Reviewing 3 Ways to Solo Clans of Caledonia
Transcript
I don't know about you but with all this social distancing going on I have been able to play quite a bit of solo gaming and so I thought this would be the perfect opportunity to talk about one of my favorite euro games of all time clans of woe the clans of freakin Caledonia this is a fantastic multiplayer game but it has a solo variant in the rulebook and packs two additional solo variants that are available online right now I'm going to be talking through all three of them and giving you my thoughts on which one is best so here we go so the first solo variant is the one that's actually in the rulebook this is the OG and in this mode you're going to have the consolidated board of the two-player game where all the misted out spaces on the edges are unavailable to you and the intent of this one is essentially to strip out all of the multiplayer aspects so you're not going to have the neighborhood bonuses where you place a component next to someone else's probably the biggest impact on what you would normally be able to do in a game is that all of the cheapest spaces on the board are made unavailable what I like to do in this mode is actually black out everything that's going to be unavailable to me with alternate pieces including all of this stuff that's not available in two-player games you're not going to have to worry about managing and other players pieces in this one
essentially what's going to happen is you're going to play your own game just trying to get as many points as you can with two dice acting as the subtle influence moderating what a impact of a multiplayer game would have so every round the dice are rolled and you determine how to adjust the market based off of the plus or negative value and what good is listed on the die you do that three times for three different Goods and then the last roll is going to indicate to you which of these six goods that are available normally and a two-player game and you're going to take that one out other than that it's just a race to get how many points that you can possibly get and then you just score against a bracket at the end of the game now what's really cool about this mode is felt it is very consolidated it is very easy to manage and you can knock out a game of this in about 40 minutes if you know what you're doing and you don't have to worry too much about if-then decisions the only real drawback about this variant is that it doesn't have some of the tight competition that the normal multiplayer game has which is what the other solar modes try to address now the second solo mode is one that's a fan variant and this is a very cool automated system it tries to have a level of complexity that is somewhere between the first one and
the second official automata that I'm going to be getting to in just a little bit what's neat about this one is it's the one where you have to get crafty you're actually going to cut up some cards and make a deck that is going to be flipped to dictate what the actions of the opponent are going to be now the other really cool thing about this variant in order to make it a little bit more consolidated and smooth is that all of the the the automated player's actions are measured through ten coin increments if it buys something it spends ten coins regardless of what price it has but it's still going to adjust the market now I do think that there are some really interesting things that are done to make this a very very smooth running variant where it's aggressive in how the AMA handles things for instance if you have to put something on to the board and it already has some of the goods available it will make the process good factories so if you already have wheat for the Ottoman it's going to build a whiskey factory or the bread factory in order to utilize those resources which will allow it to claim some of the rewards and that is the key to this Ottoman see unlike you this Ottoman travel an and their decisions are entirely based off of can they fill a contract if so they will do that if
not then they'll utilize one of the cards and if they can't utilize one of the cards or fill one of the contracts then they're going to pass into the next round it's a very convenient if then system what I really like about it is that it's super aggressive it simulates multiplayer play really well but it's also really smooth the drawback to it is unlike the official variant for solo mode in the rulebook is that it's a lot more maintenance you are going to be spending time taking care of the automated opponent and making decisions for them there's going to be sequences in which there could be six possible hexes in which it might place a thing and you're going have to utilize the dice in order to decide where they go if you don't like acting for an opponent then this one is going to probably be less preferable to you than the official one now if you don't like acting for an opponent oh boy do I have some news for you about the official Ultima that is being developed right now so the third way of playing clans a caledonia solo involves a computer or anything that can access the Internet it is simulating some card play that theoretically can be done with cards in a print play situation but it's way more convenient to do it with a computer where you just say alright I'm going to start the game this is how it's going to roll out and then it tells you all the
setup and walks you through everything now if you peeked behind the curtain and looked at all of the rules and faq having to do with this on made a player you would know that this thing is super complex like the rules for it are far more than the twelve pages that are involved in the basic rule book which covers everything for multiplayer play and a solo mode and references for all the glands and individual scoring tiles and everything who is a lot to contend with now the way that this system essentially works is that every turn you are going to do your turn and then the autumn is going to take there's and there's a sequence of things that it can possibly do if it can do this then it will do it if it can't do that then it will do this if it can't do that then it will do this and there are many many sub things within that if it can do this it will do this and there's pairings of cards of where if you are going to be expanding with the automated player placing something on the map then another card is drawn in order to dictate where on the map it can go and it might go on to different boards and then you might use the dice to decide where it goes and how it interacts with the market and how it fulfills contracts or acquires things is just very very in-depth and requires a lot of decision-making so
much so that I didn't really have fun because I'm spending more time babysitting lisanna than I am in my actual turns and it never really kind of clicked and became intuitive though I would say that the most compelling thing about this autumn ax is that it does allow you to envision a really incredible digital implementation of clans of Caledonia where this is the decision-making process that the automated player would do it just does it entirely for you instantly with the magic of technology so of the three that are available I think that the official one in the book is going to be the one that I most often play on the other hand the fan variant is really compelling and doesn't take that much more the card system is a much more streamlined than the official autumn applier that is through the you web app but have you played any of them or you've played all three of them I want to hear from you what are your favorite ways of playing clans of Caledonia solo and for that matter what are your favorite solo games I mean some recommendations all right everyone that's going to do it for us stay clean stay safe stay in a good state of mind because it can get a little stir-crazy around here but thank you for watching I'll probably have more solo content for you here soon I've been jack for the cardboard Herald if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and
recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our Channel and website cardboard Herald calm our content is the audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard Herald