Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ask the Chairman - Board Game Q&A 7

Transcript 25:38

hey everybody and welcome to another installment of ask the chairman so this is a board game related Q&A session where you could ask me anything uh you like thank you to everybody who asked a question on the last video and if you want to keep the the series going then please leave a comment below this video and I'll be sure to get them answered in the next video now for some reason sometimes YouTube hides comments or they don't show up on my apps and things and if you asked a question and it hasn't showed up in this video then I can only apologize and please be sure to ask again below this video and hopefully I'll get to it next time and before I get started on these questions I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor keend up.co who are my goto online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so let's start with questions from Keith so the qu first question from Keith is do I have a dedicated games room uh not any more so half of my lounge is my games room where I have a geek and Sun table and the shelves behind me so I have three um 3x4 cxes um and yeah that's pretty much my gaming space the other half is my Sofer and TV Etc at my old house um I did have a designated games room so I've had to cut down quite a few games uh since then to make sure it all fit snugly in one place and um I can keep on adding to it with without feeling too much pressure uh the second question from Keith is do table hog

games irk me yes more and more so actually um I generally don't like it when you know you have so much stuff that you start to encroach on other people's space um so yeah I mean not massively it's not going to be um you know a strict deal breaker for me if a game's a table hog or not but I prefer it to be a bit more concise and reigned in uh he's also asked would I like to see additional info on the side of game boxes um I think a suggestion he made was maybe if it's color blind friendly or not so that's certainly going to be very um relevant for me because I am quite badly color blind so having that kind of um confirmation on the box would be very useful for me but other than that I think I'm quite happy with what's on the game boxes I have seen at times with like um smaller filler Games and Things they'll have like the scoring breakdown on the side of the box I think a game called ohanami had that which I think is a nice little touch if they can do that and if it's of course relevant to the game itself but all in all it's not something I really think about maybe apart from that color blind issue he's also asked would I rate a game a 10 out of 10 if that game needed a house Rule now the top I only rate three games 10 out of 10 full stop that is El Grande uh Tran and Chinatown and for me none of those games need house rules so I can't really confirm or deny if I would do this I mean I suppose if I like to game enough enough I I really love the game even if I did have to make a an easy

tweak or two then I could see myself still giving it a 10 out of 10 but um generally speaking you know if it needs house rules then it's probably not going to be a 10 out of 10 but it's not a strict no um but it's not a definite yes either but thank you very much for the questions Keith Ian has asked what are my thoughts on Dungeon Crawler style games generally speaking I've not played many of them because you guys probably know I like more eurocentric style games where Dungeon Crawlers generally lean onto the kind of a merry trashy style dice rolling and big campaigns that style of gameplay and that's not normally my thing I like Standalone experiences um I don't like having you know hords of content in a box that I have to filter through and set up each time that for me is a big kind of well very off-putting so generally speaking I dismiss every dungeon quar that comes out that being said I have played a couple like for example have played Gloom Haven and despite it not being a game for me I can certainly see why other people like it I did quite like the card system but for me it's just a bit too honorous and a bit too laborious to set up each time um when I'm playing so many different games if I had a game like that i' want to leave it set up on a table whereas that's not my style at all so generally speaking I'm very inexperienced but um but yeah so I I can't really comment beyond that really uh he's also asked what are my thoughts on valal the Serta games so this is a question I get asked regularly especially when people notice that I don't have any vitala games on my

shelves or in my collection at all so I've only actually played I believe two valal the soda games um and I didn't like either of them so the first one was um the gallerist which I played very early in my kind of board gaming life um I thought it was just a convoluted mess and the second one was Mardo deis boa which was an abstract game which was to be honest half a game I think it was um quite boring and dull so generally speaking I am leaning away from Ultra heavy games I just I'm not willing to kind of put up with a fitness and um rules exceptions and for me from my kind of glance on his games it seems like they are uh very front heavy Lots do be learned before you even play the game that's just not something I'm interested in if somebody could teach a game really concisely then I'd give it a go but um am I going to sit there play uh you know a very overwrought game for 3 hours now probably not so I'm probably not going to pick up any of his games anytime soon unfortunately but thank you for the questions Ian uh Hudson has asked what are my favorite Rhino kitzia games so at the moment I believe my highest rated ones are Babylonia raah haval Landy have I got any others here chin is one that I love as well uh municipium is one that I love know High Society there are absolutely tons of Kit games that I have in my collection now he's probably my maybe my

first or second favorite designer of all time even more recent games like um marabunta is a game I think is fantastic so yeah these are my some of my favorite Kia games and I've probably um missed out on some glaringly obvious ones as well being so prolific but rnie kitzia an absolute Genius of design thank you for your question um Hudson Shan has asked do I enjoy a game more if I am the one to teach it and this is categorically yes um I do enjoy teaching games and I feel a much more comfortable teaching games than learning games from other people unless they're simpler you know I I don't like being taught games by other people to be honest because my mind seems to um jump well run astray and then start filling in gaps which probably wouldn't not even correct so I kind of jump to assumptions a lot because I've learned and taught so many games I sometimes assume the way the game are designed and then that ends up biting me on the ass later when I when I play it so you know all in all um yeah I do like teaching games and I much much prefer teaching games than being taught games uh he's also asked do I enjoy a game more if I win it um no not particularly uh to be honest sometimes if I teach a game for the first time and I win it for the first time I normally find that that puts other players off because it feels like I've maybe have pulled the wool over their eyes in some capacity but generally speaking um if I teach a game and for the first time I don't win it because I'm always trying

to make sure that everybody is playing the game correctly um so there's that as well so but yeah not definitely not um a fact that I enjoy a game less if I am if I lose the game at all I don't mind if a game's good it's good there some of my favorite games I've hardly won at all you know I've mentioned before that I've I think I've ever won a game of Rumble Nation it's one of my favorite games of all time um I think I've worn trun maybe a couple of times and that's again my second favorite game of all time so um definitely not a fact that I'll enjoy a game more if I win it he's asked me what is the difference between luck and Randomness now I've not really thought about this question and there might be a definitive answer I'm not quite sure for me um if I was to categorize luck um for example if I was to play a luck based game say Rapido which is one of my favorites I I know the odds of my luck going into the decisions that I'm making you know do I want to roll the dice one more time and risk going Bust or do I want to push my luck and continue going forward that for me is luck and that can be a good factor of luck Randomness for me is a game where I've just got no way of controlling what's going to happen you know think of games like I don't know um flux or um you know exploding kittens these styles of games where anything can happen at any time and you've got very little control over what you want to do so luck I like the idea of you know understanding the the probability of something happening and then going committing to that or not whereas Randomness everything is out of

your control and you're going to you know you're going to get blown in the direction that the game wants to put you in so that's how I would categorize it i' be interesting to um hear how you guys categorize the difference between luck and Randomness but thank you for your questions um Sean some really good ones there Richard uh has asked which two player games do myself and my girlfriend r best and to be honest um my girlfriend has very recently got into board gaming she's kind of dipped her toe into the hobby we've not played that many games at all um if you'll mean two player only games um some of the ones we played are marabunta which I've mentioned already War Chester ones that we've enjoyed um believe it or not the games that she's enjoyed most so far is a game called medich the dice game which is another kit game and the dice game version of Michi um that's her favorite game so you know everyone has their own taste but that's them the ones that she enjoys he's asked which games do I enjoy solo so I very rarely play solo games but there are a couple that I have enjoyed and played um some of the ones that stand out are Spirit Island I thought Spirit Island was way better solo than it was working as a team and I also like the different end of the weight Spectrum I like Gans Sean clever as a solo game as well and makes a really good app and something you can play on an airplane or something um so yeah those are a couple there and I'm sure sooner or later I'll make a top 10 list of my favorite solo games which is going to be very unlike anybody else's I

think because I I have a very Niche taste when it comes to solo gaming he's asked have I played clans of calonia yes I have quite a long time ago I liked it I certainly didn't love it and I do recall when I acquired Tera mystica I like Terra mystica a lot more than I liked um clans of calonia and if you were to ask me why I'm not even quite sure I could um articulate why I just I just did he's asked which board game channels do I watch and or rate highly um so I've worked with the broken me before you know Luke Hector I really like his content I think he's um he makes some really interesting content and is certainly um not scared to say if he likes or dislikes the game um and just in terms of quantity I do like the dice tower they put a lot of stuff out there and definitely things can pop up on my radar that I didn't know about through the dice tower but to be honest now they've had a lot of new you know reviewers on there I don't rate a lot of them to be honest but I do like Z Garcia I think he's um I think our tastes overlap quite a lot he likes the French designs a bit more than I do but generally speaking I do like his taste and the way he talks about games other content creators not many to be honest I did like um back of the Shelf but I think they big stop now um but other than that not really um you know I'm the best uh the other one is where do you hunt for rarer games to be honest I

don't actively hunt for them sometimes if they pop up on uh like Facebook groups I'll notice them and snap them up quickly if I can um maybe sometimes I'll do um a sparing moment eBay search to see if a game's on there for an affordable price but um there aren't actually that many rare games I'm on the hunt for at the moment and more often than not they end up coming around and getting reprinted anyway um even if that takes takes years but uh but yeah thank you Richard I'm great again great questions there morar has asked what games do I feel could be streamlined to make me like it more so there's probably a ton of these um some of the games that initially popped into my mind were a game called Bano which was actually quite a nice or Ultra heavy Euro actually but I did like a lot of the mechanisms in there but it had a ton of kind of side mechanisms that just did not need to be there and did not add anything to the experience at all um that goes for stronghold as well so stronghold a great idea of a game where it's a two-player heavy Euro where it replicates a Siege battle so there's an attacking player and a defending Castle player and you're playing cards and things and moving cubes around um but it's so overwrought and convoluted so many rules within rules it's just an absolute bloated mess could be easily stripped back and made fun um and the third one I've mentioned is traran a game that I was definitely a very near Miss for me I'd say I like the game it could have been great but again

I think there was a few two tacked on message um tacked on mechanisms that just could have been avoided anyway so there's just a few games there that um that popped into my mind thank you for the question uh the megas has asked do I see a problem with reviewers being C with Publishers do I see a problem with it I mean it is what it is I suppose I don't think it's going to change anytime soon I think you know generally speaking board game fans are very intelligent you can see right through the inauthenticity of these creators a lot of the time you know if they're in bed with the creators or the Publishers it's so obvious because they don't you know they don't hide it at all they don't have a single negative critique or even yeah even slight critique to say about these games everything is great everything's wonderful and again it's very inauthentic and transparent I think now personally you know I I have a reasonable relationship with a couple of Publishers not many at all and generally speaking they're very small ones um and I've I've not had any hesitation and saying I don't like their games my loyalty is to you guys overall it's not loyal to loyal to the um to the Publishers at all um yes it sometimes puts you in a little bit of an awkward situation but you have to be strong enough to uh to deal with that but you know is it a problem maybe maybe but um ultimately I think people know what they're getting into when they watch these videos at least I hope they do um and he also said said do I see parallels

with computer game with the computer game industry um I don't know really I'm not involved in that sphere at all I know nothing about computer games um I think the last game computer game I played was from probably 7 years ago so I I don't even know what computer games are there at the moment um and just a final comment on that I think something that the Publishers really underestimate is negative reviews or CR reviews with criticism in them because a lot of my subscribers that I've noticed um might have a polar opposite taste than me so if I say I don't like a game there's a good chance that say 30% of my audience will like it and they've told me that so it's sometimes a negative review can be positive for the publisher because it's going to show a big demograph or big demographic of the board game audience that this is a game for them because they know they don't agree with me so it is what it is again I don't think it's going to change anytime soon um maybe there needs to be a bit more transparency saying you know I was I was set this for free whatever um but hey I don't know it's I think people generally can judge if people are being true to themselves or not but thank you for the questions uh Brett has asked what is a game that I like that includes my least favorite mechanism so there are a few of these um so generally speaking I do not like kind of resource Gathering mechanisms where you collect things and then cash them in against contracts I find that incredibly dull um but a game called thinker I really do like the way that one works where you are pretty much just doing that but it

has a few little twists to um to make it interesting um I don't like trick taking at all in general but I do like juraku um in fact I love jeru and the trip taking part of that is very interesting um and generally speaking I don't like dexterity games either but there are a couple I like and I love rafter 5 and I like droter as well some dexterity mechanisms there that again I normally bounce hard off of and and in polar opposite to that he's asked a game that I don't like that has a mechanism that I do like or do normally enjoy so you know I like root building style games you know I have games like um Caesar's Empire you know I love that style of tangible Road building and connecting things together but I don't like tickets to ride I don't like the um the rumy style Drafting and I hate the negative points of having cards left in your hand at the end of the game and even some of the blocking I just find it frustrating more than anything so I don't like tickets to ride um and also I I generally like man Cara mechanisms but I don't like five tribes at all so well I say not at all I I don't think much of five tribes but um but that obviously has that manala mechanism involved so a couple of examples there but again great questions uh Brett thank you very much Matt has asked which mechanisms um do I find the most difficult to teach uh I can't really think of any immediately U would you call it a mechanism but I I find these social deduction games very

difficult to teach because normally there's a lot of information thrown at you at once um if you're playing with new Gamers they've not played like that games like that before and they have pressure on their shoulders because they need to know what their role does but they're scared of ask asking because they don't want to reveal which role they are and then the game plays and they make a mistake and everything falls flat so yeah they're generally games where you need to make the mistakes before you learn learn know how to play it properly so sometimes you just need to commit make those mistakes and then and then as I said play it properly but um yeah I generally struggle to teach those styles of games but I think that's probably goes hand in hand with a style of game like that Bradley has asked um how do I stop components from being disorganized uh due to storing games vertically I just used plastic bags to keep everything separated simple as that thank you Bradley uh Mike has asked what is the most mechan most unique mechanism that I have both enjoyed and hated so one of the most unique games I've ever played is a game called mod IM Arosa which is where you're taking these cubes you're dropping him in this big cardboard Tower and you're trying to guess how far down that Tower the Cube has fallen um the game was awful it one of the worst games I've ever played um but you know I give I give credit to the game of trying to be uh unique another game that I think is um unique that I really do enjoy is Picture Perfect where you are trying to organize all these different character

standies in a particular order based on their um individual wants and needs has a degree of memory to it but I think the game does feel very unique and I do enjoy that one um it's also asked what are my current Grail games I'm not sure if I have any at the moment so um so yeah I don't think I have any so there we go thank you for the questions ziv has asked what are my thoughts on through the desert so if you don't know what through the desert is it is a rinia root building Style game that um has recently been reprinted actually or it's just about to be sent out to Kickstarter back Kickstarter backers um it's an older game it's abstract strategy you where you're putting these camels out and trying to section off parts of the board and cut other people off now I I've only played this game I think once and this was about six seven six or seven years ago when I was into very heavy Euro games and at the time um you can probably imagine when I was you know for me the more rules the marer back then and this game for me was very underwhelming because I thought well where's the you know where's the mechanisms here what what are we doing so I gave it about a 6 out of 10 ma then um I I did actually back the most recent one because my tastes have changed so dramatically and I love these minimalist style games now that I think if I to play this one again I think the rating could go up quite drastically so very excited to get my copy of through the desert I me he's also asked is through the desert different enough from

Babylonia which is my favorite kitzia game U yes it certainly is Babylonia does have that you know root building thing but you can put your tokens anywhere in Babylonia whereas through deser you can only I believe expand on from an existing chain and the way the scoring works is completely different um the voice of fox has asked are there any games that I initially dismissed that I grew to enjoy and there are probably loads of these um but a few that popped to my mind were you know aul I didn't like At first um I remember playing it again quite a while ago um but I played it more recently and I enjoyed it way more than I remembered uh Ship Shape was one that I was maybe lukewarm one to start with and now I really enjoyed the game um and also flea market which is an older game very lucky game um that I thought is okay at best and now I think it's a really cool game so those are games I kind of dismissed but um I certainly grew to enjoy them he's also asked do I ever play solo modes even to learn the game very rarely as I said earlier solo gaming is not my my thing in general um there have been exceptions to that if I was play a very heavy game now I would probably try at least try some of the mechanisms out but it's not a regular thing that occurs for me uh he's asked which artists sell you on a game not many to be honest because

I am a mechanism's first man um but there are some really familiar artists with those kind of classic Euro games that draw me in you know artists like Dennis lausen Clemens France I love their Styles because you know they've made so many of my favorite style games um I do like some of the more modern artists like you know Vin DET trit and um San is it weon Santiago I love his style as well um you know tons of great artists in The Bard game space and it we're very spoiled really uh and he's also asked are there any designers whose games you must play um must playay might be a strong word because I do kind of pre-qualify them by doing a research but I tried to try I tried to play all stanfeld games I think I've played 95% of them um Simone Lani games I'll certainly check out danini games kit games of course which you know there's so many that come out I can barely keep up with them um but yeah those are some of my favorite designers which are of course going to prick my ears up and at least make me check out their designs but thank you for the questions there and the final um couple of questions are from Kishore I believe that's how proun his name apologies if I pronounced it incorrectly he's asked are are there any plans for me to focus on games from other countries uh not specifically I'm not going to deliberately look at a games from France or Japan whatever and go through their catalog no I'm not going to do that if a game pequs my

interest then I'm going to play that one regardless of where it's from uh and he's also asked are there any plans on a series comparing specific games so I have thought about this um and maybe if there are two very popular games I would compare them Sly recently I did that for heat and um flam Rouge um to be honest a lot of the comp comparable games are very modern and then there's an old equivalent and general audiences aren really interested in those old games so I'm not sure if there's that much of a market for that series of videos but it's something I could certainly do without any kind of regularity if that makes sense if I feel that there's a need to make a video like that I will do so but I'm not going to do it deliberately but again thank you for the questions and thank you for everybody for submitting these questions because that is the the end of the list here so hopefully you have enjoyed it I've enjoyed answering your fantastic questions um as I said if you do want to keep the series going I do need more questions so please be sure to ask those questions below um if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to to the channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved