Skip to main content
HMS Dolores box art

HMS Dolores

Game Info
Year
2016
Players
Age
Playtime
Publisher
Collection
Ratings
Creator Score
Mechanic profile
Waiting on more creator content
Vibe profile
Waiting on more creator content
Description

Eric M. Lang and Bruno Faidutti have joined forces to create the ultimate prisoner's dilemma game. Do you cooperate and risk getting outsmarted by a greedy player? Or do you compete and risk losing everything?

You are pirates who just looted a ship and must negotiate how to split the treasure. There are seven types of loot with values from 1 to 3. At the end of the game, you only score the treasure types you have the most and least of.

On each turn, open four new treasures: two in front of you and two in front of your neighbour. Simultaneously decide how to split them. Choices:

Peace (I want the 2 in front of me)
War (I want them all)
First pick (I want just one, pick first)

If both players choose peace, split the loot evenly. If both choose war, lose all treasure. If both choose first pick, lose all treasure and one of your gained treasure columns.

The game continues until the Dawn Card is drawn. 15 minutes!

Description

Eric M. Lang and Bruno Faidutti have joined forces to create the ultimate prisoner's dilemma game. Do you cooperate and risk getting outsmarted by a greedy player? Or do you compete and risk losing everything?

You are pirates who just looted a ship and must negotiate how to split the treasure. There are seven types of loot with values from 1 to 3. At the end of the game, you only score the treasure types you have the most and least of.

On each turn, open four new treasures: two in front of you and two in front of your neighbour. Simultaneously decide how to split them. Choices:

Peace (I want the 2 in front of me)
War (I want them all)
First pick (I want just one, pick first)

If both players choose peace, split the loot evenly. If both choose war, lose all treasure. If both choose first pick, lose all treasure and one of your gained treasure columns.

The game continues until the Dawn Card is drawn. 15 minutes!

Ask a Rules Question
All mentions
Browse transcript mentions, sentiments, pros/cons, mechanics, topics, quotes, and references.
Total mentions: 2
This page: 2
Sentiment: pos 0 · mix 1 · neu 1 · neg 0
Mentions per page
Showing 1–2 of 2
Video 2ZsehcxHWXc Chairman of the Board Review at 6:48 sentiment: neutral
Chairman of the Board - HMS Dolores video thumbnail
Click to watch at 6:48 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
neutral
Pros
  • Interesting twist on scoring
  • Perfectly pleasant
Cons
  • Too generic
  • Didn't raise its head above the pack
  • Nothing special
Thematic elements
  • Based on the Prisoner's Dilemma.
Comparison games
  • Ninja Capita
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Push Your Luck — Players can be greedy, share, or try for first choice of cards.
  • scoring mechanism — Scores only for the most numerous and smallest pile of cards, requiring a balancing act.
  • Set Collection — Players collect cards with different types of nautical objects.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • so these games are games i don't think a full review is warranted but nonetheless i think it'd be nice to share my thoughts about how i feel about these games and if i like them or if i didn't like them so i'm talking about 10 filler games today
  • it's not the best of filler games but it's certainly a strong one
  • it's perfectly fine but it's certainly not a game that's going to um you know stand amongst the pack and stay in our collection at least
  • ultimately there wasn't enough variation for me to keep coming back to this one but you know a 10 minute filler game that's gonna be really good for kids or you know really inexperienced gamers
  • it's just it's just okay
  • it's a shame because I think there was a a good game a good core for a game here but for those reasons and the fact that you needed to have an extremely strong memory to remember what the other options could have been for the other players that ultimately just didn't do it for me and it left me um very unsatisfied and as i said frustrated
  • if I was to recommend any I would lean towards red seven and probably port royal
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video -pa2yPh-p6c Chairman of the Board Analysis at 14:37 sentiment: mixed
Chairman of the Board - HMS Dolores video thumbnail
Click to watch at 14:37 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Really small filler game
  • Simple game
  • Nifty idea where you'd only score for your biggest set of items and your smaller set of items
  • Not a bad game
  • A lot of people will like it
  • Very quick
  • Nice artwork in this kind of pirate theme
Cons
  • Ultimately I think it was a bit too random a bit too lucky
  • So many more fillers out there that are a lot better than this one
Thematic elements
  • Set collection based on the prisoner's dilemma mechanism.
  • Pirate theme
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Prisoner's Dilemma — Choosing to agree to share or steal cards.
  • Set Collection — Scoring only for your biggest and smallest sets of items.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is a series of videos where i talk about games that have previously been in my collection but for one reason or another have been cold from the collection
  • the reason this one left my collection is not really um through a fault of the game it's more of a self-realization that i don't really enjoy real-time games as much as i thought i would
  • it is so involved it's so shouty you always stood up rolling dice constantly
  • ultimately i found that all the work placement spots were not too far different from one another
  • the game did have a bit of a weird pacing to it where the scoring phase would take a lot longer than the actual game itself
  • the reason why this one didn't stay in the collection was because i got burnt out with it
  • i won this game almost every time and i kind of find that when that happens i lose interest quickly
  • the game was divided into three very distinct rounds and at the start of each of those rounds you'd pretty much reset everything so there really wasn't much forward momentum going in this game
  • a lot of these games aren't games that i i think badly of it's just because i think a lot of games have have a shelf life and once you've hit a certain amount of plays
  • the core mechanism itself that core mechanism is what i really loved about gentas
  • the reason this one didn't stay in my collection was because i had the um i had the very lavish deluxe edition which naturally is worth you know a pretty penny
  • one of the worst games i've ever played
  • the more i played this one um i started to notice that there wasn't really much depth in terms of the way all the different minigames meshed together
  • ultimately i think it was a bit too random a bit too lucky
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Transcript Navigation
Top
Showing 1–2 of 2