the only person who has designed a farming game
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video P4eHtwCKkko Board of It Top List at 13:35 sentiment: positive
Board of It - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 13:35 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Strong thematic coherence with Scottish whiskey and farming
  • Engaging economic decisions and regional interdependencies
Cons
  • Can be heavy for newcomers
  • Some regional variants may feel samey over time
Thematic elements
  • economic development, farming, and whisky production
  • Scotland / Caledonia with whiskey-based industry
  • economic engine with strong regional flavor
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Economic engine and production chains — Develop industry, and manage imports/exports to maximize profits.
  • Whiskey-focused decision dynamics — Many abilities and strategies link to whisky production and regional power.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is a really solid euro game by one of our favorite designers Alexander Pfister and one of our favorite publishers Capstone Games
  • the reason we're not drinking this right now is because this is actually a friend's bottle
  • it's elevated if you have a glass of wine to go with it
  • it's an excellent euro game and alexander definitely has a very distinct style
  • it's a very very funny game and also the RPG elements
  • this is a really great game to play and you should check it out
  • it's a lovely little cocktail try it out
  • it's a very popular game
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video g5NHnRYXwBs Board of It Top List at 31:42 sentiment: positive
Board of It - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 31:42 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • strong thematic flavor for a Euro-style game
  • dynamic market system and contract scoring
  • solid depth with two players
Cons
  • low direct player interaction
Thematic elements
  • agro-industrial economy with whiskey, dairy, bread, and contracts
  • Scotland-based clan management, trade, and farming
  • classic euro with thematic flavor
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Contracts — fulfill contracts to trigger victory points via a tracker
  • meeples / worker-like tokens — deploy workers to farms, dairies, and other facilities
  • resource/market economy — produce goods and trade in a dynamic market with price fluctuations
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • there's basically no player interaction
  • an absolute joy to play
  • we couldn't get enough of it
  • it's a bidding set collection game
  • it's the best with two players
  • it's very addictive
  • it's obtuse to learn
  • two players is great
  • it's a dark game, but funny in the juxtaposition
  • the turn time can be unbalanced
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video guB-lNAygrA The Board Game Garden Weekend Board Game Convention at 6:29 sentiment: positive
The Board Game Garden - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 6:29 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • considered a big surprise and highlight
  • enjoyed playing an older euro
Cons
  • no in-depth mechanic discussion in the clip
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • we are calling it boaton
  • I am so so excited
  • this weekend we did end up putting together our little paper here of just all of the games that we played
  • Scholars of the South Tigress was so good
  • it's chaotic fun
  • you are somebody's reason to smile
  • Viking Seesaw was the best boat game of boaton
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video wI66Qx6GpT8 Board Of It Discussion at 12:50 sentiment: positive
Board Of It - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 12:50 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Strong regional flavor
  • Solid engine-building feel
Cons
  • Can be dense for newcomers
Thematic elements
  • Trade, farming, and rural development
  • Scotland; agricultural and economic strategy
  • Historically inspired economic euro
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • worker placement / resource engine — Place workers to gather resources and advance production.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's ambient it's really cool
  • really ambient it's really nice to have on in the background
  • we saved the best for last
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video H0eg43rDPr8 The Board Gaming Doctor Discussion at 6:36 sentiment: positive
The Board Gaming Doctor - Clans of Caledonia video thumbnail
Click to watch at 6:36 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • promising expansion to a favored title; potential TTS/TT play
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • board interaction / added board — expansion adds an extra board and new interaction
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This year I feel has more of a prominence on expansions, at least for games that I'm interested in rather than standalone games.
  • I'm excited to play Garden Lake.
  • It is an interesting year, not very heavy with Rosenberg games as well.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Transcript Navigation
Showing 1–50 of 71
Game Deep Dive