Criss Cross Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Criss Cross
Reviewers see Criss Cross as a compact roll and write that earns its place in a bag more than on a large table. The overall consensus is that the game is easy to carry, quick to start, and satisfying for the length of a short wait. Stella of Meeple University includes it among portable games for travel, pointing to its small footprint, quick setup, and flexible player count. It is treated as a filler with real staying power rather than a centerpiece.
The hosts of Rolling Dice & Taking Names approach the game from the rolling right side of the hobby. Tony describes the rules as very simple on the surface but a bear to master once the advanced rules come in, and says the game filled the gaps while waiting for the next show to start. Their recommendation is positive: they encourage viewers to pick it up and to see how it stacks up against their other rolling right games. The same channel reported from Gen Con 2018 that a vendor had already sold out of copies, a sign of the interest the game drew at the show.
Core Mechanics That Define Criss Cross
Rolling Two Dice Each Round
The game's engine is a roll at the start of each round. Meeple University describes rolling two dice and then placing the resulting symbols so that matching symbols sit next to one another, which turns a single roll into a turn of decisions rather than a long plan. Rolling Dice & Taking Names explains the same loop in plainer terms: roll two dice, mark them on the sheet, and then score from how the symbols on the sheet sit relative to one another. The dice set the tempo, and the placement choices are where the game lives.
Row and Column Symbol Matching
Scoring rewards grouping. Meeple University frames the goal as lining up as many matching symbols as possible in rows or columns to score the most points. Rolling Dice & Taking Names highlights the twist that turns the game from a warm-up into something with more bite: the advanced rules introduce negative points. The hosts say this is the part that will "eat your lunch," and note that it took them a while to master even though the core rule is short. Scoring becomes a balance between cashing in groups and avoiding the penalties that the advanced rules add.
The Criss Cross Experience
Quick Pick-Up Play for Waiting Time
Reviewers describe Criss Cross as a game that drops into the gaps of a day. Stella of Meeple University explains that the group played it while waiting to board, because it is quick to set up and ready the moment it is needed. Tony describes the same role at a convention, where the game was the thing to play between shows and while waiting on friends. The mood is relaxed and social: a short game, a quick score, and then the sheet goes back in the bag.
Simple Rules With a Slow-Burning Challenge
The second feeling is the gap between how easy the game looks and how long it takes to get good at it. Rolling Dice & Taking Names calls the core rules "real simple" but also describes the game as a bear to master. That contrast gives the experience its character: approachable at the first table, then steadily more demanding as the scoring and the advanced penalties become familiar. The hosts' enjoyment comes from that gradual unlocking rather than from any single clever twist.
What Makes Criss Cross Stand Out
Portability Without Sacrificing Play
Meeple University lists Criss Cross among the games that suit travel because of its footprint, its quick setup, and how easily it fits into a bag. The channel describes it as a very small footprint game that is easy to pack up in a hurry, and notes that it fits on airplane tray tables. Reviewers also point to its flexible number of players, which broadens its use in mixed groups and makes it a useful choice when the group size is uncertain.
Easy to Teach, Deep Enough to Return To
Rolling Dice & Taking Names praises the base game for being easy to explain, then points to the advanced rules as the source of depth that keeps players returning. Tony names Reiner as the designer and describes the game as a rolling right that is simple but takes time to master. That pairing is the standout: a new player can grasp the base game in minutes, while experienced players have a penalty-driven layer to work through.
Potential Drawbacks
A Real Learning Curve on the Advanced Rules
Not every reviewer finds the game effortless. Rolling Dice & Taking Names acknowledges that the simple base game becomes a challenge once the advanced rules introduce negative points, and the hosts admit it took them a while to master. Players who want an instant, no-thought filler may find the penalties more demanding than the quick-play pitch suggests. This is a fair tradeoff rather than a flaw, but it is worth knowing before teaching the game to a casual table.
Dependence on Paper Sheets and Markers
Because the game is played on paper with a marker, its portability depends on supplies. Stella of Meeple University explains the plan to laminate the sheet so that only markers need to be packed, avoiding the need to bring fresh pads on every trip. That workaround shows that the pack-and-go appeal depends on how the sheets are handled, and players who do not want to manage their own sheets will need to plan ahead for supplies.
If You Enjoy Criss Cross
Players who enjoy Criss Cross's quick roll and write loop will find the wider rolling right family a natural next step. The hosts of Rolling Dice & Taking Names frame Criss Cross by comparing it with their other rolling right games, so trying those alongside it makes sense. Both share the dice-and-sheet structure and the appeal of fast scoring.
The same channel also praised Yellow and Yangtze, another Grail Games title, noting that it was a hit at the table with a group that enjoyed it. Players who like Criss Cross's old-school feel and its lack of gimmicks may find that game worth exploring as well.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"We found that with this one this actually happens when we were waiting for boarding. We're just playing this because it's really easy when you know..."
— Stella, Meeple University
"There is a part of it where when you play the advanced rules it will eat your lunch. It creates negative points and it took us a while to master it but it's real simple."
— Tony, Rolling Dice & Taking Names
"I wanted to pick up criss cross a new you know rolling right I love my rolling rights and he goes I'm sold out."
— Rolling Dice & Taking Names