Habemus Papam Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Habemus Papam
Habemus Papam, a 3 to 6 player negotiation game from Salt and Pepper Games designed by Francisco Grell, is discussed mostly through its premise and its table play. Reviewers respond warmly to the setting, a papal Conclave in which cardinal factions push a candidate toward the papacy. The early preview on Chairman of the Board placed it fourth among anticipated 2025 releases, and the reviewer described the Conclave idea as something they find fascinating. Hands-on impressions came from Board Gaming Ramblings, which played a six-player session and culled the game, deciding it would sit on the shelf rather than get chosen often.
The praise centers on atmosphere and on hidden goals that keep the table tense. The criticism centers on the area majority core and on how much the game depends on player count.
Core Mechanics That Define Habemus Papam
Influence Placement and Area Majority
On a turn, players can pass, put influence on the candidates they want to back, or play a card. Board Gaming Ramblings describes influence as the scoring currency, noting that it is "basically your points." Because the design is an area control game, the timing of each placement matters. Players must decide whether a candidate‘s standing is acceptable for now or whether they need to act before the round ends. The reviewer calls this area majority approach a mechanism that is not their favorite, even while acknowledging that it can be really fun.
Hidden Objectives and Reading the Table
Each player works toward a hidden objective, which Board Gaming Ramblings says "might change completely what you want to do in the game." Players try to keep that goal concealed while still backing candidates who advance it. Guesswork is the other half of this mechanic. After repeated play, reviewers expect others to anticipate cards and block points, as in the remark "I know you‘re going to have this card. I‘m going to try to stop you from getting those points." That combination of negotiation and deduction defines the table dynamic.
The Habemus Papam Experience
A Simple Turn With Tense Timing
The loop is easy to explain. Board Gaming Ramblings says "what else I loved about it is the simpleness," since each turn offers only a few options. The depth arrives in the timing, with players "trying to see when in the round you‘re okay with it being in this state or when you need to do something for it to go your way." Holding back can be as consequential as acting, which keeps players attentive even though the actions themselves are few.
Thematic Immersion Around the Conclave
Theme is the emotional anchor of the game. Board Gaming Ramblings says "I love the theme for it. It felt really thematic," even though the reviewer is not usually drawn to theme. Tang M Studio 808 frames the premise in similar terms, with cardinal factions working to influence the election of the next Pope. Board Gaming Ramblings ties that theme to the decisions at the table, noting that a hidden objective can change what a player wants to do entirely.
What Makes Habemus Papam Stand Out
A Conclave Setting Few Designers Have Tried
Chairman of the Board says they are surprised the Conclave "hasn‘t been explored at least in depth before." The reviewer is drawn to the scenario of cardinals locked in a room, where lots of backstabbing and treachery interception can unfold. Board Gaming Ramblings adds that Salt and Pepper Games make very interesting historically themed games, and says the theme of this one is among the reasons the game stood out to them.
A Table Built Around Six Players
Board Gaming Ramblings says that six players "is great for this one," and the session that shaped their verdict was played at that count. The reviewer ties the game‘s appeal to a full table, which suggests the social pressure of reading several rival factions at once is central to the experience. Players who want to explore the candidate alignments and hidden objectives will find the larger group gives the design the most room to work.
Potential Drawbacks
Area Majority Is Not Everyone‘s Favorite
Board Gaming Ramblings says the reviewer can see the game being really fun, "but this like area majority is not my favorite mechanism." That reaction is one of the reasons the game was culled. The influence-based core is the part reviewers were least enthusiastic about, even though the theme and hidden objectives around it were praised.
Less Engaging With Fewer Players
Board Gaming Ramblings doubts the game "is going to be that fun with four," and notes that their group does not often reach five or six players for it. Because group size shapes the experience so strongly, the game risks sitting on the shelf for groups that rarely reach its ideal count. The reviewers also note that when a game is not liked by everyone at the table, it is less likely to be chosen, which compounds the problem.
If You Enjoy Habemus Papam
Players who want the elements reviewers praised, namely a Conclave-style setting, hidden objectives that shift priorities, and influence that doubles as points, should look for other negotiation and area influence games with secret goals. The Chairman of the Board preview‘s interest in intrigue within a closed room points toward games built on backstabbing and treachery. Useful starting points include:
- Negotiation games where table talk and hidden goals decide the outcome
- Area influence games where timing matters as much as the action taken
- Deduction-driven table games where reading other players‘ intentions shapes each decision
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I think it‘s a very interesting game. I think that Salt & Pepper Games make some very interesting historically themed games, and I‘m not that into theme, but I really enjoyed the themes of some of those games, and this one is one of them."
— Board Gaming Ramblings
"In this game players take on the roles of cardinal factions each with the mission to influence the election of the next Pope by supporting a candidate whose traits align with your faction‘s public profile. Forge alliances eliminate threats and outmaneuver Rivals to secure your factions dominance."
— Tang M Studio 808
"I think is so fascinating and I‘m surprised this hasn‘t been explored at least in depth before. I‘ve always been fascinated in this kind of aspect of a bunch of cardinals being locked in a room and having to make a decision."
— Chairman of the Board