Indulgence Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Indulgence
Reviewers agree that Indulgence is a clever spin on classic trick-taking, and most of the praise centers on how a single rule can reshape the whole table. The hosts of Rolling Dice and Taking Names, Marty and Tony, covered the game in an episode that also looked at Lignum and Downforce, and they came away impressed by how a familiar format becomes a social contest once the twist arrives. Bower's Game Corner offers a more measured verdict. Ranking trick-taking games on a crowded shelf, the channel placed Indulgence fourth, calling it a great trick taker that has lost some of its shine as newer trick-takers arrived. The Going Analog show approached the game from the publisher's side, with Rob, a co-founder of Restoration Games, presenting Indulgence as one of the company's first releases. The shared view is enthusiasm for the core twist, tempered by the reality that the design competes with a deep library of trick-taking favorites.
Core Mechanics That Define Indulgence
The Edict and the Choice to Sin
Each round, one player takes the role of ruler and selects an edict, a rule that everyone at the table is expected to follow. Rolling Dice and Taking Names described examples such as avoiding the first and last trick, steering clear of green cards, taking no sixes, or taking no twos and threes. The other players then decide whether to comply or to commit a sin by doing the exact opposite. The reviewers explained the money side as well. The ruler collects payment from players who break the edict, while a player who successfully pulls off the opposite gains a significant scoring benefit. Because the edict is announced before anyone commits, the ruler's choice shapes the entire hand, and the option to defy it is what keeps every player engaged.
Trick-Taking Fundamentals and the Indulgence Ring
Beneath the twist sits a conventional trick-taking game. Rolling Dice and Taking Names described four suits with cards numbered 1 through 9, where players must follow suit and regular trick-taking rules decide who wins each trick. The reward for sinning is an indulgence ring, which lets the sinner raise the value of one card a single time so they can take a trick they might otherwise lose. One host used the ring to run a suit across the other players, and the table treated that payoff as a satisfying result for taking the risk of defying the edict.
The Indulgence Experience
Tension Between the Ruler and the Table
Reviewers describe a table that shifts constantly. At first the players compete against the ruler, trying to outmaneuver an edict that is designed to make them stumble. Then, as soon as someone signals an intent to sin, the mood changes. Rolling Dice and Taking Names noted that the whole gameplay changes at that moment, because the other players stop simply avoiding the forbidden cards and start working to block the sinner from profiting. A single rule becomes a shifting set of rivalries, and the hosts described the result as a fun experience in which everybody ends up competing against somebody else.
Playful Contrarianism and Reading the Table
The second feeling reviewers highlight is the pleasure of thinking in reverse. Rolling Dice and Taking Names observed that a player studying an edict often asks how to make sure no one else can break it, which is the same watchfulness that defines Hearts. In that game, players learn to spot a shooting-the-moon attempt early, and Indulgence asks for a similar habit of reading the table. Every hand poses the question of whether to follow, bend, or break the rule, and that open-ended choice gives the game a lively, social character that reviewers seemed to enjoy more than a purely mechanical trick-taker.
What Makes Indulgence Stand Out
A Single Rule That Works in Both Directions
Reviewers praised the way the game rewards both obedience and defiance. The dual play of either following the edict or deliberately breaking it gives Indulgence a shape that Rolling Dice and Taking Names compared favorably with the shooting-the-moon moments in Hearts. Each round becomes a small puzzle: the ruler must choose an edict the table will struggle with, and the table must decide whether defiance is worth the risk. Because the twist is built into the scoring rather than attached as an afterthought, the design gives every player a reason to watch the rule closely, whether they intend to obey it or not.
A Restoration With Personal Roots
On Going Analog, Rob explained that Dragon Master, the game that Indulgence restores, was one of the titles discussed during an interview for a job at Parker Brothers and Milton Bradley. That history gives the reboot a personal meaning, and the designer described the restored version as a kind of lucky charm. Going Analog's hosts also tied Indulgence to the broader Restoration Games approach, praising the production quality that comes with the company's restored titles and noting that the publisher aims to modernize classic designs rather than simply reprint them. Rolling Dice and Taking Names echoed that appreciation with a playful nod to the company's slogan that every game deserves another turn.
Potential Drawbacks
A Crowded Trick-Taking Shelf
Bower's Game Corner ranked Indulgence fourth on its shelf but said the game has lost a little bit of shine as trick-taking games the channel enjoyed more have arrived. The criticism is less about the design itself and more about competition. Players who already own several strong trick-takers may find that Indulgence has to earn its place on the table, since its edict twist must compete with other games for a spot in a group's rotation.
Hand Luck Can Decide a Sin
Rolling Dice and Taking Names pointed out that a defiance attempt depends heavily on the cards in hand. A player holding the right combination can turn a sin into a profitable move, while a player with the wrong cards may simply pay the ruler. The hosts noted that a bold attempt to take every card of a forbidden type can succeed or fail depending on the deal, so the rewards for defiance can vary considerably from one hand to the next. For groups that prefer predictable outcomes, that variance may be the main friction point.
If You Enjoy Indulgence
Reviewers pointed toward a few related games that share its DNA.
- Hearts: Rolling Dice and Taking Names drew the most direct comparison, linking Indulgence's defiance mechanic to the shooting-the-moon tension in Hearts, where everyone watches for the one player attempting the unexpected.
- Spades: Named alongside Hearts by one of the Rolling Dice and Taking Names hosts as a trick-taking game they enjoy, Spades offers the same classic trick-taking foundation that Indulgence builds upon.
- Dragon Master: The original game that Indulgence restores. Rob named it as one of the games from childhood that shaped an interest in design, and the restored version keeps its core idea, making it a natural next step for anyone curious about where the twist came from.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Indulgence is a great trick taking game."
— Bower's Game Corner
"As soon as somebody says, we know I'm going to sin, then your whole gameplay totally changes."
— Rolling Dice and Taking Names
"Dragon Master was one of the games that got me the job in the interview, we rebooted that as Indulgence. It's sort of a lucky charm."
— Rob, Going Analog